A club on a tightrope
#11
(03-09-2019, 09:24 PM)Pickle Rick Wrote:
(03-09-2019, 09:14 PM)albion_pigeon Wrote: Spot on Heath.

Me and my old man shared similar sentiments earlier that even when we've won this season we've very rarely been convinced.

I think when the attack clicked early in the season and we scored so many it looked promising - maybe too much fear of conceding - we tightened up but still conceded and scored less. And dropped down the table. Maybe the attacking and possession approach suited this squad better and maybe they aren't always the best when it comes to putting out a first eleven in this league. Gayle isn't firing now and Barnes has gone - relying on these two loanees so much tells its own story.

The attack only clicked due to Barnes IMO. As soon as he left the tactics needed to change to suit but BD/GJ didn't have a plan B.
Reply
#12
(03-09-2019, 09:24 PM)Pickle Rick Wrote:
(03-09-2019, 09:14 PM)albion_pigeon Wrote: Spot on Heath.

Me and my old man shared similar sentiments earlier that even when we've won this season we've very rarely been convinced.

I think when the attack clicked early in the season and we scored so many it looked promising - maybe too much fear of conceding - we tightened up but still conceded and scored less. And dropped down the table. Maybe the attacking and possession approach suited this squad better and maybe they aren't always the best when it comes to putting out a first eleven in this league. Gayle isn't firing now and Barnes has gone - relying on these two loanees so much tells its own story.


We started to not get results at home due to other managers working us out at home. Constantly trying to ask limited defenders to play the ball out from the back didn’t work. All season we have picked up results despite the performance like Forest, Blues, Villa home, Sheff Weds etc. It wasn’t like we had been playing great consistently. We had better players that got us out of jail like Barnes, Phillips etc.

It’s a very harsh decision but football is a very harsh career.
Reply
#13
Whole team is devoid of confidence at home.
Reply
#14
I was talking about what may happen if we do not go up, before the match and I said we could become the next Bolton (or, in hindsight, now Forest); if we stay down.
Reply
#15
Nailed it, short term thinking is what is ruining clubs. As a club we have loads of players on load, loads of old players that will be out of contract and young kids some of which have not signed a contract. We are fucked if we don't go up and if we do go up we are absolute certainties to go down. At least Moore gave us a man with absolute integrity and did bring the players together. Recent results and performances have been desperate but do you really slam the door in his face especially as we have some of our best players out injured. We might well still go up but i'm sure i'm feeling similar to others when you just look at the club and think its just a business and not a very well run one.
Reply
#16
(03-09-2019, 09:21 PM)Birdman1811 Wrote: Villa fans calling us fickle and deluded ffs.

Is this the same Villa fans that were calling for Smith's head until last weekend, because the job is too big for him??

Meanwhile 44,000 have voted in a Sky poll, and 91% say we were wrong. I think your poll Birdy, is probably a fairer reflection.
Reply
#17
Whilst I agree with much of what has been written on this thread one thing stands out for me. A number of posters have highlighted short term thinking as a major problem but at the same time have said we need to get promoted this season or we're fugged. Unfortunately this is the conundrum the top management are faced with. It's difficult if not impossible to plan long term but get instant success. I'm glad I don't run the club and have to make the decisions. 
Modern, money mad football I suppose.
Reply
#18
I think the post is good.

For me it will be the name of the new manager that will determine what realistically the top brass think is going to happen. There aren't many on the list who id have preferred over giving Moore much more time. Most are one season wonders who had the stars align much like the Norwich manager this year. I mean something like 12 points hauled in the last 5 mins of games.. can easily go the other way.

No doubt for me though is that if we do get someone who can put the pieces on the board correctly we've still an outstanding chance of winning 3 play off games against average fodder, however, that guy no doubt will have to deal with some players who will spit their dummy out over this whole episode and so he's probably screwed anyway.
Reply
#19
(03-09-2019, 09:03 PM)HeathAyIt Wrote: I didnt join in the thread the other week where people were proclaiming how much they were enjoying the season, as I've found it hard all season to summarise how I feel about the club and where we are at. Was hugely concerned when the poison that is Jenkins returned, and remain so, more so, and this has been a factor. But more than that even when we were banging in the goals and watching games packed with entertainment, I couldnt help but have an overriding fear about just how temporary and cobbled together the club is. This stems from the very top. A bloke who paid £200m but seems to have no real plan or interest. Who the fuck does that. Returning to Jenkins, who when he was left in charge more or less for a season under Peace presided over an absolute stench fest. Only an intervention from Peace himself averted total disaster. And a squad that I just really struggle to feel connected to. A mixture of loans, OAP's and wanted-to-leaves. For me, if we stay down we are fucked and if we go up we are fucked. The biggest benefit I can see from going up is the hope that Lai is more likely to be able to sell to someone with money and a plan.

Moore has definitely had ups and downs. There is a lot of naivety in much of what we have done and as much as I have stuck up for him, the criticisms of stuff on the pitch are often fair. I have felt all season long we have never once all season looked like the maximum sum of our parts. That said, he has been asked to work with one hand tied behind his back, and we suffered for the fact that our best player was able to be whisked off back to Leicester in Jan. Not really Moore's fault. But the reason I wouldve kept Moore is that for as long as the club is being run the way it is, the only long term and realistic way forward is to bring our youth through. Moore knows this system inside out and clearly has the respect and affection of the vital network of staff and up and coming players that underpin this. 

To my mind what we have now done is gamble the entire house on someone who has no time at all to get us promoted via a 4 team lottery in 2 months time. Aside from the fact that I think this is doomed to failure even if we do go up (the problems we face will just be a can kicked down the road), if we were going to do this then why the fuck not do it with enough time to gain automatic promotion - at least 10 games ago. As it stands, we are bringing someone in who not only has 13 games to get us promoted but would then either be likely to fuck off or have to do the most ridiculous re-assembly of a squad in human history, once again with one hand tied behind their back. Add to that the probability that some of our stronger youth players aren't going to know them from Adam and to me the whole thing is a recipe for disaster - whatever the outcome. I really hope I am wrong, but I just feel that there is going to be a very lengthy spell of turmoil in front of us now.

Succinct description of the situation.  Fugged if we do (go up) fugged if we don't.  This process was in the hands of an Albion man and now it's not.  Does it make a difference? To me, yes.  To the other 50%, no.

Last appointment made with a short term financial view (JP protecting sale value) turned out well for HIM in the short term but nearly killed the club in the longer, destroying our identity.

Does Lai give a flying fugg about the club's history and identity...no, he just wanted a brand to build on in China.  No Premier League, no brand.  But as 50% of our fans don't seem to care either maybe it's a good match.

Gutted. We are in a fragile position that somehow felt in safe hands long term, even if their was possibility of short term failure. Next appointment will tell us a lot.
Reply
#20
(03-09-2019, 09:20 PM)backsidebaggie Wrote:
(03-09-2019, 09:17 PM)KratosBaggie Wrote: What we have just done is not a gamble, it's a complete joke.

It's not a complete joke. You may disagree with sacking him, but the fact the poll above is so close to 50/50 show many don't. Moore was tactically not up to scratch, and we were getting worse. That's football.
A gamble implies that you can win something.
This is no gamble. It's chucking your chances away.
If you must sack your manager, at least have the brain to do it at the right time! Christmas or summer.
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: