My take on it all....
#21
(03-10-2019, 10:05 PM)aj21 Wrote:
(03-10-2019, 07:28 PM)Cuzer Wrote:
(03-10-2019, 07:17 PM)Squid Wrote:
(03-10-2019, 07:03 PM)westbromjack Wrote: Great post. My hopes are it’s Derek McInnes and the club back him to build over the next few years. He has done wonders at Aberdeen and I always felt that he would manage us one day. The time and opportunity is right.

The SPL is a Mickey Mouse league with limited pressure. I'm not sure he's the answer.


Re: the OP, I didn't realise Lee Johnson was interviewed.

Johnson, Smith and Moore were the only three interviewed for the job. At the time I genuinely though Moore had to be interviewed on the back of how well he did in almost keeping us up, I never seriously thought he was in the running for the job, was amazed when he landed it
As others have said and I did in my OP, if it was a 3-4 season approach Moore was arguably the right call and should have been stuck with, clearly it never was, it was all about this season, and you could argue another stab next season with the 2nd lot of parachute money, if that was clearly the case why go for somebody with 10 or so games as a manager, we have made some clusterfuck decisions as a club at times, let's hope the next one is right

No hindishgt here AJ, your posts once more are pathetic in trying too hard to try and have a pop at me, what I say at the time I stand by now, nothing in the OP is with hindsight, how I saw it at the time and how I see it now. I've been fair with DM as I have in the OP, I think he's been harshly treated but scratch under the surface and those who watch us week in, week out, could see something wasn't quite right given the ability we have in the squad, act now, or the summer, that was the only question if they doubted his long term ability

Cuzer

There you go again, pontificating over others ‘those who go week in and week out could see it’.......apart from the fact you didn’t go on Saturday....and the people who have a different opinion clearly don’t watch us.

He said "those who watch us week in, week out, could see something wasn't quite right".  Do you have a different opinion to that?  The sacking of DM has understandably divided our fans but I would have thought we would all be in agreement that something wasn't quite right.
Reply
#22
Thanks GS unfortunately AJ reads and see’s what he wants to see buy you can’t educate an idiot!

Your conclusion is bob on, we were all pretty ecstatic with the business we did by the end of the Jan window, we generally felt we now had all bases covered, have we looked a better side since then? If anything we’ve looked more disjointed

Cuzer
Reply
#23
BD got the gig based on the end of season run, cost and the players/supporters, it was a risk and I said at the
time if he fails the hurt is going to cut deep and hard, such is his standing at the club. All this talk on here and
elsewhere about "not needing to bounce straight back up" is wishful thinking. Lai is looking over the cliff edge,
with an investment of around £190m turning into a valuation of £60m tops. Promotion is a must and with automatic
almost gone he has just rolled the dice to try and secure the play offs and give us a chance of winning them.

The situation is deeply concerning, not just because of the sacking of BD and Jones, but what lies ahead if we do
fail to win promotion this season.
Reply
#24
(03-11-2019, 08:55 AM)Beano Wrote: BD got the gig based on the end of season run, cost and the players/supporters, it was a risk and I said at the
time if he fails the hurt is going to cut deep and hard, such is his standing at the club. All this talk on here and
elsewhere about "not needing to bounce straight back up" is wishful thinking. Lai is looking over the cliff edge,
with an investment of around £190m turning into a valuation of £60m tops. Promotion is a must and with automatic
almost gone he has just rolled the dice to try and secure the play offs and give us a chance of winning them.

The situation is deeply concerning, not just because of the sacking of BD and Jones, but what lies ahead if we do
fail to win promotion this season.

Exactly. All the talk of slowly building a squad of young home grown players capable of ‘competing’ in the Prem is s fairytale. Quite what finishing in 8th and 10th etc was if not competing I’m not sure. Even if we did get a young team playing well, they would be poached constantly by richer clubs, it’s akin to  building a wall and just as thing would take shape some twat would come along in a JCB and punch a hole in it. 

The club wants / needs promotion, there is no ‘long term plan that involves staying in this league unless you count midtable mediocrity at best.

The clubs decision to employ DM was fraught with risk which makes the decision to give him the job baffling and that isn’t a slight on DM that’s just an objective point of view given the need to get promotion at the first time if asking.
Reply
#25
Spot on Cuzer

Cuzer
Reply
#26
The panic on here regarding whether Barnes would be recalled or not looks to have been well founded.

With Barnes
Played 26
Points per game 1.76
Goals per game 2.07

Without Barnes
Played 10
Points per game 1.5
Goals per game 1.4

Goals conceded per game also slightly higher, but possibly harder to link that to his departure.

League games only.
Reply
#27
Thumbs Up 
I've begun to see the use of the word disjointed springing up on here. This is exactly how 4-3-3 begins to show itself up when it gets exploited. Remember Keith Andrews describing it as naive after the Leeds game, it's one thing the formation being exploited for its shortcomings, it something else entirely all together sitting back and letting the game play itself out. 
When it works, great, when it doesn`t it looks bloody awful - change it, this is when a manager earns his corn.

As for Barnes, there's not a manager in world football that would not play through him at Championship level, its all relative, Zidane or Barnes, you traffic the game through them. When he fucked of back we then needed to come up with something different. For all DM`s platitudes about hard work on the training ground, I saw nothing different materialise on a match day when the chips were down, our get out clause had returned back to his parent club.

For all our fan bases goodwill towards DM, the fact is tactically we have been poor when it comes to the crunch and the blame lays firmly at the door of DM and GJ for that major shortcoming.
Reply
#28
(03-11-2019, 10:25 AM)George Stagefright Wrote: The panic on here regarding whether Barnes would be recalled or not looks to have been well founded.

With Barnes
Played 26
Points per game 1.76
Goals per game 2.07

Without Barnes
Played 10
Points per game 1.5
Goals per game 1.4

Goals conceded per game also slightly higher, but possibly harder to link that to his departure.

League games only.

It's definitely true that Barnes (and Phillips injury) has caused trouble but actually your stats dont really make that much of a compelling argument. Basically we're say we've dropped 2.6 points without Barnes so we'd still be a good long way off of automatic!
Reply
#29
(03-11-2019, 10:42 AM)MGalea Wrote:
(03-11-2019, 10:25 AM)George Stagefright Wrote: The panic on here regarding whether Barnes would be recalled or not looks to have been well founded.

With Barnes
Played 26
Points per game 1.76
Goals per game 2.07

Without Barnes
Played 10
Points per game 1.5
Goals per game 1.4

Goals conceded per game also slightly higher, but possibly harder to link that to his departure.

League games only.

It's definitely true that Barnes (and Phillips injury) has caused trouble but actually your stats dont really make that much of a compelling argument. Basically we're say we've dropped 2.6 points without Barnes so we'd still be a good long way off of automatic!

I take your point but we were 3 points off automatic when he left, now 9 points behind.
Reply
#30
For me, Darren Moore hamstrung his own approach when he failed to identify a target man in both of the windows he's been in charge.

Upon losing Barnes, a more experienced coach realises they aren't going to replace that talent like for like so takes the team in a slightly different direction and mixes thing up.

I hoped we'd become a more solid unit that has the option of scoring different types of goals and holding the ball upfront. We ended up having neither this or the option of Barnes dribbling past 2 and smashing one home.

It was pretty easy for coaches to figure us out in the end as we were so one dimensional. DM gave himself nowhere to turn.
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: