Terrible simply Terrible
#21
(10-20-2021, 09:15 PM)Birdman1811 Wrote: This defensive style is hard on Bartley. Just doesn't suit him.

Yep. He did pretty well under Allardyce where he could sit deep and do the basics. Under Moore (passing out from.the back) and Ismael (high line) he struggles
Reply
#22
Birdman1811 Wrote:This defensive style is hard on Bartley. Just doesn't suit him.

He's just bang average and generally ok with occasional slip ups.
Thought he contribute more set piece goals in this set up but, in general, our set pieces seem to have fallen off a cliff after such a great start.
Reply
#23
Interesting point on set pieces - against a side like Swansea you’d think set pieces would be huge for us - yet not only were they poor we also seemed to have no interest in using long throws when we had the chance
Reply
#24
(10-20-2021, 10:01 PM)dpb2002 Wrote: Interesting point on set pieces - against a side like Swansea you’d think set pieces would be huge for us - yet not only were they poor we also seemed to have no interest in using long throws when we had the chance

The last time we win there it was set pieces from Dawson and Hegazi that did it. Bartley in fairness unlucky not to score against Blues via a setpiece header. We're missing Dara O'Shea too.
Reply
#25
It seems the way these days that mangers pick a style, rock up and insist on playing it whether the players are able to or not.

This does no favours to Bartley who showed las season he can be a decent defender if played in the right set-up.

His lack of flexibility probably does indicate a lack of ability though.
Trump is a Cunt
Reply
#26
(10-20-2021, 09:19 PM)Sliced Wrote:
(10-20-2021, 09:15 PM)Birdman1811 Wrote: This defensive style is hard on Bartley. Just doesn't suit him.

I've heard that before for multiple previous managers. Honestly he's the least adaptable defender I've ever known. If you're that rigid in the way you play you're just not very good.

Not wrong. He's what he is, a decent no nonsense defender on a deep, well drilled line. He's not a good player himself.
Reply
#27
(10-20-2021, 10:49 PM)CA Baggie Wrote: It seems the way these days that mangers pick a style, rock up and insist on playing it whether the players are able to or not.

This does no favours to Bartley who showed las season he can be a decent defender if played in the right set-up.

His lack of flexibility probably does indicate a lack of ability though.

It works for a lot of managers. You just have to accept that it can take time and the club have to provide the resource to shape a squad that will suit the new system. It was a completely pointless hire if we're not willing to spend even a small amount of cash to bring in the players VI needs for this system. Despite what was said over the summer I don't believe for a second he is happy with our squad. If he is, he wants sectioning.

He's 13 games in, it took Bielsa two seasons to get his Leeds side out of this division and I don't remember him compromising on his ideals too much with that side.
Reply
#28
(10-21-2021, 07:59 AM)Ted Maul Wrote:
(10-20-2021, 10:49 PM)CA Baggie Wrote: It seems the way these days that mangers pick a style, rock up and insist on playing it whether the players are able to or not.

This does no favours to Bartley who showed las season he can be a decent defender if played in the right set-up.

His lack of flexibility probably does indicate a lack of ability though.

It works for a lot of managers. You just have to accept that it can take time and the club have to provide the resource to shape a squad that will suit the new system. It was a completely pointless hire if we're not willing to spend even a small amount of cash to bring in the players VI needs for this system. Despite what was said over the summer I don't believe for a second he is happy with our squad. If he is, he wants sectioning.

He's 13 games in, it took Bielsa two seasons to get his Leeds side out of this division and I don't remember him compromising on his ideals too much with that side.

Very good point that deserves a thread of its own, really.
"IMO of course..."
Reply
#29
(10-21-2021, 07:59 AM)Ted Maul Wrote:
(10-20-2021, 10:49 PM)CA Baggie Wrote: It seems the way these days that mangers pick a style, rock up and insist on playing it whether the players are able to or not.

This does no favours to Bartley who showed las season he can be a decent defender if played in the right set-up.

His lack of flexibility probably does indicate a lack of ability though.

It works for a lot of managers. You just have to accept that it can take time and the club have to provide the resource to shape a squad that will suit the new system. It was a completely pointless hire if we're not willing to spend even a small amount of cash to bring in the players VI needs for this system. Despite what was said over the summer I don't believe for a second he is happy with our squad. If he is, he wants sectioning.

He's 13 games in, it took Bielsa two seasons to get his Leeds side out of this division and I don't remember him compromising on his ideals too much with that side.
That's all well and good if you see some development and progress being made as I imagine Sheff U are with Jokanovic and Swansea with Martin. I personally only see backwards steps - decent corners becoming less threatening, the intense press becoming weaker by the game, players in form like Furlong slumping out of form.
Reply
#30
(10-21-2021, 07:59 AM)Ted Maul Wrote:
(10-20-2021, 10:49 PM)CA Baggie Wrote: It seems the way these days that mangers pick a style, rock up and insist on playing it whether the players are able to or not.

This does no favours to Bartley who showed las season he can be a decent defender if played in the right set-up.

His lack of flexibility probably does indicate a lack of ability though.

It works for a lot of managers. You just have to accept that it can take time and the club have to provide the resource to shape a squad that will suit the new system. It was a completely pointless hire if we're not willing to spend even a small amount of cash to bring in the players VI needs for this system. Despite what was said over the summer I don't believe for a second he is happy with our squad. If he is, he wants sectioning.

He's 13 games in, it took Bielsa two seasons to get his Leeds side out of this division and I don't remember him compromising on his ideals too much with that side.

I guess Leeds had adapted to being in the Chump, therefore he was allowed to do it, and he showed signs of it working. Whereas our entire club seems to be totally reliant on getting back up. I guess the main difference is that Leeds planned for their future, and we just think of the current season only? Christ knows how bad we'll end up if we don't go up this year.
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: