Vaccine passport to watch Albion
I think the thought process around not expecting us to need regular vaccine boosters until we have enough community immunity is daft. It's a sensible approach and will be for the next few years I'm afraid whether people agree with it or not. Also I'm all for vaccine mandates but in the right circumstances and herein lies the problem, I don't think we've met that threshold here. 

Johnson last night said that they will be guided by the hard medical data and listed the 4 measures: The efficacy of our vaccines and our boosters; the severity of omicron; the speed of its spread; and, the rate of hospitalisations.

The efficacy of our vaccines and boosters looks very good, in the UK we are currently running with about 50k at the moment which is very comparable with the peak of the lockdown this time last year (they were about 60k) but the numbers in hospital (about 30k last year and 6k now) show that the efficacy is very good. 

The severity of omicron and the speed of its spread is still to be determined. They showed a slide last night of its impact in South Africa which is severe, but the number of people vaccinated in SA is around 25%, which is miles below our 80+% rate. 

And the rate of hospitalisations - we have had falling numbers in hospital over the last month and last we saw a small increase (4%) which doesn't scream out as being something to worry about.

All in all, looking at the governments own reasons and the timing of this it doesn't seem clear to me that this is the right time to do this. We've put ourselves in a good position to buy the time already. These extra measures aren't needed now. 

IMO they are just an attempt to distract from the news of the day, and that is an appalling risk to the hospitality industry at this point in time.
Reply
(12-09-2021, 12:20 PM)baggy1 Wrote: I think the thought process around not expecting us to need regular vaccine boosters until we have enough community immunity is daft. It's a sensible approach and will be for the next few years I'm afraid whether people agree with it or not. Also I'm all for vaccine mandates but in the right circumstances and herein lies the problem, I don't think we've met that threshold here. 

Johnson last night said that they will be guided by the hard medical data and listed the 4 measures: The efficacy of our vaccines and our boosters; the severity of omicron; the speed of its spread; and, the rate of hospitalisations.

The efficacy of our vaccines and boosters looks very good, in the UK we are currently running with about 50k at the moment which is very comparable with the peak of the lockdown this time last year (they were about 60k) but the numbers in hospital (about 30k last year and 6k now) show that the efficacy is very good. 

The severity of omicron and the speed of its spread is still to be determined. They showed a slide last night of its impact in South Africa which is sever, but the number of people vaccinated in SA is around 25%, which is miles below our 80+% rate. 

And the rate of hospitalisations - we have had falling numbers in hospital over the last month and last wee saws a small increase (4%) which doesn't scream out as being something to worry about.

All in all, looking at the governments own reasons and the timing of this it doesn't seem clear to me that this is the right time to do this. We've put ourselves in a good position to buy the time already. These extra measures aren't needed now. 

IMO they are just an attempt to distract from the news of the day, and that is an appalling risk to the hospitality industry at this point in time.

Of course there’ll be regular boosters indefinitely, I don’t think many people thought otherwise.

Agreed the timing is diverting away from the parties.

With mandation, you’ll need a plan to deal with those who refuse. The fall out could be enormous. 

I personally think it’s insane and I’m glad Javid has said it’s morally wrong today. Of course, that’s the pattern again. Float the idea. Deny it. Float it again when they’ve persuaded enough people it’s reasonable…
Reply
If you limit the places that non-vaxed can go, that doesn't affect their ability to not have it, that choice remains. This is the compromise alternative to mandation, surely?

This will be the case with travel abroad anyway, you won't be forced to vax, but you won't be able to travel to certain places if you don't. Don't see the difference within this country.
They can maintain their beliefs provided they accept that there will be restrictions as a consequence.

I don't see the issue really, I can't come to work without certain PPE. I'm not forced to though, I always have the choice of looking for a job that doesn't require it. There is always a choice.
Reply
(12-09-2021, 12:46 PM)Bob Fossil Wrote: If you limit the places that non-vaxed can go, that doesn't affect their ability to not have it, that choice remains. This is the compromise alternative to mandation, surely?

This will be the case with travel abroad anyway, you won't be forced to vax, but you won't be able to travel to certain places if you don't. Don't see the difference within this country.
They can maintain their beliefs provided they accept that there will be restrictions as a consequence.

I don't see the issue really, I can't come to work without certain PPE. I'm not forced to though, I always have the choice of looking for a job that doesn't require it. There is always a choice.

That certainly removes the requirement for a punishment.

But it creates a segregated society. History tells me that’s never ok.

And there is zero scientific evidence to suggest this actually helps with covid numbers and protecting the nhs, which was what this was supposed to be about. Groups of people who aren’t vaccinated just go to places they can, and mix anyway. And vaccinated people still spread it anyway. So I don’t see what it achieves, other than more division.

