Leonardo Cardoso
#11
(10-28-2021, 04:22 PM)BurleyBaggie Wrote: It’s coming to the point where the Brentford model seems far more appealing. If you look at what they do, data driven recruitment of players specifically those released by other clubs academies, lower league and foreign players - pound for pound it’s a better bet.

Agree 100%

I honestly don't get why clubs our size bother even trying to run an academy. Until the loopholes over the poaching of young players are changed to a substantially higher compensation fee % for the selling club there really isnt much point. There has to be a detterant to make them think twice before taking these kids. If they see a 14 year old and knew that it was a flat fee of £2m (or whatever) to get them they might well let that player stay with his club and see how he develops before coming back in. 

If the best players are always going to be taken for a pittance then I really do believe the Brentford model is the way to go.

As long as the big 6 in the uk are allowed to grab players for pocket change and stockpile them they will continue to do it.

The whole thing needs a total root and branch reform now. 95% of the time these kids never end up better off in their careers.
Reply
#12
(10-28-2021, 05:29 PM)Peachy Wrote:
(10-28-2021, 04:22 PM)BurleyBaggie Wrote: It’s coming to the point where the Brentford model seems far more appealing. If you look at what they do, data driven recruitment of players specifically those released by other clubs academies, lower league and foreign players - pound for pound it’s a better bet.

Agree 100%

I honestly don't get why clubs our size bother even trying to run an academy. Until the loopholes over the poaching of young players are changed to a substantially higher compensation fee % for the selling club there really isnt much point. There has to be a detterant to make them think twice before taking these kids. If they see a 14 year old and knew that it was a flat fee of £2m (or whatever) to get them they might well let that player stay with his club and see how he develops before coming back in. 

If the best players are always going to be taken for a pittance then I really do believe the Brentford model is the way to go.

As long as the big 6 in the uk are allowed to grab players for pocket change and stockpile them they will continue to do it.

The whole thing needs a total root and branch reform now. 95% of the time these kids never end up better off in their careers.

The purpose of the Elite Plan was to get the best prospects into the best facilities to generate the best players, and I imagine the FA will claim the performance of English youth sides, now the National side, and our teams in Europe suggests it has worked - even if it does piss on the likes of us.

The ONE rule that needs to be introduced is that Cat 1 academies cannot poach from other Cat 1 academies.
Reply
#13
(10-28-2021, 07:02 PM)SW4Baggie Wrote:
(10-28-2021, 05:29 PM)Peachy Wrote:
(10-28-2021, 04:22 PM)BurleyBaggie Wrote: It’s coming to the point where the Brentford model seems far more appealing. If you look at what they do, data driven recruitment of players specifically those released by other clubs academies, lower league and foreign players - pound for pound it’s a better bet.

Agree 100%

I honestly don't get why clubs our size bother even trying to run an academy. Until the loopholes over the poaching of young players are changed to a substantially higher compensation fee % for the selling club there really isnt much point. There has to be a detterant to make them think twice before taking these kids. If they see a 14 year old and knew that it was a flat fee of £2m (or whatever) to get them they might well let that player stay with his club and see how he develops before coming back in. 

If the best players are always going to be taken for a pittance then I really do believe the Brentford model is the way to go.

As long as the big 6 in the uk are allowed to grab players for pocket change and stockpile them they will continue to do it.

The whole thing needs a total root and branch reform now. 95% of the time these kids never end up better off in their careers.

The purpose of the Elite Plan was to get the best prospects into the best facilities to generate the best players, and I imagine the FA will claim the performance of English youth sides, now the National side, and our teams in Europe suggests it has worked - even if it does piss on the likes of us.

The ONE rule that needs to be introduced is that Cat 1 academies cannot poach from other Cat 1 academies.

Or Cat1 to Cat1 moves come with a 50% sell-on, or if they are released on a free then £200k for every year they were in their original academy.
Reply
#14
(10-28-2021, 12:16 PM)Cuzer Wrote: Another one to add to the list

Don't know much about him personally only I was told a while ago he's off the scale for his age and being courted by Barca, PSG, Dortmund etc, on the wires today Chelsea are trying to sign him

Needless to say I don't think he'll be signing those pro forms with us Huh 

Cuzer

Can’t sign a pro deal until he turns 17 which will be in May. Of course, we can’t stop others offering him one too but whilst he’s with us the ball is in our court to try to not let him slip the net.
Reply
#15
(10-28-2021, 05:29 PM)Peachy Wrote:
(10-28-2021, 04:22 PM)BurleyBaggie Wrote: It’s coming to the point where the Brentford model seems far more appealing. If you look at what they do, data driven recruitment of players specifically those released by other clubs academies, lower league and foreign players - pound for pound it’s a better bet.

