Fair Play to Callum Robinson
(10-08-2021, 02:52 PM)boingingjim Wrote: People on this thread are still looking at COVID like it's late 2020.  COVID is here for the long haul, it isn't a case of two jabs for everyone and we will eradicate it.  Virtually everyone in the UK will get COVID over the next few year (some more than once).  Antibodies are present up to 12 months after infection (I know as I've been part of a NHS study on this after having COVID in May 2020).

This is now an endemic disease like flu, yes the vaccine has been a fantastic thing in reducing serious illness and death and without it the picture would have been very different. However to think that a double COVID infectee needs to take a vaccine to help protect other people is crazy.  People are protected as well as possible.  Did anyone call for Calum to have his flu jab 2 years ago or asked if he had - of course not, yet the IFR for flu is much higher than COVID for young kids so by this logic anyone without a flu jab should be banned from schools.

Totally agree. This is where I believe 18 months of covid in the media had left many people not thinking in a balanced way, everything through a “covid lens”.

The best example of this is the vax passports for events, which allow vaccinated people with covid into the event, but non vaccinated people who haven’t got covid are banned. I appreciate Wales version doesn’t do this so clearly as a negative test is an option, but the Scottish version does. And it’s bonkers.
Reply
(10-08-2021, 02:00 PM)Madness Wrote:
(10-06-2021, 09:21 AM)Jacobthebaggie Wrote: In general I'm finding that vaccinated people don't mention Covid and get on with life as mask wearing and keeping a distance normal now or just ignore it as if gone away. On the other hand non vaccinated people mention it more (I suspect worrying if they're doing the right thing.) Three people I know that refuse the vaccine have admitted it's because they're afraid of needles but still post bs stories on social media.

(10-08-2021, 01:58 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote:
(10-08-2021, 12:47 PM)Spandaubaggie Wrote:
(10-08-2021, 12:39 PM)Squid Wrote:
(10-08-2021, 11:05 AM)Ted Maul Wrote: If only people were this keen to defend personal choice when James McClean chose not to wear a poppy, eh?

Plenty of people did defend him.

The personal choice thing with Covid isn't some posturing. We're being told by all the medical brains to take the jab for the good of all of us health wise and economically yet some won't, bar the minuscule amount who can't for some health reason. They have their freedom of choice, but we all have our freedom to have an opinion when it affects society.

Exactly, since when is it not acceptable to think and say someone is being selfish with the decisions they make? If it just affected them, then fair enough but their decisions do affect others so don’t expect a free pass from others.

He has had Covid twice. Why are you still moaning

It was a general point not about Robinson.
Reply
(10-08-2021, 03:06 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote:
(10-08-2021, 02:00 PM)Madness Wrote:
(10-06-2021, 09:21 AM)Jacobthebaggie Wrote: In general I'm finding that vaccinated people don't mention Covid and get on with life as mask wearing and keeping a distance normal now or just ignore it as if gone away. On the other hand non vaccinated people mention it more (I suspect worrying if they're doing the right thing.) Three people I know that refuse the vaccine have admitted it's because they're afraid of needles but still post bs stories on social media.

(10-08-2021, 01:58 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote:
(10-08-2021, 12:47 PM)Spandaubaggie Wrote:
(10-08-2021, 12:39 PM)Squid Wrote: Plenty of people did defend him.

The personal choice thing with Covid isn't some posturing. We're being told by all the medical brains to take the jab for the good of all of us health wise and economically yet some won't, bar the minuscule amount who can't for some health reason. They have their freedom of choice, but we all have our freedom to have an opinion when it affects society.

Exactly, since when is it not acceptable to think and say someone is being selfish with the decisions they make? If it just affected them, then fair enough but their decisions do affect others so don’t expect a free pass from others.

He has had Covid twice. Why are you still moaning

It was a general point not about Robinson.

You're asking Dekka that? Are you new here?
Reply
(10-08-2021, 02:55 PM)backsidebaggie Wrote:
(10-08-2021, 02:52 PM)boingingjim Wrote: People on this thread are still looking at COVID like it's late 2020.  COVID is here for the long haul, it isn't a case of two jabs for everyone and we will eradicate it.  Virtually everyone in the UK will get COVID over the next few year (some more than once).  Antibodies are present up to 12 months after infection (I know as I've been part of a NHS study on this after having COVID in May 2020).

