NI Protocol
#1
Turns out the EU's original position - the NI Protocol is holy writ, implement it as was signed, no serious compromise or cherry-picking is possible - is renegotiable after all.

If the EU has dropped 80% of the restrictions between GB/NI you have to ask why they imposed them in the first place.

Reading the mental gymnastics of Remainers on Twitter praising the EU for adopting a position Remainers had previously praised the EU for insisting was impossible is quite breathtaking too.
Reply
#2
You would also ask why Frost and Johnson signed up to.

Business leaders and hauliers in the north of Ireland welcomed the EU deal so Frost now brings up the never before mentioned role of the ECJ.
Reply
#3
As I am a citizen of the UK not a citizen of a EU member state I don't really care why the EU signed the original agreement or why they are prepared to amend it now.

But I do care why the UK signed the agreement, given the negative impact it would have for NI or not has some commentators would have it.

It can only be that they failed to understand the full implications of the agreement they negotiated,  signed and lauded to the electorate as a huge success.

Or as Cummings and Paisley Jnr have intimated,  theynever intended to keep to the agreement. 

Either way it is not a good look for the Govt. Incompetence or being devious, you choose what you prefer.

That some are proclaiming this as some sort of success for the Government,  shows how far we have fallen from the ideal of good governance.
Reply
#4
There is no negative impact in NI. No empty shelves, no haulage problems, access to EU market.
Reply
#5
There is nothing for this government to be proud or smug about. Either they knew the deal wasn’t good enough, lied about how good it was, and knew all along they would rip it up after they got elected, on the basis of ‘getting Brexit dime’ or they negotiated an unworkable deal incompetently and then proclaimed it as great.
Reply
#6
I note with interest that no response so far has actually addressed the points I posted.
Reply
#7
You might note that the NI protocol isn't being renegotiated and the text will stay the same so the points you raise are, as ever, misleading.
Reply
#8
Jurisdiction and supremacy of EU law in Northern Ireland is the same, the EU went to and spoke to it's stakeholders in Northern Ireland about reducing checks to show flexibility to areas within its jurisdiction. Yet another example of the EU being flexible within its scope.

The goods that are imported into Northern Ireland still need to meet EU regulations, that hasn't changed.

And, as a correction, they've not dropped any restrictions. They've proposed the reduction of checks. The restrictions are the same. The checks between third countries and the customs territory were the same checks that the UK government supported both in terms of implementation as an EU member and approval within the scope of the NIP.

Though of course given you're so supportive of this proposal I'm sure you'll condemn the UK government when they reject it...
Reply
#9
Luckily that IT solution that Johnson promised can't be far off. Unless of course it was complete fantasy simply to win some votes.
Reply
#10
(10-15-2021, 07:52 AM)Protheroe Wrote: I note with interest that no response so far has actually addressed the points I posted.

On your post 

1  The EU did not impose these regulations on the UK.
They were part of an agreement reached between two negotiating parties. The Govt at the time the agreement was reached, claimed to be very happy with the outcome.

2 Your last paragraph seems to be a prime example of a need to continue the Brexit debate in terms of leaves and remainers,.
The debate is concluded, we have left the EU, and in my view we are very unlikely to ever re join  well certainly in my lifetime.

That said I dont think it is unreasonable to point out that there was a problem with the agreement in relation to how it dealt with NI. It's not hindsight, I and others made this point at the time it was concluded.

The Govt at the time lauded the deal, either they were too incompetent to note the obvious flaws in it, or they were aware but saw it as an expedient, and misled the British public as to its merits.
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: 1 Guest(s)