OMG M&S PC OTT
#41
No, I'm pointing out that people aren't happy about having opportunities to do things they were once able to do closed off from them when, as far as they're concerned, they're fixing something wrong with them to live life as they think they should be allowed to.

On the point of competition I believe it's dependent on a multitude of factors with respect to inherent advantages and as such things need to be looked at on a case-by-case basis by the appropriate authorities, an androgenised trans woman would have inherent advantages against a typical cis-woman owing to going through androginsation owing to bone and muscle structures but things get more complex when comparing a trans woman who hasn't gone through androgenisation (owing to them being intersex and assigned male then transitioning later in life or being a male and not undergoing the process for whatever reason) as those inherent biological advantages in competitive sports disappear. There's also the risk of intersex people being caught up in it, see Caster Semenya.

It's an incredibly complex issue and the only thing I am opposed to is how simply and one-dimensional it is being presented as, as well as presenting the issue with people like Lauren Hubble or however you spell it vs issues like trans women being blanket banned from being able to play amateur contact women's rugby even though the RFU guidance, which rightly covers the issue over health risks to others in contact sport for androgenised trans women, is based on evidence which doesn't apply to the aforementioned trans women who haven't gone through androgenisation.
Reply
#42
(11-10-2021, 07:59 PM)Borin' Baggie Wrote: No, I'm pointing out that people aren't happy about having opportunities to do things they were once able to do closed off from them when, as far as they're concerned, they're fixing something wrong with them to live life as they think they should be allowed to.

On the point of competition I believe it's dependent on a multitude of factors with respect to inherent advantages and as such things need to be looked at on a case-by-case basis by the appropriate authorities, an androgenised trans woman would have inherent advantages against a typical cis-woman owing to going through androginsation owing to bone and muscle structures but things get more complex when comparing a trans woman who hasn't gone through androgenisation (owing to them being intersex and assigned male then transitioning later in life or being a male and not undergoing the process for whatever reason) as those inherent biological advantages in competitive sports disappear. There's also the risk of intersex people being caught up in it, see Caster Semenya.

It's an incredibly complex issue and the only thing I am opposed to is how simply and one-dimensional it is being presented as, as well as presenting the issue with people like Lauren Hubble or however you spell it vs issues like trans women being blanket banned from being able to play amateur contact women's rugby even though the RFU guidance, which rightly covers the issue over health risks to others in contact sport for androgenised trans women, is based on evidence which doesn't apply to the aforementioned trans women who haven't gone through androgenisation.

They're gonna need bigger badges......  Big Grin .
Reply
#43
(11-10-2021, 07:30 PM)Borin' Baggie Wrote:
(11-10-2021, 06:54 PM)Spandaubaggie Wrote:
(11-10-2021, 06:24 PM)Borin' Baggie Wrote:
(11-10-2021, 05:56 PM)Spandaubaggie Wrote:
(11-10-2021, 05:47 PM)Sliced Wrote: Pretty much how I feel about it

Yes ditto. I’m incredibly anti woke but this is more bizarre bullshit that affects a truly microscopically minuscule number in society. 
The trans people are very vocal considering they represent a tiny indecipherable fraction of a percent in society. 
For instance, a decent barometer, in my mid 50s from a big family, and wide circle of friends I’m yet to meet someone who is undergoing/ undergone a sex change. 
They exist but there aren’t many of them in the big scheme. 
I don’t know what they want either, other than attention for being different.

They want to live their lives as the gender their brain tells them they are. There isn't some grand, insidious conspiracy.
The whole subject is incredibly complex around sport, prisons etc etc.

No it isn't. It's the same principle, you just disagree with the extent of their rights and opportunities which is fine but ultimately put themselves in their shoes, would you happy to be put into a prison you feel you're at risk in because of your gender identity or do you think it's fair you wouldn't be able to participate in certain sports?

With regards to prisons specifically, I'm not sure why being transgender is the issue as the same arguments are never made about lesbians and the issue of gay sexual assault is pretty much celebrated for male prisons (don't drop the soap etc), it's quite clear that it's a dead horse from fixing the real problem which is why people who are likely to sexually assault someone are put in with the people they're likely to sexually assault?
Trans women make up 1% of the female prison population but are responsible for over 5% of sexual assaults within said population
Reply
#44
(11-10-2021, 08:11 PM)Sotv Wrote:
(11-10-2021, 07:30 PM)Borin' Baggie Wrote:
(11-10-2021, 06:54 PM)Spandaubaggie Wrote:
(11-10-2021, 06:24 PM)Borin' Baggie Wrote:
(11-10-2021, 05:56 PM)Spandaubaggie Wrote: Yes ditto. I’m incredibly anti woke but this is more bizarre bullshit that affects a truly microscopically minuscule number in society. 
The trans people are very vocal considering they represent a tiny indecipherable fraction of a percent in society. 
For instance, a decent barometer, in my mid 50s from a big family, and wide circle of friends I’m yet to meet someone who is undergoing/ undergone a sex change. 
They exist but there aren’t many of them in the big scheme. 
I don’t know what they want either, other than attention for being different.

They want to live their lives as the gender their brain tells them they are. There isn't some grand, insidious conspiracy.
The whole subject is incredibly complex around sport, prisons etc etc.

No it isn't. It's the same principle, you just disagree with the extent of their rights and opportunities which is fine but ultimately put themselves in their shoes, would you happy to be put into a prison you feel you're at risk in because of your gender identity or do you think it's fair you wouldn't be able to participate in certain sports?

With regards to prisons specifically, I'm not sure why being transgender is the issue as the same arguments are never made about lesbians and the issue of gay sexual assault is pretty much celebrated for male prisons (don't drop the soap etc), it's quite clear that it's a dead horse from fixing the real problem which is why people who are likely to sexually assault someone are put in with the people they're likely to sexually assault?
Trans women make up 1% of the female prison population but are responsible for over 5% of sexual assaults within said population

And more people who were trans women but housed in a mens prison were sexually assaulted by cis men in 2019 alone (11) than every single instance of a trans woman sexually assaulting a cis woman between 2010 and 2018 (7) and in 2019 (1).

See how this issue is extremely complicated and reducing it down to simple terms or single statistics isn't a good idea?
Reply
#45
(11-10-2021, 08:26 PM)Borin' Baggie Wrote:
(11-10-2021, 08:11 PM)Sotv Wrote:
(11-10-2021, 07:30 PM)Borin' Baggie Wrote:
(11-10-2021, 06:54 PM)Spandaubaggie Wrote:
(11-10-2021, 06:24 PM)Borin' Baggie Wrote: They want to live their lives as the gender their brain tells them they are. There isn't some grand, insidious conspiracy.
The whole subject is incredibly complex around sport, prisons etc etc.

No it isn't. It's the same principle, you just disagree with the extent of their rights and opportunities which is fine but ultimately put themselves in their shoes, would you happy to be put into a prison you feel you're at risk in because of your gender identity or do you think it's fair you wouldn't be able to participate in certain sports?

With regards to prisons specifically, I'm not sure why being transgender is the issue as the same arguments are never made about lesbians and the issue of gay sexual assault is pretty much celebrated for male prisons (don't drop the soap etc), it's quite clear that it's a dead horse from fixing the real problem which is why people who are likely to sexually assault someone are put in with the people they're likely to sexually assault?
Trans women make up 1% of the female prison population but are responsible for over 5% of sexual assaults within said population

And more people who were trans women but housed in a mens prison were sexually assaulted by cis men in 2019 alone (11) than every single instance of a trans woman sexually assaulting a cis woman between 2010 and 2018 (7).

See how this issue is extremely complicated and reducing it down to simple terms or single statistics isn't a good idea?
And what percentage of the cis male jail population did those who carried out these crimes represent? 
 But yes I take your point that it’s extremely complex and I’m glad we have people like yourself on here who are so smart they can both patronize and educate at the same time.
Reply
#46
(11-10-2021, 08:33 PM)Sotv Wrote:
(11-10-2021, 08:26 PM)Borin' Baggie Wrote:
(11-10-2021, 08:11 PM)Sotv Wrote:
(11-10-2021, 07:30 PM)Borin' Baggie Wrote:
(11-10-2021, 06:54 PM)Spandaubaggie Wrote: The whole subject is incredibly complex around sport, prisons etc etc.

No it isn't. It's the same principle, you just disagree with the extent of their rights and opportunities which is fine but ultimately put themselves in their shoes, would you happy to be put into a prison you feel you're at risk in because of your gender identity or do you think it's fair you wouldn't be able to participate in certain sports?

With regards to prisons specifically, I'm not sure why being transgender is the issue as the same arguments are never made about lesbians and the issue of gay sexual assault is pretty much celebrated for male prisons (don't drop the soap etc), it's quite clear that it's a dead horse from fixing the real problem which is why people who are likely to sexually assault someone are put in with the people they're likely to sexually assault?
Trans women make up 1% of the female prison population but are responsible for over 5% of sexual assaults within said population

And more people who were trans women but housed in a mens prison were sexually assaulted by cis men in 2019 alone (11) than every single instance of a trans woman sexually assaulting a cis woman between 2010 and 2018 (7).

See how this issue is extremely complicated and reducing it down to simple terms or single statistics isn't a good idea?
And what percentage of the cis male jail population did those who carried out these crimes represent? 
 But yes I take your point that it’s extremely complex and I’m glad we have people like yourself on here who are so smart they can both patronize and educate at the same time.

The fact this debate is taking place shows just how much sway this micro-community have. Incidentally it’s very difficult to find statistics on the number of trans people there are.
Reply
#47
(11-10-2021, 08:33 PM)Sotv Wrote: And what percentage of the cis male jail population did those who carried out these crimes represent? 
 But yes I take your point that it’s extremely complex and I’m glad we have people like yourself on here who are so smart they can both patronize and educate at the same time.

You're the one trying to use a singular statistic devoid of any context as a gotcha against me, don't have a cry when you get called out over it.

In terms of the overall population of trans women in prison in the UK, a trans woman is 3 times more likely to be sexually assaulted in a men's prison (9%) than a trans woman is likely to commit sexual assault in a women's prison (3%). That doesn't account for is normalised against mitigating factors that apply in men's prison (people likely to sexually assault others are separated in men's prison whereas that procedure does not exist in women's prison for some reason).

Instead of going all in with this culture war bollocks and demonising a subset of the population, how about coming up with something meaningful? For example, did you know that there is no procedure in the UK to separate those likely to commit sexual assault in women's prisons as there is in men's prison, why not separate them in turn making all women safer in prison from sexual assault?
Reply
#48
I love International breaks...
Reply
#49
(11-10-2021, 08:54 PM)Tom Joad Wrote: I love International breaks...
This or Savile. Take your pick! Tongue
Reply
#50
(11-10-2021, 09:01 PM)Spandaubaggie Wrote:
(11-10-2021, 08:54 PM)Tom Joad Wrote: I love International breaks...
This or Savile. Take your prick! Tongue

Amended for you   Wink
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: