Posts: 1,036
Threads: 23
Joined: Jan 2019
I am still wondering given we have an ageing population and a lack of people in numerous sectors who is going to do those jobs if it isn't immigrants? Where is the workforce coming from?
At the risks these people are taking?
Posts: 8,954
Threads: 166
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
77
(11-26-2021, 01:41 PM)Jacobthebaggie Wrote: I am still wondering given we have an ageing population and a lack of people in numerous sectors who is going to do those jobs if it isn't immigrants? Where is the workforce coming from?
At the risks these people are taking?
Two very separate issues Jacob, none of the illegal immigrants that are trying to get across the channel in dinghies would be eligible for work until they had been granted asylum anyway so hat won't be their primary reason for coming here.
Immigration through legal work permit methods is separate to that and it will be interesting to see where we are when the world settles down. We definitely have a need for extra workers in areas that won't be deemed as highly skilled so we won't be allowing people to come into the country on work permits for that, however it remains to be seen where they will come from if we can't fill them through our own workforce.
There will probably be many reasons why people will try and get to the UK illegally, some of them will be down to understandable reasons: the language, family already over here, an understanding that they have a right e.g. afghani interpreters, other reasons will be down to thinking they can get more from the UK than they can elsewhere, housing, financial support, opportunity. Whatever the reason is it is borne out of desperation and a need for security, I can't imagine anyone leaving a secure safe place to travel across the continent risking everything including death without having a very compelling reason to do so.
What I do see is that the current posturing and soundbites from the government aren't working clearly and a new approach is needed. I see we've managed to get ourselves excluded from the discussions with other European countries because we have gone in with all guns blazing telling the French what to do.
Posts: 17,074
Threads: 614
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
114
(11-26-2021, 02:25 PM)baggy1 Wrote: (11-26-2021, 01:41 PM)Jacobthebaggie Wrote: I am still wondering given we have an ageing population and a lack of people in numerous sectors who is going to do those jobs if it isn't immigrants? Where is the workforce coming from?
At the risks these people are taking?
Two very separate issues Jacob, none of the illegal immigrants that are trying to get across the channel in dinghies would be eligible for work until they had been granted asylum anyway so hat won't be their primary reason for coming here.
Immigration through legal work permit methods is separate to that and it will be interesting to see where we are when the world settles down. We definitely have a need for extra workers in areas that won't be deemed as highly skilled so we won't be allowing people to come into the country on work permits for that, however it remains to be seen where they will come from if we can't fill them through our own workforce.
There will probably be many reasons why people will try and get to the UK illegally, some of them will be down to understandable reasons: the language, family already over here, an understanding that they have a right e.g. afghani interpreters, other reasons will be down to thinking they can get more from the UK than they can elsewhere, housing, financial support, opportunity. Whatever the reason is it is borne out of desperation and a need for security, I can't imagine anyone leaving a secure safe place to travel across the continent risking everything including death without having a very compelling reason to do so.
What I do see is that the current posturing and soundbites from the government aren't working clearly and a new approach is needed. I see we've managed to get ourselves excluded from the discussions with other European countries because we have gone in with all guns blazing telling the French what to do.
I think there is a link between 'illegal' and legal migration. We have to address one way or another the need for more workers. Yes they have come to the country in a less than ideal way but surely a pragmatic approach would be to see if some of those who enter via the channel could fill roles we have need for? Otherwise all we do is clog up hotels, hostels and government centres with people not being able to contribute to society in any other capacity than a volunteer for potentially years.
Posts: 1,036
Threads: 23
Joined: Jan 2019
Good plan. Don't worry about diseases, terrorists, thieves, rapists and murderers on the run coming across as long as they can pick an apple. They don't 'lose' their ID papers by mistake. Without the ID they can be any age or nationality they want to be and know it makes it more unlikely they'll be deported. I feel sorry for genuine people fleeing war zones and desperate situations but a lot aren't.
Posts: 17,074
Threads: 614
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
114
(11-27-2021, 01:25 PM)Jacobthebaggie Wrote: Good plan. Don't worry about diseases, terrorists, thieves, rapists and murderers on the run coming across as long as they can pick an apple. They don't 'lose' their ID papers by mistake. Without the ID they can be any age or nationality they want to be and know it makes it more unlikely they'll be deported. I feel sorry for genuine people fleeing war zones and desperate situations but a lot aren't.
Perhaps we could treat each person as a normal human being and ascertain if they would be an asset to the country? I appreciate that it would be preferable if they came through official channels but perhaps we shouldn’t pre-judge their reasons.
Posts: 1,036
Threads: 23
Joined: Jan 2019
(11-27-2021, 05:09 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: (11-27-2021, 01:25 PM)Jacobthebaggie Wrote: Good plan. Don't worry about diseases, terrorists, thieves, rapists and murderers on the run coming across as long as they can pick an apple. They don't 'lose' their ID papers by mistake. Without the ID they can be any age or nationality they want to be and know it makes it more unlikely they'll be deported. I feel sorry for genuine people fleeing war zones and desperate situations but a lot aren't.
Perhaps we could treat each person as a normal human being and ascertain if they would be an asset to the country? I appreciate that it would be preferable if they came through official channels but perhaps we shouldn’t pre-judge their reasons.
They don't discard their proof of identity for nothing. It's to hide their country of origin, their real age or their past. Not the actions of the innocent. Do a bit of searching around for wanted criminals, adults in their 30's claiming to be children and people from certain countries claiming to be from others to add kudos to their illegal migration. I'm not saying they're all like that but unfortunately it needs to stop. Legal or not at all.
Posts: 11,311
Threads: 419
Joined: Feb 2020
Reputation:
18
(11-27-2021, 05:09 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: Perhaps we could treat each person as a normal human being and ascertain if they would be an asset to the country? I appreciate that it would be preferable if they came through official channels but perhaps we shouldn’t pre-judge their reasons.
Yes, we could do that by selecting refugees from refugee camps (as we do) and making it clear to the queue jumpers that they will be neither housed nor allowed to work in the UK - as is the case in Northern France.
Not sure anyone actually saw the BBC / Sky reports on TV last night which went into great detail about one of the poor Iraqi Kurds who died last week. She was travelling (illegally) to the UK to be with her fiance who'd already travelled here (illegally). TV crews visited her grieving family in a peaceful village in Northern Iraq who stated that she left for a "better life".
It's not unreasonable to want a better life. Neither is it acceptable to drown in flimsy zodiac trying to get to the UK.
But let's not pretend we're wholly dealing with refugees fleeing violence and oppression. Because we're not. We're dealing with queue jumpers who can afford to pay thousands to people smugglers.
https://news.sky.com/story/channel-death...y-12479618
Posts: 4,261
Threads: 263
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
25
So now we're talking about "proof of identity". So here's an idea. Why don't we issue every legitimate British resident with an Identity Card, to link medical, taxation and residency status data and provide clear proof of who you are? It defies logic that we can be so opposed to uncontrolled (and especially illegal) immigration, but also so strongly opposed to the notion of ID cards. You can only control your borders if you know who people are. Just a suggestion.
Posts: 17,074
Threads: 614
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
114
Posts: 1,036
Threads: 23
Joined: Jan 2019
11-28-2021, 03:18 PM
(This post was last modified: 11-28-2021, 03:20 PM by Jacobthebaggie.)
If the legal channel is closed then it's for a reason. I'm guessing the country is running out of hotels to house them all in. Even the illegal Houses of Mass Occupation are full night and day. The barracks that they were put in weren't good enough and caused rioting. People standing in Parliament criticising the blocking of these people don't see shit because they don't live amongst it. Housing can't be built quick enough even if we had the money, materials and skilled labour. Green belt land being built on after decades of no chance as long as a percentage of the new builds are allocated to sheltered housing. Hospitals, doctors, schools, roads, sewage and public transport already stretched to breaking point. People say poor conditions cause crime and knife crime etc and you want to add to that? Control is needed not more chaos even if it is only to stop them acting like lemmings.
Being do gooders doesn't always do good
|