Posts: 15,277
Threads: 273
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
57
(12-03-2021, 11:19 AM)HLS Wrote: (12-02-2021, 08:47 PM)Birdman1811 Wrote: (12-02-2021, 08:45 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: Identifying players through stats is a very blunt tool. All seems rather one dimensional, players aren’t statistical data. I know it’s trendy, as is the pressing style of play but it seems like recruitment by numbers.
It was a big part of what we did under Ashworth. Of course the stats are very detailed and you also get full personality reports on players too.
Out of interest, how do you suggest doing it?
By seeing if they come from a nice family and if they will play for England one day.
Arf!
Posts: 13,256
Threads: 468
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
45
12-03-2021, 01:22 PM
(This post was last modified: 12-03-2021, 02:37 PM by Sliced.)
(12-02-2021, 09:33 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: (12-02-2021, 08:47 PM)Birdman1811 Wrote: (12-02-2021, 08:45 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: Identifying players through stats is a very blunt tool. All seems rather one dimensional, players aren’t statistical data. I know it’s trendy, as is the pressing style of play but it seems like recruitment by numbers.
It was a big part of what we did under Ashworth. Of course the stats are very detailed and you also get full personality reports on players too.
Out of interest, how do you suggest doing it?
Do you really need a dossier full of analysis to work out if x, y, z player fits into the way you want to play? I don’t need to count how many passes Sawyers made to tell me he is good at passing, I don’t need to realise he was also a bit lightweight and wouldn’t fit into my plans if I wanted to play an aggressive, pressing style of play. I don’t need stats to tell me Gallagher would be a better fit for example. If I was looking for a natural goalscorer i would look for ahem a player that has scored lots of goals first and foremost. I doubt Lineker would have been signed by many clubs now because his stats would show a player with unbalanced stats.
I would also trust myself and those I surround myself with opinion over any numbers presented to me via a trendy database. I would also want to talk to the player in person not rely on others to judge their characters and motivation.
We signed plenty of poor players when Ashworth was at the club, his hit rate was no better than GM’s in fact probably worse and one relies on a laptop if what you say is true the other relied on the opinion of his Dad driving a Cortina
Stats should not be the driving force behind identifying players. I know it’s old fashioned but ultimately creating a team is an art form not a science. Otherwise the sport would become a glorified Championship Manager algorithm.
Teams across Europe that have become primarily stats focused have generally been successful. The likes of Brentford, Mitjylland, the Red Bull clubs all have recruitment systems based primarily upon data science and statistics. Working heavily with data science myself, you're correct, it's not an exact science, but it is a very successful one when applied correctly. On an individual level players succeed or fail all the time for a multitude of reasons that can't be modelled. However, the idea behind it is that if you identify the right players based upon a set criteria, you'll generally have an upward trend over time with the right models and analyses.
You use the examples of not needing stats to establish that Sawyers is a good passer, but the stats echo that opinion, so instead of having scouts watching multiple games of every player accross the globe, they can quickly use the statistics to instantly tell them what their eyes would recognise after watching multiple matches. Of course the technology is such now that we can instantly have access to ground covered, pressing intensity, pass completion, any metric you can ever think of.
Also, as has been seen on here countless times, the human mind is prone to bias. Conor Townsend has always been a competent left back for us and it took some years to stop referring to him as league one level. The statistics strip away that emotion.
I apologise if I sound patronising, its not my intention, but if you think that it's a one dimensional tool then maybe you don't realise the levels of analyses that can potentially be carried out with the available data. It's not just about on pitch performance, you can also make predictions about how a player is going to adapt to a move based upon their personality, personal circumstances, historical transfers etc. As I've said, some things can't be modelled, but the amount of available data for footballers is monumental. In the higher leagues every movement has been tracked. Surely it makes sense to use what is available.
Posts: 12,682
Threads: 1,158
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
15
Didn't we hire the two Barnsley analysts Adam and Jack to purely look at analytical stats.
Posts: 9,321
Threads: 720
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
9
(12-03-2021, 10:25 AM)Gzbaggy Wrote: (12-03-2021, 09:40 AM)Bob Fossil Wrote: Sounds like a collaboration to me, which is exactly what we should expect. That's why this "xxx wasn't his player" is nonsense to me. Whilst Val may not get his first choice, he will have sanctioned every signing as did managers before him.
With our budget, every signing is a risk, however. I can think of many signings that were derided by fans who went on to be club legends (even the likes of Regis, Cunningham and Taylor had many, many doubters). There are also many that have been lauded as a coup, that went on to be complete dogs. Add in that it's January and it's all a bit of a lottery, I've just got everything crossed that we find a couple of gems, don't care if they cost £20m or are free as long as they are better than what we have and get us winning again.
many or most signings?
we have signed far too many players who have come for "one last payday" and whose career is in decline (these are usually labelled experienced) this is not difficult to predict in advance of signing them!
the better older players are those with something to prove and who we represent a step up (GMac) and those who are "very good pros"(Phillips and Taylor) Note that all of those started their professional career late and would have had a job outside football
That's why I wouldn't sign Gayle and Snods has turned out to be a disaster.
Posts: 13,407
Threads: 402
Joined: Jul 2019
Reputation:
14
(12-03-2021, 11:19 AM)HLS Wrote: (12-02-2021, 08:47 PM)Birdman1811 Wrote: (12-02-2021, 08:45 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: Identifying players through stats is a very blunt tool. All seems rather one dimensional, players aren’t statistical data. I know it’s trendy, as is the pressing style of play but it seems like recruitment by numbers.
It was a big part of what we did under Ashworth. Of course the stats are very detailed and you also get full personality reports on players too.
Out of interest, how do you suggest doing it?
By seeing if they come from a nice family and if they will play for England one day.
Damn, top 'arfs, this is the only real way!
|