Penalty - A Cardiff view....
#21
Personally dont think it was a red card challenge.

Penalty, looked like one, but would like to see a slow motion on the incident to see how much contact there was.

Also not seen a definitive camera angle on Robinson goal, is there one?
Reply
#22
Quest showed it clearly off
Reply
#23
(01-03-2022, 12:12 PM)KRO Wrote: Quest showed it clearly off

It was briefly shown on the big screens at the ground as well. You could see then he was off. Not sure if 4th official might have seen that?
Reply
#24
(01-03-2022, 11:50 AM)Shabby Russian Wrote: Personally dont think it was a red card challenge.

Penalty, looked like one, but would like to see a slow motion on the incident to see how much contact there was.

Also not seen a definitive camera angle on Robinson goal, is there one?

It's an orange card, one of those where you can rightly feel aggrieved at it being given but there's little point in it being appealed. Did think the Cardiff player pretending his leg needed to be amputated had an effect, referee went over first to check on him before sending Mowatt off.

There isn't a definitive camera angle for Robbo's goal as there's defenders missing from the picture, but the two there are show he's in front of the last man when the ball is played. Pretty telling that they didn't replay it in the ground as well.

There's this for the big penalty shout at the end, looks pretty clear cut to me. Also could see Townsend's shirt pulled back at his collar from where I sit in the Brummie. Want to see the Kipré and Diangana ones again as well though, especially the Diangana one where afterwards he was muscled off by Flint after being put off-balance by a stupid challenge.
Reply
#25
Definite pen, but he did make a meal of it.
Reply
#26
(01-03-2022, 01:24 PM)Kit Kat Chunky Wrote: Definite pen, but he did make a meal of it.

As he should, because a penalty may well have provided us with a win.
Reply
#27
Surely both Red's at the end are to be rescinded, all it looks like is Johnson and Flint holding each other and shouting at each other, no head buts, no punches thrown, absolute joke from the ref to put two reds down for that

Cuzer
Fisheatingdeludedsealwankers
Reply
#28
Ref never had control of the game at all. Allowed some quite frankly ridiculous stuff from Cardiff. Which wound some of our players up. Mowatts red was stupid, and could argue deserved for sure. However he's the type of player who if it's being given to him and his team-mates, he's going to give it back.

We were bullied yesterday, it's going to happen, but the ref was absolutely pathetic in every way.
Reply
#29
(01-03-2022, 12:47 AM)baggie_ray Wrote: Ishmael - caused the ruck then got out of there when the fists started flying   Big Grin
Sounds like a Robbie Savage impersonator.

(01-03-2022, 01:45 PM)Birdman1811 Wrote: Ref never had control of the game at all. Allowed some quite frankly ridiculous stuff from Cardiff. Which wound some of our players up. Mowatts red was stupid, and could argue deserved for sure. However he's the type of player who if it's being given to him and his team-mates, he's going to give it back.

We were bullied yesterday, it's going to happen, but the ref was absolutely pathetic in every way.

Ref standards seem to be absolutely rubbish now.
Reply
#30
Borin' Baggie Wrote:
Shabby Russian Wrote:Personally dont think it was a red card challenge.

Penalty, looked like one, but would like to see a slow motion on the incident to see how much contact there was.

Also not seen a definitive camera angle on Robinson goal, is there one?

It's an orange card, one of those where you can rightly feel aggrieved at it being given but there's little point in it being appealed. Did think the Cardiff player pretending his leg needed to be amputated had an effect, referee went over first to check on him before sending Mowatt off.

There isn't a definitive camera angle for Robbo's goal as there's defenders missing from the picture, but the two there are show he's in front of the last man when the ball is played. Pretty telling that they didn't replay it in the ground as well.

There's this for the big penalty shout at the end, looks pretty clear cut to me. Also could see Townsend's shirt pulled back at his collar from where I sit in the Brummie. Want to see the Kipré and Diangana ones again as well though, especially the Diangana one where afterwards he was muscled off by Flint after being put off-balance by a stupid challenge.

Yes, that one. A clumsy challenge cost him a split second in getting to the lesser challenge (which wasn't a pen). If he had gone down on the 1st challenge it would have been a possible pen. Personally, after Diang dropping whenever he feels a shadow cast over him, I'm for once glad he tried to stay upright.
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: 1 Guest(s)