Posts: 7,408
Threads: 458
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
29
I’ve been looking and thinking about this, are our reds fully justified, Furlong last man and got the ball unlucky, the ref also gave Fulham a non penalty in the same match. Livermore high boot again nothing malicious and an opponent did the a worse tackle and stayed on pitch.Molumby 2 yellows again nothing malicious but should stay on feet and not give ref a decision to make. Mowatt I thought not red card tackle and player rolling around before jumping to his feet after ref gives red card. Cheating again unlucky. Johnstone I cannot comment on as I have not had a good view of incident. As for Kipre yes 2 book able offences but again nothing malicious.
So really we aren’t a dirty side as some are trying to make out, but we must stop giving these crap refs a decision to make. Must admit showing my age here but not one of our sendings of would have occurred when I played, so how times have changed.
Posts: 13,407
Threads: 402
Joined: Jul 2019
Reputation:
14
Not seen anyone say we're a dirty side, but anyone saying our discipline isn't bad is really not watching the same games. Earlier in the season our dark arts were being lauded, now we're getting punished it's suddenly not our own fault...
2 yellows tend to be down to the player, if you're on a yellow you should be more aware / careful, always going to happen during a season though.
Mowatt, he never complained, and just walked, that tells me it was red. SJ DID throw a punch = red.
As you say, generally if you give the ref a decision to make then it could go against you, and that comes back to the players making stupid decisions and doing things that may get them sent off. What's got my goat the most is that most of the reds have come in pointless places where the challenges weren't even needed. Mowatt's being a prime example, there was no need to even tackle hard let alone go in like he did. Same with Livermore, seen them given, and seen them not, but there was no real need to even be doing it anyway.
Most of them are bad decisions by our players, it's a bit off to claim cheating etc...
Posts: 9,603
Threads: 515
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
32
(01-11-2022, 10:32 AM)MassDebater Wrote: Not seen anyone say we're a dirty side, but anyone saying our discipline isn't bad is really not watching the same games. Earlier in the season our dark arts were being lauded, now we're getting punished it's suddenly not our own fault...
2 yellows tend to be down to the player, if you're on a yellow you should be more aware / careful, always going to happen during a season though.
Mowatt, he never complained, and just walked, that tells me it was red. SJ DID throw a punch = red.
As you say, generally if you give the ref a decision to make then it could go against you, and that comes back to the players making stupid decisions and doing things that may get them sent off. What's got my goat the most is that most of the reds have come in pointless places where the challenges weren't even needed. Mowatt's being a prime example, there was no need to even tackle hard let alone go in like he did. Same with Livermore, seen them given, and seen them not, but there was no real need to even be doing it anyway.
Most of them are bad decisions by our players, it's a bit off to claim cheating etc...
I agree MD. I think its important to separate the "dark arts" from the sending's off though. We have at no point got a red for 2 "professional fouls" or for timewasting etc. They have been poor decisions from players.
You hit ther nail on the head regarding not needing to make challenges. This needs to be addressed quick sharp and was pleased to hear Val talk about it in his last presser.
"IMO of course..."
Posts: 5,322
Threads: 356
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
16
Not specific to us, but in general I think the game needs to be more careful in what constitutes a red card.
I am all for ensuring the safety of players from dangerous challenges and also acting against persistent cheating eg a defender continually fouling a forward who is getting the better of them.
But I also think we need to take into account the impact a red card can have on a game, making it far less competitive and a less enjoyable spectacle to watch.
For me there are too many unnecessary red cards, which detract from the game not support. A good example this season was Reece James's dismissal at Liverpool, a penalty yes, but surely the game does not benefit from making that a red card as well.
Posts: 10,860
Threads: 497
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
23
Mowatts Red was all the more difficult to take when you watch that Curtis Davis tackle the other week that got him a yellow. It was an absolute straight red. Unintentional yes but a terrible challenge.
They are either both reds or both yellows. Its the inconsistencies that fuck me off. I actually do yhink we've been unlucky on a few but Kipres and Molumbys were stupidity. Just don't give the ref a decision. When our players are on yellows our players must engage their fucking brains. Its costing us.
Posts: 8,953
Threads: 166
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
77
Obvs its different watching them live as to seeing replays but of the ones I can remember lately; Mowatt's I said at the time was a straight red before the ref had pulled the card out, I thought Kipre's was extremely harsh, he'd just picked up a yellow and was running sideways and back watching the ball, the player saw this and stopped meaning that Kipre ran into him - the brighton player wasn't watching the ball and was the one that caused the collision. The ref should have seen this and at worst given Kipre a chat, it was miles off a yellow.
Posts: 7,972
Threads: 254
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
6
(01-11-2022, 11:16 AM)Peachy Wrote: Mowatts Red was all the more difficult to take when you watch that Curtis Davis tackle the other week that got him a yellow. It was an absolute straight red. Unintentional yes but a terrible challenge.
They are either both reds or both yellows. Its the inconsistencies that fuck me off. I actually do yhink we've been unlucky on a few but Kipres and Molumbys were stupidity. Just don't give the ref a decision. When our players are on yellows our players must engage their fucking brains. Its costing us.
Correct. Dont even run the risk.
Posts: 19,719
Threads: 2,734
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
49
I wouldn't have sent Mowatt off.
A yellow and a bollocking. That's all for that.
Still not seen SJ's punch.
Posts: 15,040
Threads: 339
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
93
(01-11-2022, 11:55 AM)baggiebloke Wrote: I wouldn't have sent Mowatt off.
A yellow and a bollocking. That's all for that.
Still not seen SJ's punch.
Did anyone see it? I certainly didn't and was surprised we didn't appeal. I'm told skysports reported it as foul and abusive language.
Posts: 3,396
Threads: 176
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
9
(01-11-2022, 11:39 AM)baggy1 Wrote: Obvs its different watching them live as to seeing replays but of the ones I can remember lately; Mowatt's I said at the time was a straight red before the ref had pulled the card out, I thought Kipre's was extremely harsh, he'd just picked up a yellow and was running sideways and back watching the ball, the player saw this and stopped meaning that Kipre ran into him - the brighton player wasn't watching the ball and was the one that caused the collision. The ref should have seen this and at worst given Kipre a chat, it was miles off a yellow.
+1, the 2nd yellow was totally accidental from Kipre. The only thing I'd say is it does look worse on first glance which I guess is what the ref went with but seeing the replays you can clearly see there's no intent there. I wouldn't be critical of Kipre for this.
|