Overpaid Knee Jerkers vs Hungary
#21
(10-12-2021, 09:09 PM)Kit Kat Chunky Wrote:
(10-12-2021, 09:06 PM)Swagbaggie Wrote:
(10-12-2021, 08:41 PM)Lurker#3 Wrote: Really poor tonight.

Southgate quickly running out of credit with me.

Hes looking like a PR bloke being asked to manage the team.
I agree.
The team selection was lazy.
Man City players plus his favourites for whom form is seemingly irrelevant.
None of Sterling Kane and even Stones should have started.
They lacked structure and appeared to struggle - again - against a well organised team.
Of all the players to bring off, Grealish was not one of them. 
Neither Mount or Foden or any of the other players offered anything as dangerous.
Sterling and Kane, in fact, offered nothing.
This is a fantastic group of players.
They should not be wasted on Southgate IMO.
How many 90 mins has Sealprick completed all season? Are those shins a problem again?

I don't know the answer to that KKC but Girlish did not look 'understanding' about his substitution.
If it was about a possible injury or issue he was hiding it very well and if not it makes his substitution 'tactical' and that is even more ridiculous.
Reply
#22
A below par performance tonight. Our passing and crossing was inaccurate against a well drilled line of 5 across the back and spoiling tactics. We looked lethargic. Put it behind them and on to the next game.
Reply
#23
(10-12-2021, 08:41 PM)Lurker#3 Wrote: Really poor tonight.

Southgate quickly running out of credit with me.

Hes looking like a PR bloke being asked to manage the team.

Genuine question, what English manager would you prefer to Southgate?
Reply
#24
I think Southgate is the best man for the job. His record proves it and has done very well up to where we find ourselves today.

My one criticism though is that he tinkers too much and over thinks things. We have an explosive forward line and wide players and i think sometimes we just need to play to our strengths and not focus on the opposition. We have an embarrassment of riches in wide and creative roles imo.

It's hard to be too critical in qualifying as it's almost a formality but at the next tournament I'd like to see us fly into a few teams rather than play the two holders all the time. My guess is though that he will revert to type.
Reply
#25
(10-13-2021, 06:32 AM)Peachy Wrote: I think Southgate is the best man for the job. His record proves it and has done very well up to where we find ourselves today.

My one criticism though is that he tinkers too much and over thinks things. We have an explosive forward line and wide players and i think sometimes we just need to play to our strengths and not focus on the opposition. We have an embarrassment of riches in wide and creative roles imo.

It's hard to be too critical in qualifying as it's almost a formality but at the next tournament I'd like to see us fly into a few teams rather than play the two holders all the time. My guess is though that he will revert to type.

Can't agree with this.

The team looked unbalanced last night, not playing two more defensively minded players meant we never quite got control of midfield and were very susceptible to their counter attacks.

And it is not as if those so called defensively minded players are bad players with the ball at their feet.

And you have to ask yourself how many top club sides would play without at least 2 midfielders who can take care of the more defensive side of the game.
Reply
#26
(10-13-2021, 06:48 AM)Shabby Russian Wrote:
(10-13-2021, 06:32 AM)Peachy Wrote: I think Southgate is the best man for the job. His record proves it and has done very well up to where we find ourselves today.

My one criticism though is that he tinkers too much and over thinks things. We have an explosive forward line and wide players and i think sometimes we just need to play to our strengths and not focus on the opposition. We have an embarrassment of riches in wide and creative roles imo.

It's hard to be too critical in qualifying as it's almost a formality but at the next tournament I'd like to see us fly into a few teams rather than play the two holders all the time. My guess is though that he will revert to type.

Can't agree with this.

The team looked unbalanced last night, not playing two more defensively minded players meant we never quite got control of midfield and were very susceptible to their counter attacks.

And it is not as if those so called defensively minded players are bad players with the ball at their feet.

And you have to ask yourself how many top club sides would play without at least 2 midfielders who can take care of the more defensive side of the game.

+1. His in-game management is still second-rate.

It wasn't long before it was clear that the midfield was all at sea with the attacking midfielders not tracking or not really knowing what their job was. You could have switched Mount for Bellingham and still allowed the others pretty much free rein plus it would have potentially allowed Walker to overlap. Saka was poor when he came on but he had no options when the ball came to him. Grealish was never the player to bring off. The only thing I could say in Southgate's defence is that the regulars really didn't perform at all.
Reply
#27
I think this thread as a whole pretty much sums Gareth up.

He has done a great job of uniting the squad, engaging the fans, creating unity, bringing younger players through etc.

But his game management which at the end of the day is critical at international level, even more so than coaching ability, just isn't good enough. I think this will continue to let us down in big games at key moments, and as much as I like him, will be his undoing.
"IMO of course..."
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: 1 Guest(s)