Posts: 10,272
Threads: 694
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
32
(10-27-2021, 12:32 PM)MassDebater Wrote: (10-27-2021, 12:03 PM)cornishbaggie Wrote: https://www.hitc.com/en-gb/2021/10/20/ob...-radiator/
I learn something new everyday, I am Cisgender and was " assigned " my gender at birth. 
FFS surely stopping someone doing their job based on their gender is fecking sexist (genderist?) Scared because a man was fixing a radiator, FFS get a grip you twats.
(10-27-2021, 12:10 PM)Sotv Wrote: Thing is, I bet the majority of trans people are not that bothered. It’s a vocal minority who have styled themselves as spokespeople for trans people and now get reported as “THE trans community”
Aint that usually the way with such things? I'd say chop their cocks off, but they'd like that! 
You can sort out my radiators then Cornish?
I’m cisgender but hopeless with plumbing issues, but the plumbing the divine creator gave me works for the purpose it was designed.
Posts: 13,256
Threads: 468
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
45
(10-27-2021, 12:10 PM)Sotv Wrote: Thing is, I bet the majority of trans people are not that bothered. It’s a vocal minority who have styled themselves as spokespeople for trans people and now get reported as “THE trans community”
Absolutely. It's usually not even people who are part of that community. Just some people who want to feel good about themselves shoving their noses in where it's not needed.
Posts: 8,841
Threads: 315
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
78
(10-27-2021, 10:49 AM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: (10-27-2021, 10:08 AM)ChamonixBaggie Wrote: Like a lot of things its a storm in a teacup that's been turned into an issue by professional outrage merchants. It's not a left vs right issue as they're both playing the same game. Some rags get their clicks by calling everyone a nazi bigot and the opposite rags get their clicks by saying the trannies are coming for your children. Anyone with a couple of braincells to rub together can work out neither are true.
Bes policy is to ignore it. I've worked with some transgender/non-binary people and I think their gender/sexuality came up in conversation about 1% of the time. I call them by whatever pronoun they like if it makes them comfortable as its no skin off my nose.
Quite
It matters to the women who cannot access a domestic violence shelter without sharing it with males.
It matters to the girls who are too scared to use the toilets at school because toilet have been made single sex.
It matters to the women who were imprisoned with a male sex offender and subsequently sexually assaulted.
It matters to the women and girls who are denied scholarships and sporting victories because they have to compete with males.
It matters when health services are too scared to use the word "women" so use confusing language like "people with cervixes" when 50% of women don't actually know what a cervix is. Note that Prostate cancer charities still use the world "men"
Btw, here's a link with what JK Rowling said and the response she received and tell me who the hateful person is:
https://medium.com/@rebeccarc/j-k-rowlin...8e01dca68d
Posts: 4,043
Threads: 149
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
10
(10-27-2021, 09:15 PM)Squid Wrote: (10-27-2021, 10:49 AM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: (10-27-2021, 10:08 AM)ChamonixBaggie Wrote: Like a lot of things its a storm in a teacup that's been turned into an issue by professional outrage merchants. It's not a left vs right issue as they're both playing the same game. Some rags get their clicks by calling everyone a nazi bigot and the opposite rags get their clicks by saying the trannies are coming for your children. Anyone with a couple of braincells to rub together can work out neither are true.
Bes policy is to ignore it. I've worked with some transgender/non-binary people and I think their gender/sexuality came up in conversation about 1% of the time. I call them by whatever pronoun they like if it makes them comfortable as its no skin off my nose.
Quite
It matters to the women who cannot access a domestic violence shelter without sharing it with males.
It matters to the girls who are too scared to use the toilets at school because toilet have been made single sex.
It matters to the women who were imprisoned with a male sex offender and subsequently sexually assaulted.
It matters to the women and girls who are denied scholarships and sporting victories because they have to compete with males.
It matters when health services are too scared to use the word "women" so use confusing language like "people with cervixes" when 50% of women don't actually know what a cervix is. Note that Prostate cancer charities still use the world "men"
Btw, here's a link with what JK Rowling said and the response she received and tell me who the hateful person is:
https://medium.com/@rebeccarc/j-k-rowlin...8e01dca68d
I'm utterly confused and I'm accused of being "right on" - which side are you on? Or should one be on? As for the Twatterati - avoid it. It's a cesspit as confirmed by the abuse (still not sure what the hell is going on).
