MirroR aRticle
#11
(11-05-2021, 01:22 PM)MassDebater Wrote:
(11-05-2021, 01:15 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: As ever our fans seem to want to play down their own team’s ability seemingly wanting to believe we have an average Championship squad ‘lucky to make the play-offs’, bullshit. The top three are far and away the best squads in the Championship. It would be a complete dereliction of duty if this team didn’t reach the play-off final and it’s a very reasonable expectation to get automatic promotion.

What teams are better than the top three? Perhaps Sheff Utd but outside them, ourselves, us, Fulham, and Bournemouth are man for man better than the others.

Put up or shut up, those squads that are better…

You could try reading the comments. Not one person has said anything about the squad quality compared to the Championship in this fred, I even went back and re-read them to make sure I'd not missed any.

I commented on the author's spending suggestion and then there were queries about who in the Premiership the squads could replace, and Norwich is probably the only real one. So, again, actually try reading what's been put instead of hitting the faux outraged button about something that was never said.

Hang on even before Allardyce brought in players in January last season, we had numerous fans saying our squad should be competing with many of their Prem counterparts under Bilic. We seem as a fan base to generally over estimate the squad in the Prem (next level / we should be competing with them) and underestimating many of the same players in the Championship (‘lucky to make the play/offs, worst squad in years’). This is mainly so people can argue for or against a particular manager. The most obvious problem is we have a squad that is quite clearly good enough for promotion but not good enough to stay in the Prem. That is the problem with clubs of ours and Norwich’s size and resources when we are trying to compete whilst living within our financial means.
Reply
#12
A cheap and lazy article. If it was a foodstuff it would have been a doughnut.
Reply
#13
A cheap and lazy article. If it was a foodstuff it would have been a doughnut.
Reply
#14
Re the squad. We were woefully under-equipped for the Prem last time around, since then we have sold our best player. I understand what the article says about Fulham and Bournemouth but I'm really not sure we should have been lumped in with them. Should Val put us top two at the expense of one of those two, he will have done very well.
Reply
#15
We have the worst squad we've had in 20 years but it's still better than all but 3 of the other squads in our division. That says more about the quality of the division than our squad though.
Reply
#16
(11-05-2021, 08:12 PM)richbaggie Wrote: We have the worst squad we've had in 20 years but it's still better than all but 3 of the other squads in our division. That says more about the quality of the division than our squad though.

This.

We do not have one of the best 2 squads in this division, but it’s comfortably ahead of 90% of the others.
Reply
#17
2001-02 squad

Russel Hoult
Des Little
Neil Clement
Derek McInnes
Tony Butler
Phil Gilchrist
Ruel Fox
Micheal Appleton
Bob Taylor
Andy Johnson
Jason Robert’s
James Quinn

Left during season
Lee Hughes
Uwe Rosler

Squad Players
Adam Oliver
Mathew Turner
Mark Briggs
Chris Adamson
Eliot Morrison

2008 - 9 Squad

Dean Kiely
Carl Hoefkins
Paul Robinson
Leon Barnett
Neil Clement
Robert Koren
Jonathon Greening
Roman Bednar
Craig Beattie
Zoltan Gera
Kim Do-heon
Luke Steele
Martin Albrechtsen
Shergill MacDonald
Jared Hodgkiss

I think we do look back with rose tinted glasses when it comes to previous squads. Yes we have had some quality players in each squad but they have all had limited / weak areas despite the success.
Reply
#18
OK, 19 years sakes

No way that 2008 squad is worse than this one. Not a chance.


2008 - 9 Squad

Dean Kiely < Johnstone
Carl Hoefkins > Furlong
Paul Robinson > Townsend
Leon Barnett = Ajayi
Neil Clement > Townsend/reach
Robert Koren > mowatt
Jonathon Greening > livermore
Roman Bednar = Grant
Craig Beattie < Robinson
Zoltan Gera > Diangana
Kim Do-heon = snodgrass
Luke Steele < Button
Martin Albrechtsen = Bartley
Shergill MacDonald < Phillips
Jared Hodgkiss nothing to compare with.

You seem to have forgotten a few players of note too.....

Brunt, Mozza, Jonas, Carson to name just 4.
Reply
#19
(11-05-2021, 09:40 PM)richbaggie Wrote:
(11-05-2021, 08:54 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: 2001-02 squad

Russel Hoult
Des Little
Neil Clement
Derek McInnes
Tony Butler
Phil Gilchrist
Ruel Fox
Micheal Appleton
Bob Taylor
Andy Johnson
Jason Robert’s
James Quinn

Left during season
Lee Hughes
Uwe Rosler

Squad Players
Adam Oliver
Mathew Turner
Mark Briggs
Chris Adamson
Eliot Morrison

2008 - 9 Squad

Dean Kiely
Carl Hoefkins
Paul Robinson
Leon Barnett
Neil Clement
Robert Koren
Jonathon Greening
Roman Bednar
Craig Beattie
Zoltan Gera
Kim Do-heon
Luke Steele
Martin Albrechtsen
Shergill MacDonald
Jared Hodgkiss

I think we do look back with rose tinted glasses when it comes to previous squads. Yes we have had some quality players in each squad but they have all had limited / weak areas despite the success.
OK, 19 years 

Sakes

I don’t think the Mowbray squad is particularly strong it was just a piss poor league that season.
Reply
#20
(11-05-2021, 09:47 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote:
(11-05-2021, 09:40 PM)richbaggie Wrote:
(11-05-2021, 08:54 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: 2001-02 squad

Russel Hoult
Des Little
Neil Clement
Derek McInnes
Tony Butler
Phil Gilchrist
Ruel Fox
Micheal Appleton
Bob Taylor
Andy Johnson
Jason Robert’s
James Quinn

Left during season
Lee Hughes
Uwe Rosler

Squad Players
Adam Oliver
Mathew Turner
Mark Briggs
Chris Adamson
Eliot Morrison

2008 - 9 Squad

Dean Kiely
Carl Hoefkins
Paul Robinson
Leon Barnett
Neil Clement
Robert Koren
Jonathon Greening
Roman Bednar
Craig Beattie
Zoltan Gera
Kim Do-heon
Luke Steele
Martin Albrechtsen
Shergill MacDonald
Jared Hodgkiss

I think we do look back with rose tinted glasses when it comes to previous squads. Yes we have had some quality players in each squad but they have all had limited / weak areas despite the success.
OK, 19 years 

Sakes

I don’t think the Mowbray squad is particularly strong it was just a piss poor league that season.

Still very much better than this one, which was the original point. Its our worst squad since Megsons first build of squad.
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: 1 Guest(s)