Newcastle’s new owners...
On the back of yesterday‘s Newcastle news, it might be helpful to explain to fans of Premier League clubs why their counterparts in Germany don’t view the football world in the same way. Why being bankrolled is not the goal & why both leagues will remain different.

I was chatting to a Köln fan recently about this. For him, Köln is life - shared community, passion. He has a say in the club‘s direction along with other fans. In his words, if big wealth funds or equivalent, were to do as in England, he & others would go & watch Regionalliga.

PL club fans inevitably talk about Bayern‘s title wins. But to a Köln fan, this is irrelevant. Every season has its story. It could be (as often in the last 20 plus years) be about relegation & avoiding it. It could be in the 2. Liga or about Europe as in 2017/2018.

To feel it, you really need to attend a game in Germany. Every Köln match is special & - in normal times - a 50,000 sell out. It’s an occasion with friends, even though you may not know them all personally. Köln has fans worldwide but the club exists for the city & community.

German clubs make sure there is a ticket for everyone. Prices are kept in check, public transport in the local area is part of it. It beats the PL (in normal times) in terms of attendances. Again, you have to go, to really get it.

Dortmund CEO Hans-Joachim Watzke recently said German football will continue to go its own way - prices fans can afford, exciting, dynamic football for communities. The model is sustainable & popular. Fans don’t want their club to be the plaything of a sovereign wealth fund.

It would be hard to imagine Köln or Eintracht Frankfurt fans (both huge clubs who have had ups and downs) reacting to news of a takeover as Newcastle fans reacted. In fact, it would be a parallel universe. It wouldn’t and can’t happen.

If you love the PL, I understand. It has a glamourous air & is wonderful packaged & marketed. But that’s just one model. The Bundesliga has its own successful model & its beauty lies not just in who wins the Meisterschale. Visit some day & discover for yourself.
Reply
It should be added that no German club’s shares can be owned by any institution over 49%. 51% remain in the hands of supporters or supporters’ trusts. Known as the 50+1 rule. It ensures fans always have some say in the club’s future.
Reply
One of the best games I’ve ever been to was Nuremberg v Schalke. Every time they meet they have this concept of “Freundschaftsspiel” where essentially they have beer tents outside the ground and both sets of supporters get leathered before the game. OK, this isn’t the norm but it does lead to a cracking atmosphere.
Reply
Who will they spend the initial £190 million on?

https://www.shieldsgazette.com/sport/foo...ng-3413284
Reply
(10-09-2021, 07:12 AM)Dumbo Wrote: On the back of yesterday‘s Newcastle news, it might be helpful to explain to fans of Premier League clubs why their counterparts in Germany don’t view the football world in the same way. Why being bankrolled is not the goal & why both leagues will remain different.

I was chatting to a Köln fan recently about this. For him, Köln is life - shared community, passion. He has a say in the club‘s direction along with other fans. In his words, if big wealth funds or equivalent, were to do as in England, he & others would go & watch Regionalliga.

PL club fans inevitably talk about Bayern‘s title wins. But to a Köln fan, this is irrelevant. Every season has its story. It could be (as often in the last 20 plus years) be about relegation & avoiding it. It could be in the 2. Liga or about Europe as in 2017/2018.

To feel it, you really need to attend a game in Germany. Every Köln match is special & - in normal times - a 50,000 sell out. It’s an occasion with friends, even though you may not know them all personally. Köln has fans worldwide but the club exists for the city & community.

German clubs make sure there is a ticket for everyone. Prices are kept in check, public transport in the local area is part of it. It beats the PL (in normal times) in terms of attendances. Again, you have to go, to really get it.

Dortmund CEO Hans-Joachim Watzke recently said German football will continue to go its own way - prices fans can afford, exciting, dynamic football for communities. The model is sustainable & popular. Fans don’t want their club to be the plaything of a sovereign wealth fund.

It would be hard to imagine Köln or Eintracht Frankfurt fans (both huge clubs who have had ups and downs) reacting to news of a takeover as Newcastle fans reacted. In fact, it would be a parallel universe. It wouldn’t and can’t happen.

If you love the PL, I understand. It has a glamourous air & is wonderful packaged & marketed. But that’s just one model. The Bundesliga has its own successful model & its beauty lies not just in who wins the Meisterschale. Visit some day & discover for yourself.

Good post. Enjoyed reading that
Reply
(10-09-2021, 07:12 AM)Dumbo Wrote: On the back of yesterday‘s Newcastle news, it might be helpful to explain to fans of Premier League clubs why their counterparts in Germany don’t view the football world in the same way. Why being bankrolled is not the goal & why both leagues will remain different.

I was chatting to a Köln fan recently about this. For him, Köln is life - shared community, passion. He has a say in the club‘s direction along with other fans. In his words, if big wealth funds or equivalent, were to do as in England, he & others would go & watch Regionalliga.

PL club fans inevitably talk about Bayern‘s title wins. But to a Köln fan, this is irrelevant. Every season has its story. It could be (as often in the last 20 plus years) be about relegation & avoiding it. It could be in the 2. Liga or about Europe as in 2017/2018.

To feel it, you really need to attend a game in Germany. Every Köln match is special & - in normal times - a 50,000 sell out. It’s an occasion with friends, even though you may not know them all personally. Köln has fans worldwide but the club exists for the city & community.

German clubs make sure there is a ticket for everyone. Prices are kept in check, public transport in the local area is part of it. It beats the PL (in normal times) in terms of attendances. Again, you have to go, to really get it.

Dortmund CEO Hans-Joachim Watzke recently said German football will continue to go its own way - prices fans can afford, exciting, dynamic football for communities. The model is sustainable & popular. Fans don’t want their club to be the plaything of a sovereign wealth fund.

It would be hard to imagine Köln or Eintracht Frankfurt fans (both huge clubs who have had ups and downs) reacting to news of a takeover as Newcastle fans reacted. In fact, it would be a parallel universe. It wouldn’t and can’t happen.

If you love the PL, I understand. It has a glamourous air & is wonderful packaged & marketed. But that’s just one model. The Bundesliga has its own successful model & its beauty lies not just in who wins the Meisterschale. Visit some day & discover for yourself.
It is a great experience. I took in the Leverkusen v Leipzig game about 3 yrs ago as well as the Dusseldorf xmas market. Fabulous. Cracking game. Leipzig won 2-3 to go top ( the season after being promoted). Burke came on as a 2nd sub for Leipzig. .

(10-09-2021, 08:04 AM)baggiebloke Wrote: Who will they spend the initial £190 million on?

https://www.shieldsgazette.com/sport/foo...ng-3413284

I very much doubt they will. 

Something doesn't smell right about this deal.

For starters, if you did have £320bn, why on earth would you buy Newcastle United? Be like a multi-millionaire buying a Reliant Robin.

If whoever has £320bn, why are Stavely and the other party being allowed into the deal putting in 30m each? 

At the present time, if you had £320bn you'd buy Barcelona.

Gonna be some very unhappy gobshite toon fans in the near future when HRK rocks up on a free!  Big Grin
Reply
(10-09-2021, 09:01 AM)Hopalong Wrote:


I very much doubt they will. 

Something doesn't smell right about this deal.

For starters, if you did have £320bn, why on earth would you buy Newcastle United? Be like a multi-millionaire buying a Reliant Robin.

If whoever has £320bn, why are Stavely and the other party being allowed into the deal putting in 30m each? 

At the present time, if you had £320bn you'd buy Barcelona.

Gonna be some very unhappy gobshite toon fans in the near future when HRK rocks up on a free!  Big Grin


I wish some fucker would buy Barcelona, we might finally get our 200k.     Rolleyes
Reply
(10-09-2021, 10:49 AM)Psalm23 Wrote:
(10-09-2021, 09:01 AM)Hopalong Wrote:


I very much doubt they will. 

Something doesn't smell right about this deal.

For starters, if you did have £320bn, why on earth would you buy Newcastle United? Be like a multi-millionaire buying a Reliant Robin.

If whoever has £320bn, why are Stavely and the other party being allowed into the deal putting in 30m each? 

At the present time, if you had £320bn you'd buy Barcelona.

Gonna be some very unhappy gobshite toon fans in the near future when HRK rocks up on a free!  Big Grin


I wish some fucker would buy Barcelona, we might finally get our 200k.     Rolleyes

Crossed my mind! 

Of course, given Barca's ownership structure unless there's a restructuring they can't be bought in the traditional sense but if someone came in with 3bn promising further investment to return them to their former glories it would probably happen somehow.
Reply
(10-09-2021, 11:18 AM)Hopalong Wrote:
(10-09-2021, 10:49 AM)Psalm23 Wrote:
(10-09-2021, 09:01 AM)Hopalong Wrote:


I very much doubt they will. 

Something doesn't smell right about this deal.

For starters, if you did have £320bn, why on earth would you buy Newcastle United? Be like a multi-millionaire buying a Reliant Robin.

If whoever has £320bn, why are Stavely and the other party being allowed into the deal putting in 30m each? 

At the present time, if you had £320bn you'd buy Barcelona.

Gonna be some very unhappy gobshite toon fans in the near future when HRK rocks up on a free!  Big Grin


I wish some fucker would buy Barcelona, we might finally get our 200k.     Rolleyes

Crossed my mind! 

Of course, given Barca's ownership structure unless there's a restructuring they can't be bought in the traditional sense but if someone came in with 3bn promising further investment to return them to their former glories it would probably happen somehow.
Our structure was such that we couldn’t be “owned”, I think it was Hale who got that changed.  It was argued that was the way to get someone to put their money into the club.  

If it’s good enough for us it’s good enough for Barcelona.
Trump is a Cunt
Reply
(10-09-2021, 08:50 AM)Sliced Wrote:
(10-09-2021, 07:12 AM)Dumbo Wrote: On the back of yesterday‘s Newcastle news, it might be helpful to explain to fans of Premier League clubs why their counterparts in Germany don’t view the football world in the same way. Why being bankrolled is not the goal & why both leagues will remain different.

I was chatting to a Köln fan recently about this. For him, Köln is life - shared community, passion. He has a say in the club‘s direction along with other fans. In his words, if big wealth funds or equivalent, were to do as in England, he & others would go & watch Regionalliga.

PL club fans inevitably talk about Bayern‘s title wins. But to a Köln fan, this is irrelevant. Every season has its story. It could be (as often in the last 20 plus years) be about relegation & avoiding it. It could be in the 2. Liga or about Europe as in 2017/2018.

To feel it, you really need to attend a game in Germany. Every Köln match is special & - in normal times - a 50,000 sell out. It’s an occasion with friends, even though you may not know them all personally. Köln has fans worldwide but the club exists for the city & community.

German clubs make sure there is a ticket for everyone. Prices are kept in check, public transport in the local area is part of it. It beats the PL (in normal times) in terms of attendances. Again, you have to go, to really get it.

Dortmund CEO Hans-Joachim Watzke recently said German football will continue to go its own way - prices fans can afford, exciting, dynamic football for communities. The model is sustainable & popular. Fans don’t want their club to be the plaything of a sovereign wealth fund.

It would be hard to imagine Köln or Eintracht Frankfurt fans (both huge clubs who have had ups and downs) reacting to news of a takeover as Newcastle fans reacted. In fact, it would be a parallel universe. It wouldn’t and can’t happen.

If you love the PL, I understand. It has a glamourous air & is wonderful packaged & marketed. But that’s just one model. The Bundesliga has its own successful model & its beauty lies not just in who wins the Meisterschale. Visit some day & discover for yourself.

Good post. Enjoyed reading that

Terrific post. Thanks.
If only.....
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: 1 Guest(s)