Poll: Should Valerian Ismael be sacked?
You do not have permission to vote in this poll.
Yes, sack him.
32.00%
48 32.00%
No, needs time yet.
68.00%
102 68.00%
Total 150 vote(s) 100%
* You voted for this item. [Show Results]

Sack Val poll.
#11
I'm in the needs time camp but that time is the rest of the month. I've been patient, I've stuck up for him, I've seen deficiencies out of his control but we need points. I can't continue being willing to give more time if we keep dropping points and failing to score.
Reply
#12
No way.
Reply
#13
Yes.

I see no improvement in any of our squad. The results have nosedived. And I’m yet to see any influence he has during matches to affect them in our favour. Substitutions, tactical tweaks, etc…Also his lack of changing formation or tactics to suit certain teams or situations.

Get him gone.
Reply
#14
I'd have been content for him to go Saturday afternoon.

On a calmer more reflective I'd still be quite happy if he was sacked but I'm prepared to give him the next 3 games , players back from injuries\suspensions and see if we improve.

I would play a completely different shape and pattern to VI but I can see how and why his current system could work at PL level.
Trump is a Cunt
Reply
#15
Surprised by the results so far. Just how much time do we give him? Performances and results have been poor since October. Nothing seems to change in the way of tactics, formations, substitutions. I think it was right to sack Big Dave when we did. But the run of form under him is better than what we have under Ismael.
Reply
#16
No, but I really need to some improvement soon to back that up. It's either on the verge of clicking with the addition of Dike, or completely losing the dressing room. If it's the latter, the writing is on the wall.
In the form of his life.
Reply
#17
Still early, but shocked at this, pretty much the reverse of everywhere else on here.
Reply
#18
I was very much in the no camp, but have swung now to yes.
I just don't see enough tactical nous or flexibility to buy into any long term plan.

Of course, however, I want us to beat Peterborough and Preston and Milwall and so on and so on and, if he can do that, maybe with the help of Dike, I may well swing back the other way.

It's ok to change our mind, it's not a weakness, we don't have to pick a side and stick to it no matter what (although that's what Val does :-) ). Certainly not to the point where we disrespect each other or question our status as fans.
One thing is for sure, the vast majority of us will be here long after he's gone.
Reply
#19
Not quite yet - but anything less than 6 points from these 2 home games and he should go.

He's doing worse than Moore/Jones - and almost as bad as Robbohh in 2006/07 (who had a better side in fairness).
Reply
#20
I voted yes. Purely because it's now obvious he isn't going to change anything in regards to how we approach games so I don't expect it to get any better. Teams have bad spells and it's up to the manager to find a way out of it. Standing on the touchline, watching us struggle and doing nothing is unacceptable. Any of us could stand there and do nothing. I was excited by his appointment and the 'project' and believed him when he said he wanted us to be a more complete version of his Barnsley side, but in reality I think he thought he could do everything the exact same here that worked there. We've taken their coaching team, club captain, striker which their American DOF signed with the backup option being Woodrow and recently linked with one of their defenders. The other signings with the exception of Clarke have been poor. I expect him to stay and still hope he proves me wrong but I don't trust his judgement and think he's out of his depth
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: 2 Guest(s)