Petrol and Diesel
There's no getting away from the fact that you're asking the asset poor and low paid to subsidise my childrens' inheritance in the event I need long term care.

Tell me I'm wrong.
Reply
(11-16-2021, 09:27 AM)Protheroe Wrote: There's no getting away from the fact that you're asking the asset poor and low paid to subsidise my childrens' inheritance in the event I need long term care.

Tell me I'm wrong.

You're blinkered and wrong - you see the only way of reducing wealth inequality is by getting everyone to the lowest common denominator. A race to the bottom in the truest sense. You can't see that there are other methods of improving the services other than draining the individuals funds to pay for the service, this just kicks the can down the road as eventually everyone's asset base is eroded and everyone needs to rely on the state to support them.
Reply
Erm, no. I just don't think poor people ought to subsidise my kids' inheritance. I'm amazed that you see that as a controversial viewpoint.
Reply
(11-16-2021, 10:33 AM)Protheroe Wrote: Erm, no. I just don't think poor people ought to subsidise my kids' inheritance. I'm amazed that you see that as a controversial viewpoint.

So appropriate taxation of corporations (or simply collecting the tax due), and increasing the higher rate tax threshold to increase tax revenues to pay for better services would be impacting on the poor people how exactly? We could also add in not giving away billions of taxpayers money to those that fund the Tory party but that would be a bit obvious.
Reply
At least I know where you stand. You'd rather stifle incentives and choice by taxing people's earnings and spending (we ultimately pay Corporation Tax), rather than threaten my kids' entirely unearned inheritance. I'm staggered. My kids will thank you though.
Reply
(11-16-2021, 05:13 PM)Protheroe Wrote: At least I know where you stand. You'd rather stifle incentives and choice by taxing people's earnings and spending (we ultimately pay Corporation Tax), rather than threaten my kids' entirely unearned inheritance. I'm staggered. My kids will thank you though.

Don't talk bollox, stifle incentives  Big Grin , you'll be talking about wealth creators and trickle down economy next. You really did find an economic theory in 1996 and stuck with it for life despite how everything has turned out. You see the remedy to the wealth inequality in the UK as making everyone poor instead of creating a fairer society. The thought of paying more tax so that someone else can benefit from your rental income is actually making your eyeballs sweat isn't it  Big Grin
Reply
Creating a fairer society, by ensuring taxpayers support the in-built inequality of inherited wealth. Whilst conveniently ignoring that it's only a minority of the elderly that will need long term care.

I have literally heard it all now.
Reply
More and more will need care and milking the inheritance cow til it’s dry won’t solve that problem. Time to start working on the viable solution and building a better care system now. Or we kick the can down the road as you suggest for all of our kids to deal with. You are stuck in that 1996 theoretical world and it’s showing with your plans for fuel and the economy. I’m guessing you still ask for curtains at the barbers  Big Grin
Reply
(11-11-2021, 10:54 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: This is ridiculous, myself and others have acknowledged time and time again that global problems are impacting the U.K. However you will not accept that Brexit will exasperate many of the problems we face be it in logistics, rising food prices, shortages of workers. No point even debating anything with you if you cannot even acknowledge this. 
Freedom of movement was a choice for millions of people here and across Europe. I’d rather people whether they were rich or poor had the choice to live and work where they wanted within the EU. I would rather a lorry driver for example could work across Europe helping the economies of several countries relatively unhindered by needless red tape. 
You don’t highlight inaccuracies free from bias, you look to find ‘facts’ that back your opinions up. You've dismissed reports, experts, statistics and other people’s life experiences if they don’t fit your point of view. That’s fine we are all susceptible to this, but If you want to set yourself up as the boards watchdog then recognise your own conscious or unconscious bias. 
I don’t think it’s any secret lol that I don’t like this Tory government or the previous one, because of their actions not some deep seated admiration for Labour or the Lib Dem’s. I’ve never been a member of any political party. I make no secret of my dislike and distrust of the incumbent party. You try and argue that you are above political bias your replies on here suggest otherwise. 


Tarabit I’ve wasted far too much time on this merry-go-round of arguments.

Avoiding, sorry, decided not to grace us with how your “ counter argument” on the interpretation of concrete facts works then?  
 
You say you back up your arguments with links from people with “credentials”,    strange that, when I link to trade organisations’ reports, experts and academic papers, you brand them “obscure’ and “meaningless” links. I would have assumed you don’t think the Trussell Fund “obscure” but you have chosen to ignore its report because it shows your statement on food banks for what it is, inflammatory and wildly overblown. Again, after your usual pop at the un just and uncompassionate  U.K., when it’s pointed out that your wonderful E.U. has exactly the same problems you ignore that fact too and swiftly move on.
 
Pointing out to you that the U.K. is far from the only state in Europe suffering the problems you attribute to Brexit / the Tories is NOT “dismissing” reports, it’s highlighting your intentionally blinkered pronouncements. You are the one who has “dismissed” links as “obscure” or dropped the argument (as now) because it shows your posts to be myopic. I’m not sorry that pointing out the FACT that the E.U. is not the perfect Shangri-La you continually try to have us believe, upsets you.
I do accept that the ending of FoM is exasperating you.  Angel
What is ridiculous is that  you still equate pointing out inaccurate statements, the myopic ignoring of historical facts, norms, events and personal actions to score points for blind bias, is support for the Tories.  
 
Oh, still no answer to the question of why the wonderful Valhalla that is the E.U. has the same worker shortages, even with the panacea of FoM?

But still you carry them on with Proth!

(11-16-2021, 05:13 PM)Protheroe Wrote: At least I know where you stand. You'd rather stifle incentives and choice by taxing people's earnings and spending (we ultimately pay Corporation Tax), rather than threaten my kids' entirely unearned inheritance. I'm staggered. My kids will thank you though.

I'm sure your children will thank you when you leave them nothing of your wealth  so they won't be burdened with the stain and guilt of inequality.
Reply
(11-17-2021, 09:05 AM)JOK Wrote:
(11-16-2021, 05:13 PM)Protheroe Wrote: At least I know where you stand. You'd rather stifle incentives and choice by taxing people's earnings and spending (we ultimately pay Corporation Tax), rather than threaten my kids' entirely unearned inheritance. I'm staggered. My kids will thank you though.

I'm sure your children will thank you when you leave them nothing of your wealth  so they won't be burdened with the stain and guilt of inequality.

He won't be leaving them nothing JOK, he'll be putting it into trust or transferring it via other methods (directorship of limited companies etc), so that he can avoid any sort of taxation. I wouldn't be fooled by his sudden conversion to this level of philanthropy
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: 1 Guest(s)