Does no one else find this “them and us” in society a bit chilling? There would be non vax places open, which would no doubt be illegal and have police raids? I’m really not sure people have thought the implications of this through, let alone the lack of science behind it. It could create an “underclass” in society. This division is very alarming to me. I hope I’m not alone.
Reply
(12-09-2021, 12:46 PM)Bob Fossil Wrote: If you limit the places that non-vaxed can go, that doesn't affect their ability to not have it, that choice remains. This is the compromise alternative to mandation, surely?

This will be the case with travel abroad anyway, you won't be forced to vax, but you won't be able to travel to certain places if you don't. Don't see the difference within this country.
They can maintain their beliefs provided they accept that there will be restrictions as a consequence.

I don't see the issue really, I can't come to work without certain PPE. I'm not forced to though, I always have the choice of looking for a job that doesn't require it. There is always a choice.
 
So should Callum Robinson look for another job?
Reply
(12-09-2021, 12:58 PM)baggiebuckster Wrote:
(12-09-2021, 12:46 PM)Bob Fossil Wrote: If you limit the places that non-vaxed can go, that doesn't affect their ability to not have it, that choice remains. This is the compromise alternative to mandation, surely?

This will be the case with travel abroad anyway, you won't be forced to vax, but you won't be able to travel to certain places if you don't. Don't see the difference within this country.
They can maintain their beliefs provided they accept that there will be restrictions as a consequence.

I don't see the issue really, I can't come to work without certain PPE. I'm not forced to though, I always have the choice of looking for a job that doesn't require it. There is always a choice.
 
So should Callum Robinson look for another job?

And half the footballers by all accounts!

It won’t be long before some are calling for people to be “identified” as unvaccinated. It really is chilling, this division.
Reply
(12-09-2021, 12:20 PM)baggy1 Wrote: IMO they are just an attempt to distract from the news of the day, and that is an appalling risk to the hospitality industry at this point in time.

Being told what we have to do by a PM who should have today been tendering his resignation. Jokes on us.
Reply
(12-09-2021, 12:58 PM)baggiebuckster Wrote:
(12-09-2021, 12:46 PM)Bob Fossil Wrote: If you limit the places that non-vaxed can go, that doesn't affect their ability to not have it, that choice remains. This is the compromise alternative to mandation, surely?

This will be the case with travel abroad anyway, you won't be forced to vax, but you won't be able to travel to certain places if you don't. Don't see the difference within this country.
They can maintain their beliefs provided they accept that there will be restrictions as a consequence.

I don't see the issue really, I can't come to work without certain PPE. I'm not forced to though, I always have the choice of looking for a job that doesn't require it. There is always a choice.
 
So should Callum Robinson look for another job?

For clarity, are we talking about the Callum Robinson that plays for Albion or the Callum Robinson that plays for Ireland?

I don't think he ever said that he wouldn't get the jab, he just hasn't had it yet.
Reply
So is the requirement to enter pretty much any event during a pandemic with a new variant on the charge is a negative lateral flow test? Have I got this right? Are some really saying this is a threat to their civil liberties ffs?

Surely It’s a sensible precaution if you wish to slow down the new strain until we know more about it and get more people triple jabbed over the most social part of the year?

There is a list of things to criticise this government about longer than the Encyclopaedia Britannia before we start the ott criticism of these imo sensible and hardly draconian measures.

Oh and yes of course they were brought forward because of the Christmas Party Gate / massive dead cat but that does not mean the proposals on this are wrong no matter how many unmasked Tory backbenchers say so.
Reply
(12-09-2021, 01:02 PM)backsidebaggie Wrote:
(12-09-2021, 12:58 PM)baggiebuckster Wrote:
(12-09-2021, 12:46 PM)Bob Fossil Wrote: If you limit the places that non-vaxed can go, that doesn't affect their ability to not have it, that choice remains. This is the compromise alternative to mandation, surely?

This will be the case with travel abroad anyway, you won't be forced to vax, but you won't be able to travel to certain places if you don't. Don't see the difference within this country.
They can maintain their beliefs provided they accept that there will be restrictions as a consequence.

I don't see the issue really, I can't come to work without certain PPE. I'm not forced to though, I always have the choice of looking for a job that doesn't require it. There is always a choice.
 
So should Callum Robinson look for another job?

And half the footballers by all accounts!

It won’t be long before some are calling for people to be “identified” as unvaccinated. It really is chilling, this division.
The last time this happened it was called Apartheid. I think everyone should volunteer to be vaccinated, but you can't discriminate.
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: 2 Guest(s)