This is now an endemic disease like flu, yes the vaccine has been a fantastic thing in reducing serious illness and death and without it the picture would have been very different. However to think that a double COVID infectee needs to take a vaccine to help protect other people is crazy.  People are protected as well as possible.  Did anyone call for Calum to have his flu jab 2 years ago or asked if he had - of course not, yet the IFR for flu is much higher than COVID for young kids so by this logic anyone without a flu jab should be banned from schools.

Totally agree. This is where I believe 18 months of covid in the media had left many people not thinking in a balanced way, everything through a “covid lens”.

The best example of this is the vax passports for events, which allow vaccinated people with covid into the event, but non vaccinated people who haven’t got covid are banned. I appreciate Wales version doesn’t do this so clearly as a negative test is an option, but the Scottish version does. And it’s bonkers.
All well and good and we all have different levels of risk in life. Myself, I took the vaccine and I'm cool about all of it in my day to day life. I now go out to the pubs and am in a hotel bar at the minute mixing with fellow humans. I'm comfy enough that I'll be ok if I get a dose.

However, the problem is there's some right mixed messages on Covid in society and from the gov. I went to the dentist yesterday and I had to stand outside until my appointment and they said they have to stop certain procedures due to Covid. It was freaky. Meanwhile the cafe next door had builders slurping tea and eating bacon sandwiches as if it was 2019 again.

We are being told everyone offered the jab should take it and it provides some transmission blockage to others. The health chiefs galore are saying take it. However, some won't and when a footballer doesn't then that sends message to thousands.

All said and done though I am bewildered at the hold Covid is having on society when it appears now only those who will be badly affected are those who don't take the vaccine and have age/health issues on their side, bar a tiny minority of unlucky ones.

I really wish the BBC when giving their daily announcements of deaths would say the percentage of these who haven't been double vaccinated- that would make things a lot clearer. However, back onto the original post, I really can't see how Robinson can be praised for his decision to say he isn't jabbed. However, I do have some sympathy as he was put on the spot.
Reply
(10-08-2021, 02:24 PM)baggiebuckster Wrote:
(10-08-2021, 12:47 PM)Spandaubaggie Wrote:
(10-08-2021, 12:39 PM)Squid Wrote:
(10-08-2021, 11:05 AM)Ted Maul Wrote: If only people were this keen to defend personal choice when James McClean chose not to wear a poppy, eh?

Plenty of people did defend him.

The personal choice thing with Covid isn't some posturing. We're being told by all the medical brains to take the jab for the good of all of us health wise and economically yet some won't, bar the minuscule amount who can't for some health reason. They have their freedom of choice, but we all have our freedom to have an opinion when it affects society.

(10-08-2021, 01:58 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote:
(10-08-2021, 12:47 PM)Spandaubaggie Wrote:
(10-08-2021, 12:39 PM)Squid Wrote:
(10-08-2021, 11:05 AM)Ted Maul Wrote: If only people were this keen to defend personal choice when James McClean chose not to wear a poppy, eh?

Plenty of people did defend him.

The personal choice thing with Covid isn't some posturing. We're being told by all the medical brains to take the jab for the good of all of us health wise and economically yet some won't, bar the minuscule amount who can't for some health reason. They have their freedom of choice, but we all have our freedom to have an opinion when it affects society.

Exactly, since when is it not acceptable to think and say someone is being selfish with the decisions they make? If it just affected them, then fair enough but their decisions do affect others so don’t expect a free pass from others.

Genuine question Derek - At what point will you feel that the vulnerable people you mention will be happy to rejoin society without fear?

Is there not likely to be a lesser uptake of boosters than there has been for the initial 2 jabs? As the indications are that boosters are needed due to waning immunity then surely that means that more double jabbed people will then become a threat to those more vulnerable if they decline a 3rd jab. And this could be a rolling scenario as we have no data to suggest there won't be a need for a 4th jab in time. I may be wrong but I do wonder how keen people will be to take every jab offered.

It’s a good and sensible question. The simple answer is I don’t, but currently we have normalised 30-40k of infections a day and around a 1000 deaths a week. I’m not sure this is acceptable or inevitable. The general public have been led to believe that everyone who is vulnerable has had the vaccine. This is not true and there are many children for example under 12 who have not had the vaccine but are as vulnerable as those in their 60s - 80s to this specific virus. I would hope that this age group could at least be vaccinated by this spring and that some measures can still be put in place such as mask wearing in shops, schools and social distancing can be reintroduced during this winter. Until the vaccine is available to all age groups I think it’s not unreasonable to ask for some sensible measures to be put in place.

