Posts: 7,408
Threads: 458
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
29
(11-03-2021, 09:51 PM)MassDebater Wrote: 5 for all of them and I am being generous.
Anyone who says the defence was good, we're playing a side that cannot score.
Those marks are a total over reaction. The defence weren’t that bad all decent for his first match Taylor Hickman was very good. Some of Kipre passing from tha back was excellent. Livermore showed how to win a high press to create the goal. Reach came on and was excellent and Grant does what Grant does this season scores.
Why oh why some fans overreact I don’t know. It’s not easy playing against a packed defence we won move on.
Posts: 19,492
Threads: 824
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
60
Johnstone 7 - some lovely passing
Kipre - 5 - absolute liability
Bryan - 5
Clarke - 7 - sign at all costs.
Townsend - 6 a started well but faded at CB
Livermore - 4 - turned over possession for the goal but so many crap passes, kept dropping deep and playing as an auxiliary CB when we needed a body further forward.
Snodgrass - 5 - thinking the Bristol game was a flash in the pan. We miss Molumby’s energy and forward moving
Garner-Hickman - 6.5 - thought he was very strong first half but faded second. Used the ball very tidily.
Robinson - 6 - plenty of energy but wasteful and looked just off the pace
Grant - 6.5 - higher due to the goal, otherwise anonymous
Phillips - 4.5 - completely off the pace
Reach - 7
Hugill - 4 - generous, he is awful
Grady…. No time.
We were a mid table Champ side that edged past a league one side tonight. Let’s hope it’s a one off as we were really, really average.
Posts: 5,201
Threads: 197
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
14
SJ 6 Little to do,again could have commanded box better in last 5 when needed to take sting out of game
TGH 7 What a promising debut, full of confidence, despite obvious nerves, played like he does in the 23’s which is the biggest compliment Incan give him
Townsend 7 Started well and created plenty of attacks when switched to LCH
Bryan 6 Thought he started quite tidily before injury
Clarke 7 Solid and comfortable on the ball, one mistake late on when out of position v Eaves and his flick on gave Hull their only chance
Kipre 7 Presume Val brought him in as better on the ball than Semi and expected us to have all the ball, 69% possession in fact tonight, good passing, solid defensively and should start v Boro
Snodgrass 6 Tidy with the ball and drove us forward 2nd half and certainly played his part
Livermore 7* Clearly the new scrapgoat/scapegoat/crapgoat. Won the ball for the goal, worked tirelessly all night, took, the ball in tight areas and tried to play through the lines. Some of the stick he’s getting is absolutely disgusting
Phillips 5 Another poor one from Matty, nothing happening for him currently
Robbo 5 Seems low on confidence currently and touch was off tonight, still a managed to set up goal though and should be in the team every week for me
Grant 6 Extra point for the goal but all round game was poor
Subs
Reach 7 Lively and always looking to get forward and played some excellent balls into midfield tonight to get attacks going
Hugill 6 As expected plenty of endeavor and much better coming off the bench to make an impact
Grady 6 Not on long enough but hope he starts Saturday, offers us something so different to what we have against these defensive sides
Struggling to get my head around the criticism tonight in all honesty, Hull defended deep and put bodies on the line, given the lack of a creative centre midfielder in our ranks we have to wear teams down
Cuzer
Fisheatingdeludedsealwankers
Posts: 13,017
Threads: 1,260
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
6
(11-03-2021, 09:51 PM)MassDebater Wrote: 5 for all of them and I am being generous.
Anyone who says the defence was good, we're playing a side that cannot score.
Clarke, Gardner Hickman, Townsend and Reach all played well in defence.
Posts: 13,256
Threads: 468
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
45
(11-03-2021, 11:47 PM)Cuzer Wrote: SJ 6 Little to do,again could have commanded box better in last 5 when needed to take sting out of game
TGH 7 What a promising debut, full of confidence, despite obvious nerves, played like he does in the 23’s which is the biggest compliment Incan give him
Townsend 7 Started well and created plenty of attacks when switched to LCH
Bryan 6 Thought he started quite tidily before injury
Clarke 7 Solid and comfortable on the ball, one mistake late on when out of position v Eaves and his flick on gave Hull their only chance
Kipre 7 Presume Val brought him in as better on the ball than Semi and expected us to have all the ball, 69% possession in fact tonight, good passing, solid defensively and should start v Boro
Snodgrass 6 Tidy with the ball and drove us forward 2nd half and certainly played his part
Livermore 7* Clearly the new scrapgoat/scapegoat/crapgoat. Won the ball for the goal, worked tirelessly all night, took, the ball in tight areas and tried to play through the lines. Some of the stick he’s getting is absolutely disgusting
Phillips 5 Another poor one from Matty, nothing happening for him currently
Robbo 5 Seems low on confidence currently and touch was off tonight, still a managed to set up goal though and should be in the team every week for me
Grant 6 Extra point for the goal but all round game was poor
Subs
Reach 7 Lively and always looking to get forward and played some excellent balls into midfield tonight to get attacks going
Hugill 6 As expected plenty of endeavor and much better coming off the bench to make an impact
Grady 6 Not on long enough but hope he starts Saturday, offers us something so different to what we have against these defensive sides
Struggling to get my head around the criticism tonight in all honesty, Hull defended deep and put bodies on the line, given the lack of a creative centre midfielder in our ranks we have to wear teams down
Cuzer
Wouldn't change any of that
Posts: 8,841
Threads: 315
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
78
(11-03-2021, 11:57 PM)Sliced Wrote: (11-03-2021, 11:47 PM)Cuzer Wrote: SJ 6 Little to do,again could have commanded box better in last 5 when needed to take sting out of game
TGH 7 What a promising debut, full of confidence, despite obvious nerves, played like he does in the 23’s which is the biggest compliment Incan give him
Townsend 7 Started well and created plenty of attacks when switched to LCH
Bryan 6 Thought he started quite tidily before injury
Clarke 7 Solid and comfortable on the ball, one mistake late on when out of position v Eaves and his flick on gave Hull their only chance
Kipre 7 Presume Val brought him in as better on the ball than Semi and expected us to have all the ball, 69% possession in fact tonight, good passing, solid defensively and should start v Boro
Snodgrass 6 Tidy with the ball and drove us forward 2nd half and certainly played his part
Livermore 7* Clearly the new scrapgoat/scapegoat/crapgoat. Won the ball for the goal, worked tirelessly all night, took, the ball in tight areas and tried to play through the lines. Some of the stick he’s getting is absolutely disgusting
Phillips 5 Another poor one from Matty, nothing happening for him currently
Robbo 5 Seems low on confidence currently and touch was off tonight, still a managed to set up goal though and should be in the team every week for me
Grant 6 Extra point for the goal but all round game was poor
Subs
Reach 7 Lively and always looking to get forward and played some excellent balls into midfield tonight to get attacks going
Hugill 6 As expected plenty of endeavor and much better coming off the bench to make an impact
Grady 6 Not on long enough but hope he starts Saturday, offers us something so different to what we have against these defensive sides
Struggling to get my head around the criticism tonight in all honesty, Hull defended deep and put bodies on the line, given the lack of a creative centre midfielder in our ranks we have to wear teams down
Cuzer
Wouldn't change any of that
I agree. It matches what I saw from the Brummie.
Tonight was a chance to see some different players, which I enjoyed. Great to see a young player in Gardner-Hickman and Kipré did well.
Reach was great when he came on, blasting down the pitch.
I'd agree with Phillips, looks like he's about to enter his annual quiet phase.
Robinson hasn't looked the same since the international break, I thought he looked a bit faded against Bristol and assist aside, he's not done much to win his place.
Snodgrass and Livermore are not the midfield pairing for me.
Finally, I like watching Matt Clarke. Yes, he makes the odd mistake, but he's a clever footballer to watch.
Posts: 8,841
Threads: 315
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
78
(11-03-2021, 11:57 PM)Sliced Wrote: (11-03-2021, 11:47 PM)Cuzer Wrote: SJ 6 Little to do,again could have commanded box better in last 5 when needed to take sting out of game
TGH 7 What a promising debut, full of confidence, despite obvious nerves, played like he does in the 23’s which is the biggest compliment Incan give him
Townsend 7 Started well and created plenty of attacks when switched to LCH
Bryan 6 Thought he started quite tidily before injury
Clarke 7 Solid and comfortable on the ball, one mistake late on when out of position v Eaves and his flick on gave Hull their only chance
Kipre 7 Presume Val brought him in as better on the ball than Semi and expected us to have all the ball, 69% possession in fact tonight, good passing, solid defensively and should start v Boro
Snodgrass 6 Tidy with the ball and drove us forward 2nd half and certainly played his part
Livermore 7* Clearly the new scrapgoat/scapegoat/crapgoat. Won the ball for the goal, worked tirelessly all night, took, the ball in tight areas and tried to play through the lines. Some of the stick he’s getting is absolutely disgusting
Phillips 5 Another poor one from Matty, nothing happening for him currently
Robbo 5 Seems low on confidence currently and touch was off tonight, still a managed to set up goal though and should be in the team every week for me
Grant 6 Extra point for the goal but all round game was poor
Subs
Reach 7 Lively and always looking to get forward and played some excellent balls into midfield tonight to get attacks going
Hugill 6 As expected plenty of endeavor and much better coming off the bench to make an impact
Grady 6 Not on long enough but hope he starts Saturday, offers us something so different to what we have against these defensive sides
Struggling to get my head around the criticism tonight in all honesty, Hull defended deep and put bodies on the line, given the lack of a creative centre midfielder in our ranks we have to wear teams down
Cuzer
Wouldn't change any of that
I agree. It matches what I saw from the Brummie.
Tonight was a chance to see some different players, which I enjoyed. Great to see a young player in Gardner-Hickman and Kipré did well.
Reach was great when he came on, blasting down the pitch.
I'd agree with Phillips, looks like he's about to enter his annual quiet phase.
Robinson hasn't looked the same since the international break, I thought he looked a bit faded against Bristol and assist aside, he's not done much to win his place.
Snodgrass and Livermore are not the midfield pairing for me.
Finally, I like watching Matt Clarke. Yes, he makes the odd mistake, but he's a clever footballer to watch.
Posts: 290
Threads: 11
Joined: Jan 2021
G-H played very well and a 8 for me. Very composed and confident just wish he'd got the assist he deserved. Connor wasn't his usual self but still a 7 and the rest were around 6 to 7 apart from snodgrass who is shite and a 4 was reduced to a 3 for his pathetic dive which nearly got him back on his sick bed.
Kipre did well imo and played a couple of great passes out wide to Connor.
Biggest gripe was we need to start converting more of the chances and CR is going through a rough patch but was still unselfish enough to pass to KG when he could have had a shot so he gets a extra mark for that and a 6.
I don't understand how anyone can really criticise a makeshift defence which was further weakened by injury resulting in a reshuffle, and had a young debutant.
They put there bodies on the line and stopped an equaliser at the end and preserved their clean sheet.
Oh yeah, it was against Hull and they only have 9 points ans goals, and we all know teams at the bottom can never get a result against teams at the top, so obviously the makeshift defence that didn't conceed was shit and should also have cured cancer during the game.
FFS what have some of our fans become.
Posts: 1,459
Threads: 169
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
1
SJ - 7 - much better kicking.
Kipre - 7 - someone said absolute liability. Must have been at a different game. Defended well & quality passing. The quick ball to free Grant should have been an assist.
Clarke - 7 - winner
Bryan 6 -
Gardner-Hickman - 7 - Promising debut. Excellent going forward.
Livermore- 6 - Trier & did well for the goal
Snodgrass - 4 - Way off the pace. Molumby needs to be back in on Sat.
Townsend - 7 - Decent in Two positions.
Phillips - 5 - ineffective
Robinson- 5 - Off his game
Grant - 6 - Extra point for the goal
Reach - 8 - MOTM - always looking forward. Two excellent balls slid across the six yard box that a decent striker would have gobbled up.
Hugill - 6 - Tries
Posts: 9,603
Threads: 515
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
32
11-04-2021, 07:48 AM
(This post was last modified: 11-04-2021, 07:50 AM by Lurker#3.)
SJ - 7 - a couple of good saves and some good, quick distribution. Best in the league by a mile.
Kipre - 7 - Good in posession, some great switches of play and some great powerful defending. BUT can be so rash, gets dragged out of position and misses challenges when being reserved would be a better choice. I would definitely keep working with him though as at 23/24 he's still a baby and could be the real deal.
Clarke - 7 - much better in the middle of the back 3. As previously stated, it should be him or Barts in a three. Solid, progressive on the ball and his lack of pace isn't an issue centrally.
Bryan - 6 - Tidy enough then injured.
TGH - 7 - Good debut, showed energy, confidence and good ability. Needs more work on his positioning and body shape defensively if he's to be a wingback/fullback, but all in all, good.
Livermore - 7 - Our captain, the scrapGOAT... awful, shocking, slow. Except all the times he presses, wins the ball and allows us to score. Feel sorry for Jake he's really pissing in the wind with some of our lot.
Snodgrass - 6 - Nice in posession, but a 2 of him and Jake doesn't really work. No slight on either, but they are too similar in terms of their weaknesses.
Townsend - 6 - another mixed display for me. He seems to be little fatigued. Improved immeasurably when he moved into LCB though.
Phillips - 5 - Poor again. Needs taking out the team.
Robinson - 4 - Shocking again, I wish we could sign his brother who plays for Ireland.
Grant - 8 (motm) - One of the reasons I think I was watching a different game. Great movement, good hold up play, a good finish, and great work rate. He's showing a consistency in his performances and becoming a real reliable fixture in the team.
Subs:
Reach - 8 - Close to motm, only pipped by Grant doing it for 90 mins. His energy and running power gives us a different dimension, add this to his quality in posession it makes us a better team when playing against a low, unambitious block.
Hugill - 6 - Tried hard, worked the defenders.
"IMO of course..."
|