Petrol and Diesel
#91
(11-10-2021, 01:12 PM)strawman Wrote:
(11-10-2021, 12:58 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: So we stop freedom of movement for 26 neighbouring countries with diverse populations coming to live and work in the UK as well as setting up our own monetary (skills) barriers to live and work here from everywhere in the world.

We give equality of entry based not on which passport you have, not on which country you come from, not on what colour you are or what religion you are but based on skills. This is exactly the same as the immigration rules for EU third countries.

We are no longer a member of the EU, they are now a third party as far as the UK is concerned as is each of their countries yet you are quite prepared to sacrifice equality and discriminate on the altar of economic simplicity. That makes you an extended border racist and xenophobe in my eyes and any attempt to justify your discrimination is mute.

If you want to think about the UK as a club and the EU as a club then the  truth is that the rules for immigration are very similar. The EU also is no saint. Its countries have built more fences than Trump. It harbours openly racist countries like Hungary. It forcibly returns asylum seekers and pays countries and African chiefs to keep them in camps.  Its commission is the epitome of white middle class and its parliament is under represented for minorities.

If the UK is racist and xenophobic, then the EU is just an extended border edition of the same thing.

I don't claim the UK is any better or worse unlike you  blabbering on incessantly about how bad we are compared to the EU. I appreciate that you are heartbroken that you can’t get cheap labour  anymore to make your negative little life exactly as you want it. You are like some pathetic teenager that harbours a love for something that  never  returned the emotion and in reality wasn’t the thing you thought it was anyway.


In answer to your points...without the childish insults you pretend you're above when it suits. 

I have never said the EU is prefect. No one on here who is a 'Remainer' and posts regularly has ever said so as far as I can remember. We recognise it's faults but on balance believe it better to be part of than not. A pragmatic decision rather than one based on 'belief' alone that we will see 'sunlit uplands'. 

Stopping the populations of 26 countries freedom of movement to live and work here unless they can hit a certain wage / skill criteria, whilst applying the same tariff's to the rest of the world does not make it a fairer or more equitable system. It makes the system skewed in favour of the relatively well off / well educated across the world access to work and live in the UK. The opportunity to work and live here has always been open to the most able, well resourced, well educated. Unless the UK is going to help address the massive inequalities in education, across the globe that hamper many of the countries we are looking to work with, then those opportunities will still be limited, it certainly won't be anymore equitable. You can't say only skilled, educated people with x amount of cash are welcome from anywhere in the world with a straight face and accuse others of borderline xenophobia and racism because we think closing opportunities down for people with very diverse backgrounds across Europe does not help our country only hinders it.  

You mean this Hungary? Conservative MEP's and Hungary's Orban Government

I think I preferred it when you pretended to put me on ignore but some how know all about my posts.  Big Grin
Reply
#92
(11-10-2021, 01:54 PM)Borin' Baggie Wrote: Was it the look of confusion as to why you were talking about something that had nothing to do with the UK's membership of the EU?

Who said it had anything to do with the UK's membership of the EU?

It was a riposte to the cheap and lazy implication she'd been making all night that the Leave campaign was a front for UK racists. I merely pointed out that the Blue Card Directive did for most of the Schengen area what Leave proposed for the UK.

(11-10-2021, 02:43 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: It makes the system skewed in favour of the relatively well off / well educated across the world access to work and live in the UK.

Good. Given that you're prone to make the point that EU Migrants paid more in tax than they withdrew in benefits this ensures that's the case - and helps increase wages amongst the lower paid where cheap labour becomes more scarce.

As a fully paid up member of the whinging Pinko faction I'm amazed you're not wholly supportive of that.
Reply
#93
You pointed out something within the competencies of EU member states (not the EU) that has nothing to do with EU membership as attested by the fact that the UK hadn't implemented it nor had a few other member states. One of the things I hated about the Leave campaigns were the distractions and red herrings that ultimately had nothing to do with the UK's membership of the EU but were convenient distractions, effective campaigning sure but designed to obfuscate the actual issues.
Reply
#94
(11-10-2021, 02:48 PM)Protheroe Wrote:
(11-10-2021, 01:54 PM)Borin' Baggie Wrote: Was it the look of confusion as to why you were talking about something that had nothing to do with the UK's membership of the EU?

Who said it had anything to do with the UK's membership of the EU?

It was a riposte to the cheap and lazy implication she'd been making all night that the Leave campaign was a front for UK racists. I merely pointed out that the Blue Card Directive did for most of the Schengen area what Leave proposed for the UK.

(11-10-2021, 02:43 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: It makes the system skewed in favour of the relatively well off / well educated across the world access to work and live in the UK.

Good. Given that you're prone to make the point that EU Migrants paid more in tax than they withdrew in benefits this ensures that's the case - and helps increase wages amongst the lower paid where cheap labour becomes more scarce.

As a fully paid up member of the whinging Pinko faction I'm amazed you're not wholly supportive of that.

It won't solve the problem of a lack of UK nationals willing to take on jobs in care, agriculture etc. It won't address the growing inequality in our country, it won't be a meritocracy. It'll simply push inflation up to negate any 'gains' that the lower paid will see. Which was my point four or five pages back.
Reply
#95
(11-09-2021, 05:01 PM)baggy1 Wrote:
(11-09-2021, 04:57 PM)JOK Wrote: I will not be bounced into judging differences, benefits or detriments after just 10 months.
Glad you concur that all the examples I cited have nothing to do with Brexit.

When do you feel will be a good period to judge any of those items?

You love the E.U. so, how long would you wait to judge outcomes?
 
The price of butter (amongst other things) sky rocketed immediately upon entry to the EEC and within 5 years had almost quadrupled. (The price was set by the council of European ministers)
Cost of butter per tonne at start of 1976 in Germany = £1900. In U.K. £1010. (Spot £) By end of the year, the U.K. was having to pay, as transitional members, £2238.
The average world price was £600 per tonne
The price of all stable commodities in the U.K. had risen substantially by 1976. After three years of the transition period.
From Hansard July 1974:
 
Mr. John Ellis. Does my right hon. Friend agree that the average amount spent on food in Common Market countries is considerably higher than it is in this country and, therefore, that harmonisation with the EEC must have a deleterious effect on wage earners in this country?
Mrs. Williams. My hon. Friend is right in the sense that the price levels for food in Britain are well below those which were common in Europe before we entered the Common Market.
 
”See for instance the Guardian, 14 January 1977, where it is suggested that buying food at world' market prices would save the UK £700 million per annum.”
 
So, it took well over 5 years for any of the ‘benefits’ you claim we received from being members of the EU. (if you can claim paying 4 times the price for commodities a benefit) Would you have been happy then to wait for a clearer picture or would you have been quick to criticise and say “how are we better off”?
 
As I once asked Dekka, (with no response, as usual) do you think the political and commercial worlds are going to be pickled in 2020 aspic?
Reply
#96
A very black and white view on my opinions on the EU, I don't 'love the EU' but I do see the benefit of being a trading partner of theirs from years of being involved in companies trading across the continent. I also see the benefits of being able to move and work freely across the continent.

And I'm not certain as to the benefits of looking at the 1970s as a comparison with the modern world, 1970s England was a pretty grim place to live and has benefited from a greatly improved lifestyle that has come about whilst we were members of the EU.

And not at all but likewise they weren't pickled in 1974 aspic either, but you appear to want to draw a 45 year old example as proof of how bad things are being part of them. The overarching theme of the current narrative is that it won't make much difference and if that is the case, why did we gamble when we have a pretty good hand to start with.
Reply
#97
The same old arguments between the same old posters. Nobody listening to the others' views. I repeatedly asked SOTV (I hope he still has me on ignore btw) to tell me what he thought the actual benefits of leaving would be. He has never answered that one, just tells me that I think all Leave voters are racist (which isn't true, I've never said it and I don't think it). I don't think it's unreasonable to expect some positives to balance the disruption that I've experienced in my life as a result of Brexit. I'm not seeing anything other than the vaguest of notions about sovereignty.

Now JOK has given us some 1976 vintage stats to back up the idea that it could take 5 years for the benefits to kick in. He should note that the world isn't pickled in 1976 aspic.

But - - - if the Leave campaign had said, "There will be a 'hard Brexit' which will result in disruption to supply chains due to logistical problems, labour shortages in key areas, increase in food prices and wastage of home-grown produce. There will be unrest in Ireland due to the difficulties of aligning goods from differing regulatory and customs regimes. Trade with Europe will be hit with VAT - many retailers will cease trying to trade between UK and EU, other UK firms will set up EU hubs with local staff to ensure they can export their goods efficiently. You will not be able to breeze through the blue channel on your annual trip to Magaluf - also sterling will lose 20% of its value against both the dollar and the euro, so your holidays will cost much more. Overall export figures from the UK will be reduced - in particular a free trade deal with the USA will not be agreed in the foreseeable future. In about 5 years we will begin to see benefits" - I reckon the outcome might have been different. Don't forget how close the vote was anyway. Can any of you Brexiteers honestly say that a) you knew all this shit would happen and b) you think its OK? Or are you still trying to tell us that it's imaginary, none of it is really happening?

The Leave campaign said:
"Totally free trade with EU will be agreed, so there will be no disruption or added complication for trade with EU".
"Free trade deal with USA will happen and will open up huge markets for UK".
"There will be £350m per week extra to spend on the NHS".
"Brexit will end free movement for workers between EU and UK, so no more Poles besmirching the streets of Crewe".

By 2018 we had Rees-Mogg saying "we'll see the benefits in 50 years" and Farage saying "I never said that it would be a beneficial thing to leave". Thanks guys.

It is to the eternal discredit of all the Remain supporting groups that they couldn't expose the basic dishonesty behind the Leave campaign. It's very telling that Leave never expected to win, and have made a pretty poor job of executing their Brexit. Yet people pretend that "there's nothing to see here".
Reply
#98
(11-10-2021, 09:50 AM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: ‘We’ was not a term I used for the government but the countries decision as a result of the referendum. The anti-immigration rhetoric was clear from some sections of the Vote Leave campaign. To argue otherwise is an obtuse position to take. The problem is untangling Vote Leave from the current government, it’s extremely difficult. It is both a strength and weakness for this government. 

Whilst it was the right thing to do to help those who wanted to stay, the new system of only been welcome to work and live here is based on arbitrary monetary value placed on someone’s skills. This is hardly an open and welcoming policy. 

Anecdotally people I know from the EU love the U.K. but have felt unwelcome, and singled out more so during and since the referendum. Many left at the end of the transition period and haven’t returned which is disappointing but understandable. 

As has been said many times in reply to your points about global problems, no one as far as I have seen has argued this isn’t the case. What they have argued is that Brexit will exasperate problems. To argue the loss of workers in agriculture, butchery, healthcare, social care, transport, and other sectors is helpful at this difficult time is again a obtuse position to take. 

Let’s be honest you hardly ever criticise this government so you could argue your opinions are no less biased than mine, given their current record. How do you think the government is performing, behaving? 

You aren’t performing a public duty arguing with me you’re just offering a different opinion.

I am not arguing with you, I am highlighting your inaccuracies and deliberate, false inferences. Again, you equate this, or try to as a deflection, with blind support for the government which is not so. As I have pointed out before, I hardly criticise any party, and if I mention Labour, it is to emphasise your hypocrisy by pointing out their doings, historically, have been no better at times.
Pointing out facts is not “my opinion”. Are other states official inflation rates “My opinion”? Is the fact that the ECB injected $2.8 trillion of newly printed money into the eurozone economy, “My opinion”? Is the fact government agencies pumped tens of millions of pounds into encouraging E.U. citizens into applying for resident status “My opinion”? Is it “My Opinion” that it is an accepted fact that most E.U. member states have worker shortages? Calling out your inflammatory hyperbole on food banks by referencing the Trussell Trust's own statement is not “My Opinion”.
 
Taking you some time, is it, to find the references to foreigners being “told to go back to their own country”? Anecdotally I am not aware of anyone (the Royal we, if you like) that told anybody to “Go Home” Have you not read the news lately about how welcoming the E.U. is being to ‘ refugees’ on it’s eastern borders? Probably yes but choose to ignore it.
So, you think it wrong to want immigrants who can offer skills which would benefit our economy?
 
I think your phrase “Inflation is inevitable” in your post, again attacking leave voters, suggests you are blaming the U.K.s inflation rate on Brexit. You have certainly, on numerous occasions, inferred that the ‘global problems’ only exist in the U.K and are directly the result of Brexit and to deny that is bizarre.
 
What is an obtuse position to take, is wanting to denude other states’ workforces to, slightly, improve ours.
Again, I’ll ask you the questions:

1, Are you happy to take workers from Poland, Rumania et al, countries which are also suffering shortages of the type workers we need, simply to improve your lot?

2, If ‘Freedom of Movement’ is the answer to our worker shortages, why are most the states in the E.U. suffering the same problem?
Reply
#99
I just wonder when Remainers will move on from the second stage of grief tbh. If they put as much effort into trying to make money as they do into unpicking a democratic decision taken 5 years ago they'd all be millionaires.

(11-10-2021, 03:01 PM)Borin' Baggie Wrote: You pointed out something within the competencies of EU member states (not the EU) that has nothing to do with EU membership as attested by the fact that the UK hadn't implemented it nor had a few other member states. One of the things I hated about the Leave campaigns were the distractions and red herrings that ultimately had nothing to do with the UK's membership of the EU but were convenient distractions, effective campaigning sure but designed to obfuscate the actual issues.

I pointed out an EU Directive called the EU Blue Card Directive, forgive me if that's not an EU Directive but the title of it sort of gave me the impression that it was. As far as I know the only Schengen states who haven't adopted it are Ireland & Denmark. 

One things I hated about the Remain campaign was the mealy mouthed semantics and the denial that black was black and white was white. The EU Blue Card Directive is an inherently racist policy position.
Reply
You pointed out something completely unrelated to the UK's membership of the EU. The reason it was pushed through as an EU directive was to allow for easier transfer of documents between the countries in the scheme as it's easier than going on a country-by-country basis with 25 different systems in place.

Was the UK party to the Blue Card scheme? No. Therefore it's irrelevant and a distraction.
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: 1 Guest(s)