Posts: 8,954
Threads: 166
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
77
Watched episode 1 today and seriously fascinating. You can see how much Paul is driving them by then but also how insecure he is and looking for their assurance and support. You can see the tensions when they get tired but most of the time they are a group of mates and you can see it clearly.
To come up with Get Back, Long and Winding Road, Two of us, Accross the UNiverse, I me mine, and All things must pass in the 1st 7 days is unbelievable.
Linda and Yoko gossiping and getting on. And then George finally popping after being ignored for basically every bit of input is great to see in one episode. A proper music documentary
Posts: 2,955
Threads: 67
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
12
(11-26-2021, 04:04 PM)Fido Wrote: (11-26-2021, 03:25 PM)1971 Wrote: (11-26-2021, 02:53 PM)MassDebater Wrote: I downloaded their discography for my old man... it comes up on my random shuffled play lists still. They were vastly over rated, but different enough for their day. A case of perfect timing for a now watered down product?
"Vastly overated" Not many other bands still finding new fans after 60 odd years.
Have to agree with Danny Baker. Any discussion about the best band ever is actually a discussion about who was the second best band ever. Never heard that Danny Baker quote.
Brilliant. And true.
Posts: 4,261
Threads: 263
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
25
(11-26-2021, 02:53 PM)MassDebater Wrote: I downloaded their discography for my old man... it comes up on my random shuffled play lists still. They were vastly over rated, but different enough for their day. A case of perfect timing for a now watered down product?
As you obviously weren't alive at the time, MD, you can't possibly comprehend the huge influence they had on pop music the world over. OK, American rock'n'roll was a happening thing, skiffle was getting some airplay in Britain, but The Beatles blew the whole scene open. So many other influential bands would not have made it if the Fab Four hadn't conquered the world, and specifically the USA. The charts were full of nothing but crooning balladeers and novelty songs when I was a kid - don't take my word for it, have a look at British Hit Singles up to 1963.
It's beyond belief that anyone can doubt the songwriting talent of Lennon/McCartney as a team and the musicianship of Macca and George Harrison over many years. Is your old man still around? Have you told him they were "vastly over rated" and "now watered down"? Good way to get disinherited if you were my son (perish the thought). You are either as big an idiot as you seem, or a complete wind-up merchant.
Posts: 3,808
Threads: 49
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
3
(11-28-2021, 11:00 PM)Cheshire East Baggie Wrote: (11-26-2021, 02:53 PM)MassDebater Wrote: I downloaded their discography for my old man... it comes up on my random shuffled play lists still. They were vastly over rated, but different enough for their day. A case of perfect timing for a now watered down product?
As you obviously weren't alive at the time, MD, you can't possibly comprehend the huge influence they had on pop music the world over. OK, American rock'n'roll was a happening thing, skiffle was getting some airplay in Britain, but The Beatles blew the whole scene open. So many other influential bands would not have made it if the Fab Four hadn't conquered the world, and specifically the USA. The charts were full of nothing but crooning balladeers and novelty songs when I was a kid - don't take my word for it, have a look at British Hit Singles up to 1963.
It's beyond belief that anyone can doubt the songwriting talent of Lennon/McCartney as a team and the musicianship of Macca and George Harrison over many years. Is your old man still around? Have you told him they were "vastly over rated" and "now watered down"? Good way to get disinherited if you were my son (perish the thought). You are either as big an idiot as you seem, or a complete wind-up merchant. I have a much older, less good looking brother, ( only joking ), he remembers the early 60's, tripe like Val Doonican, Charlie Drake etc being on T.V. He always preferred the Beach Boys, Yardbirds to name two, but even he says the Beatles were great, they didn't just change music, they changed the world.
Posts: 27,984
Threads: 1,168
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
64
(11-28-2021, 11:00 PM)Cheshire East Baggie Wrote: (11-26-2021, 02:53 PM)MassDebater Wrote: I downloaded their discography for my old man... it comes up on my random shuffled play lists still. They were vastly over rated, but different enough for their day. A case of perfect timing for a now watered down product?
As you obviously weren't alive at the time, MD, you can't possibly comprehend the huge influence they had on pop music the world over. OK, American rock'n'roll was a happening thing, skiffle was getting some airplay in Britain, but The Beatles blew the whole scene open. So many other influential bands would not have made it if the Fab Four hadn't conquered the world, and specifically the USA. The charts were full of nothing but crooning balladeers and novelty songs when I was a kid - don't take my word for it, have a look at British Hit Singles up to 1963.
It's beyond belief that anyone can doubt the songwriting talent of Lennon/McCartney as a team and the musicianship of Macca and George Harrison over many years. Is your old man still around? Have you told him they were "vastly over rated" and "now watered down"? Good way to get disinherited if you were my son (perish the thought). You are either as big an idiot as you seem, or a complete wind-up merchant.
Fucking hell Chesh, bit of an overreaction no?
Music is entirely subjective, it’s quite possible to think a massive act is overrated (I feel that way about Springsteen for instance). Personally I love the Beatles and can’t wait to see this film, but not liking them doesn’t make one an idiot or a WUM.
