Posts: 8,954
Threads: 166
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
77
(11-12-2021, 12:36 PM)Protheroe Wrote: You may wish that the end of FOM was exacerbating the UK's problems, and perhaps it is - but the effect would appear to be very marginal.
Arf, wish indeed - and today's lesson in the bleedin' obvious. The UK needs more workers in lots of sectors, the UK cuts off the supply of those workers from the EU. Nothing related here clearly.
Posts: 17,074
Threads: 614
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
114
(11-12-2021, 02:33 PM)baggy1 Wrote: (11-12-2021, 12:36 PM)Protheroe Wrote: You may wish that the end of FOM was exacerbating the UK's problems, and perhaps it is - but the effect would appear to be very marginal.
Arf, wish indeed - and today's lesson in the bleedin' obvious. The UK needs more workers in lots of sectors, the UK cuts off the supply of those workers from the EU. Nothing related here clearly.
No, no it's going to make access to hardworking staff easier!
Fruit Pickers wanted £60 an hour, luxury hotel accommodation from March to October free.
Care Staff wanted, limitless earnings from local council guaranteed by government budget! Hours to suit you, no evening, night or weekend work. Only do the nice bits of the job you want!
Not going to be quite so easy to fill any of these jobs with a very small pool of people to choose from.
Posts: 11,311
Threads: 419
Joined: Feb 2020
Reputation:
18
You're doing absolutely nothing to convince me that you're merely lamenting the death of cheap labour, subsidised by the state.
Every major economy has the same labour issues, yet within your UK bubble of self-loathing you're completely unable to see that.
What's the answer? Simple. We need to buy food at prices that support its cost of production and processing + margin. Food has never been cheaper in the UK. Food price inflation in the UK is still below that of other developed economies. Supermarkets ae super efficient, but also rely on the production industry working on wafer thin margins. Surely you'd be happy to pay for better wages and working conditions in the food production industry?
The care sector has been a Cinderella service for decades. We need to pay the going rate for care. This involves using the assets built up during your working life if you've been fortunate enough, otherwise the state can step in with a safety net. Surely you'd be happy to use the assets you'd accumulated during your working life to pay the going rate for care?
Or do you just identify as a Lefty, for likes and high status?
Posts: 8,954
Threads: 166
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
77
(11-15-2021, 11:05 AM)Protheroe Wrote: You're doing absolutely nothing to convince me that you're merely lamenting the death of cheap labour, subsidised by the state.
Every major economy has the same labour issues, yet within your UK bubble of self-loathing you're completely unable to see that.
What's the answer? Simple. We need to buy food at prices that support its cost of production and processing + margin. Food has never been cheaper in the UK. Food price inflation in the UK is still below that of other developed economies. Supermarkets ae super efficient, but also rely on the production industry working on wafer thin margins. Surely you'd be happy to pay for better wages and working conditions in the food production industry?
The care sector has been a Cinderella service for decades. We need to pay the going rate for care. This involves using the assets built up during your working life if you've been fortunate enough, otherwise the state can step in with a safety net. Surely you'd be happy to use the assets you'd accumulated during your working life to pay the going rate for care?
Or do you just identify as a Lefty, for likes and high status?
The tory gaslighting myth that everyone has assets to pay for care in the later life. Also the future state of less people owning homes whilst some accumulate assets that push up houseprices and lock out people from getting on the ladder.
For the people without assets how should they pay for their care? Also in a country where less people are going to be homeowners in the future where do you future-proof your plan for this pat as you go care world.
Most of the population pay taxes throughout their working life, those taxes are to pay for the state services that the population needs. Currently that money is going directly into the pockets of people that look after their mates in government. I'd prefer it to go into the services that we will need in the future.
Your view is that we create a two tier society where those that have assets get a good level of care and those that don't have assets just wither and die. All very American of you, but this isn't America and we try and look after the vulnerable and not give them scraps off the table. Is that lefty enough for you?
Posts: 11,311
Threads: 419
Joined: Feb 2020
Reputation:
18
(11-15-2021, 12:05 PM)baggy1 Wrote: (11-15-2021, 11:05 AM)Protheroe Wrote: You're doing absolutely nothing to convince me that you're merely lamenting the death of cheap labour, subsidised by the state.
Every major economy has the same labour issues, yet within your UK bubble of self-loathing you're completely unable to see that.
What's the answer? Simple. We need to buy food at prices that support its cost of production and processing + margin. Food has never been cheaper in the UK. Food price inflation in the UK is still below that of other developed economies. Supermarkets ae super efficient, but also rely on the production industry working on wafer thin margins. Surely you'd be happy to pay for better wages and working conditions in the food production industry?
The care sector has been a Cinderella service for decades. We need to pay the going rate for care. This involves using the assets built up during your working life if you've been fortunate enough, otherwise the state can step in with a safety net. Surely you'd be happy to use the assets you'd accumulated during your working life to pay the going rate for care?
Or do you just identify as a Lefty, for likes and high status?
The tory gaslighting myth that everyone has assets to pay for care in the later life. Also the future state of less people owning homes whilst some accumulate assets that push up houseprices and lock out people from getting on the ladder.
For the people without assets how should they pay for their care? Also in a country where less people are going to be homeowners in the future where do you future-proof your plan for this pat as you go care world.
Most of the population pay taxes throughout their working life, those taxes are to pay for the state services that the population needs. Currently that money is going directly into the pockets of people that look after their mates in government. I'd prefer it to go into the services that we will need in the future.
Your view is that we create a two tier society where those that have assets get a good level of care and those that don't have assets just wither and die. All very American of you, but this isn't America and we try and look after the vulnerable and not give them scraps off the table. Is that lefty enough for you?
Did you miss the "otherwise the state can step in with a safety net" part?
Let me spell it out again: Otherwise the state can step in with a safety net.
Otherwise the asset poor are simply subsidising the asset rich. You wouldn't want that would you?
Posts: 8,954
Threads: 166
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
77
The number of people in rental properties in the UK is increasing - who does that benefit? Landlords
Your plan is to remove any assets in the general population so that the young generation, who are renting more, never inherit enough to get on the property ladder. Who does that benefit? Landlords
Who pay the most into the tory party coffers - 20% of the transparent donations come from property owners.
OK lets take this a step further, given that the above will push the next generations into renting and not owning assets then eventually we will be in a situation where the state will need to provide more and more, so we will be back to square 1 and needing to boost the care sector provision. Your plan simply kicks the can down the road with the added benefit that the rich get richer in the meantime.
"the poor are simply, subsidising the asset rich" Arf - straight out of the pretend tory handbook of quotes to fool the masses.
Posts: 11,311
Threads: 419
Joined: Feb 2020
Reputation:
18
(11-15-2021, 03:15 PM)baggy1 Wrote: The number of people in rental properties in the UK is increasing - who does that benefit? Landlords
Your plan is to remove any assets in the general population so that the young generation, who are renting more, never inherit enough to get on the property ladder. Who does that benefit? Landlords
Who pay the most into the tory party coffers - 20% of the transparent donations come from property owners.
OK lets take this a step further, given that the above will push the next generations into renting and not owning assets then eventually we will be in a situation where the state will need to provide more and more, so we will be back to square 1 and needing to boost the care sector provision. Your plan simply kicks the can down the road with the added benefit that the rich get richer in the meantime.
"the poor are simply, subsidising the asset rich" Arf - straight out of the pretend tory handbook of quotes to fool the masses.
I love it when folks defend inherited wealth on here. If you want to protect your assets then there should be an insurance market for it. The poor (and renters) should not subsidise my kids' inheritance via tax, that's outrageous.
Never mind that a majority of people will not need long term care.
Landlordism is only increasing for two reasons; Borrowing is virtually free (allowing for inflation) and cash returns are sub zero (allowing for inflation).
Posts: 8,954
Threads: 166
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
77
(11-15-2021, 05:19 PM)Protheroe Wrote: (11-15-2021, 03:15 PM)baggy1 Wrote: The number of people in rental properties in the UK is increasing - who does that benefit? Landlords
Your plan is to remove any assets in the general population so that the young generation, who are renting more, never inherit enough to get on the property ladder. Who does that benefit? Landlords
Who pay the most into the tory party coffers - 20% of the transparent donations come from property owners.
OK lets take this a step further, given that the above will push the next generations into renting and not owning assets then eventually we will be in a situation where the state will need to provide more and more, so we will be back to square 1 and needing to boost the care sector provision. Your plan simply kicks the can down the road with the added benefit that the rich get richer in the meantime.
"the poor are simply, subsidising the asset rich" Arf - straight out of the pretend tory handbook of quotes to fool the masses.
I love it when folks defend inherited wealth on here. If you want to protect your assets then there should be an insurance market for it. The poor (and renters) should not subsidise my kids' inheritance via tax, that's outrageous.
Never mind that a majority of people will not need long term care.
Landlordism is only increasing for two reasons; Borrowing is virtually free (allowing for inflation) and cash returns are sub zero (allowing for inflation).
Landlordism (a word?) should be taxed to the hilt, it pushes the prices of housing out of the reach of most unless they have some inheritance. The only people that will benefit from draining peoples inheritance are the already very wealthy, we don't want any of those new money people bridging the gap do we.
Passing inheritance down to kids gives them a chance to compete. Your world view is that nobody should have that right and are confusing that with the state supporting with appropriate care facilities that don't rely on scraps from the table. Increase the higher rate of tax, collect the appropriate taxes that are due in the 1st place and we wouldn't need to have this conversation.
Posts: 11,311
Threads: 419
Joined: Feb 2020
Reputation:
18
(11-15-2021, 05:36 PM)baggy1 Wrote: (11-15-2021, 05:19 PM)Protheroe Wrote: (11-15-2021, 03:15 PM)baggy1 Wrote: The number of people in rental properties in the UK is increasing - who does that benefit? Landlords
Your plan is to remove any assets in the general population so that the young generation, who are renting more, never inherit enough to get on the property ladder. Who does that benefit? Landlords
Who pay the most into the tory party coffers - 20% of the transparent donations come from property owners.
OK lets take this a step further, given that the above will push the next generations into renting and not owning assets then eventually we will be in a situation where the state will need to provide more and more, so we will be back to square 1 and needing to boost the care sector provision. Your plan simply kicks the can down the road with the added benefit that the rich get richer in the meantime.
"the poor are simply, subsidising the asset rich" Arf - straight out of the pretend tory handbook of quotes to fool the masses.
I love it when folks defend inherited wealth on here. If you want to protect your assets then there should be an insurance market for it. The poor (and renters) should not subsidise my kids' inheritance via tax, that's outrageous.
Never mind that a majority of people will not need long term care.
Landlordism is only increasing for two reasons; Borrowing is virtually free (allowing for inflation) and cash returns are sub zero (allowing for inflation).
Landlordism (a word?) should be taxed to the hilt, it pushes the prices of housing out of the reach of most unless they have some inheritance. The only people that will benefit from draining peoples inheritance are the already very wealthy, we don't want any of those new money people bridging the gap do we.
Passing inheritance down to kids gives them a chance to compete. Your world view is that nobody should have that right and are confusing that with the state supporting with appropriate care facilities that don't rely on scraps from the table. Increase the higher rate of tax, collect the appropriate taxes that are due in the 1st place and we wouldn't need to have this conversation.
Like I say, I love it when those to the left of me defend inherited wealth - the greatest cause of wealth inequality. It's most amusing.
Tax landlords to the hilt if you like, you'll find there'll be no rented housing for those who need it and the condition of those remaining properties will be crap - just as it was under rent control. Many will simply keep homes empty and enjoy the capital growth whilst your policy makes thousands of families homeless.
Posts: 8,954
Threads: 166
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
77
A brilliant piece of Proth logic there - remove the people who have some money and bring their assets down to nothing to solve wealth inequality, i.e. have everyone on no money and then there is less wealth inequality, whilst the very rich just get on with their lives. Classic.
|