Posts: 10,272
Threads: 694
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
32
10-28-2021, 04:43 AM
(This post was last modified: 10-28-2021, 05:12 AM by Spandaubaggie.)
(10-27-2021, 11:12 AM)MassDebater Wrote: I've just looked up what he said, and well I guess I'm going to get cancelled soon too.
Gender is a fact. All of us were born from a woman. LGBTQ+ are overly sensitive. And he doesn't want a woman with a cock peeing next to him.
I agree with the first 2, partially with the third, and am not bothered by the last as I don't look at who is next to me when peeing, other than maybe a perfunctory glance to establish I'm not going to get mugged if in some dodgy place sort of thing.
So basically if you agree with the above you are now a TERF (“trans-exclusionary radical feminist”). So the Trans community is name calling those who hold different views and well it's all fuggin' stupid.
**meant to add - I've no idea how any of that makes it into an alleged stand up show though...**
**Oh and the Trans community apparently believe his comments are encouraging people to kill trans people, that's some fecking jump! ** The issue that rattles the cages of so many is the way it seems that if someone says the slightest thing today, views that aren’t controversial to the huge majority of people, they still face backlashes by a tiny minority, who seem capable of wielding extraordinary power to negativity affect their life/income.
I find what JK Rowling said as being pretty ordinary stuff. However, the abuse she’s got and the effect on her reputation and the willingness of organisations to align themselves with her has been utterly disproportionate.
As the playwright Tom Stoppard said recently it means we live in an atmosphere of self cancellation.
An example of the broader effect on freedom is my mate, who is in his 30s, is training to be a psychologist and in the class there’s a mix of different characters of ethnic backgrounds etc. He was asked about his view on racism in the class last week in a tutor led question. He told me his overriding mindset then was blind panic that he could say the wrong thing and did his utmost to get the question over and done with by saying as little as possible.
This thing with the transgender crowd, whoever they are, the angry ones that is, epitomises it.
My view on people who have sex changes is incredibly limited. I find it bizarre that someone should be in such a situation that they want to get a knife etc and surgically remove their bits they are born with.
I really struggle with the thoughts someone would want to do this.
However, I respect that person for being human and clearly massively troubled to go down a route that is so rare and life altering.
There are many groups I really don’t understand, get their viewpoint, and we all feel the same, but the step from misunderstanding, holding different viewpoints to etc, to hate is a chasm yet a handful of anonymous scream this every time they hear views they don’t like.
The ones stoking up such issues are incredibly intolerant themselves and vengeful, often against people broadly on their side. It’s a very worrying and unhealthy situation for the development of society and freedom of speech.
By the way this and the lesbian thread are morphing into one in many ways.
Posts: 13,407
Threads: 402
Joined: Jul 2019
Reputation:
14
(10-28-2021, 04:43 AM)Spandaubaggie Wrote: (10-27-2021, 11:12 AM)MassDebater Wrote: I've just looked up what he said, and well I guess I'm going to get cancelled soon too.
Gender is a fact. All of us were born from a woman. LGBTQ+ are overly sensitive. And he doesn't want a woman with a cock peeing next to him.
I agree with the first 2, partially with the third, and am not bothered by the last as I don't look at who is next to me when peeing, other than maybe a perfunctory glance to establish I'm not going to get mugged if in some dodgy place sort of thing.
So basically if you agree with the above you are now a TERF (“trans-exclusionary radical feminist”). So the Trans community is name calling those who hold different views and well it's all fuggin' stupid.
**meant to add - I've no idea how any of that makes it into an alleged stand up show though...**
**Oh and the Trans community apparently believe his comments are encouraging people to kill trans people, that's some fecking jump! ** The issue that rattles the cages of so many is the way it seems that if someone says the slightest thing today, views that aren’t controversial to the huge majority of people, they still face backlashes by a tiny minority, who seem capable of wielding extraordinary power to negativity affect their life/income.
I find what JK Rowling said as being pretty ordinary stuff. However, the abuse she’s got and the effect on her reputation and the willingness of organisations to align themselves with her has been utterly disproportionate.
As the playwright Tom Stoppard said recently it means we live in an atmosphere of self cancellation.
An example of the broader effect on freedom is my mate, who is in his 30s, is training to be a psychologist and in the class there’s a mix of different characters of ethnic backgrounds etc. He was asked about his view on racism in the class last week in a tutor led question. He told me his overriding mindset then was blind panic that he could say the wrong thing and did his utmost to get the question over and done with by saying as little as possible.
