My take on it all....
#1
I missed yesterdays game, a works commitment meant I ended up watching egg chasing rather than my beloved Albion

Saying that, I watched bits of it on my phone, through a stream and have since read the posts on here, post game before the sacking and spoke to a few friends who went and the general feeling was one of more issues with our set up, lack of clarity on tactics or approach and some half hearted performances from certain players

Of course, the shite performance pailed into insignifcance when it was announced he was sacked

I posted last week on a Moore thread post Leeds that he wasn't held in such high regard by the management, I was aware of this but I have to say the timing of the sacking surpirsed me, the fact it's now come to light Jones was off in the summer regardless, maybe the heirarchy just thought DM wasn't the man to take us forward

For me if this season was promotion at all costs then he should never have got the job in the first place, if so much emphasis was put on getting back up and not developing the youth players or building for the future then it should have been Smith or Johnson who were also interviewed at the time, or of course somebody else who had that extra experience you need for the Championship

He's done so much right DM and if you felt this was a 3-4 year project to try and get up, but ultimately bring in a style of football, bring through youth and ensure in 2-3 years if we haven't bounced back we've got 4-5 of our talented youngsters good enough to play in the first team week in, week out, then DM was the right man for the job. However, we all said Feb was a make or break month for us, we all wanted to be still in touch with the top two post the Leeds game and frankly we've been found badly wanting

Harvey Barnes was/is a special talent, he bailed us out on numerous occasions for the first half of the season, I got slated for my "papering over the grand canyon" comment after he saved our bacon away at Sheffield Wednesday but even then, with us perssisting with the 3-5-2 formation signs were there that tactically DM and GJ left a lot to be desired
4-3-3 came, looked great but ultimately went as sides figured us out, our midfield is so one paced and the Leeds game was as embarrassed as we've been by any opposition for a long time, it really was men against boys

Post game he also let himself down badly, his interviews were just full of cliches, even pre game he never spoke much sense, most fans have an idea what's going on and what's required, he never once really said we were poor, players not performing, need to look at ourselves etc, despite some piss poor showings

This reminds me a bit of the Steve Clarke sacking, those oustide the club wondering what the fuck we're doing, yet those watching us week in, week out, not overly concerned by him losing his job


2nd is gone and the only thing I'm still not 100% on is should we have given him until the end of the season, even if we did clearly they didn't have the belief in him to either make a fist of it in the Prem or get us up next season so taking that into consideration maybe now is the right time to do it and whoever we bring in it must be an 18 month plan, if we do it through the play offs this year, great, if not full steam ahead for next season and another stab at it

Will be interesting in time to hear what he has to say on it but I would expect it will be more manufactured cliche's and little substance. I'm sure he will get another job soon and best of luck to him, he will always be welcome back here but as a manager, he just fell short of what was required. I also had an underlying feeling for some time he's a little weak as a man manager, too many of them for me are playing within themselves and he seems to let so many players take extra time to recover when sometimes we've needed to patch them up and get them out there

So who now? Jokanovic would probably be my call, he seems the stand out candidate and has previous of winning the play offs and getting sides promoted, Dekka I'm sure would move south for this job, given some assurances on time to be able to turn things around


It seems something will be announced soon, I really hope we don't go for a short term experienced guy such as Moyes or Dingle Sam until the end of the season, not what we need IMO

Once more over to the club, I think they got it wrong appointing him in the first place, although I saw the sentiment, no place for that now, we need to move quick and get the right bloke

Cuzer
Reply
#2
Good post - especially those last few paragraphs 

My problem with the regime has been the half arsed performances from so many so regularly.  The only exceptions have been Barnes and, until yesterday, Gayle.
Reply
#3
Imagine how successful the club would be if you ran the show. Would love to see you in charge and see how we’d get on. I know it might seem as though I’m getting at you as I’ve had a pop before but your posts are always full of hindsight and they do wind me up Smile

If we’d appointed someone else - like Smith then who knows what would happen but some Villa fans wanted Smith out recently, this is because football is full of short term thinking and their best player was out injured for months. When you lose big players it’s hard, the last few weeks we have had a run of injuries and losing Barnes was massive. Yes some of the tactics have been wrong but some of the tactics at times have been right. He has had to contend with taking over from the worst manager in the clubs history and players stealing fucking taxis, to turn us around to challenge promotion is quite something in my eye and I’m gutted he’s been dumped on at the first sign of trouble.

AJ21
Reply
#4
Good post. Agree with much of that.

FWIW I did think he deserved the job based on last season’s success but that was based on unity and hard work not ridiculous football that the players weren’t suited for. That was ultimately the death knell for him as a) such a style change takes time and it appears the club want instant promotion and b) we didn’t have the players and didn’t buy players suited to that style.

So either the importance of promotion wasn’t communicated or the style he wanted to introduce. Or, as I suspect, the decision was only made post Bolton with Jones.
Reply
#5
Great post. My hopes are it’s Derek McInnes and the club back him to build over the next few years. He has done wonders at Aberdeen and I always felt that he would manage us one day. The time and opportunity is right.
Reply
#6
Smith wanted 3 years to get us up
Reply
#7
Although I don't entirely agree with it, that was a good op from Cuzer,

Where I do agree with you is that Moore had to be seen as a long term appointment. It does seem to me that the club has sent out mixed messages this season, i'm sure somebody high up said earlier in the season that promotion wasn't a priority this season - well apparently it is.

This is a high risk decision by the club., and one that might backfire spectacularly even if we get promoted this season. The way in which decisions are taken at the club does not inspire confidence that we will be remotely prepared for a premiership campaign next season.

Added to this, any incoming manager must now be aware that the club prioritise short term decision making, a strategy that may mean that we do not capitalise on a crop of very promising youngsters coming through the ranks.
Reply
#8
(03-10-2019, 07:03 PM)westbromjack Wrote: Great post. My hopes are it’s Derek McInnes and the club back him to build over the next few years. He has done wonders at Aberdeen and I always felt that he would manage us one day. The time and opportunity is right.

The SPL is a Mickey Mouse league with limited pressure. I'm not sure he's the answer.


Re: the OP, I didn't realise Lee Johnson was interviewed.
Reply
#9
Almost every club in the country prioritises short term thinking. I don't get the idea that Moore was a "long term appointment". Such a thing doesn't exist these days in football.
Reply
#10
(03-10-2019, 07:17 PM)backsidebaggie Wrote: Almost every club in the country prioritises short term thinking. I don't get the idea that Moore was a "long term appointment". Such a thing doesn't exist these days in football.

I think there are some very clear examples of clubs who are not take a predominantly short term view.

Liverpool and Tottenham. Neither club has won anything under their current managers and yet their jobs are not at risk.

Sean Dyche at Burnley - there have been times when other clubs might have considered giving him the bullet, but have stuck with him.

In the championship, Norwich's decision to stick by Farke is being rewarded  There are a number of clubs who would have binned him after the first few weeks of this season after their slow start to the season, and there are some clubs where he wouldn't have started the season given their mediocre season last season.
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: 1 Guest(s)