Posts: 7,371
Threads: 181
Joined: Jul 2020
Reputation:
27
(11-01-2021, 10:04 AM)Lillwall's left foot Wrote: (11-01-2021, 09:28 AM)MrFizz Wrote: (11-01-2021, 09:12 AM)Lillwall's left foot Wrote: First viewing I thought he'd be ok. A trier, a scrapper and a good old shithouser. Expected his movement, touch and hold up play to improve as he got match sharp. Problem is that it hasn't! Add to the fact that he doesn't even look like getting on the end of the crosses that Townsend whips in and we've got a problem as this role is pivotal to proper Valball being successful.
As has been said he would be fine as a back up number 9. Let's hope that's the role he has after Crimbo. Not holding my breath in that one though.
Well he got on the end of at least 2 crosses against Brizzle. Scored with one and missed scoring a second by an inch. Don't get me wrong, Hugill aint no Mitrovic, but he aint no Paul Williams/Stewart Evans/Winston White/Tony Rees either. But as he seems to be Scrapgoat of the month i suppose reasoned arguments for and against are a waste of time.....
On reflection my post probably came across more scrapgoat than intended. Indeed it was a nice finish against Brizzle at the end of a lovely passing move and he could have had a hat trick on another day. He looks a decent chump level trier and we have had much worse. I can still see him having a run of goals at some point with the right service.
My point is that he's just not provided either the hold up play or goal threat that Val requires from a number 9 which is a pivotal role in this set up. I've seen those longer direct balls bounce off and away from him on regular occasion and although a scrapper he doesn't dominate more physical defenders. Neither have I seem him show the kind of movement and instinct in the box to be a threat on those crosses, not always accurate it has to be said, that Townsend or Furlong put in.
To get both qualities can be very expensive (the leagues aren't brimming with Tonney's) but at the moment Hugill is not quite providing either. And yes, there are other players who deserve equal attention but they all have replacements. It is not the fault of Hugil that he is currently the only option we have to play that role.
I still hope that the management team can find a way of getting Hugill on top of his game and more effective for us, but regardless we need another front man to share the load. Unfortunately we do have one, who cost £8 million and is doing very little for his £1 million a year salary. Comparatively Hugill is giving good value!!
I agree that he seems to fall in between 'scrapper target man' and 'poacher'. He doesnt excel at either. But as with a lot of forwards they're only as good as the service they get. IMO Phillips/Robbo/Grady have done worse than Hugill over the last month or so.
Posts: 9,321
Threads: 720
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
9
(11-01-2021, 10:04 AM)Lillwall's left foot Wrote: (11-01-2021, 09:28 AM)MrFizz Wrote: (11-01-2021, 09:12 AM)Lillwall's left foot Wrote: First viewing I thought he'd be ok. A trier, a scrapper and a good old shithouser. Expected his movement, touch and hold up play to improve as he got match sharp. Problem is that it hasn't! Add to the fact that he doesn't even look like getting on the end of the crosses that Townsend whips in and we've got a problem as this role is pivotal to proper Valball being successful.
As has been said he would be fine as a back up number 9. Let's hope that's the role he has after Crimbo. Not holding my breath in that one though.
Well he got on the end of at least 2 crosses against Brizzle. Scored with one and missed scoring a second by an inch. Don't get me wrong, Hugill aint no Mitrovic, but he aint no Paul Williams/Stewart Evans/Winston White/Tony Rees either. But as he seems to be Scrapgoat of the month i suppose reasoned arguments for and against are a waste of time.....
On reflection my post probably came across more scrapgoat than intended. Indeed it was a nice finish against Brizzle at the end of a lovely passing move and he could have had a hat trick on another day. He looks a decent chump level trier and we have had much worse. I can still see him having a run of goals at some point with the right service.
My point is that he's just not provided either the hold up play or goal threat that Val requires from a number 9 which is a pivotal role in this set up. I've seen those longer direct balls bounce off and away from him on regular occasion and although a scrapper he doesn't dominate more physical defenders. Neither have I seem him show the kind of movement and instinct in the box to be a threat on those crosses, not always accurate it has to be said, that Townsend or Furlong put in.
To get both qualities can be very expensive (the leagues aren't brimming with Tonney's) but at the moment Hugill is not quite providing either. And yes, there are other players who deserve equal attention but they all have replacements. It is not the fault of Hugil that he is currently the only option we have to play that role.
I still hope that the management team can find a way of getting Hugill on top of his game and more effective for us, but regardless we need another front man to share the load. Unfortunately we do have one, who cost £8 million and is doing very little for his £1 million a year salary. Comparatively Hugill is giving good value!!
I believe the initial Zohore fee was £4m guaranteed over 4 yrs (£1m a yr) with further add-ons up to £8m in total which are unlikely to ever be realised, so not 'as bad' as it's made out.
Posts: 655
Threads: 185
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
6
Christ ! he's had more Clubs than Jack Nicklaus, and he's played for 70 years
Posts: 7,371
Threads: 181
Joined: Jul 2020
Reputation:
27
(11-01-2021, 10:39 AM)ferencpuskas Wrote: Christ ! he's had more Clubs than Jack Nicklaus, and he's played for 70 years 
He's been to some backwaters sure enough. Jerez Industrial? Sounds more like a Quango than a football club. Still, life experiences and all that.
Posts: 974
Threads: 11
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
2
11-01-2021, 11:29 AM
(This post was last modified: 11-01-2021, 11:30 AM by Lillwall's left foot.)
(11-01-2021, 10:35 AM)Hopalong Wrote: (11-01-2021, 10:04 AM)Lillwall's left foot Wrote: (11-01-2021, 09:28 AM)MrFizz Wrote: (11-01-2021, 09:12 AM)Lillwall's left foot Wrote: First viewing I thought he'd be ok. A trier, a scrapper and a good old shithouser. Expected his movement, touch and hold up play to improve as he got match sharp. Problem is that it hasn't! Add to the fact that he doesn't even look like getting on the end of the crosses that Townsend whips in and we've got a problem as this role is pivotal to proper Valball being successful.
As has been said he would be fine as a back up number 9. Let's hope that's the role he has after Crimbo. Not holding my breath in that one though.
Well he got on the end of at least 2 crosses against Brizzle. Scored with one and missed scoring a second by an inch. Don't get me wrong, Hugill aint no Mitrovic, but he aint no Paul Williams/Stewart Evans/Winston White/Tony Rees either. But as he seems to be Scrapgoat of the month i suppose reasoned arguments for and against are a waste of time.....
On reflection my post probably came across more scrapgoat than intended. Indeed it was a nice finish against Brizzle at the end of a lovely passing move and he could have had a hat trick on another day. He looks a decent chump level trier and we have had much worse. I can still see him having a run of goals at some point with the right service.
My point is that he's just not provided either the hold up play or goal threat that Val requires from a number 9 which is a pivotal role in this set up. I've seen those longer direct balls bounce off and away from him on regular occasion and although a scrapper he doesn't dominate more physical defenders. Neither have I seem him show the kind of movement and instinct in the box to be a threat on those crosses, not always accurate it has to be said, that Townsend or Furlong put in.
To get both qualities can be very expensive (the leagues aren't brimming with Tonney's) but at the moment Hugill is not quite providing either. And yes, there are other players who deserve equal attention but they all have replacements. It is not the fault of Hugil that he is currently the only option we have to play that role.
I still hope that the management team can find a way of getting Hugill on top of his game and more effective for us, but regardless we need another front man to share the load. Unfortunately we do have one, who cost £8 million and is doing very little for his £1 million a year salary. Comparatively Hugill is giving good value!!
I believe the initial Zohore fee was £4m guaranteed over 4 yrs (£1m a yr) with further add-ons up to £8m in total which are unlikely to ever be realised, so not 'as bad' as it's made out.
Just the £4 million  that's ok then. So under a million per goal after all.....bargain.
Posts: 8,002
Threads: 188
Joined: Jul 2019
Reputation:
37
(11-01-2021, 10:26 AM)MrFizz Wrote: (11-01-2021, 10:04 AM)Lillwall's left foot Wrote: (11-01-2021, 09:28 AM)MrFizz Wrote: (11-01-2021, 09:12 AM)Lillwall's left foot Wrote: First viewing I thought he'd be ok. A trier, a scrapper and a good old shithouser. Expected his movement, touch and hold up play to improve as he got match sharp. Problem is that it hasn't! Add to the fact that he doesn't even look like getting on the end of the crosses that Townsend whips in and we've got a problem as this role is pivotal to proper Valball being successful.
As has been said he would be fine as a back up number 9. Let's hope that's the role he has after Crimbo. Not holding my breath in that one though.
Well he got on the end of at least 2 crosses against Brizzle. Scored with one and missed scoring a second by an inch. Don't get me wrong, Hugill aint no Mitrovic, but he aint no Paul Williams/Stewart Evans/Winston White/Tony Rees either. But as he seems to be Scrapgoat of the month i suppose reasoned arguments for and against are a waste of time.....
On reflection my post probably came across more scrapgoat than intended. Indeed it was a nice finish against Brizzle at the end of a lovely passing move and he could have had a hat trick on another day. He looks a decent chump level trier and we have had much worse. I can still see him having a run of goals at some point with the right service.
My point is that he's just not provided either the hold up play or goal threat that Val requires from a number 9 which is a pivotal role in this set up. I've seen those longer direct balls bounce off and away from him on regular occasion and although a scrapper he doesn't dominate more physical defenders. Neither have I seem him show the kind of movement and instinct in the box to be a threat on those crosses, not always accurate it has to be said, that Townsend or Furlong put in.
To get both qualities can be very expensive (the leagues aren't brimming with Tonney's) but at the moment Hugill is not quite providing either. And yes, there are other players who deserve equal attention but they all have replacements. It is not the fault of Hugil that he is currently the only option we have to play that role.
I still hope that the management team can find a way of getting Hugill on top of his game and more effective for us, but regardless we need another front man to share the load. Unfortunately we do have one, who cost £8 million and is doing very little for his £1 million a year salary. Comparatively Hugill is giving good value!!
I agree that he seems to fall in between 'scrapper target man' and 'poacher'. He doesnt excel at either. But as with a lot of forwards they're only as good as the service they get. IMO Phillips/Robbo/Grady have done worse than Hugill over the last month or so. One thing he's not going to do is go get the ball himself, he has to be fed. 7 touches in the first half, one of which was in our box, suggests it was the supply that was the issue.
Said earlier, no point picking him and not playing to his strength (deliberately singular)
Posts: 13,261
Threads: 468
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
45
I actually think signing Hugill has hurt us. Our most successful front three this season was easily Grant, Diangana and Robinson, with Phillips able to play the Diangana role. This relationship had been developing well, and then bringing in Hugill gave us the illusion of having an equally good alternative option. It destroyed the momentum.
In reality, Hugill should only be used as a backup, if three of the four above are fit then they should be playing.
In January we should get someone competent in, but it's not going to happen. We might as well flip a coin now regarding promotion, I don't think we'll finish below 6th but we also won't be top 2. Playoffs is a lottery
|