Flybe
#11
I like BHX, because you don't have to walk miles through a shopping mall and endless corridors to get on a plane. Gatwick is atrocious for that.

I agree with Massdebator about Manchester upthread, I agree it's really tatty looking now and Liverpool just seems some big shopping area with hardly anywhere to sit.

Of course Heathrow has better choices and flight times, it's one of the biggest fight hubs in the world and it's handily on the right side of London for us.
Reply
#12
(11-17-2021, 10:23 AM)MassDebater Wrote:
(11-17-2021, 09:48 AM)Ted Maul Wrote: On a separate note, how shite has Birmingham Airport got?

Even pre-Covid it was getting rid of destinations AOTS and all the flight times are crap. Considering it's the second city airport it's embarrassing how far its fallen behind the likes of Manchester, Luton and Stansted.

BHX is pretty crap these days agreed. however we went from Manchester the other year and that I would say is now worse, I remembered it being really good ages ago, but was sorely disappointed about 3 years ago. I actually thought it was worse than Brum. BHX is handy if you want to go to Asian places, but shyte if you want to go west...or to a lot of Europe, so hopefully this new Flybe will start going to places people want instead... I won't hold my breath though!

In terms of destinations Manchester is miles ahead of Birmingham. It's a bit of a shambles that you can't fly direct to the states from the second largest city on this island.
Reply
#13
Ted Maul Wrote:
MassDebater Wrote:
Ted Maul Wrote:On a separate note, how shite has Birmingham Airport got?

Even pre-Covid it was getting rid of destinations AOTS and all the flight times are crap. Considering it's the second city airport it's embarrassing how far its fallen behind the likes of Manchester, Luton and Stansted.

BHX is pretty crap these days agreed. however we went from Manchester the other year and that I would say is now worse, I remembered it being really good ages ago, but was sorely disappointed about 3 years ago. I actually thought it was worse than Brum. BHX is handy if you want to go to Asian places, but shyte if you want to go west...or to a lot of Europe, so hopefully this new Flybe will start going to places people want instead... I won't hold my breath though!

In terms of destinations Manchester is miles ahead of Birmingham. It's a bit of a shambles that you can't fly direct to the states from the second largest city on this island.

Always baffling that BHX cannot hold some key schedules to major US hubs.

So many airlines have tried with varying US destinations but they rarely last, not that many charters over the years either considering the catchment area.
Reply
#14
(11-17-2021, 12:55 PM)EastMidsBaggie Wrote:
Ted Maul Wrote:
MassDebater Wrote:
Ted Maul Wrote:On a separate note, how shite has Birmingham Airport got?

Even pre-Covid it was getting rid of destinations AOTS and all the flight times are crap. Considering it's the second city airport it's embarrassing how far its fallen behind the likes of Manchester, Luton and Stansted.

BHX is pretty crap these days agreed. however we went from Manchester the other year and that I would say is now worse, I remembered it being really good ages ago, but was sorely disappointed about 3 years ago. I actually thought it was worse than Brum. BHX is handy if you want to go to Asian places, but shyte if you want to go west...or to a lot of Europe, so hopefully this new Flybe will start going to places people want instead... I won't hold my breath though!

In terms of destinations Manchester is miles ahead of Birmingham. It's a bit of a shambles that you can't fly direct to the states from the second largest city on this island.

Always baffling that BHX cannot hold some key schedules to major US hubs.

So many airlines have tried with varying US destinations but they rarely last, not that many charters over the years either considering the catchment area.

Let's face it... BHX is an hour and a half from one of the largest airports in the world meaning it's unlikely to need US links of its own - given the plethora of transatlantic flights departing Heathrow and the fact people are unlikely to be making those flights more then once or twice a year means the commute is hardly a problem. For those that don't want to commute, it has multiple daily links to Schipol, CDG and Frankfurt as well as Dubai and Istanbul meaning the rest of the world is 1 change away. 

Domestically, there aren't too many routes which BHX needs outside of Scotland Ireland/NI - destinations like Southampton, Exeter, Newquay, Norwich are all 3-4 hours away by car, which when you factor in the faffing around either side, there's not much to be gained.

I'm going to be travelling a lot from Brum in the coming months due to taking on a role around Europe, and I've been surprised at how easy it will be to do the majority of my routes from Brum. There will be the odd jaunt to a London airport, but for the most part you can get to pretty much all the major European hubs a couple times a day with relative ease.
Reply
#15
(11-17-2021, 11:45 AM)Ted Maul Wrote:
(11-17-2021, 10:23 AM)MassDebater Wrote:
(11-17-2021, 09:48 AM)Ted Maul Wrote: On a separate note, how shite has Birmingham Airport got?

Even pre-Covid it was getting rid of destinations AOTS and all the flight times are crap. Considering it's the second city airport it's embarrassing how far its fallen behind the likes of Manchester, Luton and Stansted.

BHX is pretty crap these days agreed. however we went from Manchester the other year and that I would say is now worse, I remembered it being really good ages ago, but was sorely disappointed about 3 years ago. I actually thought it was worse than Brum. BHX is handy if you want to go to Asian places, but shyte if you want to go west...or to a lot of Europe, so hopefully this new Flybe will start going to places people want instead... I won't hold my breath though!

In terms of destinations Manchester is miles ahead of Birmingham. It's a bit of a shambles that you can't fly direct to the states from the second largest city on this island.

I agree about the destinations, but I was on about the airport experience being shyte at Manc these days. BHX simply has to get some of its routes back if it is going to do anything.
Reply
#16
BHX is really expensive to fly from. I always find that the cows shed (EMA), is much cheaper. Big Grin
Reply
#17
(11-17-2021, 03:58 PM)SausEggBaton Wrote: BHX is really expensive to fly from. I always find that the cows shed (EMA), is much cheaper. Big Grin

Yep and for European flights ahead of BHX a lot of the time.
Reply
#18
Talking of second city airports I once got into an argument at Lyon airport with their catering staff. It's a bit like Charles de Gaulle (another shit airport given the city it caters for) in that there is a decent choice of food before you go through security but not a lot after - in Lyon there's virtually nothing. So I went to the snack bar near to my gate and wanted to buy the last, lonely baguette that was available for purchase. Only it wasn't available as the girl behind the counter said she was about to finish her shift and that she's kept it for herself to eat when she was off!
Reply
#19
(11-17-2021, 11:18 AM)Squid Wrote: I like BHX, because you don't have to walk miles through a shopping mall and endless corridors to get on a plane. Gatwick is atrocious for that.

I agree with Massdebator about Manchester upthread, I agree it's really tatty looking now and Liverpool just seems some big shopping area with hardly anywhere to sit.

Of course Heathrow has better choices and flight times, it's one of the biggest fight hubs in the world and it's handily on the right side of London for us.

What's the first rule of fight hub?
Reply
#20
As Sw4 says, BHX suffers from just being too close to Heathrow, Manchester gets some of the routes by simply being too far from Heathrow for the commute to be worthwhile whilst still having enough population density to support it, unlike say Newcastle.

So in reality you can be at either Heathrow or Manchester in little over an hour for the vast majority of the population caught in the BHX "catchment area". It would be better served acting as Heathrow's overspill and with HS2 will be pushing "fly to BHX and be in central London in 60 minutes". To people in the UsofA 60 minutes is a neighbour!
Trump is a Cunt
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: