First post in a while….
#51
I think Val thought he would come in and his methods, which, let's face it, superseded all expectations last year, would just be elevated with an, undoubtedly, better squad. What he's found is that it is a different ball game (ironic pun, seeing as he only has one!) when you are expected to challenge at the top of the table, without the siege mentality, and the style of football is questioned as well as results. For that bit of inexperience I can forgive him, there's nothing wrong with believing in yourself, what is more difficult to forgive is his inability to adapt.
Yes he's tweaked the style slightly, but without any real definition, as it's all a bit hap-hazard and has actually made us worse in terms of goals scored.

The most telling and worrying stat of all for me is, as Dumbo raised, his inability to affect a game in progress. His in-game management is honestly as bad as I've seen in 40 odd years and that's not knee jerk or hysterical, it's an honest assessment of what I see. I can't think of a single change or sub, where the game has turned in our favour. Look at Derby as an example, we bought on Hugill, who was rubbish, again, but also TGH and Fellows, both of whom performed well, but never looked like turning the game and this, for me, is because changing personnel is simply not enough if the system isn't working! If you are behind with 20 minutes to go, you still have a massive chance, but not if you just do the same old thing, you have to take risks!

All the best managers have this ability to read and affect a game, I see zero evidence of Val having any of it, and that is extremely worrying, if this is truly a long term project.
Reply
#52
Just been discussing with a Liverpool fan who wants Klopp sacked.

Modern football has got really shite now. No clubs fans seem happy with their manager.
Reply
#53
Every team at this level will have gaps in quality and personnel. A manager has a responsibility to manage those gaps and come up with solutions to negate them. We are stubbornly sticking to the same tactics and formation every week. It’s too easy to play against, and that isn’t hindsight as some did point out how to stop our pressing game when we were riding high and in form a few weeks into the season.

We won’t get better the longer we stay in this division unless Lai changes tactics and the owners decide to spend more than we bring in for a season or two. 

This is simply down to results, if we go up he’s done his job, if we don’t he’s failed, the degree to that failure will determine how long his tenure is next season and beyond. 

I don’t care about styles of play or some antiquated idea of the ‘Albion’ way. However when I look at the teams around us and above us there is really no excuse not to get promotion this season. 

Long term solutions will not be found until we have an owner who doesn’t want to sell the club and wants to invest in its future. Having a manager on a four year contract doesn’t go anyway to addressing this unless results are good. It helps the manager and his pay-off if things go badly but the club doesn’t gain anything unless he’s a success. Personally think 4yrs is far too long a contract, it’s a comfort blanket that means failure to get promotion can be seen as all part of the plan, when it might just mean the start of a long road to worse results and ever weaker squads. 

The manager like all the others will stand or fall by results. He was bobbling along doing ok until recently even if performances weren’t great but the objective still has to be promotion not some hopeful rebuild over a number of seasons.
Reply
#54
Don't disagree Derek. Think that sums up my view tbh.
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: 1 Guest(s)