Opposition tactics
#11
Good analysis in this. Simply though we’ve had bad injuries and still adapting. We have to persevere as painful as it can be at times.
January will be interesting as we’ll see what we are doing as a club in the big scheme.
Reply
#12
(11-07-2021, 12:14 PM)Baggeridgebaggy Wrote: We’ve been a big scalp in the Championship for 20 yrs ….historically many teams have set up to frustrate us but because the coach & our players were good enough that was hardly ever an issue

So all of a sudden coach and some fans are using other teams tactics as an excuse for really poor performances against some of the poorest teams in the Championship

Truth is this is a combination of a one dimensional coach, awful lob sided recruitment and players who aren’t good enough

This is not all the coaches fault, but he has to take some responsibility for turgid, virtually unwatchable football and results that are going the wrong way

Never changing formation or tactics …team selection, getting most out of his players. Coaches remit

Although he has a preferred formation nobody can argue that he hasn't changed tactics.   The first month of blood and thunder contained very little passing through the lines but last night we were playing out from the back and through the lines majority of the second half.   

In regards to formation, of course I agree but I can see both sides of the argument.  For the manager this is a formation he trusts and has had considerable success with.  He wants all players, at every level of the club, to know their role in this system.  And transfer activity should be guided by it.   He's got to back himself on this.

The fans are watching something that isn't working.  Instinctively the answer must be to change something, anything.  Change formation, bring back discarded players, try the yoof etc.     

Well, for example an extra man in midfield might help us control the game, but where does that body come from? Four at the back?  Well, take out the Fulham game and we have conceded 12 goals in 16 games.  Take into account we've lost our best defenders in Dara and Clarke for extended periods and the numbers suggest that this part of the team is working fine, so do we want to change it? Will Zahore really fit back into this team? Are any of the yoofs BETTER than the experienced pros? 

I guess the argument is you don't know until you try but I can't think of ANY recent Baggies managers that have made those kind of changes when less risk averse options have been available. We know that Pep and Tuchel can change things mid game if needed but they have the quality of players to do it.
Reply
#13
(11-07-2021, 01:13 PM)Lillwall's left foot Wrote:
(11-07-2021, 12:14 PM)Baggeridgebaggy Wrote: We’ve been a big scalp in the Championship for 20 yrs ….historically many teams have set up to frustrate us but because the coach & our players were good enough that was hardly ever an issue

So all of a sudden coach and some fans are using other teams tactics as an excuse for really poor performances against some of the poorest teams in the Championship

Truth is this is a combination of a one dimensional coach, awful lob sided recruitment and players who aren’t good enough

This is not all the coaches fault, but he has to take some responsibility for turgid, virtually unwatchable football and results that are going the wrong way

Never changing formation or tactics …team selection, getting most out of his players. Coaches remit

Although he has a preferred formation nobody can argue that he hasn't changed tactics.   The first month of blood and thunder contained very little passing through the lines but last night we were playing out from the back and through the lines majority of the second half.   

In regards to formation, of course I agree but I can see both sides of the argument.  For the manager this is a formation he trusts and has had considerable success with.  He wants all players, at every level of the club, to know their role in this system.  And transfer activity should be guided by it.   He's got to back himself on this.

The fans are watching something that isn't working.  Instinctively the answer must be to change something, anything.  Change formation, bring back discarded players, try the yoof etc.     

Well, for example an extra man in midfield might help us control the game, but where does that body come from? Four at the back?  Well, take out the Fulham game and we have conceded 12 goals in 16 games.  Take into account we've lost our best defenders in Dara and Clarke for extended periods and the numbers suggest that this part of the team is working fine, so do we want to change it? Will Zahore really fit back into this team? Are any of the yoofs BETTER than the experienced pros? 

I guess the argument is you don't know until you try but I can't think of ANY recent Baggies managers that have made those kind of changes when less risk averse options have been available.  We know that Pep and Tuchel can change things mid game if needed but they have the quality of players to do it.


You can get an extra man in midfield by dropping one of the forwards and playing a version of 352.

That won't happen though Ismael insists on 343. Yesterday the 3 was actually more of a 21 with Diangana and Grant narrower and deeper behind Robinson and then Hugill. That is the only variation you will get from VI how he subtly adapts the front three.
Reply
#14
(11-07-2021, 01:19 PM)Atomic Wrote:
(11-07-2021, 01:13 PM)Lillwall's left foot Wrote:
(11-07-2021, 12:14 PM)Baggeridgebaggy Wrote: We’ve been a big scalp in the Championship for 20 yrs ….historically many teams have set up to frustrate us but because the coach & our players were good enough that was hardly ever an issue

So all of a sudden coach and some fans are using other teams tactics as an excuse for really poor performances against some of the poorest teams in the Championship

Truth is this is a combination of a one dimensional coach, awful lob sided recruitment and players who aren’t good enough

This is not all the coaches fault, but he has to take some responsibility for turgid, virtually unwatchable football and results that are going the wrong way

Never changing formation or tactics …team selection, getting most out of his players. Coaches remit

Although he has a preferred formation nobody can argue that he hasn't changed tactics.   The first month of blood and thunder contained very little passing through the lines but last night we were playing out from the back and through the lines majority of the second half.   

In regards to formation, of course I agree but I can see both sides of the argument.  For the manager this is a formation he trusts and has had considerable success with.  He wants all players, at every level of the club, to know their role in this system.  And transfer activity should be guided by it.   He's got to back himself on this.

The fans are watching something that isn't working.  Instinctively the answer must be to change something, anything.  Change formation, bring back discarded players, try the yoof etc.     

Well, for example an extra man in midfield might help us control the game, but where does that body come from? Four at the back?  Well, take out the Fulham game and we have conceded 12 goals in 16 games.  Take into account we've lost our best defenders in Dara and Clarke for extended periods and the numbers suggest that this part of the team is working fine, so do we want to change it? Will Zahore really fit back into this team? Are any of the yoofs BETTER than the experienced pros? 

I guess the argument is you don't know until you try but I can't think of ANY recent Baggies managers that have made those kind of changes when less risk averse options have been available.  We know that Pep and Tuchel can change things mid game if needed but they have the quality of players to do it.


You can get an extra man in midfield by dropping one of the forwards and playing a version of 352.

That won't happen though Ismael insists on 343. Yesterday the 3 was actually more of a 21 with Diangana and Grant narrower and deeper behind Robinson and then Hugill. That is the only variation you will get from VI how he subtly adapts the front three.

With 352 you loose the overloading out wide Val likes to use and get crosses into the box, however, at the moment we just don't have instinctive forwards and or midfielders/wing backs making runs into those crosses.  We see a lot of crosses flying across with no one near them. Hugil seems to be getting a bit closer in moments but still not close enough. Maybe it works in training?
Reply
#15
Atomic Wrote:
Lillwall's left foot Wrote:
Baggeridgebaggy Wrote:We’ve been a big scalp in the Championship for 20 yrs ….historically many teams have set up to frustrate us but because the coach & our players were good enough that was hardly ever an issue

So all of a sudden coach and some fans are using other teams tactics as an excuse for really poor performances against some of the poorest teams in the Championship

Truth is this is a combination of a one dimensional coach, awful lob sided recruitment and players who aren’t good enough

This is not all the coaches fault, but he has to take some responsibility for turgid, virtually unwatchable football and results that are going the wrong way

Never changing formation or tactics …team selection, getting most out of his players. Coaches remit

Although he has a preferred formation nobody can argue that he hasn't changed tactics.   The first month of blood and thunder contained very little passing through the lines but last night we were playing out from the back and through the lines majority of the second half.   

In regards to formation, of course I agree but I can see both sides of the argument.  For the manager this is a formation he trusts and has had considerable success with.  He wants all players, at every level of the club, to know their role in this system.  And transfer activity should be guided by it.   He's got to back himself on this.

The fans are watching something that isn't working.  Instinctively the answer must be to change something, anything.  Change formation, bring back discarded players, try the yoof etc.     

Well, for example an extra man in midfield might help us control the game, but where does that body come from? Four at the back?  Well, take out the Fulham game and we have conceded 12 goals in 16 games.  Take into account we've lost our best defenders in Dara and Clarke for extended periods and the numbers suggest that this part of the team is working fine, so do we want to change it? Will Zahore really fit back into this team? Are any of the yoofs BETTER than the experienced pros? 

I guess the argument is you don't know until you try but I can't think of ANY recent Baggies managers that have made those kind of changes when less risk averse options have been available.  We know that Pep and Tuchel can change things mid game if needed but they have the quality of players to do it.


You can get an extra man in midfield by dropping one of the forwards and playing a version of 352.

That won't happen though Ismael insists on 343. Yesterday the 3 was actually more of a 21 with Diangana and Grant narrower and deeper behind Robinson and then Hugill. That is the only variation you will get from VI how he subtly adapts the front three.
This. Firstly, I agree with Lilwall's Left Foot. There has been a noticeable change of style, into attemting playing through the opposition not lumping it forward. After all, you can't press when the opposition gets rid of the ball at the earliest chance. For me, the next subtle change would be (in the absence of a recognised CF), playing an extra midfielder behind the front 2 at the price of removing one of our 3 (wide player) attackers.
All in all, I don't think our football is anywhere near as bad as made out. I can name a good number of seasons when it has been worse. I can name times when we have played better football, but we don't have a Brunty, Mozza, Superbob, Hope, Willie or Laurie nowadays. In view of our finances, I'm fairly content, although this may change of the manager does not get at least some backing.
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: