Posts: 15,278
Threads: 273
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
57
(10-17-2021, 02:38 PM)Baggeridgebaggy Wrote: Club has to get promoted for the money. Sadly that’s the starting point
The alternative is the probable downward spiral of the club and its playing squad. Promotion means possible sale of the club and hopefully ability to buy better players. There is no happy medium of staying the Championship with this owner
If we have to sacrifice entertainment for promotion most would take that (I certainly would) but if results don’t follow there is a problem
I do really find the attitude of some posters on here arrogant in the extreme - who do they think they are ? Some don’t even attend matches but criticise & denigrate real fans (who actually attend games) for having a valid opinion
The football has been dreadful to watch at times. Opinion. To me no more shit than I've seen from any manager of ours, including Sir Bilic the great and fantastic, who Pep wants classes from in fantastic football. Honestly, looking at Twitter you'd think Bilic was next in line for the Man Utd job as some massive managerial coup for them the way people are going on about him still. Certainly no worse than post lockdown and January last season we were down here.
The manager is one dimensional and fixated with same formation, same subs, same tactics. Formation isn't actually as big as pundits and fans think, what matters is the style attached to it, Val has mentioned several times we need to work on our approach play. It's whether the players can do it, or capable of adapting during the game, without knowing what is being instructed I can't say.
Saying Fact after things, does not make opinions fact.
Posts: 4,261
Threads: 263
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
25
(10-17-2021, 02:38 PM)Baggeridgebaggy Wrote: Club has to get promoted for the money. Sadly that’s the starting point
The alternative is the probable downward spiral of the club and its playing squad. Promotion means possible sale of the club and hopefully ability to buy better players. There is no happy medium of staying the Championship with this owner
If we have to sacrifice entertainment for promotion most would take that (I certainly would) but if results don’t follow there is a problem
I do really find the attitude of some posters on here arrogant in the extreme - who do they think they are ? Some don’t even attend matches but criticise & denigrate real fans (who actually attend games) for having a valid opinion
The football has been dreadful to watch at times. Fact
The manager is one dimensional and fixated with same formation, same subs, same tactics. Fact
BB, you represent a growing faction on here, the "if you haven't been at the match you can't have an opinion" brigade. The "you haven't played the game at a high level, so you can't have an opinion" lot at least could claim to know more about the game than the rest of us. But those of us who watch from our armchairs have a better view than you, access to replays, multiple camera angles etc. All we are missing is the ambience, the attitude of the crowd, the chance to pick up on the vibe. We can't join in the baiting and abuse of our spacegoats, we can't boo our own side off at half time or jeer at substitutions. So yes, we clearly have no connection at all with the Albion and should just fuck off and watch rugby instead.
And by the way, I know who I am and I'm reasonably happy with it. Who do you think you are?
Posts: 8,841
Threads: 315
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
78
(10-17-2021, 02:26 PM)Dumbo Wrote: (10-17-2021, 01:46 PM)Squid Wrote: (10-17-2021, 10:40 AM)Cheshire East Baggie Wrote: It's happened, hasn't it? It's become an accepted FACT on here that Val isn't quite right, that it's OK so long as he keeps winning but he'll be gone as soon as the results turn against him. Why is he getting such bad press compared with some of our managerial appointments in recent decades? For example:
Underwhelming - Irvine, Smith, Buckley
Unpopular but necessary - Pulis
Plain wrong - Little, Gould, Pardew, Allardyce
I call it "second husband syndrome". You know when the charming and much loved son-in-law turns out to be a bit of a waster, a crook, and the happy family disintegrates in a sudden, surprising and shocking manner? The second husband can never get the same warm cosy appreciation - he's always paying the price of the first scoundrel's sins, his mother-in-law will always treat him with suspicion at best, if not downright hostility.* So is Val being punished for the fact that Slaven Bilic promised so much in the first half season, then collapsed into apparent incompetence? It went from great to pathetic in less than 12 months, it was spectacular.
* There may be an autobiographical element to this analogy - - -or not 
I wonder about this too. I think there are lots of factors.
Last time we were in the stadiums (West Ham match aside) we were in the midst of the Bilic-era, on course to be promoted. What happened in between then and now seems to have been memory-holed by a lot of fans. I think if fans had been at Crystal Palace at home, Fulham away, there may be been a different attitude to the Bilic and the need to sack him. There's also the fact that rightly or wrongly, Bilic was viewed as an "aspirational" choice of manager, which means he seems to have been adored from day one. So has CA Baggie says, he had a lot of goodwill in the bank, albeit not entirely fairly.
I am now going to make a very controversial statement. But I have to say this because it's troubling me and I feel like everyone is avoiding mentioning it.
A frequent criticism of VI is "No Plan B". Some fans apparently chanted "You don't know what you're doing" when Grady was subbed against QPR and that he basically lacks knowledge seems to be underlying criticism of him. It's clear that he won't be given the opportunities to make mistakes and put things right the way Bilic was.
Is this starting to ring any alarm bells for anyone yet?
That some of these attitudes may not be entirely generated by what we are seeing on the pitch but by the colour of the manager stood beside it?
I cannot be the only one to remember some of the criticisms of Darren Moore from the very early days of the seasons and the ferocity of them being completely out of kilter with what we were seeing on the pitch. It's just that a lot of criticism people used to make about having a black captain seems to have been transferred to having a black manager and that perturbs me deeply.
That’s a very deep, potentially damaging claim.
It is. I hesitated before writing it, but I'm watching another black manager getting called thick and clueless by (some) of our fans and thought it needed saying.
Despite the fact that Bilic clearly had no Plan B once the wheels fell off, couldn't see the team were unfit and that fitness was critical to our performance, nobody ever insulted his intelligence. Ditto Pardew Pulis. Despite their failings, nobody called Pardew and Pulis stupid either. Yet it seems to happen to Moore and Ismael and it's right to wonder why.
Posts: 4,043
Threads: 149
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
10
(10-17-2021, 03:36 PM)Squid Wrote: (10-17-2021, 02:26 PM)Dumbo Wrote: (10-17-2021, 01:46 PM)Squid Wrote: (10-17-2021, 10:40 AM)Cheshire East Baggie Wrote: It's happened, hasn't it? It's become an accepted FACT on here that Val isn't quite right, that it's OK so long as he keeps winning but he'll be gone as soon as the results turn against him. Why is he getting such bad press compared with some of our managerial appointments in recent decades? For example:
Underwhelming - Irvine, Smith, Buckley
Unpopular but necessary - Pulis
Plain wrong - Little, Gould, Pardew, Allardyce
I call it "second husband syndrome". You know when the charming and much loved son-in-law turns out to be a bit of a waster, a crook, and the happy family disintegrates in a sudden, surprising and shocking manner? The second husband can never get the same warm cosy appreciation - he's always paying the price of the first scoundrel's sins, his mother-in-law will always treat him with suspicion at best, if not downright hostility.* So is Val being punished for the fact that Slaven Bilic promised so much in the first half season, then collapsed into apparent incompetence? It went from great to pathetic in less than 12 months, it was spectacular.
* There may be an autobiographical element to this analogy - - -or not 
I wonder about this too. I think there are lots of factors.
Last time we were in the stadiums (West Ham match aside) we were in the midst of the Bilic-era, on course to be promoted. What happened in between then and now seems to have been memory-holed by a lot of fans. I think if fans had been at Crystal Palace at home, Fulham away, there may be been a different attitude to the Bilic and the need to sack him. There's also the fact that rightly or wrongly, Bilic was viewed as an "aspirational" choice of manager, which means he seems to have been adored from day one. So has CA Baggie says, he had a lot of goodwill in the bank, albeit not entirely fairly.
I am now going to make a very controversial statement. But I have to say this because it's troubling me and I feel like everyone is avoiding mentioning it.
A frequent criticism of VI is "No Plan B". Some fans apparently chanted "You don't know what you're doing" when Grady was subbed against QPR and that he basically lacks knowledge seems to be underlying criticism of him. It's clear that he won't be given the opportunities to make mistakes and put things right the way Bilic was.
Is this starting to ring any alarm bells for anyone yet?
That some of these attitudes may not be entirely generated by what we are seeing on the pitch but by the colour of the manager stood beside it?
I cannot be the only one to remember some of the criticisms of Darren Moore from the very early days of the seasons and the ferocity of them being completely out of kilter with what we were seeing on the pitch. It's just that a lot of criticism people used to make about having a black captain seems to have been transferred to having a black manager and that perturbs me deeply.
That’s a very deep, potentially damaging claim.
It is. I hesitated before writing it, but I'm watching another black manager getting called thick and clueless by (some) of our fans and thought it needed saying.
Despite the fact that Bilic clearly had no Plan B once the wheels fell off, couldn't see the team were unfit and that fitness was critical to our performance, nobody ever insulted his intelligence. Ditto Pardew Pulis. Despite their failings, nobody called Pardew and Pulis stupid either. Yet it seems to happen to Moore and Ismael and it's right to wonder why. Who on here ever called Darren Moore thick? Or Val?
Posts: 760
Threads: 71
Joined: Feb 2019
Reputation:
6
10-17-2021, 03:48 PM
(This post was last modified: 10-17-2021, 03:55 PM by Baggeridgebaggy.)
Bringing in race … how truly moronic,
How can anyone discuss, disagree argue about anything if idiots effectively play the race card?
And laughably some are accusing me and others of doing exactly what they’re doing …. suggesting those with a valid opinion are intellectually inferior and shouldn’t express a view ….. because they know better
Posts: 3,488
Threads: 101
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
5
(10-17-2021, 03:36 PM)Squid Wrote: (10-17-2021, 02:26 PM)Dumbo Wrote: (10-17-2021, 01:46 PM)Squid Wrote: (10-17-2021, 10:40 AM)Cheshire East Baggie Wrote: It's happened, hasn't it? It's become an accepted FACT on here that Val isn't quite right, that it's OK so long as he keeps winning but he'll be gone as soon as the results turn against him. Why is he getting such bad press compared with some of our managerial appointments in recent decades? For example:
Underwhelming - Irvine, Smith, Buckley
Unpopular but necessary - Pulis
Plain wrong - Little, Gould, Pardew, Allardyce
I call it "second husband syndrome". You know when the charming and much loved son-in-law turns out to be a bit of a waster, a crook, and the happy family disintegrates in a sudden, surprising and shocking manner? The second husband can never get the same warm cosy appreciation - he's always paying the price of the first scoundrel's sins, his mother-in-law will always treat him with suspicion at best, if not downright hostility.* So is Val being punished for the fact that Slaven Bilic promised so much in the first half season, then collapsed into apparent incompetence? It went from great to pathetic in less than 12 months, it was spectacular.
* There may be an autobiographical element to this analogy - - -or not 
I wonder about this too. I think there are lots of factors.
Last time we were in the stadiums (West Ham match aside) we were in the midst of the Bilic-era, on course to be promoted. What happened in between then and now seems to have been memory-holed by a lot of fans. I think if fans had been at Crystal Palace at home, Fulham away, there may be been a different attitude to the Bilic and the need to sack him. There's also the fact that rightly or wrongly, Bilic was viewed as an "aspirational" choice of manager, which means he seems to have been adored from day one. So has CA Baggie says, he had a lot of goodwill in the bank, albeit not entirely fairly.
I am now going to make a very controversial statement. But I have to say this because it's troubling me and I feel like everyone is avoiding mentioning it.
A frequent criticism of VI is "No Plan B". Some fans apparently chanted "You don't know what you're doing" when Grady was subbed against QPR and that he basically lacks knowledge seems to be underlying criticism of him. It's clear that he won't be given the opportunities to make mistakes and put things right the way Bilic was.
Is this starting to ring any alarm bells for anyone yet?
That some of these attitudes may not be entirely generated by what we are seeing on the pitch but by the colour of the manager stood beside it?
I cannot be the only one to remember some of the criticisms of Darren Moore from the very early days of the seasons and the ferocity of them being completely out of kilter with what we were seeing on the pitch. It's just that a lot of criticism people used to make about having a black captain seems to have been transferred to having a black manager and that perturbs me deeply.
That’s a very deep, potentially damaging claim.
It is. I hesitated before writing it, but I'm watching another black manager getting called thick and clueless by (some) of our fans and thought it needed saying.
Despite the fact that Bilic clearly had no Plan B once the wheels fell off, couldn't see the team were unfit and that fitness was critical to our performance, nobody ever insulted his intelligence. Ditto Pardew Pulis. Despite their failings, nobody called Pardew and Pulis stupid either. Yet it seems to happen to Moore and Ismael and it's right to wonder why.
I can’t recall that on this forum ?
I think you’ll find that the likes of Pulis and Pardew were called plenty of things !
Posts: 15,278
Threads: 273
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
57
Yeah I don't think race is part of it at all.
Posts: 4,733
Threads: 105
Joined: May 2019
Reputation:
3
Val comes off as intelligent so I don't see why anyone would call him thick. The style of football is always going to draw criticism.
Posts: 3,488
Threads: 101
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
5
10-17-2021, 04:10 PM
(This post was last modified: 10-17-2021, 04:15 PM by EastMidsBaggie.)
I think everyone who loves the club should have their say whether we agree or not or go to games or not.
Many can’t afford to attend or necessarily have other priorities.
However, I will add that it does grate a little when those that didn’t go give little leeway to those that have invested a lot of time and effort ( and petrol !) to be there and support the team. Saying that performances don’t matter is a bit insulting because they do BUT results are still the main thing.
I was there on Friday as usual and really was as bored as under most Pulis games until our goal.
The crowd was very subdued compared to the likes of the Sheff Utd, Luton even the Millwall game; even leaving the ground it was all very flat considering we had just won a local derby and gone back top.
So, we can only portray what we and many around us felt watching live. No body was very happy at half time as we discussed it I can tell you ! The standard of play was shocking from both sides.
(10-17-2021, 04:09 PM)Big Daddy Cool Wrote: Val comes off as intelligent so I don't see why anyone would call him thick. The style of football is always going to draw criticism.
Never heard anyone call him thick ?
I like the guy and think, given time and a bit more resource in January, the may yet to come as he, hopefully, tweaks the set up and style.
It is painful at times though…
Posts: 15,040
Threads: 339
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
93
Re Squid, I think you are way off in this instance. Historically, our more Route 1 managers have always had less goodwill in the bank. Even Megson (who fans of all ages adored), was criticized plenty for the lack of adventure. Whereas De Matteo and Ossie, along with Bilic, were rarely attacked for their many obvious shortcomings. Giles (admittedly after the mind numbing Don Howe), even commented on the patience shown by our support as he struggled initially to get the team winning.
|