Appalling to mention Moore’s colour
#11
(03-11-2019, 11:05 AM)Squid Wrote: His sacking was not a racial issue.

But. People seemed to analyse his every word in a way they don't with white managers. Those are my onions.

Good post - Moore's sacking was not a racial matter.

The issues regarding BAME managers are more subtle.  When the BAME manager performs well - he is treated no different to his white counterpart.  The point is that mediocre/ journeymen white managers get sacked and immediately get another job - a BAME manager fails and it is much harder/ takes longer for him to get another job.

This and the number of BAME managers who struggle to land their first job is the issue.  This is v different to Moore's case.  It will be interesting to see where/ when he gets his next opportunity.
Reply
#12
(03-11-2019, 11:43 AM)MancBaggie Wrote:
(03-11-2019, 11:05 AM)Squid Wrote: His sacking was not a racial issue.

But. People seemed to analyse his every word in a way they don't with white managers. Those are my onions.

Good post - Moore's sacking was not a racial matter.

The issues regarding BAME managers are more subtle.  When the BAME manager performs well - he is treated no different to his white counterpart.  The point is that mediocre/ journeymen white managers get sacked and immediately get another job - a BAME manager fails and it is much harder/ takes longer for him to get another job.

This and the number of BAME managers who struggle to land their first job is the issue.  This is v different to Moore's case.  It will be interesting to see where/ when he gets his next opportunity.

Well said. 

There is a problem, but Moore was not sacked due to the colour of his skin.
Reply
#13
(03-11-2019, 11:32 AM)rsbaggy2 Wrote: Garth Crooks demonstrating what an ill informed twat he is... nothing new there I suppose?

''If ever the casual football supporter wanted to know why there is a concerted effort for organisations like Kick it Out and the PFA to challenge the game on its woeful record on the opportunities afforded black players to establish themselves as managers then the sacking of Darren Moore must have put it into sharp perspective. To say I was shocked by the news was an understatement.

Do West Bromwich Albion have no shame?

As a player Moore, helped West Brom win two promotions to the Premier League but in pure managerial terms his team are fourth in the Championship and still in with a chance of gaining promotion. Meanwhile, Derby and Middlesbrough, clubs who have invested in their teams and tipped to go up this season are below them.

We are told that out of work managers Slavisa Jokanovic and David Wagner both fit the profile of potential candidates to take over from Moore. Well, both those managers did well at Fulham and Huddersfield respectively this season didn't they!''

How many caps did Morrison get for England in the end?
Reply
#14
The fact we appointed him in the first place blows this argument out the water. People like Ince and Crooks are basically saying that because Darren Moore is black we should have given him more time.
Reply
#15
This was always going to look like a strange decision to outsiders, but Darren's race and club history makes it worse.

I agree that some ofbthe outrage about his sacking is misplaced, but DM's tenure has highlighted the difficulties Black British mangers face.
Reply
#16
It's easy enough to shout "racism" every time something negative happens to a black person. But after a while it starts to look like a cry wolf response and loses its impact.

I've seen a white Icelendic manager get sacked by a white Icelandic board a couple of days after achieving promotion. You could make a fairly strong case for saying that Rowett was sacked far too quickly given that it's accepted that his successor will be given far longer to put our clusterfuck of a club back together again. What would Crook's response have been if they'd been black?

Things happen in life and football that are hard to explain. From the outside the sacking of Moore does look odd. But just because outsiders don't know the reasons doesn't give anyone the right to accuse someone of racism as a default explanation unless there's actually some evidence of it. It's predictably pathetic.
Reply
#17
(03-11-2019, 12:49 PM)Dreamkiller Wrote: It's easy enough to shout "racism" every time something negative happens to a black person. But after a while it starts to look like a cry wolf response and loses its impact.

I've seen a white Icelendic manager get sacked by a white Icelandic board a couple of days after achieving promotion. You could make a fairly strong case for saying that Rowett was sacked far too quickly given that it's accepted that his successor will be given far longer to put our clusterfuck of a club back together again. What would Crook's response have been if they'd been black?

Things happen in life and football that are hard to explain. From the outside the sacking of Moore does look odd. But just because outsiders don't know the reasons doesn't give anyone the right to accuse someone of racism as a default explanation unless there's actually some evidence of it. It's predictably pathetic.

Top post.
Reply
#18
(03-11-2019, 12:49 PM)Dreamkiller Wrote: It's easy enough to shout "racism" every time something negative happens to a black person. But after a while it starts to look like a cry wolf response and loses its impact.

I've seen a white Icelendic manager get sacked by a white Icelandic board a couple of days after achieving promotion. You could make a fairly strong case for saying that Rowett was sacked far too quickly given that it's accepted that his successor will be given far longer to put our clusterfuck of a club back together again. What would Crook's response have been if they'd been black?

Things happen in life and football that are hard to explain. From the outside the sacking of Moore does look odd. But just because outsiders don't know the reasons doesn't give anyone the right to accuse someone of racism as a default explanation unless there's actually some evidence of it. It's predictably pathetic.

Excellent post DK as with most things in life, everyone has an agenda. It has to be remembered that Crooks lambasted Wolves for not giving Conner the managers job on a permanent basis although the whole world could see he aspired to be useless.
Reply
#19
(03-11-2019, 11:32 AM)rsbaggy2 Wrote: Garth Crooks demonstrating what an ill informed twat he is... nothing new there I suppose?

''If ever the casual football supporter wanted to know why there is a concerted effort for organisations like Kick it Out and the PFA to challenge the game on its woeful record on the opportunities afforded black players to establish themselves as managers then the sacking of Darren Moore must have put it into sharp perspective. To say I was shocked by the news was an understatement.

Do West Bromwich Albion have no shame?

As a player Moore, helped West Brom win two promotions to the Premier League but in pure managerial terms his team are fourth in the Championship and still in with a chance of gaining promotion. Meanwhile, Derby and Middlesbrough, clubs who have invested in their teams and tipped to go up this season are below them.

We are told that out of work managers Slavisa Jokanovic and David Wagner both fit the profile of potential candidates to take over from Moore. Well, both those managers did well at Fulham and Huddersfield respectively this season didn't they!''

David Wagner is BAME isn't he? Maybe not enough for Garth.
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: