Penalty - A Cardiff view....
#11
(01-02-2022, 07:55 PM)Peachy Wrote:
(01-02-2022, 07:51 PM)MassDebater Wrote: I suppose if the FA / EFL decides to ban him a few games then at least we know it won't make a blind bit of difference to what happens on the pitch.

It could have a positive effect!  Big Grin

Sadly I don't think bans prevent the manager picking the team! Big Grin

'i'm int eh stands today assistant blokey, you know what to do?'
'Yes boss, meaningless 60th minute substitute'
'Hugill'
'Of course, we all know that!'

(Yes I realise he never got bought on today).
Reply
#12
Only Albion could moan about the officials despite only scraping a point through an offside goal.
Reply
#13
(01-02-2022, 07:07 PM)MassDebater Wrote: Fair play him admitting it was a penalty, pretty clear that the ref felt bad about our offside goal...

As for SJ, the twat threw a punch, there is no way on Earth that his will be overturned, if anything the FA may extend it(if they can do so?). not sure if their player did anything other than pushing and shoving.

Watched it back on quest & it showed no sign of s punch being thrown. 

I think we will & should appeal it, handbags, yellows.
Reply
#14
(01-02-2022, 07:07 PM)MassDebater Wrote: Fair play him admitting it was a penalty, pretty clear that the ref felt bad about our offside goal...

As for SJ, the twat threw a punch, there is no way on Earth that his will be overturned, if anything the FA may extend it(if they can do so?). not sure if their player did anything other than pushing and shoving.

Ingerlund's No 1 (puncher)

(01-02-2022, 07:47 PM)MassDebater Wrote:
(01-02-2022, 07:45 PM)Peachy Wrote:
(01-02-2022, 07:29 PM)Cheshire East Baggie Wrote: Yes, Steve Morison's comments went a long way towards putting the ref in the frame. Many managers would have declined to comment. Doesn't absolve Val and SJ of blame for their stupidity. Will the EFL (or is it the FA that do these things???) charge Ismael for his "pitch invasion", which surely raised the temperature more than a little?

I don't think they'll charge Val. He marched on, was stopped 30 yards from the ref, waived his arms then left the pitch. Watching it back the players were kicking off despite Val walking on. They didn't need any encouragement....

It kind of came out of nothing, was very confusing. Yes, it was a clear penalty, but FFS you don't start throwing punches because of it.

No idea what Six was thinking, didn't Slav get sent off for calmly speaking to the ref and crossing the pitch to get to the changing rooms at half time once?

Everton away - Mike -I'm the star of the show -Dean.  He wanted to know why Everton's first goal - which was a blatant foul wasn't disallowed.
Reply
#15
Ishmael - caused the ruck then got out of there when the fists started flying   Big Grin
Reply
#16
I can see both clubs getting a 5k fine for failure to control their players. It's about right. Val shouldn't have marched on. But in all of this carnage (which was no doubt due to feeling the pressures), the referee from start to finish was an absolute charlatan.
Bartley carded for a foul, correctly IMO, but their guy wasn't. For an identical offence.
Kipre getting hauled down in their penalty area.
Allowing sheer shithousery AOTS.
Our goal looked offside (I may be wrong on this).
Mowatts was a yellow all day but their guy lay there like he'd been shot.
The foul on Diangana in the box.
The last minute most obvious penalty ever not given.
Plus all the other inconsistencies about positioning throw ins and free kicks and allowing players to fall on the ball to win a free kick. 
A ref like that is going to cause problems at any level. He was awful for both teams although we clearly came out of it worse.
Reply
#17
(01-03-2022, 11:19 AM)Tom Joad Wrote: I can see both clubs getting a 5k fine for failure to control their players. It's about right. Val shouldn't have marched on. But in all of this carnage (which was no doubt due to feeling the pressures), the referee from start to finish was an absolute charlatan.
Bartley carded for a foul, correctly IMO, but their guy wasn't. For an identical offence.
Kipre getting hauled down in their penalty area.
Allowing sheer shithousery AOTS.
Our goal looked offside (I may be wrong on this).
Mowatts was a yellow all day but their guy lay there like he'd been shot.
The foul on Diangana in the box.
The last minute most obvious penalty ever not given.
Plus all the other inconsistencies about positioning throw ins and free kicks and allowing players to fall on the ball to win a free kick. 
A ref like that is going to cause problems at any level. He was awful for both teams although we clearly came out of it worse.

By asking the first kick off to be re-taken, he set his stall out. At that precise moment we knew we had a twat in charge.
Reply
#18
(01-02-2022, 11:52 PM)B36baggie Wrote:
(01-02-2022, 07:07 PM)MassDebater Wrote: Fair play him admitting it was a penalty, pretty clear that the ref felt bad about our offside goal...

As for SJ, the twat threw a punch, there is no way on Earth that his will be overturned, if anything the FA may extend it(if they can do so?). not sure if their player did anything other than pushing and shoving.

Watched it back on quest & it showed no sign of s punch being thrown. 

I think we will & should appeal it, handbags, yellows.

Not seen any replays, and Christ fair play to anyone that has! But at the time on the match fred I said SJ just threw a punch... In real time it definitely looked like he threw one.
Reply
#19
We had another Pratt again yesterday. Some of the players were crap, but he was worse. The standard is dire.
I actually thought Mowatt was a red, but I reckon he didn't give you a pen because he'd been told your equaliser was offside. That's shameful. When you've got your arms all over a players shoulders and he's got the ball and goes down, it's a penalty
Reply
#20
Yep ,if it had been given against us I would have had no complaints .
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: