Hear Me Out.....
#1
------------Johnstone
O'Shea   Bartley   Clarke    Townsend
        Livermore    Mowatt
Phillips       Sawyers        Grant
                 Dike


Would be a better fit than the current lineup? Thoughts?
Reply
#2
Val will never play 4 at the back
Reply
#3
(01-17-2022, 11:11 AM)AmsterdamBaggie Wrote: Val will never play 4 at the back

I know this, unfortunately
Reply
#4
I'd love to see a back four, but wouldn't waste O'Shea at full back. I actually think Furlong is OK at full back, at least at Championship level. O'Shea starts, hard to choose between Barts, Clarke and Kipre for the other spot.

And Sawyers won't be back, will he? And none of this is going to happen.
Reply
#5
The system isn't the issue. Our issue is...

Our inability to move the ball quickly.
Play a progressive pass.
Create overloads.
Put quality deliveries into the penalty area.

We're actually at the point where I think Sawyers and Mowatt would be our best midfield pairing.
Reply
#6
I don’t think 3 at the back is the issue, it’s the personnel within the shape. That’s not to defend Val, it’s a criticism as sometimes you have to put pragmatism before ideology. At the moment it’s ideology before pragmatism.

The key to us playing 3-4-3 is having dynamic centre halves either side, a target centre striker and full backs who can deliver quality.

O’Shea is key, as is Clarke, but his absence has been massive.
Dike - a lot riding on him and not fully fit (but looked good Saturday)
Townsend/Furlong - they have shown they can have quality but not consistently. I genuinely believe though part of that is having bugga all in front of them and no real targets in the box. Hoping that Dike and his affect on the front three changes this and it helps them improve. Doesn’t absolve them from their need to improve.

What all of this tells me though is we aren’t playing in a way that maximises our available resources.

The reason I’ve laid off Val and will do until the end of the season is a) he was appointed with the club knowing his style and agreement we’d support him with transfers to help adoption b) come end of Jan, with Dike, O’She and maybe one more addition, he’ll have a much better chance of enacting his style.

If he fails then - well that will be another thing.
Reply
#7
(01-17-2022, 11:11 AM)Sliced Wrote: ------------Johnstone
O'Shea   Bartley   Clarke    Townsend
        Livermore    Mowatt
Phillips       Sawyers        Grant
                 Dike


Would be a better fit than the current lineup? Thoughts?

Put TGH in for Livermore and I completely agree. Its never ever going to happen though. The stubborn one just wont ever countenance such an idea.

Its 100% the way we should be playing with a No10 in behind a big striker. We don't need 5 at the back. Especially putting Dara in at RB. That back four woul be solid as a rock.

This is why I get so frustrated with Val. He won't even try something new to see of he gets a response and a positive outcome.
Reply
#8
(01-17-2022, 11:11 AM)Sliced Wrote: ------------Johnstone
O'Shea   Bartley   Clarke    Townsend
        Livermore    Mowatt
Phillips       Sawyers        Grant
                 Dike


Would be a better fit than the current lineup? Thoughts?

Absolutely. We are crying out for a third midfielder, don't think Sawyers is much of a 10 anymore but I'd certainly have him in the squad if it was me. Obviously has his limitations but at least he can put his foot on the ball, take his time and pass it to one of our players. Currently ours are finding it very hard to do just that. All pointless really though as Val doesn't want this for whatever reason
Reply
#9
(01-17-2022, 11:11 AM)Sliced Wrote: ------------Johnstone
O'Shea   Bartley   Clarke    Townsend
        Livermore    Mowatt
Phillips       Sawyers        Grant
                 Dike


Would be a better fit than the current lineup? Thoughts?

That team with a new manager. I like.

……………….Johnstone…………………
O’Shea Bartley Clarke Townsend
…..…..Yokuslu…..Mowatt…………
Phillips.…..Sawyers………..Grant
…………………..Dike……………………..
Reply
#10
Why the fuck are people putting our best centre back at right back?

People had meltdowns when Pulis put central defenders there.
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: