Posts: 9,321
Threads: 720
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
9
(01-03-2022, 04:43 PM)Cuzer Wrote: Ronnie, you're an intelligent bloke and know your onions
Do you not see the opposition are completely changing how they play against us since Luton, Sheff Utd etc? Milwall and Peterborough were the two to start it and I'm pretty sure I'm right in saying with the exception of Blackpool, where we created loads, and Fulham who are a good side, every team we've played has gone 3 centre halves against us and matched us up?
Now, you're right to say the onus is on us to change our approach and to me we have, initially VI was all about press, harry, husstle, win the ball high, make it unfomfortable for the opposition however now we get 50-60% possession pretty much every game, sides sit off us, give our three front players no space to run in behind and allow our midfield two and wing backs to have the ball as our creativity is pretty poor from these areas
We are a lot more patient in our build up, certainly play more football than Barnsley ever did, the general feeling of the Cov fans I was with when we went there was Albion were the best side to go their this season, for me we're not a million miles away, Dike will help massively and if we can get a central midfielder in to work with Mowatt this will help our creativity. I'd also like to see Phillips given a go at RWB, especially at home
I've never known our fan base so split and unsuportive as we are currently, this isn't just down to Val for me, it's anger at last season, bringing Sam in who was unpopular, getting rid of Bilic without backing, overlooking Wilder due to Lai then not backing Val in the summer, bringing in tripe like Hugill, average players such as Reach and Moloumby, we all see the league is shite and we all see we're struggling in 4th when we really should be in the top 2
Part of me feels for Val as he's never quite had the backing of the fans, we liked it early but as soon as we drew a few we quickly got frustrated and our support level dwindled, in volume if not in numbers
I've had a lot of frustrations this season and at times I've been unhappy but I'm still behind Val, let's judge at the end of this window and next season whatever league we're in when he's had a full summer and a window to get players in he wants. Defensively we're decent, we've a keeper who doesn't really want to be here and we should cash in, we now have a number 9 and a saleable asset moving forward given his age and potential, we have some good youth players who Val has shown will get opportunities, we have all sides throughout the club playing the same system, a lot of positives are overlooked, it's hard at times but keep the faith would be my message
Cuzer
Good post Cuzer. Still quietly confident we can go up (probably through the play-offs being realistic - but let's see who we sign and what difference Dike makes) but if not we move a few dinosaurs on and bring in young hungry players.
Posts: 5,322
Threads: 356
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
16
(01-03-2022, 04:24 PM)RonnieWallwork Wrote: (01-03-2022, 04:19 PM)wba13 Wrote: I can’t be bothered with some fans negativity, agreed some don’t like his style but in a lot of cases it’s those same fans who loved us at the start of the season, we have to give Ismael a chance to show how is style works once he has all the correct players he wants in the right positions. This will not be until at least after next Summer’s transfer window. I think Dyke will be a big asset into how Ismael wants to play up front.agreed we need a creative spark in midfield things will also improve once O’Shea is back.
Sheffield Utd game was excellent.
Luton game was excellent until that huge delay.
No issue - thoroughly enjoyed the intensity. Not seen it since. Same players. Same manager. Same crowd.
In the Sheff U and Luton games, the opposition's defending from set pieces was appalling, 5 of the 7 goals we scored would embarrass a sunday pub team.
And I think it led fans into a false belief we would score loads of goals this season.
There are plenty of games since then where we have struggled to score, but dominated in the same way that we did against Sheff u and Luton.
The lack of goalscorers throughout the squad is our biggest weakness and has been for some time now.
Posts: 9,321
Threads: 720
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
9
(01-03-2022, 07:50 PM)Shabby Russian Wrote: (01-03-2022, 04:24 PM)RonnieWallwork Wrote: (01-03-2022, 04:19 PM)wba13 Wrote: I can’t be bothered with some fans negativity, agreed some don’t like his style but in a lot of cases it’s those same fans who loved us at the start of the season, we have to give Ismael a chance to show how is style works once he has all the correct players he wants in the right positions. This will not be until at least after next Summer’s transfer window. I think Dyke will be a big asset into how Ismael wants to play up front.agreed we need a creative spark in midfield things will also improve once O’Shea is back.
Sheffield Utd game was excellent.
Luton game was excellent until that huge delay.
No issue - thoroughly enjoyed the intensity. Not seen it since. Same players. Same manager. Same crowd.
In the Sheff U and Luton games, the opposition's defending from set pieces was appalling, 5 of the 7 goals we scored would embarrass a sunday pub team.
And I think it led fans into a false belief we would score loads of goals this season.
There are plenty of games since then where we have struggled to score, but dominated in the same way that we did against Sheff u and Luton.
The lack of goalscorers throughout the squad is our biggest weakness and has been for some time now.
You say that but Grant, Robinson, Diang. Mowatt, Zohore and Hugill have all scored goals in the championship.
Grant has chipped in fair do's but should have more including missing that pen, Robinson's return has been appalling and Hugill has been a disaster but on clear-cut chances alone he should be on 6/7. Mowatt hasn't scored as many as he should have and hasn't been right since his injury and Diang has just completely lost his way. Even Zohore scored a load for Cardiff.
Posts: 3,396
Threads: 176
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
9
01-03-2022, 08:07 PM
(This post was last modified: 01-03-2022, 08:10 PM by TartanRug.)
Good post from Cuzer.
The fact is that for quite a few games all that has been missing is a finish/finisher, score a reasonable proportion of these and we'd probably be top 2 now.
I'd add that not winning games we should have won has more than likely affected confidence leading to some of the poor displays we see now
Posts: 19,492
Threads: 824
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
60
01-03-2022, 08:26 PM
(This post was last modified: 01-03-2022, 08:28 PM by SW4Baggie.)
The vast majority of this squad has been here for 3 or more managers - in Livermore and Phillips' case I think it's now 6. During that time we've lurched from the diabolical anti-football of Pulis to the chaos of Pardew, the misguided hybrid of Moore-Jones, the swashbuckling to aimless nothingness of Bilic, and then Fat Sam's "improvement"
In just over 4 years we've played every type of football imaginable, and in the meantime we've made just over 50 transfers with almost 50% of them being on loan - that's almost 7 players a season on loan... over the last 5 summers, 37 players have been signed and sold - over two thirds of our players have been moved on less than 3 years after signing - either through being a loan or a short term fix.
Eventually, especially at a club like ours, we have to accept the need for some stability. We need to look at players we can bed in for more than a season at a time and with that commit to a style. I appreciate the need to get results immediately, but overhauling squads and paying off players who no longer fit the mould costs money which reduces the quality of replacement we can afford.
I have serious concerns about Val, but with no DoF, and with no footballing experience in senior positions in the club we need stability in the dug out and need to see how this plays out.
Posts: 324
Threads: 8
Joined: Feb 2019
Reputation:
0
(01-03-2022, 08:26 PM)SW4Baggie Wrote: The vast majority of this squad has been here for 3 or more managers - in Livermore and Phillips' case I think it's now 6. During that time we've lurched from the diabolical anti-football of Pulis to the chaos of Pardew, the misguided hybrid of Moore-Jones, the swashbuckling to aimless nothingness of Bilic, and then Fat Sam's "improvement"
In just over 4 years we've played every type of football imaginable, and in the meantime we've made just over 50 transfers with almost 50% of them being on loan - that's almost 7 players a season on loan... over the last 5 summers, 37 players have been signed and sold - over two thirds of our players have been moved on less than 3 years after signing - either through being a loan or a short term fix.
Eventually, especially at a club like ours, we have to accept the need for some stability. We need to look at players we can bed in for more than a season at a time and with that commit to a style. I appreciate the need to get results immediately, but overhauling squads and paying off players who no longer fit the mould costs money which reduces the quality of replacement we can afford.
I have serious concerns about Val, but with no DoF, and with no footballing experience in senior positions in the club we need stability in the dug out and need to see how this plays out.
Great post.
Posts: 1,816
Threads: 69
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
5
(01-03-2022, 05:05 PM)Cheshire East Baggie Wrote: (01-03-2022, 04:43 PM)Cuzer Wrote: Ronnie, you're an intelligent bloke and know your onions
Do you not see the opposition are completely changing how they play against us since Luton, Sheff Utd etc? Milwall and Peterborough were the two to start it and I'm pretty sure I'm right in saying with the exception of Blackpool, where we created loads, and Fulham who are a good side, every team we've played has gone 3 centre halves against us and matched us up?
Now, you're right to say the onus is on us to change our approach and to me we have, initially VI was all about press, harry, husstle, win the ball high, make it unfomfortable for the opposition however now we get 50-60% possession pretty much every game, sides sit off us, give our three front players no space to run in behind and allow our midfield two and wing backs to have the ball as our creativity is pretty poor from these areas
We are a lot more patient in our build up, certainly play more football than Barnsley ever did, the general feeling of the Cov fans I was with when we went there was Albion were the best side to go their this season, for me we're not a million miles away, Dike will help massively and if we can get a central midfielder in to work with Mowatt this will help our creativity. I'd also like to see Phillips given a go at RWB, especially at home
I've never known our fan base so split and unsuportive as we are currently, this isn't just down to Val for me, it's anger at last season, bringing Sam in who was unpopular, getting rid of Bilic without backing, overlooking Wilder due to Lai then not backing Val in the summer, bringing in tripe like Hugill, average players such as Reach and Moloumby, we all see the league is shite and we all see we're struggling in 4th when we really should be in the top 2
Part of me feels for Val as he's never quite had the backing of the fans, we liked it early but as soon as we drew a few we quickly got frustrated and our support level dwindled, in volume if not in numbers
I've had a lot of frustrations this season and at times I've been unhappy but I'm still behind Val, let's judge at the end of this window and next season whatever league we're in when he's had a full summer and a window to get players in he wants. Defensively we're decent, we've a keeper who doesn't really want to be here and we should cash in, we now have a number 9 and a saleable asset moving forward given his age and potential, we have some good youth players who Val has shown will get opportunities, we have all sides throughout the club playing the same system, a lot of positives are overlooked, it's hard at times but keep the faith would be my message
Cuzer
That's a very positive interpretation of the current situation. We should all be positive. But I don't quite fit the profile you've outlined above.
I didn't much like Bilic - I didn't see much of the good stuff 'cos it wasn't easily available, but watching the Baggies post-lockdown was appalling. I wouldn't have backed him with more cash for signings. He should have been fired before the Premier League season started.
I didn't object to the appointment of Sam. I thought the players were unprofessional at best, and Allardyce turned out to be past it in every way, which with hindsight was a big risk to take.
I wasn't sold on Wilder, but I'll admit that the block by Lai was unusual and unhelpful.
I think Reach is quality, and would like to see him play more. Molumby has potential and should get more game time ahead of Livermore. In a side note about midfield, I'm struggling to see Mowatt as the answer to anything much, it's all a bit "emperor's new clothes" for me.
Which forwards (apart from Dike) were we chasing? Yes, Hugill turned out to be a turkey, but what else was on the menu?
Where am I heading with this waffle? I'm heading towards the Wallwork/Ferenc point of view. My dissatisfaction with Ismael is based on what I've seen him do, not on a cocktail of gripes with the club's behaviour over the last couple of years. He's on trial as far as I'm concerned, he needs to get better results out of these players and soon.
Some really good posts on here tonight. I do wonder if Val thought when he arrived that he could get a better tune out of some of the players than he has in reality and knowing he would have to wait for Dike only went for a couple of additions.
What I find frustrating is the lack of in game flexibility to work out a way of combating teams that match us up.
Our achilles heal (as well as a striker) is our midfield and lack of leader. I don’t really rate any of them and agree with the comment that we need a Molumbu rather than an Okay. If we did sign ok I would put him in the back 3 and he would be the defender to play out with the ball.
I’m not a big Reach fan but feel sorry that he and Molumby have been dropped after doing better than the players they replace.
Townsend has regressed rapidly and is no way a wing back. What we need in this side is a Clement, Johnson and Balis.
It looks like SJ is also off and I wonder if his recent form may be down to off the field shenanigans.
Finally, not appointing a Director of Football is a strange decision and gives VI too much control on recruitment.
I’m not enjoying this season at all but am willing to see where we are at the end of the window. The worry is we’ve performed poorly against 3 poor teams and are falling back into the chasing pack.
My hope is that Lai has found a bit more cash down the back of his sofa for a few more players.
Posts: 2,843
Threads: 197
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
6
I'd be behind Val if he didn't keep selecting Livermore & Mowatt when they're both available. When Livermore's been unable to play and it's been Mowatt and Molumby we've been a different side.
I don't understand why he can't/refuses to see it.
Anyway for the next 3 games he'll have to come up with something different. If results improve and he then reverts to Livermore & Mowatt then that will tell us all we need to know.
Posts: 17,074
Threads: 614
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
114
(01-03-2022, 09:35 PM)Jack Halford Wrote: (01-03-2022, 05:05 PM)Cheshire East Baggie Wrote: (01-03-2022, 04:43 PM)Cuzer Wrote: Ronnie, you're an intelligent bloke and know your onions
Do you not see the opposition are completely changing how they play against us since Luton, Sheff Utd etc? Milwall and Peterborough were the two to start it and I'm pretty sure I'm right in saying with the exception of Blackpool, where we created loads, and Fulham who are a good side, every team we've played has gone 3 centre halves against us and matched us up?
Now, you're right to say the onus is on us to change our approach and to me we have, initially VI was all about press, harry, husstle, win the ball high, make it unfomfortable for the opposition however now we get 50-60% possession pretty much every game, sides sit off us, give our three front players no space to run in behind and allow our midfield two and wing backs to have the ball as our creativity is pretty poor from these areas
We are a lot more patient in our build up, certainly play more football than Barnsley ever did, the general feeling of the Cov fans I was with when we went there was Albion were the best side to go their this season, for me we're not a million miles away, Dike will help massively and if we can get a central midfielder in to work with Mowatt this will help our creativity. I'd also like to see Phillips given a go at RWB, especially at home
I've never known our fan base so split and unsuportive as we are currently, this isn't just down to Val for me, it's anger at last season, bringing Sam in who was unpopular, getting rid of Bilic without backing, overlooking Wilder due to Lai then not backing Val in the summer, bringing in tripe like Hugill, average players such as Reach and Moloumby, we all see the league is shite and we all see we're struggling in 4th when we really should be in the top 2
Part of me feels for Val as he's never quite had the backing of the fans, we liked it early but as soon as we drew a few we quickly got frustrated and our support level dwindled, in volume if not in numbers
I've had a lot of frustrations this season and at times I've been unhappy but I'm still behind Val, let's judge at the end of this window and next season whatever league we're in when he's had a full summer and a window to get players in he wants. Defensively we're decent, we've a keeper who doesn't really want to be here and we should cash in, we now have a number 9 and a saleable asset moving forward given his age and potential, we have some good youth players who Val has shown will get opportunities, we have all sides throughout the club playing the same system, a lot of positives are overlooked, it's hard at times but keep the faith would be my message
Cuzer
That's a very positive interpretation of the current situation. We should all be positive. But I don't quite fit the profile you've outlined above.
I didn't much like Bilic - I didn't see much of the good stuff 'cos it wasn't easily available, but watching the Baggies post-lockdown was appalling. I wouldn't have backed him with more cash for signings. He should have been fired before the Premier League season started.
I didn't object to the appointment of Sam. I thought the players were unprofessional at best, and Allardyce turned out to be past it in every way, which with hindsight was a big risk to take.
I wasn't sold on Wilder, but I'll admit that the block by Lai was unusual and unhelpful.
I think Reach is quality, and would like to see him play more. Molumby has potential and should get more game time ahead of Livermore. In a side note about midfield, I'm struggling to see Mowatt as the answer to anything much, it's all a bit "emperor's new clothes" for me.
Which forwards (apart from Dike) were we chasing? Yes, Hugill turned out to be a turkey, but what else was on the menu?
Where am I heading with this waffle? I'm heading towards the Wallwork/Ferenc point of view. My dissatisfaction with Ismael is based on what I've seen him do, not on a cocktail of gripes with the club's behaviour over the last couple of years. He's on trial as far as I'm concerned, he needs to get better results out of these players and soon.
Some really good posts on here tonight. I do wonder if Val thought when he arrived that he could get a better tune out of some of the players than he has in reality and knowing he would have to wait for Dike only went for a couple of additions.
What I find frustrating is the lack of in game flexibility to work out a way of combating teams that match us up.
Our achilles heal (as well as a striker) is our midfield and lack of leader. I don’t really rate any of them and agree with the comment that we need a Molumbu rather than an Okay. If we did sign ok I would put him in the back 3 and he would be the defender to play out with the ball.
I’m not a big Reach fan but feel sorry that he and Molumby have been dropped after doing better than the players they replace.
Townsend has regressed rapidly and is no way a wing back. What we need in this side is a Clement, Johnson and Balis.
It looks like SJ is also off and I wonder if his recent form may be down to off the field shenanigans.
Finally, not appointing a Director of Football is a strange decision and gives VI too much control on recruitment.
I’m not enjoying this season at all but am willing to see where we are at the end of the window. The worry is we’ve performed poorly against 3 poor teams and are falling back into the chasing pack.
My hope is that Lai has found a bit more cash down the back of his sofa for a few more players.
We already have a decent squad, far better than those around us bar Fulham and to a lesser extent Bournemouth. This is about the manager utilising his squad and getting the best out of the squad he has. Currently we are is it one place off where Val finished with Barnsley last season with a poorer squad.
Posts: 3,396
Threads: 176
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
9
(01-03-2022, 09:50 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: (01-03-2022, 09:35 PM)Jack Halford Wrote: (01-03-2022, 05:05 PM)Cheshire East Baggie Wrote: (01-03-2022, 04:43 PM)Cuzer Wrote: Ronnie, you're an intelligent bloke and know your onions
Do you not see the opposition are completely changing how they play against us since Luton, Sheff Utd etc? Milwall and Peterborough were the two to start it and I'm pretty sure I'm right in saying with the exception of Blackpool, where we created loads, and Fulham who are a good side, every team we've played has gone 3 centre halves against us and matched us up?
Now, you're right to say the onus is on us to change our approach and to me we have, initially VI was all about press, harry, husstle, win the ball high, make it unfomfortable for the opposition however now we get 50-60% possession pretty much every game, sides sit off us, give our three front players no space to run in behind and allow our midfield two and wing backs to have the ball as our creativity is pretty poor from these areas
We are a lot more patient in our build up, certainly play more football than Barnsley ever did, the general feeling of the Cov fans I was with when we went there was Albion were the best side to go their this season, for me we're not a million miles away, Dike will help massively and if we can get a central midfielder in to work with Mowatt this will help our creativity. I'd also like to see Phillips given a go at RWB, especially at home
I've never known our fan base so split and unsuportive as we are currently, this isn't just down to Val for me, it's anger at last season, bringing Sam in who was unpopular, getting rid of Bilic without backing, overlooking Wilder due to Lai then not backing Val in the summer, bringing in tripe like Hugill, average players such as Reach and Moloumby, we all see the league is shite and we all see we're struggling in 4th when we really should be in the top 2
Part of me feels for Val as he's never quite had the backing of the fans, we liked it early but as soon as we drew a few we quickly got frustrated and our support level dwindled, in volume if not in numbers
I've had a lot of frustrations this season and at times I've been unhappy but I'm still behind Val, let's judge at the end of this window and next season whatever league we're in when he's had a full summer and a window to get players in he wants. Defensively we're decent, we've a keeper who doesn't really want to be here and we should cash in, we now have a number 9 and a saleable asset moving forward given his age and potential, we have some good youth players who Val has shown will get opportunities, we have all sides throughout the club playing the same system, a lot of positives are overlooked, it's hard at times but keep the faith would be my message
Cuzer
That's a very positive interpretation of the current situation. We should all be positive. But I don't quite fit the profile you've outlined above.
I didn't much like Bilic - I didn't see much of the good stuff 'cos it wasn't easily available, but watching the Baggies post-lockdown was appalling. I wouldn't have backed him with more cash for signings. He should have been fired before the Premier League season started.
I didn't object to the appointment of Sam. I thought the players were unprofessional at best, and Allardyce turned out to be past it in every way, which with hindsight was a big risk to take.
I wasn't sold on Wilder, but I'll admit that the block by Lai was unusual and unhelpful.
I think Reach is quality, and would like to see him play more. Molumby has potential and should get more game time ahead of Livermore. In a side note about midfield, I'm struggling to see Mowatt as the answer to anything much, it's all a bit "emperor's new clothes" for me.
Which forwards (apart from Dike) were we chasing? Yes, Hugill turned out to be a turkey, but what else was on the menu?
Where am I heading with this waffle? I'm heading towards the Wallwork/Ferenc point of view. My dissatisfaction with Ismael is based on what I've seen him do, not on a cocktail of gripes with the club's behaviour over the last couple of years. He's on trial as far as I'm concerned, he needs to get better results out of these players and soon.
Some really good posts on here tonight. I do wonder if Val thought when he arrived that he could get a better tune out of some of the players than he has in reality and knowing he would have to wait for Dike only went for a couple of additions.
What I find frustrating is the lack of in game flexibility to work out a way of combating teams that match us up.
Our achilles heal (as well as a striker) is our midfield and lack of leader. I don’t really rate any of them and agree with the comment that we need a Molumbu rather than an Okay. If we did sign ok I would put him in the back 3 and he would be the defender to play out with the ball.
I’m not a big Reach fan but feel sorry that he and Molumby have been dropped after doing better than the players they replace.
Townsend has regressed rapidly and is no way a wing back. What we need in this side is a Clement, Johnson and Balis.
It looks like SJ is also off and I wonder if his recent form may be down to off the field shenanigans.
Finally, not appointing a Director of Football is a strange decision and gives VI too much control on recruitment.
I’m not enjoying this season at all but am willing to see where we are at the end of the window. The worry is we’ve performed poorly against 3 poor teams and are falling back into the chasing pack.
My hope is that Lai has found a bit more cash down the back of his sofa for a few more players.
We already have a decent squad, far better than those around us bar Fulham and to a lesser extent Bournemouth. This is about the manager utilising his squad and getting the best out of the squad he has. Currently we are is it one place off where Val finished with Barnsley last season with a poorer squad.
We might have a decent squad compared to most others but it's unbalanced, where is the creativity coming from now Pereira has gone, up until Dike arrived where is the out and out striker? Without these we'll have problems breaking teams down.
|