There will be people who simply cannot have the vaccine and I genuinely don’t know the answer to how they can be kept safe within U.K. society given how little thought is given to them. If I was in their shoes I would be angry, scared and disillusioned with the country and many of those who live here.
Reply
As it happens, I have an older mate who is classed as vulnerable. He does the antibodies test now and again. At the last call, he had antibodies from having covid some 18 months previous, and antibodies from being double jabbed earlier this year. Encouraging, I thought.
Reply
(10-08-2021, 10:22 AM)boingingjim Wrote:
(10-08-2021, 08:45 AM)KratosBaggie Wrote: I do believe that as a fairly high standing public figure, the very least Robinson (and other professional footballers who have refused the vaccine) should give factual and well reasoned arguments as to why they've not received the jab.

Whilst it's a personal choice, and that needs respecting, footballers are very privileged and are in a position to change public opinion. They could use this platform to squash the ridiculous anti-vaccine conspiracy theories.

It's a very difficult subject, and I'm torn between protecting others and yourself, as well as preserving the freedom of choice. But I believe those in the public eye hiding being 'it's my choice' and saying nothing more, is not good enough.

Other than valid health reasons, I just don't understand the reluctance to not get vaccinated. Surely it largely down to ignorance?

I suspect if the club, FA, or football league, cut pay and prevented un-vaccinated players from playing (which would be ridiculous), then Robinson, and others would suddenly have no qualms about getting jabbed. Which would show that they don't have legitimate concerns.

Let's be honest there is no explanation he could give that would sufficiently satisfy you as you have already called him and idiot and ignorant, your position is clear.  If he said "I've read many scientific studies that prove antibodies post infection are as strong as the vaccine while meaning I eliminate any risk of adverse reaction however small from the vaccine" - you'd still think that he was wrong.

You don't actually believe his body his choice, which is ultimately what he is saying.  He is less likely to pass on COVID than virtually anyone given the strict testing regime that is in place for footballers and the isolation post testing positive.  You however could well be carrying the virus and because you are double jabbed believe that's that and go into the pub / football ground blissfully unaware.

Maybe idiotic is too strong a term. But I do think point blank refusal, for no reasonable grounds, other than 'it's my choice', is silly, selfish, and not very clever. The medical evidence speaks for itself.

Like I say, it's a very difficult position, as I said, freedom of choice needs to be protected, but that doesn't mean I can't have the opinion that those who refuse to get vaccinated, without valid reason, are selfish at worse, and misguided at best. 

I'll repeat, if Robinson or any other footballer who refuses the vaccine, were told they won't be able to play or earn a wage, due to their vaccination status, they'd soon get vaccinated, wouldn't they? That to me, just proves that they're being ignorant and selfish. Of course I don't know they would for sure, but I'd bet good money it would happen, if that situation ever arises.

I wonder what the fall out will be, if a non-vaccinated player is proven to have spread covid 19, and spreads the disease onto another club, or to his own staff, which results in a fatality, or even fatalities..

Who would you blame in that situation? If anyone.

It's a very tough situation, and I'm somewhat conflicted, to a degree, despite the tone of your post, as I do understand both points, and freedom of choice should be protected.

But all this controversy could all be eased by receiving a medically safe vaccine, that takes less than 30 seconds to administer, that can, has and will save lives. Surely saving lives is of the upmost importance?

Just a final thought - I dislike smoking, and believe people who smoke are selfish to a degree. They're slowly killing themselves, and even those around them. I have close friends and family who smoke, whom I love and respect. It's their choice to smoke, which I respect, but part of me does think 'you're being stupid', why are you doing that.

I suppose the same can be said about drinking too much alcohol (guilty).

I'll shut up now, maybe I'm talking bollocks here, maybe not! Have a good night y'all!
Clarnet v2.0
Reply
Sensible words
Reply
Will CR be allowed to play at Swansea? Fans have to be double jabbed to attend?
Reply
(10-10-2021, 12:09 PM)Harryhanley Wrote: Will CR be allowed to play at Swansea?  Fans have to be double jabbed to attend?

They don’t. They need jab or negative test.
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: 2 Guest(s)