Posts: 8,846
Threads: 270
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
29
(11-09-2021, 11:48 AM)Sotv Wrote: (11-09-2021, 11:27 AM)baggy1 Wrote: (11-09-2021, 10:17 AM)Cunninghamismagic Wrote: As net contributors we will ultimately save money by leaving
It's debatable that the savings will outweigh the extra costs of being a independent nation not able to pull on the pooled resources. For that net contribution we actually got some 'free' services that we will now have to create.
(11-09-2021, 11:25 AM)Sotv Wrote: (11-09-2021, 09:46 AM)baggy1 Wrote: So what you are saying is that leaving the EU made no difference, glad we spent all that time and money on it when we needed it elsewhere as you have highlighted.
i think the point is that despite the energy used by some telling us how the sky would fall in and how much worse off we would be, that doesn't seem to be the case when you compare the UK to the EU.
Given the evidence supplied by JOK seems to suggest this isn't the case, you do have to wonder if it really was worth all the name calling, bitterness and division stirred up by project fear.
The main benefit i see is that politicians can no longer backslide and pin the blame for their actions / inactions on EU regulations. That in a nutshell is what the widely derided sovereignty means.
So we've gone from 'sunlit uplands' and '£350M a week for the NHS' to 'it's not as bad as some said'. That was well worth the cost then. Or conversely we have gone from £4,500 a year worse off, the need for an emergency budget and economic collapse to being in at least as a good a position as EU member states, no emergency budget and not being £4,500 a year worse off. Foreign companies such as Nissan have also underlined their commitment to a post Brexit UK.
What we have gained is the removal of a huge excuse used by politicians of all parties for unpopular decisions.
£350 million a week for the NHS was never promised and most of us who voted to leave never believed we would be spending that sum on the health service.
So given that the evidence suggests we are no worse off, just exactly why is it some people still seem insistent on telling us how terrible everything is and looking to blame everything on Brexit? Could it be that some can't just accept they were wrong and were fooled by the lies of the remain campaign given they have spent the last 5 years calling leave voters stupid for believing lies?
Quite.
Posts: 8,954
Threads: 166
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
77
11-09-2021, 12:09 PM
(This post was last modified: 11-09-2021, 12:10 PM by baggy1.)
(11-09-2021, 12:01 PM)Fido Wrote: (11-09-2021, 11:48 AM)Sotv Wrote: (11-09-2021, 11:27 AM)baggy1 Wrote: (11-09-2021, 10:17 AM)Cunninghamismagic Wrote: As net contributors we will ultimately save money by leaving
It's debatable that the savings will outweigh the extra costs of being a independent nation not able to pull on the pooled resources. For that net contribution we actually got some 'free' services that we will now have to create.
(11-09-2021, 11:25 AM)Sotv Wrote: (11-09-2021, 09:46 AM)baggy1 Wrote: So what you are saying is that leaving the EU made no difference, glad we spent all that time and money on it when we needed it elsewhere as you have highlighted.
i think the point is that despite the energy used by some telling us how the sky would fall in and how much worse off we would be, that doesn't seem to be the case when you compare the UK to the EU.
Given the evidence supplied by JOK seems to suggest this isn't the case, you do have to wonder if it really was worth all the name calling, bitterness and division stirred up by project fear.
The main benefit i see is that politicians can no longer backslide and pin the blame for their actions / inactions on EU regulations. That in a nutshell is what the widely derided sovereignty means.
So we've gone from 'sunlit uplands' and '£350M a week for the NHS' to 'it's not as bad as some said'. That was well worth the cost then. Or conversely we have gone from £4,500 a year worse off, the need for an emergency budget and economic collapse to being in at least as a good a position as EU member states, no emergency budget and not being £4,500 a year worse off. Foreign companies such as Nissan have also underlined their commitment to a post Brexit UK.
What we have gained is the removal of a huge excuse used by politicians of all parties for unpopular decisions.
£350 million a week for the NHS was never promised and most of us who voted to leave never believed we would be spending that sum on the health service.
So given that the evidence suggests we are no worse off, just exactly why is it some people still seem insistent on telling us how terrible everything is and looking to blame everything on Brexit? Could it be that some can't just accept they were wrong and were fooled by the lies of the remain campaign given they have spent the last 5 years calling leave voters stupid for believing lies?
Quite.
And you may have noticed I don't point out how bad off we are, because ultimately it makes no difference we are where we are now. But I will point out that it was a completely pointless exercise as it does make it more expensive to trade with, and visit the EU now. So as a country the best we are hoping for is its a bit 'meh' whereas for the individuals and businesses it is a pain in the arse. So we've gone through it all to make ourselves a bit less well off - great.
Gaining an excuse for politicians is not really a win as we appear to believe the shit they come out with anyway, and they can blatantly lie and fill their own, and their mates, pockets but I would lay good odds on you still voting for them next time.
Posts: 8,846
Threads: 270
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
29
(11-09-2021, 12:09 PM)baggy1 Wrote: (11-09-2021, 12:01 PM)Fido Wrote: (11-09-2021, 11:48 AM)Sotv Wrote: (11-09-2021, 11:27 AM)baggy1 Wrote: (11-09-2021, 10:17 AM)Cunninghamismagic Wrote: As net contributors we will ultimately save money by leaving
It's debatable that the savings will outweigh the extra costs of being a independent nation not able to pull on the pooled resources. For that net contribution we actually got some 'free' services that we will now have to create.
(11-09-2021, 11:25 AM)Sotv Wrote: i think the point is that despite the energy used by some telling us how the sky would fall in and how much worse off we would be, that doesn't seem to be the case when you compare the UK to the EU.
Given the evidence supplied by JOK seems to suggest this isn't the case, you do have to wonder if it really was worth all the name calling, bitterness and division stirred up by project fear.
The main benefit i see is that politicians can no longer backslide and pin the blame for their actions / inactions on EU regulations. That in a nutshell is what the widely derided sovereignty means.
So we've gone from 'sunlit uplands' and '£350M a week for the NHS' to 'it's not as bad as some said'. That was well worth the cost then. Or conversely we have gone from £4,500 a year worse off, the need for an emergency budget and economic collapse to being in at least as a good a position as EU member states, no emergency budget and not being £4,500 a year worse off. Foreign companies such as Nissan have also underlined their commitment to a post Brexit UK.
What we have gained is the removal of a huge excuse used by politicians of all parties for unpopular decisions.
£350 million a week for the NHS was never promised and most of us who voted to leave never believed we would be spending that sum on the health service.
So given that the evidence suggests we are no worse off, just exactly why is it some people still seem insistent on telling us how terrible everything is and looking to blame everything on Brexit? Could it be that some can't just accept they were wrong and were fooled by the lies of the remain campaign given they have spent the last 5 years calling leave voters stupid for believing lies?
Quite.
And you may have noticed I don't point out how bad off we are, because ultimately it makes no difference we are where we are now. But I will point out that it was a completely pointless exercise as it does make it more expensive to trade with, and visit the EU now. So as a country the best we are hoping for is its a bit 'meh' whereas for the individuals and businesses it is a pain in the arse. So we've gone through it all to make ourselves a bit less well off - great.
Gaining an excuse for politicians is not really a win as we appear to believe the shit they come out with anyway, and they can blatantly lie and fill their own, and their mates, pockets but I would lay good odds on you still voting for them next time.
I don't think you were the intended target in all honesty
Leaving the EU was always an opportunity or at least that was my reasoning. Whether that opportunity has been fully grasped through good leadership and strong strategy, well, I think that's something we probably all agree on. There were absolute whoppers told on both sides prior to the event which gives no-one any credit; I think Sotv's point is that some people bang their drum very loudly despite evidence to the contrary, particularly on this subject.
Posts: 1,712
Threads: 20
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
18
11-09-2021, 12:49 PM
(This post was last modified: 11-09-2021, 01:17 PM by fuzzbox.)
The physical goods free trade agreement is a phony war. The real war is yet to come.
We were running a deficit with EC, so if we can't even win that, where we had a few cards to play, what chance do we have with financial services where we actually run a surplus?
Talking of 'seeing it as an opportunity'...well that works both ways.
France, Ireland, Netherlands and Germany are certainly seeing it as an opportunity. They're making it clear they're after our financial services business - which is by far the largest contributor to our tax income. The Eu is clear that this is their number one goal and that they will enact legislation to stop the Uk from competing fairly within Europe.
How successful they are will be the real decider on who wins or who loses.
What worries me is that even the brexit side only sees we retain it as the best possible scenario. Nobody sees any upside except for maybe shady finance deals done due to lower financial oversight or going head to head with China and the US for the developing world business (some chance!)
Calling it a victory or loss yet is premature - especially when we haven't even fought the most important battle. But when everybody in the room is calling you an idiot, you must be absolutely certain of yourself to take the opposing decision. I hope I'm wrong and I want us to be the lone maverick that reaps the rewards, but I haven't seen it yet. At the very best, I'd say we've risked a lot for nothing.
Posts: 343
Threads: 14
Joined: May 2021
Reputation:
1
(11-09-2021, 12:49 PM)fuzzbox Wrote: France, Ireland, Netherlands and Germany are certainly seeing it as an opportunity. They're making it clear they're after our financial services business - which is by far the largest contributor to our tax income. The Eu is clear that this is their number one goal and that they will enact legislation to stop the Uk from competing fairly within Europe.
Yep, here in Amsterdam, we've seen huge amounts of British ex-pats move here due to Brexit (including myself).
Posts: 1,816
Threads: 69
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
5
(11-08-2021, 03:14 PM)Cheshire East Baggie Wrote: (11-08-2021, 01:44 PM)Protheroe Wrote: (11-08-2021, 12:54 PM)Kit Kat Chunky Wrote: I'm awaiting delivery of a 3.0 petrol car. I'm dreading it!
It's fine mate. I'm getting 13 mpg from the Mazza V8 and 17 mpg from the Alfa V6 at the moment. None of this water-based E10 crap either - just had to put the tenants' rent up a bit to cover the cost of Shell V Power.
What you getting?
This is the problem though, isn't it Proth? Those who drive the gas guzzlers can afford the fuel price and any extra taxation heaped upon them. You know perfectly well that you could get around in a car doing 50 mpg and all that would be hurt was your self-image as a wealthy petrol head.
Rather than talking crap about banning all combustion-engined cars by some arbitrary date, they should ban the sale of any vehicles which don't meet high standards of efficiency. They could also retrospectively increase the tax on existing gas guzzlers (which they've never done because it wouldn't be "fair"). Old cars should be subject to emission checks at any stage (not just the annual MOT. Really old cars should be compulsorily taken off the road.
None of this will happen, because the climate debate is just another can for British governments to kick down the road.
The carbon footprint of keeping my 11 year old petrol mini on the road ( to drive 10 minutes to my office and back) is far smaller than changing to an electric car.
The increase mining for lithium and copper will also do untold environmental damage.
If my emissions are fine then let’s keep older cars on the road rather than force electric on everybody.
Posts: 8,846
Threads: 270
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
29
(11-09-2021, 01:29 PM)Jack Halford Wrote: (11-08-2021, 03:14 PM)Cheshire East Baggie Wrote: (11-08-2021, 01:44 PM)Protheroe Wrote: (11-08-2021, 12:54 PM)Kit Kat Chunky Wrote: I'm awaiting delivery of a 3.0 petrol car. I'm dreading it!
It's fine mate. I'm getting 13 mpg from the Mazza V8 and 17 mpg from the Alfa V6 at the moment. None of this water-based E10 crap either - just had to put the tenants' rent up a bit to cover the cost of Shell V Power.
What you getting?
This is the problem though, isn't it Proth? Those who drive the gas guzzlers can afford the fuel price and any extra taxation heaped upon them. You know perfectly well that you could get around in a car doing 50 mpg and all that would be hurt was your self-image as a wealthy petrol head.
Rather than talking crap about banning all combustion-engined cars by some arbitrary date, they should ban the sale of any vehicles which don't meet high standards of efficiency. They could also retrospectively increase the tax on existing gas guzzlers (which they've never done because it wouldn't be "fair"). Old cars should be subject to emission checks at any stage (not just the annual MOT. Really old cars should be compulsorily taken off the road.
None of this will happen, because the climate debate is just another can for British governments to kick down the road.
The carbon footprint of keeping my 11 year old petrol mini on the road ( to drive 10 minutes to my office and back) is far smaller than changing to an electric car.
The increase mining for lithium and copper will also do untold environmental damage.
If my emissions are fine then let’s keep older cars on the road rather than force electric on everybody.
Get a bike, you lazy fugger
Posts: 1,816
Threads: 69
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
5
Posts: 1,972
Threads: 136
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
3
(11-09-2021, 12:09 PM)baggy1 Wrote: (11-09-2021, 12:01 PM)Fido Wrote: (11-09-2021, 11:48 AM)Sotv Wrote: (11-09-2021, 11:27 AM)baggy1 Wrote: (11-09-2021, 10:17 AM)Cunninghamismagic Wrote: As net contributors we will ultimately save money by leaving
It's debatable that the savings will outweigh the extra costs of being a independent nation not able to pull on the pooled resources. For that net contribution we actually got some 'free' services that we will now have to create.
(11-09-2021, 11:25 AM)Sotv Wrote: i think the point is that despite the energy used by some telling us how the sky would fall in and how much worse off we would be, that doesn't seem to be the case when you compare the UK to the EU.
Given the evidence supplied by JOK seems to suggest this isn't the case, you do have to wonder if it really was worth all the name calling, bitterness and division stirred up by project fear.
The main benefit i see is that politicians can no longer backslide and pin the blame for their actions / inactions on EU regulations. That in a nutshell is what the widely derided sovereignty means.
So we've gone from 'sunlit uplands' and '£350M a week for the NHS' to 'it's not as bad as some said'. That was well worth the cost then. Or conversely we have gone from £4,500 a year worse off, the need for an emergency budget and economic collapse to being in at least as a good a position as EU member states, no emergency budget and not being £4,500 a year worse off. Foreign companies such as Nissan have also underlined their commitment to a post Brexit UK.
What we have gained is the removal of a huge excuse used by politicians of all parties for unpopular decisions.
£350 million a week for the NHS was never promised and most of us who voted to leave never believed we would be spending that sum on the health service.
So given that the evidence suggests we are no worse off, just exactly why is it some people still seem insistent on telling us how terrible everything is and looking to blame everything on Brexit? Could it be that some can't just accept they were wrong and were fooled by the lies of the remain campaign given they have spent the last 5 years calling leave voters stupid for believing lies?
Quite.
And you may have noticed I don't point out how bad off we are, because ultimately it makes no difference we are where we are now. But I will point out that it was a completely pointless exercise as it does make it more expensive to trade with, and visit the EU now. So as a country the best we are hoping for is its a bit 'meh' whereas for the individuals and businesses it is a pain in the arse. So we've gone through it all to make ourselves a bit less well off - great.
Gaining an excuse for politicians is not really a win as we appear to believe the shit they come out with anyway, and they can blatantly lie and fill their own, and their mates, pockets but I would lay good odds on you still voting for them next time. Really?
" All of which could have happened whilst we were in the EU so as you were. We are worse off from leaving, it means nothing what any politician said either way, there are no benefits to leaving apart from ideological ones."
Remainer pre Brexit 'facts' come true. (wbaunofficial.org.uk)
" So basically, we've spent billions of pounds and wasted 5 years of our lives to be a little bit worse off? That was worth it."
Brexit Gains 2 (wbaunofficial.org.uk)
And it's not an excuse for politicians we have gained, quite the opposite. Voting to leave has removed an excuse they could previously fall back on.
Posts: 12,682
Threads: 1,158
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
15
Right, this is getting moved to the Politics board.
|