Big Val - Poll of sorts....
#31
3 for me at the moment, but I'm closer to the 4 camp than the 2 currently. Just when we see an improvement, we're back to square one after some abject performances.

He's right to call out the players, but the buck stops with him. He manages and coaches them all week, and picks the side.

I think he needs more time, but remain unconvinced that he'll get it right, even if I'd be delighted if he does.
Reply
#32
5
Out of his depth
We’re 24 games in to the season. He hasn’t changed the system once, no matter how bad some performances have been.
There’s no visible signs of improvement. If anything it’s getting worse.
He continually brings in players who don’t deserve a spot (Robinson, furlong, Livermore to name 3).
Even todays commentators told you what subs he’d be making, when, and at what time.
There’s no visible ‘style’ to us at all.
Reply
#33
5. The bloke is absolutely inept, you could see it from the Peterborough away game onwards. Inability to change the formation is absolutely shocking.
Reply
#34
2 for me ,I don't believe players like Hugill ,Reach etc were on his wish list in the summer ,so until he's backed and got a few players in (but doubt that will happen in Jan)then we keep him and hope TGH and a few kids like him get more game time but until he relises this he's making a rod for himself .
Reply
#35
He's a 3 to 3.5 for me.

He is still in credit (just) and by every possible measure we are doing enough to win football matches, we just don't have the personnel to stick the ball in the net. Until he's given the chance to bring in some of his own players then I'm not sure how we can be giving him five. Lots of mentions on this thread that he should be doing better with a squad that is better than most in this division, well we're 4th that kind of proves we are doing better than most.

He's lost some marks the last few weeks with strange team selections and dropping players who played well for those who are clearly his favourite. If he keeps that up he'll lose any remaining good will pretty sharpish from me.

It's getting together to support him when we've got some decent youngsters on the bench ready to impact a game and we have to sit through Hugill, Robinson, Furlong and Livermore each week.
Reply
#36
Option no.2.
Clarnet v2.0
Reply
#37
Option 3 for me.
Although his lack of flexibility is extremely annoying and bewildering.
I think we all knew the lack of a goal scorer and playmaker would hinder us this season.
Let’s see what happens if and when he is eventually given some money to spend!
Reply
#38
2-3 for me, but I do really love the bloke's passion, if the wankers on the pitch showed the same amount of passion we'd be pissing this league.
Reply
#39
I'm a bit torn. I'm extremely wary of being a reactionary drama queen but I really don't think he's the one. I'll say number 3 for now. My least favourite attribute in a manager is picking the same players regardless of form and he is all over that. He also seems to have made some previously decent players worse (Robinson, Furlong, even my beloved Townsend has been crap recently) and it's difficult to see what they do on the training pitch.
Reply
#40
2 For me.

Not got the players he wants and there's clearly a few bad eggs in the dressing room. I thought against Forest that some weren't playing for him, so I'm not surprised to hear about yesterday.

I'd agree with the comments that his style is nothing like PulisBall either.

Unfortunately, though, he seems to have brought out a bad side in some of our fans. The desire to rubbish Val seems to have been there from day one of the season, when it became apparent that we would not be tearing the league asunder. I feel like I've only been to one home match this season where there hasn't been booing at half time. That's ridiculous and it's not what we used to be as fans.
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: 2 Guest(s)