This thing with the transgender crowd, whoever they are, the angry ones that is, epitomises it.
My view on people who have sex changes is incredibly limited. I find it bizarre that someone should be in such a situation that they want to get a knife etc and surgically remove their bits they are born with.
I really struggle with the thoughts someone would want to do this.
However, I respect that person for being human and clearly massively troubled to go down a route that is so rare and life altering.
There are many groups I really don’t understand, get their viewpoint, and we all feel the same, but the step from misunderstanding, holding different viewpoints to etc, to hate is a chasm yet a handful of anonymous scream this every time they hear views they don’t like.
The ones stoking up such issues are incredibly intolerant themselves and vengeful, often against people broadly on their side. It’s a very worrying and unhealthy situation for the development of society and freedom of speech.
By the way this and the lesbian thread are morphing into one in many ways.
I think we see it in a very similar manner. And yes the Lesbian one and this cover different ends of the same spectrum. Like you I'm a live and let live kind of person, if you're not fecking someone else up then it's up to you what you do. I'll probably never understand why it happens, as I've always been very fond of my bits and any harm to them is monumental to me!
I feel for your mate in that class, that's a question that nobody who is not black seems to be allowed to answer with any clarity these days, and the fear of giving incorrect answers is a form of abuse aimed at those seen as the perpetrators of racism, as it seems only the whites can be defined as racist, which is utter bollix as we've all discussed on here before.
Also, I agree with what Squid said, however all of that comes into the choices of some and their current power to distort the context (I like that phrase, I think I might use it more) of the World's reality shows the power again of the minority.
Posts: 13,568
Threads: 492
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
40
(10-27-2021, 09:15 PM)Squid Wrote: It matters when health services are too scared to use the word "women" so use confusing language like "people with cervixes" when 50% of women don't actually know what a cervix is. Note that Prostate cancer charities still use the world "men"
You're not referring to the tweet that was aimed at people who have a cervix but aren't on the register for regular screening so need to actively be encouraged by external sources to get a smear test, are you? I'll let you guess the composition of those who have cervix and aren't on the register for smear tests. Hint: trans men over the age of 25 in this country usually have cervixes as hysterectomies weren't offered on the NHS until recently for transition, but they are taken off the register by the NHS to be contacted for smear tests.
Posts: 8,841
Threads: 315
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
78
(10-28-2021, 07:35 AM)Borin' Baggie Wrote: (10-27-2021, 09:15 PM)Squid Wrote: It matters when health services are too scared to use the word "women" so use confusing language like "people with cervixes" when 50% of women don't actually know what a cervix is. Note that Prostate cancer charities still use the world "men"
You're not referring to the tweet that was aimed at people who have a cervix but aren't on the register for regular screening so need to actively be encouraged by external sources to get a smear test, are you? I'll let you guess the composition of those who have cervix and aren't on the register for smear tests. Hint: trans men over the age of 25 in this country usually have cervixes as hysterectomies weren't offered on the NHS until recently for transition, but they are taken off the register by the NHS to be contacted for smear tests.
"People with cervixes" has been used far more widely than one tweet.
The Lancet saw fit to use the even more dehumanising "Bodies with vaginas" on their front cover recently. Apparently this was them being "inclusive".
Do not even try to defend the use of that kind of terminology. It is bad enough living in a world with sexual predators who view women solely as walking holes, without a medical journal using similar words.
What you are discussing with regards to trans men is a failure of the NHS date collection, which currently allows people to change their sex marker on their NHS records. While well-intentioned is potentially very dangerous, as it means trans people can miss out on the healthcare they actually need, as in the case of this trans man who was pregnant and had a still born baby, due to staff not realising they were in labour until it was too late:
https://www.usatoday.com/story/news/heal...692201002/
The solution to this issue is to add a category to medical records which captures gender transition, so that people are invited to the screening services their body requires.
The solution is not make health care information harder to understand for 50% of the population, especially women with learning disabilities or limited English skills.
Posts: 13,568
Threads: 492
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
40
10-28-2021, 10:20 AM
(This post was last modified: 10-28-2021, 10:27 AM by Borin' Baggie.)
(10-28-2021, 10:00 AM)Squid Wrote: (10-28-2021, 07:35 AM)Borin' Baggie Wrote: (10-27-2021, 09:15 PM)Squid Wrote: It matters when health services are too scared to use the word "women" so use confusing language like "people with cervixes" when 50% of women don't actually know what a cervix is. Note that Prostate cancer charities still use the world "men"
You're not referring to the tweet that was aimed at people who have a cervix but aren't on the register for regular screening so need to actively be encouraged by external sources to get a smear test, are you? I'll let you guess the composition of those who have cervix and aren't on the register for smear tests. Hint: trans men over the age of 25 in this country usually have cervixes as hysterectomies weren't offered on the NHS until recently for transition, but they are taken off the register by the NHS to be contacted for smear tests.
"People with cervixes" has been used far more widely than one tweet.
The Lancet saw fit to use the even more dehumanising "Bodies with vaginas" on their front cover recently. Apparently this was them being "inclusive".
That one tweet was what was caught up by a sitting MP, in turn missing the point of the tweet and diverting a drive for people not asked to get cervical screening automatically to get smear tested into a social wedge issue. And that MP instead of admitting their misinterpretation has doubled down and made a mountain out of a flat bit of land. You say it's one tweet, but it's a pretty big "one tweet" though it is an example of why social media, and Twitter especially", is shit.
As for the Lancet article, are you referring to this passage in this article?
"Historically, the anatomy and physiology of bodies with vaginas have been neglected—for example, the paucity in understanding of endometriosis and the way women's pain has been seen as more likely to have an emotional or psychological cause, a hangover from centuries of theorising about hysteria. This exhibition and the Vagina Museum as a whole aim to redress this lack of attention."
Did you read the article? It's an article on the stigmatisation women get for their own biology, the reference to "bodies with vaginas" is literally made in the same passage as the word women. It clearly isn't erasing or altering the terminology of the words women or woman, it wasn't chosen for inclusivity purposes as otherwise it wouldn't use the word women. It was using it in a medical context.
I highly suggest you read the article you're complaining about, it's pretty second wave feminist and I'd imagine you'd like it and agree with it.
And I agree that the NHS should move into the 21st century and be inclusive for trans people so it's less messy for people to use. I'm glad we're on the same page. Then maybe a lot of the fluff and misinformation being used as wedge issues will go away. Same with domestic violence shelters, I'm sure if they were actually properly funded so there's less competition for resources enabling better allocation of said resources for various factors then people would stop complaining.
Posts: 10,272
Threads: 694
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
32
(10-28-2021, 10:00 AM)Squid Wrote: (10-28-2021, 07:35 AM)Borin' Baggie Wrote: (10-27-2021, 09:15 PM)Squid Wrote: It matters when health services are too scared to use the word "women" so use confusing language like "people with cervixes" when 50% of women don't actually know what a cervix is. Note that Prostate cancer charities still use the world "men"
You're not referring to the tweet that was aimed at people who have a cervix but aren't on the register for regular screening so need to actively be encouraged by external sources to get a smear test, are you? I'll let you guess the composition of those who have cervix and aren't on the register for smear tests. Hint: trans men over the age of 25 in this country usually have cervixes as hysterectomies weren't offered on the NHS until recently for transition, but they are taken off the register by the NHS to be contacted for smear tests.
"People with cervixes" has been used far more widely than one tweet.
The Lancet saw fit to use the even more dehumanising "Bodies with vaginas" on their front cover recently. Apparently this was them being "inclusive".
Do not even try to defend the use of that kind of terminology. It is bad enough living in a world with sexual predators who view women solely as walking holes, without a medical journal using similar words.
What you are discussing with regards to trans men is a failure of the NHS date collection, which currently allows people to change their sex marker on their NHS records. While well-intentioned is potentially very dangerous, as it means trans people can miss out on the healthcare they actually need, as in the case of this trans man who was pregnant and had a still born baby, due to staff not realising they were in labour until it was too late:
https://www.usatoday.com/story/news/heal...692201002/
The solution to this issue is to add a category to medical records which captures gender transition, so that people are invited to the screening services their body requires.
The solution is not make health care information harder to understand for 50% of the population, especially women with learning disabilities or limited English skills.
Excellent incisive knowledge shared Squid. Whilst the understanding of this topic is one thing, and you know far more than me on this, I think the broader issue is why in an incredibly tolerant country where the parameters of discrimination have been watered down so much, showing how much we've enlightened, there is such an agenda for micro-minorities to get headlines time and time again, totally disproportionate to their numbers.
It's truly baffling times.
|