VI criticism
#21
Pulis and Big Sam got worse than Dave and Val because they were far easier to dislike, just as I think Bilic was far easier to like.
Reply
#22
Val has inherited a squad on the decline. A squad that stumbled over the finish line 2 years ago and were abject in the prem. Is this lost on people?

Big Sam, for all my dislike, saw this and brought in players to address it (albeit far too late).

To suggest VI is getting an easier time from fans is nonsense. He’s had one transfer window and a day into the second we have a player coveted by teams in higher much vaunted leagues. As I said in another post I can’t believe anyone is happy with results and style, that said, why is it always the managers fault? There’s a perception that because our squad is well paid they must be good - where’s the evidence? This squad is past peak.

The addition of Dike and another CM, plus the return of Dara will be a much much needed impetus - but can we stop with the belief we ‘deserve’ we ‘should’ be better and it’s all the managers fault. The data suggests otherwise.
Reply
#23
(01-04-2022, 12:16 PM)BurleyBaggie Wrote: Val has inherited a squad on the decline. A squad that stumbled over the finish line 2 years ago and were abject in the prem. Is this lost on people?

No not at all. 

It also isn't lost on me either that the captain of that said side that presided over our stumbling post lockdown promotion, who was bombed out as soon as Big Sam came in, is now back with the armband and plodding around after being given a free pass to start every single game irrespective of form.

I don't want Val sacked. I agree he should be given more time to bring in players who can play his particular "brand" of football, players who can meet his "philosophy" and commit to his "project", but he also has to prove he can make players better. He has to coach the squad he has to get more out of them as after all that is a coaches job. He has to adapt to games and opposition tactics like everybody else.

He should not be sacked but imo fans are quite right to expect to see some positive signs going forwards. Like it or not performances are regressing from the start of the season and we are seeing no signs of positive changes.

Lets hope Dike is the start of a change in fortunes....
Reply
#24
(01-04-2022, 12:36 PM)Peachy Wrote:
(01-04-2022, 12:16 PM)BurleyBaggie Wrote: Val has inherited a squad on the decline. A squad that stumbled over the finish line 2 years ago and were abject in the prem. Is this lost on people?

No not at all. 

It also isn't lost on me either that the captain of that said side that presided over our stumbling post lockdown promotion, who was bombed out as soon as Big Sam came in, is now back with the armband and plodding around after being given a free pass to start every single game irrespective of form.

I don't want Val sacked. I agree he should be given more time to bring in players who can play his particular "brand" of football, players who can meet his "philosophy" and commit to his "project", but he also has to prove he can make players better. He has to coach the squad he has to get more out of them as after all that is a coaches job. He has to adapt to games and opposition tactics like everybody else.

He should not be sacked but imo fans are quite right to expect to see some positive signs going forwards. Like it or not performances are regressing from the start of the season and we are seeing no signs of positive changes.

Lets hope Dike is the start of a change in fortunes....

I can absolutely see the point on Livermore. I’ve questioned this. 

The point I keep coming back to though is he is respected and gives leadership - that’s the only reason he can be keeping his place. We are mentally weak as a team with few leaders. 

On positivity - well we’ve been bang average and we’re 4th - considering a lot of posts from August, consecutive relegations, mid table team etc we’ve outperformed a lot of the doom merchants
Reply
#25
We're bound to click back into gear again soon. And when we do someone's in for a serious pasting. The trick then will be to maintain momentum by not ignoring learned lessons.

Forwards and COYB  Cool .
Reply
#26
(01-04-2022, 12:48 PM)BurleyBaggie Wrote:
(01-04-2022, 12:36 PM)Peachy Wrote:
(01-04-2022, 12:16 PM)BurleyBaggie Wrote: Val has inherited a squad on the decline. A squad that stumbled over the finish line 2 years ago and were abject in the prem. Is this lost on people?

No not at all. 

It also isn't lost on me either that the captain of that said side that presided over our stumbling post lockdown promotion, who was bombed out as soon as Big Sam came in, is now back with the armband and plodding around after being given a free pass to start every single game irrespective of form.

I don't want Val sacked. I agree he should be given more time to bring in players who can play his particular "brand" of football, players who can meet his "philosophy" and commit to his "project", but he also has to prove he can make players better. He has to coach the squad he has to get more out of them as after all that is a coaches job. He has to adapt to games and opposition tactics like everybody else.

He should not be sacked but imo fans are quite right to expect to see some positive signs going forwards. Like it or not performances are regressing from the start of the season and we are seeing no signs of positive changes.

Lets hope Dike is the start of a change in fortunes....

I can absolutely see the point on Livermore. I’ve questioned this. 

The point I keep coming back to though is he is respected and gives leadership - that’s the only reason he can be keeping his place. We are mentally weak as a team with few leaders. 

On positivity - well we’ve been bang average and we’re 4th - considering a lot of posts from August, consecutive relegations, mid table team etc we’ve outperformed a lot of the doom merchants

We were top. Then we were comfortably top 2. Then we were comfortably 3rd. Now we are 4th and 3 points above 7th! Once Fulham pick up more points from their 2 games in hand we will be miles off the top two.

I'm all for being positive but surely you can see the same manager and players are gradually getting worse not better.

Like I say I want Val to succeed but you can't bury your head in the sand and pretend all is rosy. He needs to show more imo.
Reply
#27
Revision to the mean or decline? That’s the question isn’t it? Are we now where we should be, is this a short term blip or a decline.

I think until we get to the seasons end we won’t know.

In 19/20 we won 4 in 20 from January and got promoted on what we did in the first 23 games. So I’m willing to see whether the decline, if it is one, is terminal or short lived.

Also it’s not head in sand it’s trying to balance what I believe, what is this squad is not as good as we think it is with whether the manager is getting the most out of it. I think that is something we won’t know until May.
Reply
#28
Val is human, and the club is in a far from perfect state.

Whilst for me there are a few things counting against him - notably his predictability during game management, team selection over recent weeks, the fact that we seem to have effectively lost some players (Snodgrass and Phillips, the latter of whom really hasn't contributed enough for me as a senior player) and most notably the seemingly blind faith in a thoroughly decent but clearly underperforming captain - there are a few things to his credit. He is giving the youngsters a chance, he seems to be partially succeeding in getting a tune out of Grant, Robbo (when he plays him) and his trying to work with Diangana. And to be fair, we are still in touch.

But for me, the squad isn't really good enough to consider ourselves promotion candidates elect. And I think that Val is hamstrung by this, especially against the expectation that we all say we don't have when we are lying at the foot of the EPL and want to start over again, bomb them all out, start from the ground up etc., but seem to magically regain the inverse attitude again by the curtain opener in mid-August.

Under Big Dave, I think the squad clearly was head-and-shoulders good enough, and Slav just about proved this the following year. But this time around I am not so sure. I think that some of the transfer crimes of the past have caught up with us, severely impacted upon the budget (and consequently the team selection) to the extent Val has had to work with what he's got, to a more counterproductive extent than either Slav or Big Dave had to.

Add to that the TD woes and the ensuing shambles that occurred which actually led to Val, and it appears that he really wasn't joining all that steady a ship.

So in effect, he's had far less wriggle room, and I think it was an easier job for both of the previous Chump managers than it is for Val. I think both Slav and Big Dave had more than enough quality at their disposal to mask their shortcomings short-term. To me, a fine squad in terms of not just numbers (we've seldom enjoyed a huge roster of players) but quality in addition, not only makes it harder to get points on the board, but to bring those youngsters in confidently also.

Losing two key defensive players early on hasn't helped much, and seems to coincide with when we appeared to lose our guile. Also a couple of players haven't returned with quite the same form.

But I do think that - had Val had either BD or Slav's squad to inherit, we wouldn't be quite so impatient with it all now. Impossible to say of course, but to me the imperfections of the manager are not necessarily the biggest factor at play here. It would be much fairer to judge his work when he has a few more of his own tools to work with, and I doubt replacing him now would result in a candidate with fewer imperfections any more than it would fix what remains wrong behind the scenes.
Reply
#29
(01-04-2022, 01:40 PM)HawkingsHalfpint Wrote: Val is human, and the club is in a far from perfect state.

Whilst for me there are a few things counting against him - notably his predictability during game management, team selection over recent weeks, the fact that we seem to have effectively lost some players (Snodgrass and Phillips, the latter of whom really hasn't contributed enough for me as a senior player) and most notably the seemingly blind faith in a thoroughly decent but clearly underperforming captain - there are a few things to his credit. He is giving the youngsters a chance, he seems to be partially succeeding in getting a tune out of Grant, Robbo (when he plays him) and his trying to work with Diangana. And to be fair, we are still in touch.

But for me, the squad isn't really good enough to consider ourselves promotion candidates elect. And I think that Val is hamstrung by this, especially against the expectation that we all say we don't have when we are lying at the foot of the EPL and want to start over again, bomb them all out, start from the ground up etc., but seem to magically regain the inverse attitude again by the curtain opener in mid-August.

Under Big Dave, I think the squad clearly was head-and-shoulders good enough, and Slav just about proved this the following year. But this time around I am not so sure. I think that some of the transfer crimes of the past have caught up with us, severely impacted upon the budget (and consequently the team selection) to the extent Val has had to work with what he's got, to a more counterproductive extent than either Slav or Big Dave had to.

Add to that the TD woes and the ensuing shambles that occurred which actually led to Val, and it appears that he really wasn't joining all that steady a ship.

So in effect, he's had far less wriggle room, and I think it was an easier job for both of the previous Chump managers than it is for Val. I think both Slav and Big Dave had more than enough quality at their disposal to mask their shortcomings short-term. To me, a fine squad in terms of not just numbers (we've seldom enjoyed a huge roster of players) but quality in addition, not only makes it harder to get points on the board, but to bring those youngsters in confidently also.

Losing two key defensive players early on hasn't helped much, and seems to coincide with when we appeared to lose our guile. Also a couple of players haven't returned with quite the same form.

But I do think that - had Val had either BD or Slav's squad to inherit, we wouldn't be quite so impatient with it all now. Impossible to say of course, but to me the imperfections of the manager are not necessarily the biggest factor at play here. It would be much fairer to judge his work when he has a few more of his own tools to work with, and I doubt replacing him now would result in a candidate with fewer imperfections any more than it would fix what remains wrong behind the scenes.

Val with either the squad that Big Dave or Bilic had would have got us up. We'd have been fitter and more organised, the last promotion was down to the wealth of attacking talent we had and in spite of Bilic' inability to organise the team defensively.
Reply
#30
(01-04-2022, 01:49 PM)Ted Maul Wrote:
(01-04-2022, 01:40 PM)HawkingsHalfpint Wrote: Val is human, and the club is in a far from perfect state.

Whilst for me there are a few things counting against him - notably his predictability during game management, team selection over recent weeks, the fact that we seem to have effectively lost some players (Snodgrass and Phillips, the latter of whom really hasn't contributed enough for me as a senior player) and most notably the seemingly blind faith in a thoroughly decent but clearly underperforming captain - there are a few things to his credit. He is giving the youngsters a chance, he seems to be partially succeeding in getting a tune out of Grant, Robbo (when he plays him) and his trying to work with Diangana. And to be fair, we are still in touch.

But for me, the squad isn't really good enough to consider ourselves promotion candidates elect. And I think that Val is hamstrung by this, especially against the expectation that we all say we don't have when we are lying at the foot of the EPL and want to start over again, bomb them all out, start from the ground up etc., but seem to magically regain the inverse attitude again by the curtain opener in mid-August.

Under Big Dave, I think the squad clearly was head-and-shoulders good enough, and Slav just about proved this the following year. But this time around I am not so sure. I think that some of the transfer crimes of the past have caught up with us, severely impacted upon the budget (and consequently the team selection) to the extent Val has had to work with what he's got, to a more counterproductive extent than either Slav or Big Dave had to.

Add to that the TD woes and the ensuing shambles that occurred which actually led to Val, and it appears that he really wasn't joining all that steady a ship.

So in effect, he's had far less wriggle room, and I think it was an easier job for both of the previous Chump managers than it is for Val. I think both Slav and Big Dave had more than enough quality at their disposal to mask their shortcomings short-term. To me, a fine squad in terms of not just numbers (we've seldom enjoyed a huge roster of players) but quality in addition, not only makes it harder to get points on the board, but to bring those youngsters in confidently also.

Losing two key defensive players early on hasn't helped much, and seems to coincide with when we appeared to lose our guile. Also a couple of players haven't returned with quite the same form.

But I do think that - had Val had either BD or Slav's squad to inherit, we wouldn't be quite so impatient with it all now. Impossible to say of course, but to me the imperfections of the manager are not necessarily the biggest factor at play here. It would be much fairer to judge his work when he has a few more of his own tools to work with, and I doubt replacing him now would result in a candidate with fewer imperfections any more than it would fix what remains wrong behind the scenes.

Val with either the squad that Big Dave or Bilic had would have got us up. We'd have been fitter and more organised, the last promotion was down to the wealth of attacking talent we had and in spite of Bilic' inability to organise the team defensively.

Correct
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: 1 Guest(s)