Where do we go from here......
#51
(11-21-2021, 08:31 PM)coxy134 Wrote:
(11-21-2021, 07:19 PM)Tom Joad Wrote:
coxy134 Wrote:
Dial M for Mick Wrote:Sam Allardyce was blamed for not getting the best out of this shower last season. Now Ismael is getting the same treatment. All that will change if he goes is that a different person will be blamed for problems that have been going on for years now.

Sam had a few players (OK etc) who marginally improved the team. We had Perriera and Gallagher. Those players have not been replaced. He also it seems had no confidence in Livermore.

Seems to me its the quality of players thats the issue and investment by owners.
You've nailed it, Coxy.  Chuck in the fact we have a load of wingers attempting to be strikers. This squad ain't all that.
Don't think its just the squad either, I think the whole club has gone flat. I stood in an empty ticket office last week for a few minutes before any of the 3 cashiers could be bothered to end their chat and call me forward. 
Not sure if its the fault of the owners who aren't pushing the club forward or the we have just got into the idea of relegation then promotion? Or is it we are simply sitting back and waiting to be sold. 

Personally at the moment I feel we are in a gloomy place yet we are 3rd in the league.

You’ve got it bang on. I’m a glass half full kind of guy, but there’s just a real nagging feeling many of us have that the club is rudderless. 
At least Peace stamped his identity on the club.
Reply
#52
(11-21-2021, 10:07 PM)Spandaubaggie Wrote:
(11-21-2021, 08:31 PM)coxy134 Wrote:
(11-21-2021, 07:19 PM)Tom Joad Wrote:
coxy134 Wrote:
Dial M for Mick Wrote:Sam Allardyce was blamed for not getting the best out of this shower last season. Now Ismael is getting the same treatment. All that will change if he goes is that a different person will be blamed for problems that have been going on for years now.

Sam had a few players (OK etc) who marginally improved the team. We had Perriera and Gallagher. Those players have not been replaced. He also it seems had no confidence in Livermore.

Seems to me its the quality of players thats the issue and investment by owners.
You've nailed it, Coxy.  Chuck in the fact we have a load of wingers attempting to be strikers. This squad ain't all that.
Don't think its just the squad either, I think the whole club has gone flat. I stood in an empty ticket office last week for a few minutes before any of the 3 cashiers could be bothered to end their chat and call me forward. 
Not sure if its the fault of the owners who aren't pushing the club forward or the we have just got into the idea of relegation then promotion? Or is it we are simply sitting back and waiting to be sold. 

Personally at the moment I feel we are in a gloomy place yet we are 3rd in the league.

You’ve got it bang on. I’m a glass half full kind of guy, but there’s just a real nagging feeling many of us have that the club is rudderless. 
At least Peace stamped his identity on the club.

Yes. I'd say I was an optimist, can't bear that clique of fans who are always gleefully predicting doom for the club, but I think we have some hard times ahead.

Back to the earlier conversation, you can punch above your weight if you are a well-run club. We arent.

We also have a reputation for getting through managers in a manner that those outside of the club and supporter base find harsh. Aside from Pardew, there has been no managerial sacking of recent times that hasn't had the media shaking their heads at how brutal we and and what should Little West Brom expect. That all impacts how attractive we are as a club to potential managers.

In fairness, any club with a shot of PL will have some appeal to British managers, because PL level jobs are increasingly a closed shop and it's their best opportunity to get one.

However, most managers want some money to spend and we appear not to have any. Which again, will lessen our appeal.
Reply
#53
Squid Wrote:
Spandaubaggie Wrote:
coxy134 Wrote:
Tom Joad Wrote:
coxy134 Wrote:Sam had a few players (OK etc) who marginally improved the team. We had Perriera and Gallagher. Those players have not been replaced. He also it seems had no confidence in Livermore.

Seems to me its the quality of players thats the issue and investment by owners.
You've nailed it, Coxy.  Chuck in the fact we have a load of wingers attempting to be strikers. This squad ain't all that.
Don't think its just the squad either, I think the whole club has gone flat. I stood in an empty ticket office last week for a few minutes before any of the 3 cashiers could be bothered to end their chat and call me forward. 
Not sure if its the fault of the owners who aren't pushing the club forward or the we have just got into the idea of relegation then promotion? Or is it we are simply sitting back and waiting to be sold. 

Personally at the moment I feel we are in a gloomy place yet we are 3rd in the league.

You’ve got it bang on. I’m a glass half full kind of guy, but there’s just a real nagging feeling many of us have that the club is rudderless. 
At least Peace stamped his identity on the club.

Yes. I'd say I was an optimist, can't bear that clique of fans who are always gleefully predicting doom for the club, but I think we have some hard times ahead.

Back to the earlier conversation, you can punch above your weight if you are a well-run club. We arent.

We also have a reputation for getting through managers in a manner that those outside of the club and supporter base find harsh. Aside from Pardew, there has been no managerial sacking of recent times that hasn't had the media shaking their heads at how brutal we and and what should Little West Brom expect. That all impacts how attractive we are as a club to potential managers.

In fairness, any club with a shot of PL will have some appeal to British managers, because PL level jobs are increasingly a closed shop and it's their best opportunity to get one.

However, most managers want some money to spend and we appear not to have any. Which again, will lessen our appeal.

And how ironic was that? Big Dave kept us alive into the last week despite us being inept all season. In a whole year  of ifs, buts and "let's shoot ourselves in the foot another time", if we had got shot of Pardew  at ANY time at all sooner, BD may have engineered the greatest escape ever.

Back on the OP. I admit, I'm one of the nearest on here to a glass half full. This manager has not been given a chance. I agree with the criticism of the  inflexible 3-4-3, and the predictable subs but I'd like to see him with a few decent signings before I join in with the condemnation. What I saw on Saturday was a team busting a gut in effort but lacking in quality, particularly in midfield and attack. As for those saying Periera wouldn't suit this system, he would be ideal as one of the front 3 and absolutely leagues above anything else we have. Okay would have transformed us too, as would the mood on legs that is Diagne.
Reply
#54
(11-21-2021, 10:07 PM)Spandaubaggie Wrote:
(11-21-2021, 08:31 PM)coxy134 Wrote:
(11-21-2021, 07:19 PM)Tom Joad Wrote:
coxy134 Wrote:
Dial M for Mick Wrote:Sam Allardyce was blamed for not getting the best out of this shower last season. Now Ismael is getting the same treatment. All that will change if he goes is that a different person will be blamed for problems that have been going on for years now.

Sam had a few players (OK etc) who marginally improved the team. We had Perriera and Gallagher. Those players have not been replaced. He also it seems had no confidence in Livermore.

Seems to me its the quality of players thats the issue and investment by owners.
You've nailed it, Coxy.  Chuck in the fact we have a load of wingers attempting to be strikers. This squad ain't all that.
Don't think its just the squad either, I think the whole club has gone flat. I stood in an empty ticket office last week for a few minutes before any of the 3 cashiers could be bothered to end their chat and call me forward. 
Not sure if its the fault of the owners who aren't pushing the club forward or the we have just got into the idea of relegation then promotion? Or is it we are simply sitting back and waiting to be sold. 

Personally at the moment I feel we are in a gloomy place yet we are 3rd in the league.

You’ve got it bang on. I’m a glass half full kind of guy, but there’s just a real nagging feeling many of us have that the club is rudderless. 
At least Peace stamped his identity on the club.

We need a dynamic CEO to lead from the front. I didn't like Jenkins as a person, but by Christ he knew how to run the ship from top to bottom.
Reply
#55
(11-21-2021, 05:36 PM)Jacobthebaggie Wrote: Where were these managers that would love to come here when Roy left? We don't pay the big money, they don't get big transfer budgets and it's generally a scrap against relegation or a dogfight for promotion. None of these appeal to any names. Also name these English and Scottish managers claimed to be out there to do the job. I've listened to music day and night for over 50 years but still can't play a note. The third best squad is in third place on a ladder trying to escape a shark infested sea.

This, for me - is the absolute essence of our downfall. Under the Hodgson / Ashworth / Peace axis for the first time in my adult life we appeared to have a plan. 

The football was downright attritional at times - but it was absolutely right for the players that we had. Roy did a magnificent job and his legacy was crying out to be built on.

We neither employed the right manager (over several appointments) or provided a budget that really would have allowed us to consolidate. Why? Well Peace also had an eye for the exit. 

We are where we are. With a remote owner who won't (can't?) invest, an overpaid decidedly average squad and a manager with the ideological zeal of Jeremy Corbyn. Actually, I think we're overachieving with what he has.

Nothing will change until the ownership does. On the anniversary of JFK's shooting - Val is merely the latest patsy.
Reply
#56
(11-22-2021, 12:27 PM)Protheroe Wrote:
(11-21-2021, 05:36 PM)Jacobthebaggie Wrote: Where were these managers that would love to come here when Roy left? We don't pay the big money, they don't get big transfer budgets and it's generally a scrap against relegation or a dogfight for promotion. None of these appeal to any names. Also name these English and Scottish managers claimed to be out there to do the job. I've listened to music day and night for over 50 years but still can't play a note. The third best squad is in third place on a ladder trying to escape a shark infested sea.

This, for me - is the absolute essence of our downfall. Under the Hodgson / Ashworth / Peace axis for the first time in my adult life we appeared to have a plan. 

The football was downright attritional at times - but it was absolutely right for the players that we had. Roy did a magnificent job and his legacy was crying out to be built on.

We neither employed the right manager (over several appointments) or provided a budget that really would have allowed us to consolidate. Why? Well Peace also had an eye for the exit. 

We are where we are. With a remote owner who won't (can't?) invest, an overpaid decidedly average squad and a manager with the ideological zeal of Jeremy Corbyn. Actually, I think we're overachieving with what he has.

Nothing will change until the ownership does. On the anniversary of JFK's shooting - Val is merely the latest patsy.

That's the truth of it.
Reply
#57
(11-22-2021, 12:27 PM)Protheroe Wrote:
(11-21-2021, 05:36 PM)Jacobthebaggie Wrote: Where were these managers that would love to come here when Roy left? We don't pay the big money, they don't get big transfer budgets and it's generally a scrap against relegation or a dogfight for promotion. None of these appeal to any names. Also name these English and Scottish managers claimed to be out there to do the job. I've listened to music day and night for over 50 years but still can't play a note. The third best squad is in third place on a ladder trying to escape a shark infested sea.

This, for me - is the absolute essence of our downfall. Under the Hodgson / Ashworth / Peace axis for the first time in my adult life we appeared to have a plan. 

The football was downright attritional at times - but it was absolutely right for the players that we had. Roy did a magnificent job and his legacy was crying out to be built on.

We neither employed the right manager (over several appointments) or provided a budget that really would have allowed us to consolidate. Why? Well Peace also had an eye for the exit. 

We are where we are. With a remote owner who won't (can't?) invest, an overpaid decidedly average squad and a manager with the ideological zeal of Jeremy Corbyn. Actually, I think we're overachieving with what he has.

Nothing will change until the ownership does. On the anniversary of JFK's shooting - Val is merely the latest patsy.

Tbf.

Clarke's appointment was in that plan, and how that first year went showed why the plan was there. Yes the second half of the season got derailed, loss of Gera and Wingie, two key players for Clarke contributed to that, plus the departure of Ashworth himself. 

That summer onwards, fuck me, if we could fuck it up, we did.
Reply
#58
Wim shit, Tom.
Clarnet v2.0
Reply
#59
(11-21-2021, 11:03 AM)ferencpuskas Wrote: is the question being asked  on this board, following yesterday's result . I posted a thread on here back in Sept stating this manager is not for us! Of course it was met with derision, scorn and a few personal insults, but after 65 years in football, both as a player and manager, I'd heard  worse, so it was water off a duck's back really, however the chickens are now coming home to roost aren't they ?   
The answer ?   Bite the bullet, pay this clown of a manager off, put Jimmy Morrison in charge temporarily and bring in a new bloke, British if possible.  I firmly believe this squad properly managed, and motivated, and the right team selected can easily make the play offs, if not directly promoted, there's plenty of points available, here endeth the lesson!

We knew Val's style when he came and accepted him generally.  

He is not a clown Ferenc, he has been badly let down by the players through chances missed and stupid decisions and mistakes which have possibly cost us at 9/10 points.  

2 - Derby - chance after chance went begging
1 - Stoke - bad mistake by Townsend cost us two points
3 - Swans - bad mistake by Furlong and then keystone cops defending by the back 3 - Clarke was appalling - cost us 3 points when we never looked in trouble
1? - Fulham - never looked in trouble 'til ref intervened with a non-penalty and then shocking schoolboy error by Snodgrass cost us the chance of getting something
2 - Boro - again poor defending for the goal and shocking performances by the front 3 
3 - Hudds - poor defending again, Kipre playing offside but TGH not on the same wavelength then 20 shots but not one hit the net. 

The players are to blame for the position we currently find ourselves in not Val.  I'm backing him to turn it round.
Reply
#60
Hoppy you as a supporter have comprehensively, highlighted the catalogue of mistakes, both in missed chances, and defensive errors  that have resulted in this loss of points, then surely it must be the Manager and his "coaches" job to address this and ensure it does not continue. Obviously for whatever reason, it isn't happening..... ..why?          Who then is at fault ...?   Certainly not always the officials, and definitely not the Board.
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: