We must be realistic
#21
(01-02-2022, 06:34 PM)wbamitch Wrote: Also, how is the side going to look drastically different in 2 windows time? Grant, Robinson & Grady are on long term contracts, is anyone going to sign these guys off us? He rewarded Furlong, Bartley and Matt Phillips with new contracts soon after arriving. Those hoping for wholesale changes are going to be a bit disappointed I think

I guess it comes down to having something to cling onto in that hope that something will improve? At least that's all I can imagine it is.

Those 3 I think most teams in this league would love to have, just not playing how they are being played.
Reply
#22
(01-02-2022, 04:51 PM)Lurker#3 Wrote:
(01-02-2022, 04:48 PM)Cheshire East Baggie Wrote: A better coach would get better results out of these players. Which is easier, change one coach or change 15 players?

Even if that was the case , which I don't think it is. It would only be a sticky plaster. 

As I say. 4 managers, all with varying styles  but we still end up with a tepid, medium block, with no power and desire.

Exactly some of these players have under performed for at least the last 4 managers constantly going missing when things get tough thats our real problem. As for Livermore as nice a guy as he may be but what has he actually done or achieved since we signed him one 4month purple patch under Bijc is a i can think off.
Reply
#23
(01-02-2022, 06:37 PM)MassDebater Wrote:
(01-02-2022, 06:34 PM)wbamitch Wrote: Also, how is the side going to look drastically different in 2 windows time? Grant, Robinson & Grady are on long term contracts, is anyone going to sign these guys off us? He rewarded Furlong, Bartley and Matt Phillips with new contracts soon after arriving. Those hoping for wholesale changes are going to be a bit disappointed I think

I guess it comes down to having something to cling onto in that hope that something will improve? At least that's all I can imagine it is.

Those 3 I think most teams in this league would love to have, just not playing how they are being played.

There are goals in Grant, Robinson and Grady... and adding Dike to the party means there is absolutely no excuse for us not scoring... even Phillips would get into most sides in the Championship.

Unfortunately we are incredibly poor out wide... Furlong and Townsend are not attacking enough - they don't get forward fast enough and the quality of their crossing isn't good enough or consistent enough.... but, we have to keep going wide due to a complete lack of progressive runners from midfield.

I hear the clamour for Yokuslu but he's another player do not need in our midfield, we need someone who can put his foot on a ball and pick a pass - the three times we played through the middle today Robinson and Grady got into one on ones, and either fluffed them or were pulled down and should have won a penalty... we don't do this enough. 

We need a direct wide player (Phillips !!) and someone with a bit more ability on the ball to partner Mowatt or TGH in the middle. I think I'd be sending Molumby back in May to fund it.
Reply
#24
(01-02-2022, 07:03 PM)SW4Baggie Wrote:
(01-02-2022, 06:37 PM)MassDebater Wrote:
(01-02-2022, 06:34 PM)wbamitch Wrote: Also, how is the side going to look drastically different in 2 windows time? Grant, Robinson & Grady are on long term contracts, is anyone going to sign these guys off us? He rewarded Furlong, Bartley and Matt Phillips with new contracts soon after arriving. Those hoping for wholesale changes are going to be a bit disappointed I think

I guess it comes down to having something to cling onto in that hope that something will improve? At least that's all I can imagine it is.

Those 3 I think most teams in this league would love to have, just not playing how they are being played.

There are goals in Grant, Robinson and Grady... and adding Dike to the party means there is absolutely no excuse for us not scoring... even Phillips would get into most sides in the Championship.

Unfortunately we are incredibly poor out wide... Furlong and Townsend are not attacking enough - they don't get forward fast enough and the quality of their crossing isn't good enough or consistent enough.... but, we have to keep going wide due to a complete lack of progressive runners from midfield.

I hear the clamour for Yokuslu but he's another player do not need in our midfield, we need someone who can put his foot on a ball and pick a pass - the three times we played through the middle today Robinson and Grady got into one on ones, and either fluffed them or were pulled down and should have won a penalty... we don't do this enough. 

We need a direct wide player (Phillips !!) and someone with a bit more ability on the ball to partner Mowatt or TGH in the middle. I think I'd be sending Molumby back in May to fund it.

Will be interesting to see if Six allows our natural wide players a chance to play in their position when Dike is (hopefully) storming through the middle. or if he persists on making wingers play as strikers.
Reply
#25
(01-02-2022, 07:03 PM)SW4Baggie Wrote:
(01-02-2022, 06:37 PM)MassDebater Wrote:
(01-02-2022, 06:34 PM)wbamitch Wrote: Also, how is the side going to look drastically different in 2 windows time? Grant, Robinson & Grady are on long term contracts, is anyone going to sign these guys off us? He rewarded Furlong, Bartley and Matt Phillips with new contracts soon after arriving. Those hoping for wholesale changes are going to be a bit disappointed I think

I guess it comes down to having something to cling onto in that hope that something will improve? At least that's all I can imagine it is.

Those 3 I think most teams in this league would love to have, just not playing how they are being played.

There are goals in Grant, Robinson and Grady... and adding Dike to the party means there is absolutely no excuse for us not scoring... even Phillips would get into most sides in the Championship.

Unfortunately we are incredibly poor out wide... Furlong and Townsend are not attacking enough - they don't get forward fast enough and the quality of their crossing isn't good enough or consistent enough.... but, we have to keep going wide due to a complete lack of progressive runners from midfield.

I hear the clamour for Yokuslu but he's another player do not need in our midfield, we need someone who can put his foot on a ball and pick a pass - the three times we played through the middle today Robinson and Grady got into one on ones, and either fluffed them or were pulled down and should have won a penalty... we don't do this enough. 

We need a direct wide player (Phillips !!) and someone with a bit more ability on the ball to partner Mowatt or TGH in the middle. I think I'd be sending Molumby back in May to fund it.

Agree with all of that. The problem for me is I don’t think that’s how the manager sees it. Each time someone has done well in midfield (TGH, Molumby at times, even snodgrass vs Bristol) we’ve reverted back to Livermore/Mowatt straight after. The two wingbacks have both signed new contracts, he obviously likes both. He is completely unwilling to sacrifice a defender and is happy to watch matches pass us by being dominated in midfield (Stoke, Swansea). Basically we’re banking on Dike being the missing piece that brings it all together, which he may well be but what about if he gets injured. We need to have another way of playing which he seemingly doesn’t have and that is a massive worry
Reply
#26
(01-02-2022, 07:17 PM)wbamitch Wrote: Agree with all of that. The problem for me is I don’t think that’s how the manager sees it. Each time someone has done well in midfield (TGH, Molumby at times, even snodgrass vs Bristol) we’ve reverted back to Livermore/Mowatt straight after. The two wingbacks have both signed new contracts, he obviously likes both. He is completely unwilling to sacrifice a defender and is happy to watch matches pass us by being dominated in midfield (Stoke, Swansea). Basically we’re banking on Dike being the missing piece that brings it all together, which he may well be but what about if he gets injured. We need to have another way of playing which he seemingly doesn’t have and that is a massive worry

More likely will be Dike getting a red card! can't remember our discipline being this bad before.
Reply
#27
(01-02-2022, 07:34 PM)MassDebater Wrote:
(01-02-2022, 07:17 PM)wbamitch Wrote: Agree with all of that. The problem for me is I don’t think that’s how the manager sees it. Each time someone has done well in midfield (TGH, Molumby at times, even snodgrass vs Bristol) we’ve reverted back to Livermore/Mowatt straight after. The two wingbacks have both signed new contracts, he obviously likes both. He is completely unwilling to sacrifice a defender and is happy to watch matches pass us by being dominated in midfield (Stoke, Swansea). Basically we’re banking on Dike being the missing piece that brings it all together, which he may well be but what about if he gets injured. We need to have another way of playing which he seemingly doesn’t have and that is a massive worry

More likely will be Dike getting a red card! can't remember our discipline being this bad before.

Wonder what the odds are on Dike being sent off before he scores…
Reply
#28
(01-02-2022, 07:51 PM)SW4Baggie Wrote:
(01-02-2022, 07:34 PM)MassDebater Wrote:
(01-02-2022, 07:17 PM)wbamitch Wrote: Agree with all of that. The problem for me is I don’t think that’s how the manager sees it. Each time someone has done well in midfield (TGH, Molumby at times, even snodgrass vs Bristol) we’ve reverted back to Livermore/Mowatt straight after. The two wingbacks have both signed new contracts, he obviously likes both. He is completely unwilling to sacrifice a defender and is happy to watch matches pass us by being dominated in midfield (Stoke, Swansea). Basically we’re banking on Dike being the missing piece that brings it all together, which he may well be but what about if he gets injured. We need to have another way of playing which he seemingly doesn’t have and that is a massive worry

More likely will be Dike getting a red card! can't remember our discipline being this bad before.

Wonder what the odds are on Dike being sent off before he scores…

Big Grin Doesn't even bear thinking / joking about!
Reply
#29
Many questions we are never brave enough to sort out.
Phillips, Livermore have had long enough, it's time they were moved on. Phillips takes weeks to get back up to speed after any injuries. No goals in the guy either. Livermore should be relabelled Mr Negative.
We loan players out e.g. Tulloch who is deemed not good enough to get on our bench, but will walk into another side.
We have totally forgotten what the object is. It's simple score more goals then the opposition.
Val has one plan and that's it, shame as if he could adapt we could find a way to win games.
I would like to see Woodrow and OKay join us. While Dike is a great signing I don't expect him on his own to change everything overnight.
Getting promotion this season is everything, next season will be harder and our last parachute season.
A DoF is a vital position that has been left unfilled and long term is a disastrous decision.
Reply
#30
(01-02-2022, 05:22 PM)Sliced Wrote: Nah our squad is clearly top 3 standard apparently. Most of the teams in the league would kill to have Kipre and Furlong in the starting 11 and have to resort to playing under 21s in favour of seasoned professionals.

The quality of this squad has always been over-exaggerated. Adding Dike helps a bit, but we’re still much weaker than some seem to think

Which specific teams have better squads? I have seen pretty much all the teams in this division play and I haven’t seen any squads bar Fulham perhaps Bournemouth that are better equipped / stocked with players. Val is underachieving, playing tactics that are predictable and formulaic. It’s way too easy to negate our tactics and they rarely if ever change. 

We aren’t going to get better the longer we stay in this division and if that happens I think there really will be a reason to doubt the squads quality over the next few years.
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: 1 Guest(s)