F1
#31
(12-12-2021, 04:07 PM)BilstonBaggie Wrote:
(12-12-2021, 04:01 PM)Sliced Wrote:
(12-12-2021, 03:43 PM)MrFizz Wrote:
(12-12-2021, 03:17 PM)wba13 Wrote: We’ll probably won’t bother watching F1 anymore, because the F1 bosses decide to contrive who wins as it clearly showed who they wanted to win.

I would argue that they were clearly desperate to see the title decided on track by the two best drivers, rather than behind a safety car. Verstappen still had to get past, still had to defend Lewis' counter-attack. Hardly a contrived winner. 

Contrived/rules bent to get the race restarted with those two up front? Maybe, yes. Stay tuned for a possible Mercedes appeal here.

Spot on. You would think Hamilton had never benefitted from a safety car before.

Bizarrely enough Hamilton is being relatively graceful in defeat, it’s his fans who have had a surprisingly petulant reaction to a relatively common occurrence in formula one.

“a relatively common occurrence in formula one.”

Ok then, please fill us all in in the number of times only a few lapped cars are instructed to overtake the safety car which then comes in on the same lap it is overtaken rather than completing another lap before coming in. I’ll wait.

Exactly. Thats what i said about FIA rules possibly not being followed by the FIA themselves and a possible Mercedes appeal. Interesting wording though according to Sky. The rule says 'any lapped cars may overtake' not 'all lapped cars may overtake'. 

Definately one for the clever lawyers. Big Grin
Reply
#32
Red Bull have been summoned to the stewards room
Reply
#33
(12-12-2021, 04:20 PM)Sliced Wrote:
(12-12-2021, 04:07 PM)BilstonBaggie Wrote:
(12-12-2021, 04:01 PM)Sliced Wrote:
(12-12-2021, 03:43 PM)MrFizz Wrote:
(12-12-2021, 03:17 PM)wba13 Wrote: We’ll probably won’t bother watching F1 anymore, because the F1 bosses decide to contrive who wins as it clearly showed who they wanted to win.

I would argue that they were clearly desperate to see the title decided on track by the two best drivers, rather than behind a safety car. Verstappen still had to get past, still had to defend Lewis' counter-attack. Hardly a contrived winner. 

Contrived/rules bent to get the race restarted with those two up front? Maybe, yes. Stay tuned for a possible Mercedes appeal here.

Spot on. You would think Hamilton had never benefitted from a safety car before.

Bizarrely enough Hamilton is being relatively graceful in defeat, it’s his fans who have had a surprisingly petulant reaction to a relatively common occurrence in formula one.

“a relatively common occurrence in formula one.”

Ok then, please fill us all in in the number of times only a few lapped cars are instructed to overtake the safety car which then comes in on the same lap it is overtaken rather than completing another lap before coming in. I’ll wait.

Probably as often as they let a driver gain a massive advantage by cutting a corner and turn a complete blind eye to it. Swings and roundabouts.

We English aren’t half sore losers at times. 

Shame not to see Hamilton win but happy to admit the best driver over the season won. Mercedes complaint won’t do anything. A bit of graciousness in defeat wouldn’t go amiss.

So that’s your answer to my question. You can’t cite a past incident of a similar nature so resort to whataboutism. I can answer my own question anyway. The answer is zero. It has never happened before. It directly violates at least two rules and one of those rules is a safety issue and in those instances there is no black and white. Safety rules have to be followed.
Reply
#34
The English driver has been awesome in defeat. It's the team that are kicking off (justifiably imo) Red Bull are out of the meeting.
Reply
#35
The FIA will never change their decision, they are more contrived than FIFA.

Unfortunately this Championship has been decided outside of driver or team control or participation.

FIA did this for the Abu Dhabi sponsors wanting a result under race conditions.
Reply
#36
The irony of Mercedes saying they want it to be decided on the track and are now bringing in the lawyers shouldn't be lost on anyone.

"Ok let's null and void the race"

"No no, NOT THAT! Just the last lap so our bloke wins"

The FIA didn't make Verstappen overtake Hamilton on the last lap, he did that himself, and if they were looking for an excuse to punish Lewis they had the perfect one in the first lap and they chose to let it go.
Reply
#37
I can’t agree with Verstappen being the best driver, he won the title through a contrived result, and remember there was 1 race that Hamilton didn’t drive in through Covid so there’s a possibility he could also have won that race and that would have meant that Verstappen would have been behind on points. If Verstappen would have won today by fare means great, and he is a great driver but a lot has gone his way in the last few races.
Reply
#38
(12-12-2021, 05:47 PM)Sliced Wrote: The irony of Mercedes saying they want it to be decided on the track and are now bringing in the lawyers shouldn't be lost on anyone.

"Ok let's null and void the race"

"No no, NOT THAT! Just the last lap so our bloke wins"

The FIA didn't make Verstappen overtake Hamilton on the last lap, he did that himself, and if they were looking for an excuse to punish Lewis they had the perfect one in the first lap and they chose to let it go.

I think the line about winning the title on the track is largely contingent on the powers that be not arbitrarily changing/ignoring their own rules just to manufacture a false close finish.
Reply
#39
Get in Max!! Deserved Champion
Reply
#40
Sounds like F1 is turning into WWE
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: