The manager not backed
#51
Derek, Pulis isn’t coming back. Get fucking over it mon.
Reply
#52
(03-10-2019, 03:42 PM)WorcBaggie Wrote:
(03-10-2019, 03:36 PM)Shabby Russian Wrote:
(03-10-2019, 03:22 PM)backsidebaggie Wrote:
(03-10-2019, 03:13 PM)Shabby Russian Wrote: I am sure in financial terms Moore has had good backing.

But I would question the strategy of keeping the squad together.

For those who obviously fell asleep for the whole of the 2017-18 season, we finished bottom of the premiership and for significant spells of time the attitude of the players was atrocious. This time last season we lost consecutive matches against Southampton (twice), Huddersfield, Watford, Burnley, Bournemouth, not to mention the Barcelona debacle,

You really do have to question  why keeping that squad together was so imperative.

Norwich who had a mediocre season last year kept faith with their manager, they also sold their best player in James Maddison, some of the proceeds of which they re-invested in players.

I can't help thinking that it would have been better for us to sell some of our so called  premiership players and re-invest it .The only flaw in this plan was our recent record in player recruitment.

After the window closed in August last season, it struck me how few goal scorers we had in the squad and this season when the window closed it struck me how few players we had in the 21-27 age group.

Keeping the squad together was seen as imperative as in most similar cases, its given a club the best chance of going back up.

We can all pick holes in bits of the squad and say it could be better, but that's the same everywhere.

You could be right that we'd have been better selling some and re-investing, we'll never know. But BD wanted to keep them as far as we know.

Although of the last 30 teams who have been relegated only 9 have come back at the first time of asking.

It depends on the squad you have, the last time we were relegated, we had a lot of players who had experience of being promoted under Mowbray, and a good nucleus of younger players in their early to mid 20s, Brunt, Morrison, Dorrans, Mulumbu.

Our previous relegation to that we had a squad of players who when relegated basically gave up after January - it wasn't called the Great Surrender for nothing. Needless to say they didn't attain promotion the next season. It was only when that squad was broke up and a new one assembled from the proceeds of player sales, that we got promotion.

In my view the squad that got relegated last season resembled far more the great surrender squad, than the one that got relegated under Mowbray.

Your last sentence makes some sense BUT then who made the decision to keep the likes of Dawson, JRod etc and to give Livermore a contract extension? If it was Moore then it really negates your argument as they are obviously players he wanted and who he felt would get us promoted.

OK I give in we should have got some worse cheap players and won the title.
Reply
#53
(03-10-2019, 03:47 PM)Remi_Moses Wrote:
(03-10-2019, 03:42 PM)WorcBaggie Wrote:
(03-10-2019, 03:36 PM)Shabby Russian Wrote:
(03-10-2019, 03:22 PM)backsidebaggie Wrote:
(03-10-2019, 03:13 PM)Shabby Russian Wrote: I am sure in financial terms Moore has had good backing.

But I would question the strategy of keeping the squad together.

For those who obviously fell asleep for the whole of the 2017-18 season, we finished bottom of the premiership and for significant spells of time the attitude of the players was atrocious. This time last season we lost consecutive matches against Southampton (twice), Huddersfield, Watford, Burnley, Bournemouth, not to mention the Barcelona debacle,

You really do have to question  why keeping that squad together was so imperative.

Norwich who had a mediocre season last year kept faith with their manager, they also sold their best player in James Maddison, some of the proceeds of which they re-invested in players.

I can't help thinking that it would have been better for us to sell some of our so called  premiership players and re-invest it .The only flaw in this plan was our recent record in player recruitment.

After the window closed in August last season, it struck me how few goal scorers we had in the squad and this season when the window closed it struck me how few players we had in the 21-27 age group.

Keeping the squad together was seen as imperative as in most similar cases, its given a club the best chance of going back up.

We can all pick holes in bits of the squad and say it could be better, but that's the same everywhere.

You could be right that we'd have been better selling some and re-investing, we'll never know. But BD wanted to keep them as far as we know.

Although of the last 30 teams who have been relegated only 9 have come back at the first time of asking.

It depends on the squad you have, the last time we were relegated, we had a lot of players who had experience of being promoted under Mowbray, and a good nucleus of younger players in their early to mid 20s, Brunt, Morrison, Dorrans, Mulumbu.

Our previous relegation to that we had a squad of players who when relegated basically gave up after January - it wasn't called the Great Surrender for nothing. Needless to say they didn't attain promotion the next season. It was only when that squad was broke up and a new one assembled from the proceeds of player sales, that we got promotion.

In my view the squad that got relegated last season resembled far more the great surrender squad, than the one that got relegated under Mowbray.

Your last sentence makes some sense BUT then who made the decision to keep the likes of Dawson, JRod etc and to give Livermore a contract extension? If it was Moore then it really negates your argument as they are obviously players he wanted and who he felt would get us promoted.

OK I give in we should have got some worse cheap players and won the title.

He didn't say that, he made the point that even keeping it to a similar standard is backing the manager now we're in a lower division. The point is if keeping most of a squad like this together on high wages (Gibbs, Dawson, Jrod, Hegazi, Livermore, Barry, adding SJ and Gayle for Foster and Rondon) isn't backing a manager, then I don't now what is. And BD wanted to keep them!

I know the squad isn't perfect, there's always bits you can say are unbalanced etc, but my god who gets a perfect squad? BD didn't make the most of this squad due to lack of tactical nous. He wasnt far off (or we'd be lower), but ultimately he hasn't done the job set for him, and we were getting worse. And without Barnes for the first 5 months, we'd probably be mid table.

We all love Big Dave, but he's not done the job they asked of him, and he's got a strong squad who are steadily getting worse. I'll stick me neck out here and say when he gets another job somewhere, he'll be shown up as not good enough again. Harsh, but football's harsh.
Reply
#54
This talk about a high wage bill confuses me. Of course we had a high wage bill, we had an overinflated wage bill in the Premier League and even with the flex down clauses it's still overinflated.
Reply
#55
(03-10-2019, 04:05 PM)Borin\ Baggie Wrote: This talk about a high wage bill confuses me. Of course we had a high wage bill, we had an overinflated wage bill in the Premier League and even with the flex down clauses it's still overinflated.

Is is over inflated, but it still in general means the players are better than those earning a quarter at other clubs in the champ. That's why these players have played in the prem most of their careers, and hence earn a shit load more.

And more often than not when squads are kept together, they go back up. And if they don't, the manager gets the boot.
Reply
#56
DM had some success in the Prem because he took over and played players in their correct positions and instilled a bit of discipline and belief. In the Chump he has consistently failed to find a system the players fit into, repeated mistakes ad nauseum, ruined good players by using them in positions they don't perform well in, failed to change the course of games by using sensible substitutions, employed static and geriatric midfielders far too often, has been out-thought by far too many opposition managers and provided pathetic summaries on radio and in the press. Nice guy and an ex-hero but not up to the job,I'm afraid. It was the right decision but badly handled,by the sound of it.
Reply
#57
Our biggest problem is along with Darren's severance cheque will be a confidentiality agreement.
So we will never know the in's & out's - that's why we can only have our own opinions from our own points of view.
It would also be a major problem if we all agreed with one another. Age - reading - viewing - talking - visiting boreds - experience - nature - even the weather can alter peoples opinions.
The one great thing is I think we all still love Big Dave. Can't remember an ex manager who is so well thought of ?
Maybe Roy was highly regarded but not loved?
Reply
#58
(03-10-2019, 04:10 PM)col lard Wrote: DM had some success in the Prem because he took over and played players in their correct positions and instilled a bit of discipline and belief. In the Chump he has consistently failed to find a system the players fit into, repeated mistakes ad nauseum, ruined good players by using them in positions they don't perform well in, failed to change the course of games by using sensible substitutions, employed static and geriatric  midfielders far too often, has been out-thought by far too many opposition managers and provided pathetic summaries on radio and in the press. Nice guy and an ex-hero but not up to the job,I'm afraid. It was the right decision but badly handled,by the sound of it.

Exactly, except it wasn't really badly handled. There's no easy way to sack Big Dave. Only those inside the dressing room know if it was badly handled, and I doubt it was.

(03-10-2019, 04:13 PM)Remi_Moses Wrote: Our biggest problem is along with Darren's severance cheque will be a confidentiality agreement.
So we will never know the in's & out's - that's why we can only have our own opinions from our own points of view.
It would also be a major problem if we all agreed with one another. Age - reading - viewing - talking - visiting boreds - experience - nature - even the weather can alter peoples opinions.
The one great thing is I think we all still love Big Dave. Can't remember an ex manager who is so well thought of ?
Maybe Roy was highly regarded but not loved?

A confidentiality agreement? They're normal, but my god he ain't been sacked due to some crazy shit going on behind the scenes.

Its confidential, but he's had the sack because his job was to get top 2, we're getting worse, he has shit tactical nous and kept making the same mistakes. That's the ins and outs.
Reply
#59
(03-10-2019, 03:36 PM)Shabby Russian Wrote:
(03-10-2019, 03:22 PM)backsidebaggie Wrote:
(03-10-2019, 03:13 PM)Shabby Russian Wrote: I am sure in financial terms Moore has had good backing.

But I would question the strategy of keeping the squad together.

For those who obviously fell asleep for the whole of the 2017-18 season, we finished bottom of the premiership and for significant spells of time the attitude of the players was atrocious. This time last season we lost consecutive matches against Southampton (twice), Huddersfield, Watford, Burnley, Bournemouth, not to mention the Barcelona debacle,

You really do have to question  why keeping that squad together was so imperative.

Norwich who had a mediocre season last year kept faith with their manager, they also sold their best player in James Maddison, some of the proceeds of which they re-invested in players.

I can't help thinking that it would have been better for us to sell some of our so called  premiership players and re-invest it .The only flaw in this plan was our recent record in player recruitment.

After the window closed in August last season, it struck me how few goal scorers we had in the squad and this season when the window closed it struck me how few players we had in the 21-27 age group.

Keeping the squad together was seen as imperative as in most similar cases, its given a club the best chance of going back up.

We can all pick holes in bits of the squad and say it could be better, but that's the same everywhere.

You could be right that we'd have been better selling some and re-investing, we'll never know. But BD wanted to keep them as far as we know.

Although of the last 30 teams who have been relegated only 9 have come back at the first time of asking.

It depends on the squad you have, the last time we were relegated, we had a lot of players who had experience of being promoted under Mowbray, and a good nucleus of younger players in their early to mid 20s, Brunt, Morrison, Dorrans, Mulumbu.

Our previous relegation to that we had a squad of players who when relegated basically gave up after January - it wasn't called the Great Surrender for nothing. Needless to say they didn't attain promotion the next season. It was only when that squad was broke up and a new one assembled from the proceeds of player sales, that we got promotion.

In my view the squad that got relegated last season resembled far more the great surrender squad, than the one that got relegated under Mowbray.

You nailed it.  The squad in the summer wasn’t like those in 2006 and 2009. 

But the decision to stick with these fat sloth-like losers ultimately was that of Moore.  He’s paid a harsh price and now we need to do the hard bit of appointing someone who can knock this rabble into shape
Reply
#60
(03-10-2019, 04:09 PM)backsidebaggie Wrote:
(03-10-2019, 04:05 PM)Borin\ Baggie Wrote: This talk about a high wage bill confuses me. Of course we had a high wage bill, we had an overinflated wage bill in the Premier League and even with the flex down clauses it's still overinflated.

Is is over inflated, but it still in general means the players are better than those earning a quarter at other clubs in the champ. That's why these players have played in the prem most of their careers, and hence earn a shit load more.

And more often than not when squads are kept together, they go back up. And if they don't, the manager gets the boot.

Only if they have significant promotion experience already, see 2003/04 and 2009/10 Albion as well as Norwich and Burnley, the only real exception is Newcastle.
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: