(10-06-2021, 07:51 AM)strawman Wrote: (10-06-2021, 07:39 AM)Sliced Wrote: Why do people think that having the vaccine will reduce transmission more than having had Covid twice?
'People who have previously been infected with covid-19 are likely to be protected against reinfection for several months, but could still carry the virus in their nose and throat and transmit it to others, according to a study which regularly tested thousands of healthcare workers.'
https://www.bmj.com/content/372/bmj.n124...0The%20BMJ
'Adults infected with covid-19 three weeks after receiving one dose of the Pfizer-BioNTech or Oxford-AstraZeneca vaccine were 38-49% less likely to pass the virus on to their household contacts than people who were unvaccinated, a preprint released by Public Health England has shown'
https://www.bmj.com/content/373/bmj.n1112
"Could still carry the virus and transmit is" is not the same as saying that the transmission levels will be the same.
The article you've sent a link to is literally called "Covid-19: Past infection provides 83% protection for five months but
may not stop transmission, study finds".
We're talking about reducing transmission, not stopping. The article also states:
"The research team warned, however, that early evidence from the next stage of the study suggested
that some people who are themselves protected by antibodies still carry high levels of virus and could continue to infect others."
In other words: transmission is reduced.
(10-06-2021, 07:56 AM)backsidebaggie Wrote: (10-06-2021, 07:39 AM)Sliced Wrote: Why do people think that having the vaccine will reduce transmission more than having had Covid twice?
I’ve no idea. I’m afraid many people think the vaccine does something it doesn’t do. It reduces transmission, but the extent is debatable.
If he’s had it twice, he’s hardly a threat to anyone.
And anyone who’s worried would have had the vaccine anyway, which very much limits the chance of severe disease - this is its main effect.
It does reduce transmission, as does having had COVID. That's why in some European countries it's enough to be able to prove that you've had COVID in the past few months and recovered.
The crazy thing about it is this shouldn't be controversial at all. If you've had COVID and that's a) protecting yourself and b) reducing the likelihood of transmission in the same way as the vaccine is doing, then what's the difference? The outcomes are going to be similar; and the reason I use similar is because nobody genuinely knows the level at which transmission is decreased for the vaccines with regards to different variants vs. for previous COVID infection.
As has been done to death on here I think the reason it's controversial is because there's a tendency to lump everyone who hasn't had the vaccine in the same group as tin foil hat anti-vaxxers. But if you're genuinely interested in reducing the spread of COVID and protecting others, Callum Robinson having the jab isn't going to make any difference at all.