Agree 100%

I honestly don't get why clubs our size bother even trying to run an academy. Until the loopholes over the poaching of young players are changed to a substantially higher compensation fee % for the selling club there really isnt much point. There has to be a detterant to make them think twice before taking these kids. If they see a 14 year old and knew that it was a flat fee of £2m (or whatever) to get them they might well let that player stay with his club and see how he develops before coming back in. 

If the best players are always going to be taken for a pittance then I really do believe the Brentford model is the way to go.

As long as the big 6 in the uk are allowed to grab players for pocket change and stockpile them they will continue to do it.

The whole thing needs a total root and branch reform now. 95% of the time these kids never end up better off in their careers.

I agree totally, but if every club adopts the Brentford model, then there is nowhere for these kids to be delivered and poached. 

It needs proper compensation. The big clubs will still pay compo if they are forced to (unless it's Barcelona).
Reply
#16
(10-28-2021, 08:29 PM)Kit Kat Chunky Wrote:
(10-28-2021, 05:29 PM)Peachy Wrote:
(10-28-2021, 04:22 PM)BurleyBaggie Wrote: It’s coming to the point where the Brentford model seems far more appealing. If you look at what they do, data driven recruitment of players specifically those released by other clubs academies, lower league and foreign players - pound for pound it’s a better bet.

Agree 100%

I honestly don't get why clubs our size bother even trying to run an academy. Until the loopholes over the poaching of young players are changed to a substantially higher compensation fee % for the selling club there really isnt much point. There has to be a detterant to make them think twice before taking these kids. If they see a 14 year old and knew that it was a flat fee of £2m (or whatever) to get them they might well let that player stay with his club and see how he develops before coming back in. 

If the best players are always going to be taken for a pittance then I really do believe the Brentford model is the way to go.

As long as the big 6 in the uk are allowed to grab players for pocket change and stockpile them they will continue to do it.

The whole thing needs a total root and branch reform now. 95% of the time these kids never end up better off in their careers.

I agree totally, but if every club adopts the Brentford model, then there is nowhere for these kids to be delivered and poached. 

It needs proper compensation. The big clubs will still pay compo if they are forced to (unless it's Barcelona).

I get that and I do agree. We have worked bloody hard to get a CAT A academy. I can see if a kid leaves a lower league club to move to a Cat A club then he's furthering his career by moving to a club with better facilities. But the category system is there for a reason and we have the same level academy as the top sides in the Prem and regularly beat them in all age groups.

So a player leaving Albion for a top 6 Cat A club is going because they are offering him and his family more money. 

The pathway to first team football (despite our terrible record over recent decades of promoting youth) is just as hard if not harder at these big clubs. These kids are moving for money plain and simple and in some respects I really dont have a problem with that. However seeing that they are moving for money then surely Albion should be compensated too as well as the player. 

A system needs to be put in place where different Catagory academies should have their own set fee's imo. If a Cat A young un moves to another Cat A then that should be the highest fee simply because its obvious, or should be to the FA, that that player is moving for purely monetary gain. The FA cannot turn around and argue that because they set the Catagory system. 

So a set fee of £1m for any player signed under the age of 15. £1.5m for age 15-17 and £2m for 17-18 before they can sign a contract (like Cleary at the moment for example). On top of this a minimum sell on fee of 30% is inserted in all transfers. 

Setting these fees means other Cat A clubs get proper money for their nurturing of the player for 8/10 years. It will also focus the buying club into really thinking about who they invest in. 

The fee's and structures haven't changed at all in the last 10 years at least and its just too easy at the moment for big clubs to do what the fuck they like as its just pocket change. 

The only caveat to all the above is clubs can be allowed to negotiate between themselves sensibly to agree a sensible fee ala Morgan Rodgers to Man City. All sides were happy so thats fine. 

It has to be looked at imo......
Reply
#17
(10-28-2021, 04:22 PM)BurleyBaggie Wrote: It’s coming to the point where the Brentford model seems far more appealing. If you look at what they do, data driven recruitment of players specifically those released by other clubs academies, lower league and foreign players - pound for pound it’s a better bet.

You are baldy and I claim my £5


Joking aside I totally agree and JP was right. what’s the point of the academy?
Reply
#18
Imagine the shit that Bellingham City would be in without the Jude dosh...
Reply
#19
Remind me again of how much we got for Barry ?
Reply
#20
I love these freds, as I can't remember one of the ones ever mentioned actually going on to do anything.

Even the great hope Rogers has yet to achieve anything and doesn't even regularly start for Bournemouth, but at least we got decent dosh for him. The others, nope not a thing.
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: