Downing Street Party
(01-12-2022, 09:47 AM)Protheroe Wrote:
(01-12-2022, 08:44 AM)Brentbaggie Wrote: After 11 years of I'm rather sick and tired of all this lazy "All the alternatives are worse" nonsense. I'm sick and tired of "All politicians are the same/liars/hypocrites".  The Tories only concern is whether they can win the next election with or without Boris.  They have long stopped having the interests of the British people at heart and the fact that everything that happens now is obscuring several varied attempts to pass legislation that would remove a whole raft of rights of the British people is passing almost unnoticed.  This is the most reactionary government in this country in a century and their efforts to change laws that will be nearly impossible to unpick barely rates a mention.  It takes a New York Times journalist to bother laying this out.

https://www.nytimes.com/2022/01/10/opini...d=em-share

And if the other side were in charge we'd probably never have emerged from Lockdown last summer and have even more draconian restrictions on our freedom in place. So "all the alternatives are worse" is not nonsense - unless you're Dekka and you'd welcome semi-permanent Lockdown.

I agree with the general tone of your insofar as we have a Tory government happily implementing the type of illiberal legislation I have spent most of my sentient life opposing.

Serious question - does this come as a surprise to you? You spent years campaigning for the party and one of its current cabinet members so was this never on the agenda at the conference or in the campaign preparation meetings? Added to that one of your favoured next leaders Priti Patel seems to be driving the clamp down on our freedoms, was that something preannounced or are these new measures that were not built into the manifesto?
Reply
(01-12-2022, 09:47 AM)Protheroe Wrote:
(01-12-2022, 08:44 AM)Brentbaggie Wrote: After 11 years of I'm rather sick and tired of all this lazy "All the alternatives are worse" nonsense. I'm sick and tired of "All politicians are the same/liars/hypocrites".  The Tories only concern is whether they can win the next election with or without Boris.  They have long stopped having the interests of the British people at heart and the fact that everything that happens now is obscuring several varied attempts to pass legislation that would remove a whole raft of rights of the British people is passing almost unnoticed.  This is the most reactionary government in this country in a century and their efforts to change laws that will be nearly impossible to unpick barely rates a mention.  It takes a New York Times journalist to bother laying this out.

https://www.nytimes.com/2022/01/10/opini...d=em-share

And if the other side were in charge we'd probably never have emerged from Lockdown last summer and have even more draconian restrictions on our freedom in place. So "all the alternatives are worse" is not nonsense - unless you're Dekka and you'd welcome semi-permanent Lockdown.

I agree with the general tone of your insofar as we have a Tory government happily implementing the type of illiberal legislation I have spent most of my sentient life opposing.

Do you think Labour would have shown more compassion / empathy for normal people? 

Do you think they’d have given 100’s of million pound contracts to mates?

Would they have wasted £37bn on a pointless & dreadful track & trace system?

Would they have fed hungry school kids?

Would Corbyn / Starmer be trying to get cash from donors in exchange for favours to decorate downing street in the middle of the crisis?

Would they not bother to turn up to vital cobra meetings?

Would they be hiding in fridges to not answer questions / take responsibility for their actions?
Reply
(01-12-2022, 09:54 AM)baggy1 Wrote:
(01-12-2022, 09:47 AM)Protheroe Wrote:
(01-12-2022, 08:44 AM)Brentbaggie Wrote: After 11 years of I'm rather sick and tired of all this lazy "All the alternatives are worse" nonsense. I'm sick and tired of "All politicians are the same/liars/hypocrites".  The Tories only concern is whether they can win the next election with or without Boris.  They have long stopped having the interests of the British people at heart and the fact that everything that happens now is obscuring several varied attempts to pass legislation that would remove a whole raft of rights of the British people is passing almost unnoticed.  This is the most reactionary government in this country in a century and their efforts to change laws that will be nearly impossible to unpick barely rates a mention.  It takes a New York Times journalist to bother laying this out.

https://www.nytimes.com/2022/01/10/opini...d=em-share

And if the other side were in charge we'd probably never have emerged from Lockdown last summer and have even more draconian restrictions on our freedom in place. So "all the alternatives are worse" is not nonsense - unless you're Dekka and you'd welcome semi-permanent Lockdown.

I agree with the general tone of your insofar as we have a Tory government happily implementing the type of illiberal legislation I have spent most of my sentient life opposing.

Serious question - does this come as a surprise to you? You spent years campaigning for the party and one of its current cabinet members so was this never on the agenda at the conference or in the campaign preparation meetings? Added to that one of your favoured next leaders Priti Patel seems to be driving the clamp down on our freedoms, was that something preannounced or are these new measures that were not built into the manifesto?

Serious answer? Do you think I'd have campaigned for this if I believed it was the likely outcome? Do you believe I'd have left the Party after 30+ years if I wasn't bewildered and disgusted by the Tories retreat from liberalism? 

Some MSM and plenty on here believe that Johnson is some sort of free market libertarian and leads the government as such which flies in the face of all the evidence of the last two years. He's a big state, high tax authoritarian chancer.

Does this come as a surprise to me? Well, yes it does. It's come as a pretty nasty surprise to anyone, including most Tory members and very many ex-Tory members. I'm still lurking on some Whats App groups I haven't been chucked off and the atmosphere is vicious. It's not helped by some of the 2019 intake who are nearly as thick and incapable as Labour's intake under Corbyn. 

It's also well worth noting that Parliament is voting for these measures, not just the Tories - and as I've already stated, HM Opposition would be clamping down even further on our freedoms.

Priti Patel seems pretty incapable of clamping down on anything; whether that's cnuts blocking road junctions, an open door economic migrant policy or the state of the individuals policing this country. 

Brent is right about one thing - and that's my only hope; The Tories have been an election winning machine for centuries - I floated the concept that Boris will be their useful idiot a long time ago. It really depends on when they dump him now. But I'm inclined to hope now that he takes plenty of the others with him who're tainted by association - including my own MP.
Reply
And that is a fair answer. I don't think the voting to support the covid measures should be confused with any voting to reduce the application of the HRA or the increase in policing powers for demonstrations, Labour have voted for the former but not the latter.

One further question - if this approach is so far away from the core membership's ideals why is he still in post?
Reply
(01-12-2022, 11:07 AM)baggy1 Wrote: And that is a fair answer. I don't think the voting to support the covid measures should be confused with any voting to reduce the application of the HRA or the increase in policing powers for demonstrations, Labour have voted for the former but not the latter.

One further question - if this approach is so far away from the core membership's ideals why is he still in post?

Because the membership don't have the power to remove him.

To be honest most of us who aren't remunerated in some way by politics (as a Councillor, agent or office employee) have already walked. There will be very few activists on the streets for the Tories for the May elections who don't in some way have skin in the game. Once the Tories have been routed in May it will be carnage - there are very good friends of mine who will lose their Council seats and there will be others who won't win marginals.

The Tory vote won't go to Labour or any of the others, it'll simply stay at home like it always does when the party is going through a cretinous phase. If I had a vote this May, then for the first time in my adult life I wouldn't bother.

The issue with removing Johnson is that there remains a huge degree of patronage from the 2019 intake. There are some, like the increasingly ridiculous Suzanne Webb (Stourbridge) who would literally follow him over a cliff. My friend James Morris (Halesowen) lost his mother during the first Lockdown as I did - and attended her funeral with less than a dozen people, as I did. Yet he seems content to act as a whip in this government.

There are the usual Spartans out there who I'm ridiculed by our resident Lockdown-fetishist for agreeing with most of the time, but Johnson is supported by the 2019 lobby fodder. It won't last as many of their careers are dead in the water under him but they will have to weigh anchor soon, and it will be very painful for them.

I am out of it for good. I've spent enough of my own time volunteering when I should have been running my businesses. The scales have now lifted from my eyes, for which I'm truly grateful.
Reply
Thanks for the insight and honest answer
Reply
(01-12-2022, 11:29 AM)Protheroe Wrote:
(01-12-2022, 11:07 AM)baggy1 Wrote: And that is a fair answer. I don't think the voting to support the covid measures should be confused with any voting to reduce the application of the HRA or the increase in policing powers for demonstrations, Labour have voted for the former but not the latter.

One further question - if this approach is so far away from the core membership's ideals why is he still in post?

Because the membership don't have the power to remove him.

To be honest most of us who aren't remunerated in some way by politics (as a Councillor, agent or office employee) have already walked. There will be very few activists on the streets for the Tories for the May elections who don't in some way have skin in the game. Once the Tories have been routed in May it will be carnage - there are very good friends of mine who will lose their Council seats and there will be others who won't win marginals.

The Tory vote won't go to Labour or any of the others, it'll simply stay at home like it always does when the party is going through a cretinous phase. If I had a vote this May, then for the first time in my adult life I wouldn't bother.

The issue with removing Johnson is that there remains a huge degree of patronage from the 2019 intake. There are some, like the increasingly ridiculous Suzanne Webb (Stourbridge) who would literally follow him over a cliff. My friend James Morris (Halesowen) lost his mother during the first Lockdown as I did - and attended her funeral with less than a dozen people, as I did. Yet he seems content to act as a whip in this government.

There are the usual Spartans out there who I'm ridiculed by our resident Lockdown-fetishist for agreeing with most of the time, but Johnson is supported by the 2019 lobby fodder. It won't last as many of their careers are dead in the water under him but they will have to weigh anchor soon, and it will be very painful for them.

I am out of it for good. I've spent enough of my own time volunteering when I should have been running my businesses. The scales have now lifted from my eyes, for which I'm truly grateful.

Fair play to you Proth.
An honest and straight post.
Reply
I do admire Johnson's hubris to admit something and lie in the same sentence.
Reply
(01-12-2022, 01:33 PM)Borin' Baggie Wrote: I do admire Johnson's hubris to admit something and lie in the same sentence.

Those whom the gods wish to destroy they first make mad.

(01-12-2022, 09:47 AM)Protheroe Wrote:
(01-12-2022, 08:44 AM)Brentbaggie Wrote: After 11 years of I'm rather sick and tired of all this lazy "All the alternatives are worse" nonsense. I'm sick and tired of "All politicians are the same/liars/hypocrites".  The Tories only concern is whether they can win the next election with or without Boris.  They have long stopped having the interests of the British people at heart and the fact that everything that happens now is obscuring several varied attempts to pass legislation that would remove a whole raft of rights of the British people is passing almost unnoticed.  This is the most reactionary government in this country in a century and their efforts to change laws that will be nearly impossible to unpick barely rates a mention.  It takes a New York Times journalist to bother laying this out.

https://www.nytimes.com/2022/01/10/opini...d=em-share

And if the other side were in charge we'd probably never have emerged from Lockdown last summer and have even more draconian restrictions on our freedom in place. So "all the alternatives are worse" is not nonsense - unless you're Dekka and you'd welcome semi-permanent Lockdown.

I agree with the general tone of your insofar as we have a Tory government happily implementing the type of illiberal legislation I have spent most of my sentient life opposing.

I think you're confusing freedom with liberty - a mistake that seems to be of no consequence to your former political soulmates or yourself. Freedom is the idea that one can do things or exercise one's will without restraint in order to fulfil one's desires.  Liberty equates to the responsible use of freedom under the law.  It is pretty clear that your former party and the present government have no interest in liberty, or even acting according to the law full stop, but would exercise control over this country by the removal of legal constraints that they find uncomfortable. 

The idea that the Labour Party would act in a way more "draconian" is a myth that is constantly peddled in order to justify the appalling behaviour of a government that long ceased to abide not just by the rule of law but in any humane and reasonable manner. You can't keep blaming a party not in power for 11 years on the basis that you know they would be worse.  Given you say yourself you now only care about your family I think it ill-behoves you to make any claims about what might be good for the country or society, not least given you backed a party that somehow amazingly surprised you to be unfit to govern, when it's been pretty obvious to most of the rest us for years.
Reply
(01-12-2022, 08:44 AM)Brentbaggie Wrote: The idea that the Labour Party would act in a way more "draconian" is a myth.

It's a truth in Wales. An example Starmer would have happily applied here.

So, no.
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: 2 Guest(s)