Vaccine passport to watch Albion
(12-09-2021, 07:22 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote:
(12-09-2021, 06:36 PM)backsidebaggie Wrote:
(12-09-2021, 06:32 PM)Bob Fossil Wrote:
(12-09-2021, 06:12 PM)backsidebaggie Wrote:
(12-09-2021, 06:07 PM)Bob Fossil Wrote: It's not though is it, because the choice remains? Everyone can weigh up the data, risks, consequences and decide whether to have it, that is not mandatory.

People keep talking about it being divisive, but it really isn't is it?

This vaccine is available FREE OF CHARGE to everyone, regardless of:
Sex
Race
Religion
Sexuality
Financial Status
Class
Postcode
Political Leaning
Borders

I would say that makes it the single most universal government policy in my lifetime and the only people creating a divide are those that choose not to have it, which is fine, but they have to factor potential consequences into their decision.

I don’t see anyone who has chosen not to have it slagging off those who have. Whereas those who haven’t are getting called anti vax morons by a few.

Choosing to do, or not to do, something doesn’t create a divide per se. That’s the case with many things in life. It’s the reactions to people’s choices which creates divide. There’s no divide created by people who have it, or don’t have it, if they don’t demonise the other group and respect choices. Thankfully, most don’t at the moment, but I believe it’s getting worse.
Again, not true, people have been protesting outside schools and vaccination centres. My daughter's school was included so I saw this with my own eyes, grown adults screaming at kids. Also the signs for the vax centre near me have had "NO" daubed all over them.

And I agree with you, if they were screaming at kids, or anyone, for having it, they are definitely out of order and adding to the division.

People calling those following the rules called sheeples, calling masks muzzles, wearing ludicrous T-shirts about not vaccinating kids (seen them with my own eyes), protesting outside schools whether they are shouting or standing quietly is pathetic bullying / intimidation of children, parents, teachers and staff, shouting at people at protests, bullying health and scientific experts online and in person, graffiti / vandalising Covid centre signs again seen with my own eyes, spreading untruths on the vaccine on social media and in person. 

Yes all those against having the vaccine are mild mannered, non-judgemental, live and let live, selfless types!

You’re right, they’re all extremely divisive. In my original post, I actually meant only on this thread.

But you’re absolutely right, such name calling, labelling, generalising, bullying, is very very divisive and vile.

That’s why I avoid those things as much as possible. Ask yourself if you do. Not just on this subject matter, but on many subjects.
Reply
So, apparently the chances of someone under 30 dying from Covid are ‘virtually zero’ ( over 100 under 30’s died from Covid from July 2020 to Feb 2021), yet the risk from having the vaccination is a good reason not to have it? Please enlighten me as to how many under 30s have died as a result of the vaccination over a similar period - none, 1,2?
Reply
(12-09-2021, 07:29 PM)backsidebaggie Wrote:
(12-09-2021, 07:22 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote:
(12-09-2021, 06:36 PM)backsidebaggie Wrote:
(12-09-2021, 06:32 PM)Bob Fossil Wrote:
(12-09-2021, 06:12 PM)backsidebaggie Wrote: I don’t see anyone who has chosen not to have it slagging off those who have. Whereas those who haven’t are getting called anti vax morons by a few.

Choosing to do, or not to do, something doesn’t create a divide per se. That’s the case with many things in life. It’s the reactions to people’s choices which creates divide. There’s no divide created by people who have it, or don’t have it, if they don’t demonise the other group and respect choices. Thankfully, most don’t at the moment, but I believe it’s getting worse.
Again, not true, people have been protesting outside schools and vaccination centres. My daughter's school was included so I saw this with my own eyes, grown adults screaming at kids. Also the signs for the vax centre near me have had "NO" daubed all over them.

And I agree with you, if they were screaming at kids, or anyone, for having it, they are definitely out of order and adding to the division.

People calling those following the rules called sheeples, calling masks muzzles, wearing ludicrous T-shirts about not vaccinating kids (seen them with my own eyes), protesting outside schools whether they are shouting or standing quietly is pathetic bullying / intimidation of children, parents, teachers and staff, shouting at people at protests, bullying health and scientific experts online and in person, graffiti / vandalising Covid centre signs again seen with my own eyes, spreading untruths on the vaccine on social media and in person. 

Yes all those against having the vaccine are mild mannered, non-judgemental, live and let live, selfless types!

You’re right, they’re all extremely divisive. In my original post, I actually meant only on this thread.

But you’re absolutely right, such name calling, labelling, generalising, bullying, is very very divisive and vile.

That’s why I avoid those things as much as possible. Ask yourself if you do.

I don’t wear stupid pro vax T-shirts 
I don’t stand outside schools shouting get the jab 
I don’t vandalise buildings with pro vaccine messages 
I don’t go on social media to harangue anti-vaccine ‘experts’ tbf they are hard to find
I don’t go on any pro-vaccine marches 
I don’t spread untruths about the vaccine 

I do come on here and state my opinion that I think people should accept that if they want to defend their rights they need to accept they have responsibilities. 
I do think that those working with the vulnerable should be vaccinated 
I do think people who refuse the vaccine are taking an ill informed and selfish position 

Your position on this subject in contrast can be described as positively angelic and completely balanced Wink
Reply
Mr Squid and I have just booked our boosters, my daughter's had her single dose in school. I support health workers having to have the vaccine in exactly the same way we've had to have the Hep B, MMR jab for years.

So, I am not anti-vax.


But I am very wary about the vaccine mandate. As people have asked, what would we do to enforce it?

I'm also not going back into lock down. It would cause more harm then it would solve now.
Reply
(12-09-2021, 06:10 PM)Cheshire East Baggie Wrote:
(12-09-2021, 05:20 PM)OnlyOneRealAlbion Wrote:
(12-09-2021, 04:29 PM)Cheshire East Baggie Wrote:
(12-09-2021, 04:05 PM)boingingjim Wrote: Still yet to hear from any of the people claiming that those not taking vaccines are selfish and are uneducated would do about those people who are directly killed by taking the vaccine?

Like this: https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/uk-england-tyne-58330796

If the vaccine had zero side effects then I also could see the argument but given some people will die from having the vaccine what possible grounds do you have to mandate anyone has this injected into their body?  I am vaccinated but there is no way I would expect anyone else to take the vaccine.  It's their choice. 

What if you pressurised your mate to have it against their judgement and then they ended up dead from complications?  Are you okay with that?

Without wishing to get all statty on you, this sad story tells us that 73 people died of this rare reaction out of 24.8 million who had received at least one dose of the AZ vaccine. Which is less than half of one thousandth of a percent.

Today's national figures tell us that there have been 10,610,958 Covid cases in total and 145,987 of those people have died within 28 days of diagnosis. I accept that this figure includes people whose major cause of death may not have been Covid - equally it excludes people who were never diagnosed or who died after the 28 day window. But the headline death rate from Covid in UK is 1.37%. I know which of those risks I would rather take.

One unnecessary death from the vaccine is one death too many. How many of those who have died as a direct result of a vaccine side-effect knew there was a chance of death from taking it? I would wager none. I would vehemently disagree that those unnecessary deaths are somehow acceptable 'collateral damage'.

As to the rate of death from Covid, it is NOT 1.37%. The death from COVID for those under 60 with no serious underlying conditions is less than 0.1%, which is about the same risk of dying from influenza. Children (and even those under the age of 40 in reality) have a statistical chance of dying from Covid so low it is effectively 0. It may well be somewhat closer to 1.37% for those over 70 (though still likely well under that stat), and possibly over 1% for those over 80.

The vaccine does not stop transmission, nor does not stop infection. It's available for those that want it and as long as those that do are doing so with proper informed consent then I have no problem with it. I do however have a serious issue with such a vaccine (or any vaccine) being made mandatory. That the possibility of it is even being discussed is quite disturbing.

I'm 65. You're telling me my life doesn't matter. Thanks.

Vaccination stops pandemic diseases. No matter how vehemently you try to argue otherwise, the best way to live with this is to vaccinate against it. It reduces the risk of infection, the severity of symptoms and the risk of death.

And no matter how you "do the math", 145,000 deaths out of over 10,000,000 cases is 1.37%. It can't be less in every age group. Your bogus figure of 0.1% is still 200 times higher than the risk of dying from blood clotting associated with the AZ vaccine.


You have absolutely no idea what you are talking about when it comes to the IFR. When calculating the IFR of an illness such as virus you don't simply divide the known cases with the fatal cases and say 'that is the fatality rate'. The undisputed fact is that the KNOWN cases only amount to a FRACTION of the ACTUAL cases. In reality the known cases will account for 10% of the ACTUAL cases, AT MOST. Most people who have had COVID will have not even known, as it's undisputed that the overwhelming majority of infections result in NO SYMPTOMS.

The 0.1% fatality rate is not remotely bogus but is established fact. Even at the age of 65 the fatality rate is something like 0.3% WITHOUT being vaccinated. It's only a percentile more deadly than 'flu.

And where did I say YOUR life didn't matter? How old do you think I am? My next door neighbour and friend died during the first lockdown. Cancer. It was operable and he had an op scheduled. That was cancelled however because of 'COVID'. Now that's quite literally being told your life doesn't 'matter'.
Reply
(12-09-2021, 07:43 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote:
(12-09-2021, 07:29 PM)backsidebaggie Wrote:
(12-09-2021, 07:22 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote:
(12-09-2021, 06:36 PM)backsidebaggie Wrote:
(12-09-2021, 06:32 PM)Bob Fossil Wrote: Again, not true, people have been protesting outside schools and vaccination centres. My daughter's school was included so I saw this with my own eyes, grown adults screaming at kids. Also the signs for the vax centre near me have had "NO" daubed all over them.

And I agree with you, if they were screaming at kids, or anyone, for having it, they are definitely out of order and adding to the division.

People calling those following the rules called sheeples, calling masks muzzles, wearing ludicrous T-shirts about not vaccinating kids (seen them with my own eyes), protesting outside schools whether they are shouting or standing quietly is pathetic bullying / intimidation of children, parents, teachers and staff, shouting at people at protests, bullying health and scientific experts online and in person, graffiti / vandalising Covid centre signs again seen with my own eyes, spreading untruths on the vaccine on social media and in person. 

Yes all those against having the vaccine are mild mannered, non-judgemental, live and let live, selfless types!

You’re right, they’re all extremely divisive. In my original post, I actually meant only on this thread.

But you’re absolutely right, such name calling, labelling, generalising, bullying, is very very divisive and vile.

That’s why I avoid those things as much as possible. Ask yourself if you do.

I don’t wear stupid pro vax T-shirts 
I don’t stand outside schools shouting get the jab 
I don’t vandalise buildings with pro vaccine messages 
I don’t go on social media to harangue anti-vaccine ‘experts’ tbf they are hard to find
I don’t go on any pro-vaccine marches 
I don’t spread untruths about the vaccine 

I do come on here and state my opinion that I think people should accept that if they want to defend their rights they need to accept they have responsibilities. 
I do think that those working with the vulnerable should be vaccinated 
I do think people who refuse the vaccine are taking an ill informed and selfish position 

Your position on this subject in contrast can be described as positively angelic and completely balanced Wink

I’m not saying you do any of those things you’ve listed there. And I know you give your opinion on things, and that’s fine, never said you shouldn’t. Again, that wasn’t my point.

I’m very happy for people to make their mind up, not whether they agree or disagree with either of us, but which of us engages in generalising, labelling, name calling and divisiveness. Not on this subject, but on all sorts of things.
Reply
(12-09-2021, 07:52 PM)OnlyOneRealAlbion Wrote:
(12-09-2021, 06:10 PM)Cheshire East Baggie Wrote:
(12-09-2021, 05:20 PM)OnlyOneRealAlbion Wrote:
(12-09-2021, 04:29 PM)Cheshire East Baggie Wrote:
(12-09-2021, 04:05 PM)boingingjim Wrote: Still yet to hear from any of the people claiming that those not taking vaccines are selfish and are uneducated would do about those people who are directly killed by taking the vaccine?

Like this: https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/uk-england-tyne-58330796

If the vaccine had zero side effects then I also could see the argument but given some people will die from having the vaccine what possible grounds do you have to mandate anyone has this injected into their body?  I am vaccinated but there is no way I would expect anyone else to take the vaccine.  It's their choice. 

What if you pressurised your mate to have it against their judgement and then they ended up dead from complications?  Are you okay with that?

Without wishing to get all statty on you, this sad story tells us that 73 people died of this rare reaction out of 24.8 million who had received at least one dose of the AZ vaccine. Which is less than half of one thousandth of a percent.

Today's national figures tell us that there have been 10,610,958 Covid cases in total and 145,987 of those people have died within 28 days of diagnosis. I accept that this figure includes people whose major cause of death may not have been Covid - equally it excludes people who were never diagnosed or who died after the 28 day window. But the headline death rate from Covid in UK is 1.37%. I know which of those risks I would rather take.

One unnecessary death from the vaccine is one death too many. How many of those who have died as a direct result of a vaccine side-effect knew there was a chance of death from taking it? I would wager none. I would vehemently disagree that those unnecessary deaths are somehow acceptable 'collateral damage'.

As to the rate of death from Covid, it is NOT 1.37%. The death from COVID for those under 60 with no serious underlying conditions is less than 0.1%, which is about the same risk of dying from influenza. Children (and even those under the age of 40 in reality) have a statistical chance of dying from Covid so low it is effectively 0. It may well be somewhat closer to 1.37% for those over 70 (though still likely well under that stat), and possibly over 1% for those over 80.

The vaccine does not stop transmission, nor does not stop infection. It's available for those that want it and as long as those that do are doing so with proper informed consent then I have no problem with it. I do however have a serious issue with such a vaccine (or any vaccine) being made mandatory. That the possibility of it is even being discussed is quite disturbing.

I'm 65. You're telling me my life doesn't matter. Thanks.

Vaccination stops pandemic diseases. No matter how vehemently you try to argue otherwise, the best way to live with this is to vaccinate against it. It reduces the risk of infection, the severity of symptoms and the risk of death.

And no matter how you "do the math", 145,000 deaths out of over 10,000,000 cases is 1.37%. It can't be less in every age group. Your bogus figure of 0.1% is still 200 times higher than the risk of dying from blood clotting associated with the AZ vaccine.


You have absolutely no idea what you are talking about when it comes to the IFR. When calculating the IFR of an illness such as virus you don't simply divide the known cases with the fatal cases and say 'that is the fatality rate'. The undisputed fact is that the KNOWN cases only amount to a FRACTION of the ACTUAL cases. In reality the known cases will account for 10% of the ACTUAL cases, AT MOST. Most people who have had COVID will have not even known, as it's undisputed that the overwhelming majority of infections result in NO SYMPTOMS.

The 0.1% fatality rate is not remotely bogus but is established fact. Even at the age of 65 the fatality rate is something like 0.3% WITHOUT being vaccinated. It's only a percentile more deadly than 'flu.

And where did I say YOUR life didn't matter? How old do you think I am? My next door neighbour and friend died during the first lockdown. Cancer. It was operable and he had an op scheduled. That was cancelled however because of 'COVID'. Now that's quite literally being told your life doesn't 'matter'.

Your getting confused between facts and fiction. 
And most people not knowing they have had covid - try telling the 5,300,000 who have already passed or their relatives and friends.
Reply
(12-09-2021, 08:01 PM)backsidebaggie Wrote:
(12-09-2021, 07:43 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote:
(12-09-2021, 07:29 PM)backsidebaggie Wrote:
(12-09-2021, 07:22 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote:
(12-09-2021, 06:36 PM)backsidebaggie Wrote: And I agree with you, if they were screaming at kids, or anyone, for having it, they are definitely out of order and adding to the division.

People calling those following the rules called sheeples, calling masks muzzles, wearing ludicrous T-shirts about not vaccinating kids (seen them with my own eyes), protesting outside schools whether they are shouting or standing quietly is pathetic bullying / intimidation of children, parents, teachers and staff, shouting at people at protests, bullying health and scientific experts online and in person, graffiti / vandalising Covid centre signs again seen with my own eyes, spreading untruths on the vaccine on social media and in person. 

Yes all those against having the vaccine are mild mannered, non-judgemental, live and let live, selfless types!

You’re right, they’re all extremely divisive. In my original post, I actually meant only on this thread.

But you’re absolutely right, such name calling, labelling, generalising, bullying, is very very divisive and vile.

That’s why I avoid those things as much as possible. Ask yourself if you do.

I don’t wear stupid pro vax T-shirts 
I don’t stand outside schools shouting get the jab 
I don’t vandalise buildings with pro vaccine messages 
I don’t go on social media to harangue anti-vaccine ‘experts’ tbf they are hard to find
I don’t go on any pro-vaccine marches 
I don’t spread untruths about the vaccine 

I do come on here and state my opinion that I think people should accept that if they want to defend their rights they need to accept they have responsibilities. 
I do think that those working with the vulnerable should be vaccinated 
I do think people who refuse the vaccine are taking an ill informed and selfish position 

Your position on this subject in contrast can be described as positively angelic and completely balanced Wink

I’m not saying you do any of those things you’ve listed there. And I know you give your opinion on things, and that’s fine, never said you shouldn’t. Again, that wasn’t my point.

I’m very happy for people to make their mind up, not whether they agree or disagree with either of us, but which of us engages in generalising, labelling, name calling and divisiveness. Not on this subject, but on all sorts of things.

Both of us.
Reply
(12-09-2021, 08:04 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote:
(12-09-2021, 08:01 PM)backsidebaggie Wrote:
(12-09-2021, 07:43 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote:
(12-09-2021, 07:29 PM)backsidebaggie Wrote:
(12-09-2021, 07:22 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: People calling those following the rules called sheeples, calling masks muzzles, wearing ludicrous T-shirts about not vaccinating kids (seen them with my own eyes), protesting outside schools whether they are shouting or standing quietly is pathetic bullying / intimidation of children, parents, teachers and staff, shouting at people at protests, bullying health and scientific experts online and in person, graffiti / vandalising Covid centre signs again seen with my own eyes, spreading untruths on the vaccine on social media and in person. 

Yes all those against having the vaccine are mild mannered, non-judgemental, live and let live, selfless types!

You’re right, they’re all extremely divisive. In my original post, I actually meant only on this thread.

But you’re absolutely right, such name calling, labelling, generalising, bullying, is very very divisive and vile.

That’s why I avoid those things as much as possible. Ask yourself if you do.

I don’t wear stupid pro vax T-shirts 
I don’t stand outside schools shouting get the jab 
I don’t vandalise buildings with pro vaccine messages 
I don’t go on social media to harangue anti-vaccine ‘experts’ tbf they are hard to find
I don’t go on any pro-vaccine marches 
I don’t spread untruths about the vaccine 

I do come on here and state my opinion that I think people should accept that if they want to defend their rights they need to accept they have responsibilities. 
I do think that those working with the vulnerable should be vaccinated 
I do think people who refuse the vaccine are taking an ill informed and selfish position 

Your position on this subject in contrast can be described as positively angelic and completely balanced Wink

I’m not saying you do any of those things you’ve listed there. And I know you give your opinion on things, and that’s fine, never said you shouldn’t. Again, that wasn’t my point.

I’m very happy for people to make their mind up, not whether they agree or disagree with either of us, but which of us engages in generalising, labelling, name calling and divisiveness. Not on this subject, but on all sorts of things.

Both of us.

Keep telling yourself that. As I say, people can decide for themselves.
Reply
(12-09-2021, 07:41 PM)Everything Zin Wrote: So, apparently the chances of someone under 30 dying from Covid are ‘virtually zero’ ( over 100 under 30’s died from Covid from July 2020 to Feb 2021), yet the risk from having the vaccination is a good reason not to have it? Please enlighten me as to how many under 30s have died as a result of the vaccination over a similar period - none, 1,2?

The Governments own 'yellow card' vaccine adverse reaction system has recorded 1814 deaths so far and 395000 adverse reactions. It's well known these are lowball figures also, as a large percentage of adverse effects don't get reported.

Now, despite the correlation all of these obviously won't be related to the vaccine, but without multiple proper, scientific investigations carried out over years this isn't known. This is why vaccines are tested rigorously for several years before full roll-out. Not the case with this one.

Can't say how many of those 1814 deaths are people under 30 without access to that data. It's certainly considerably higher than '1 or 2' however.

To show you that death isn't the only concern, I can tell you that official Government figures show there have been 641 'Abortions Spontaneous' reported directly after having had the vaccine, so there clearly is a correlation there.

As to 100+ deaths of 30 year olds from COVID over your date range, out of how many ACTUAL infections? Over a 6-8 month period no doubt several million, which statistically makes 100+ deaths practically zero risk. Also, how many of those had other, serious comorbidities? I suspect the majority did.
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: