Big Val - Poll of sorts....
#51
A 3 moving quickly to a 4.

What really pissed me off yesterday was the number of times Clarke was in an advanced position in their half only to pass to them lump an aimless cross or go backwards.

The wing backs are ineffective so why not try something different and add another midfielder.

I’m happy to give him the transfer window but fear we will lose our best youth players for lack of game time.
Reply
#52
(12-27-2021, 10:06 PM)Brandywell Wrote: Between 3/4

The fact he refuses to change formation
His obvious substitutions
His comments re Livermore
His reluctance to give Cleary minutes

He has tweaked things but not the basic formation but we often have three centre-halves in the opposition penalty box so what's not to like, he's the most attacking positive manager since Big Dave, lol.  

The subs are to do with maintaining the intensity as much as anything.  He didn't have much to play with last night but almost saved the game with the double Fellows/TGH sub - who incidentally he said after the game "did exactly as we asked them to do" - 'get to the byeline and cross' -  inferring the others didn't.  

I believe he's qualified his comments re Livermore being a shoe-in regardless.   

Cleary is apparently not fit enough at the moment to deal with the intensity of the Championship (that's what Val has said).  That is an easy judgement call for the management team but he has been training with the first team now for a number of weeks so hopefully he'll get there soon - if he has the desire?
Reply
#53
(12-28-2021, 01:48 PM)Hopalong Wrote:
(12-27-2021, 10:06 PM)Brandywell Wrote: Between 3/4

The fact he refuses to change formation
His obvious substitutions
His comments re Livermore
His reluctance to give Cleary minutes

He has tweaked things but not the basic formation but we often have three centre-halves in the opposition penalty box so what's not to like, he's the most attacking positive manager since Big Dave, lol.  

The subs are to do with maintaining the intensity as much as anything.  He didn't have much to play with last night but almost saved the game with the double Fellows/TGH sub - who incidentally he said after the game "did exactly as we asked them to do" - 'get to the byeline and cross' -  inferring the others didn't.  

I believe he's qualified his comments re Livermore being a shoe-in regardless.   

Cleary is apparently not fit enough at the moment to deal with the intensity of the Championship (that's what Val has said).  That is an easy judgement call for the management team but he has been training with the first team now for a number of weeks so hopefully he'll get there soon - if he has the desire?

Serious question: Is attacking intent better than attacking less but being far more dangerous when you do? Personally I want the second.
Reply
#54
(12-28-2021, 01:48 PM)Hopalong Wrote:
(12-27-2021, 10:06 PM)Brandywell Wrote: Between 3/4

The fact he refuses to change formation
His obvious substitutions
His comments re Livermore
His reluctance to give Cleary minutes

He has tweaked things but not the basic formation but we often have three centre-halves in the opposition penalty box so what's not to like, he's the most attacking positive manager since Big Dave, lol.  

Looooooooool
Reply
#55
(12-28-2021, 01:17 PM)Stourbridge Baggie Wrote: 2 for me. Yesterday before the game Albion fans “we'll really miss Grant and Mowatt”. We did, badly. After the the game the meltdown starts and we are shit, players, Manager, board etc. We were, yesterday but not always. Also Albion fans “short termism has ruined the Club, where’s the long term plan”? Give the Manager a 4 year contract and “why the fuck did we give him a four year contract”? Is he the right manager? How can I or anyone else know yet? He needs a couple of windows before I’ll make a judgment.

Good post. Its beginning to drive me mad. 'We didn't win, boo o oo, sack the manager' Let's try backing him with a few signings first, we really are still in the hunt.
Reply
#56
I started somewhere between 1 and 2 but now I'm on 3. I'd be interested to see what backing he gets in January.
If its decent and he continues in this manner, I'll be heading towards 4.
Too rigid in his approach, if you only play one way then opposition managers who are halfway decent will suss you out and counter it.
I'm a little worried that this rigidity isn't just about sticking to a particular philosophy, but is also about ego and pig headedness.
Reply
#57
Between 2 and 3

Cuzer
Fisheatingdeludedsealwankers
Reply
#58
Between 4 - 5
I hear we need to give him more windows to bring "his" players in.
He took the job on knowing he wouldn't get a war chest to improve the squad.
He knew 15 players were leaving last summer and he couldn't buy any replacements.
He must of planned to improve the team with what he had got.
Well it's simple really we are worse and half the season has now gone.
The football is mainly dire stuff and the ability to change anything is beyond him.
If you don't change anything why would the outcome be any different.
Senior Pro's like Snodders gets dumped because he doesn't approve of Val's tactics or lack of.
The only positive is he has played a couple of the youngsters, but only when he has been forced to by injury or suspensions.
IMO we have to go up this season as the 3 clubs coming down will be better then us next year and after that the parachute
payments disappear and so will we.
So if we are to have any chance of going up and getting some more PL money we need to change and Val ain't going to, so he has to go, the sooner the better.
I'm not 100% blaming Val, he has tried but we have to hold our hands up and say he's not good enough.
The board are to blame 200% for the way the club is being run.
If Val stays I just can't see where the improvement is coming from.
Reply
#59
(12-28-2021, 08:45 PM)Remi_Moses Wrote: Between 4 - 5
I hear we need to give him more windows to bring "his" players in.
He took the job on knowing he wouldn't get a war chest to improve the squad.
He knew 15 players were leaving last summer and he couldn't buy any replacements.
He must of planned to improve the team with what he had got.
Well it's simple really we are worse and half the season has now gone.
The football is mainly dire stuff and the ability to change anything is beyond him.
If you don't change anything why would the outcome be any different.
Senior Pro's like Snodders gets dumped because he doesn't approve of Val's tactics or lack of.
The only positive is he has played a couple of the youngsters, but only when he has been forced to by injury or suspensions.
IMO we have to go up this season as the 3 clubs coming down will be better then us next year and after that the parachute
payments disappear and so will we.
So if we are to have any chance of going up and getting some more PL money we need to change and Val ain't going to, so he has to go, the sooner the better.
I'm not 100% blaming Val, he has tried but we have to hold our hands up and say he's not good enough.
The board are to blame 200% for the way the club is being run.
If Val stays I just can't see where the improvement is coming from.

WALOB
Reply
#60
3 but realistically 2. We have a bag o shite squad of bottlers who have shirked it for so many managers. Deserves the opportunity to get rid of the dead wood - which we need to do whether he stays or goes - and give it a go
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: 2 Guest(s)