Posts: 4,261
Threads: 263
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
25
(11-28-2021, 11:52 PM)Duffers Wrote: (11-28-2021, 11:00 PM)Cheshire East Baggie Wrote: (11-26-2021, 02:53 PM)MassDebater Wrote: I downloaded their discography for my old man... it comes up on my random shuffled play lists still. They were vastly over rated, but different enough for their day. A case of perfect timing for a now watered down product?
As you obviously weren't alive at the time, MD, you can't possibly comprehend the huge influence they had on pop music the world over. OK, American rock'n'roll was a happening thing, skiffle was getting some airplay in Britain, but The Beatles blew the whole scene open. So many other influential bands would not have made it if the Fab Four hadn't conquered the world, and specifically the USA. The charts were full of nothing but crooning balladeers and novelty songs when I was a kid - don't take my word for it, have a look at British Hit Singles up to 1963.
It's beyond belief that anyone can doubt the songwriting talent of Lennon/McCartney as a team and the musicianship of Macca and George Harrison over many years. Is your old man still around? Have you told him they were "vastly over rated" and "now watered down"? Good way to get disinherited if you were my son (perish the thought). You are either as big an idiot as you seem, or a complete wind-up merchant.
Fucking hell Chesh, bit of an overreaction no?
Music is entirely subjective, it’s quite possible to think a massive act is overrated (I feel that way about Springsteen for instance). Personally I love the Beatles and can’t wait to see this film, but not liking them doesn’t make one an idiot or a WUM.
No, MD was on the wind up. It's impossible to overstate the influence of the Beatles. Trying to quantify talent is pointless in any field, but particularly the performing arts. What counts is impact and legacy. Nothing matches the Beatles in popular music history, nor ever will. I'm not saying that they were the best, or even my personal favourite, just that they unlocked popular music as we know it now. I was buying their singles for six'n'eightpence at Taylor's music shop in Walsall in 1963 (still got 'em). Take my word for it, they changed things.
Posts: 343
Threads: 14
Joined: May 2021
Reputation:
1
Agree Chesire, people who think The Beatles are overrated are wrong. Whether you're a fan or not, they changed absolutely everything. Whilst I wasn't there (born in 1990!), the world of music would be a very different place without them.
Posts: 3,392
Threads: 218
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
8
I’ve watched the first 2 parts now. Really good
Posts: 15,040
Threads: 339
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
93
Cheshire East Baggie Wrote:MassDebater Wrote:I downloaded their discography for my old man... it comes up on my random shuffled play lists still. They were vastly over rated, but different enough for their day. A case of perfect timing for a now watered down product?
As you obviously weren't alive at the time, MD, you can't possibly comprehend the huge influence they had on pop music the world over. OK, American rock'n'roll was a happening thing, skiffle was getting some airplay in Britain, but The Beatles blew the whole scene open. So many other influential bands would not have made it if the Fab Four hadn't conquered the world, and specifically the USA. The charts were full of nothing but crooning balladeers and novelty songs when I was a kid - don't take my word for it, have a look at British Hit Singles up to 1963.
It's beyond belief that anyone can doubt the songwriting talent of Lennon/McCartney as a team and the musicianship of Macca and George Harrison over many years. Is your old man still around? Have you told him they were "vastly over rated" and "now watered down"? Good way to get disinherited if you were my son (perish the thought). You are either as big an idiot as you seem, or a complete wind-up merchant.
I mostly agree with Cheshire East Baggie, The Beatles blew the scene open. Personally though, I'm not a big fan (George apart). That said, they were the catalyst that sparked the revolution. Their tight playing and vocal harmonies honed in the sweaty clubs of Hamburg gave them a big start when back in England and they were truly innovative. Songs such as I Saw Her Standing There and Twist and Shout take me right back to infants school playtimes when we would all play imaginary guitars and fight to be John or Paul. We didn't do that over any other band. For me though, interest peaked and waned. For every Penny Lane there was a Maxwells Silver Hammer , for every In My Life, there seems to be an Octopus's Garden. I soon preferred the bad boy Stones, the pure energy of The Who, the quaint Englishness of The Kinks, then Dylan and The Band and almost everything American.
Then just to throw petrol on the flames, I really can't stand Sergeant Pepper. I don't care how innovative it was, where are the good songs? Odyssey and Oracle by The Zombies is my go-to album of the sixties plus by that time Chas Chandler had found Jimi Hendrix.
The Beatles can rightly be recognised as leading the way but I really believe if they hadn't existed, someone else would have done it. The bonfire was already built, they lit the match.
Posts: 8,954
Threads: 166
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
77
11-30-2021, 05:20 PM
(This post was last modified: 11-30-2021, 05:21 PM by baggy1.)
It's very easy to judge the music by different standards and improvements in recording equipment (much like comparing 60s and 70s footballers to todays standards) but if you put each of the Beatles alums in the time with it's direct comparisons then they stand out a mile - they were the run away league leaders of their time. The only other artist that I can see falls into that category is Bowie (listen to his albums and try and date them without looking, they are all a couple of years ahead of the trend).
And as for Sgt Pepper's I would challenge your view with the title track, with a little help.., LSD, and A day in the life as the good songs on there. You have one big advantage though which is that I wasn't there (well not in a way that I could critique the quality of the tunes) and it really does make a big difference being in the moment when it comes to music.
|