Avoiding the jab
#31
It's their choice, and no-one should be forced. We still live in a democracy, and not a dictatorship, as far as I'm aware.

With professional footballers, they'll receive private health care, so it won't impact on the NHS as much as Joe Public who refuse the jab.

If you're a mere peasant, and have refused the jab (medical conditions notwithstanding), you should pay for any NHS treatment you receive if you contract covid.

I've no idea why you wouldn't get the jab, and some of the anti-vax comments and stances I've read have been ridiculous and idiotic, but ultimately it's a free county we live in.
Clarnet v2.0
Reply
#32
(10-02-2021, 11:45 AM)baggiebuckster Wrote: I find it hard to understand why people still take the attitude that the vaccine is making a huge difference in protecting others. From the outset we were led to believe that the jabs would do a very good job of preventing transmission along with preventing most people from requiring hospital treatment. However as the months and weeks have gone by it is becoming increasingly hard to ignore the fact that the jab is looking more and more like a self-preventative measure.

Obviously this is a good thing - preventing serious ill health and death reduces the fear factor. However in terms of reducing transmission the jab seems much less effective. I don't have a particularly wide social circle yet I know of at least a dozen double jabbed friends and colleagues that have caught Covid. Only time will tell what the real statistics are but all these models stating x% reduction in transmission are purely hypothetical it seems - there is no way of knowing to any degree of accuracy as there are too many factors at play such as age, waning immunity, previous Covid cases etc.

How many people on here know of double jabbed people who have still caught it? I can't be the only one who seem to hear of someone every few days - hardly what I would term breakthrough cases.

What makes you think that isn't effective at reducing transmission?

(10-02-2021, 07:13 AM)Remi_Moses Wrote: How do we view the Anti-vaxers ?
The papers are reporting 5 England players have refused to take a Covid jab ?
Is it -
Madness, Stupidity, Sensible, freedom of choice?

It sets a bad example and would be interesting to know why they don't want it
Reply
#33
(10-04-2021, 02:05 PM)KratosBaggie Wrote: It's their choice, and no-one should be forced. We still live in a democracy, and not a dictatorship, as far as I'm aware.

With professional footballers, they'll receive private health care, so it won't impact on the NHS as much as Joe Public who refuse the jab.

If you're a mere peasant, and have refused the jab (medical conditions notwithstanding), you should pay for any NHS treatment you receive if you contract covid.

I've no idea why you wouldn't get the jab, and some of the anti-vax comments and stances I've read have been ridiculous and idiotic, but ultimately it's a free county we live in.

You underestimate how reliant private healthcare providers are on the NHS, they are not decoupled. Anything that isn't profitable gets pawned off to the state to deal with and the private sector does not have facilities to offer any level of emergency care which is what is needed to deal with Covid more often than not, especially if it's serious.

(10-04-2021, 01:27 PM)strawman Wrote: The flu vaccine does not stop you getting the flu - it reduces the chance of getting flu and if you get it then hopefully the effects are less. And at approx 40-60% it is less effective that the covid vaccine

Yes, as is the case with all vaccines. Vaccines help improve immune response to make how you deal with an illness more efficient, that is their job. That is what immunity is.
Reply
#34
it needs one of these high profile players to end up in hospital, recover and say they wished they had the jab.
Reply
#35
(10-04-2021, 04:41 PM)baggy1 Wrote:
(10-02-2021, 11:45 AM)baggiebuckster Wrote: I find it hard to understand why people still take the attitude that the vaccine is making a huge difference in protecting others. From the outset we were led to believe that the jabs would do a very good job of preventing transmission along with preventing most people from requiring hospital treatment. However as the months and weeks have gone by it is becoming increasingly hard to ignore the fact that the jab is looking more and more like a self-preventative measure.

Obviously this is a good thing - preventing serious ill health and death reduces the fear factor. However in terms of reducing transmission the jab seems much less effective. I don't have a particularly wide social circle yet I know of at least a dozen double jabbed friends and colleagues that have caught Covid. Only time will tell what the real statistics are but all these models stating x% reduction in transmission are purely hypothetical it seems - there is no way of knowing to any degree of accuracy as there are too many factors at play such as age, waning immunity, previous Covid cases etc.

How many people on here know of double jabbed people who have still caught it? I can't be the only one who seem to hear of someone every few days - hardly what I would term breakthrough cases.

What makes you think that isn't effective at reducing transmission?

(10-02-2021, 07:13 AM)Remi_Moses Wrote: How do we view the Anti-vaxers ?
The papers are reporting 5 England players have refused to take a Covid jab ?
Is it -
Madness, Stupidity, Sensible, freedom of choice?

It sets a bad example and would be interesting to know why they don't want it
Just going on the pure number of jabbed people catching Covid. I know 3 households where one of the members caught Covid and then within a few days the rest of the family caught it too. These weren't old people who may have waning immunity either. 

As I said previously with waning immunity, length of time from when jabbed, strength of individuals immune system etc it is hard to determine just how effective the jabs are. 

The fact that boosters are already required only 6 months after the second jab tells it own story surely.
Reply
#36
(10-04-2021, 04:52 PM)Kit Kat Chunky Wrote: it needs one of these high profile players to end up in hospital, recover and say they wished they had the jab.

Isn't Karl Darlow high profile enough?
Reply
#37
(10-04-2021, 04:48 PM)Borin' Baggie Wrote:
(10-04-2021, 02:05 PM)KratosBaggie Wrote: It's their choice, and no-one should be forced. We still live in a democracy, and not a dictatorship, as far as I'm aware.

With professional footballers, they'll receive private health care, so it won't impact on the NHS as much as Joe Public who refuse the jab.

If you're a mere peasant, and have refused the jab (medical conditions notwithstanding), you should pay for any NHS treatment you receive if you contract covid.

I've no idea why you wouldn't get the jab, and some of the anti-vax comments and stances I've read have been ridiculous and idiotic, but ultimately it's a free county we live in.

You underestimate how reliant private healthcare providers are on the NHS, they are not decoupled. Anything that isn't profitable gets pawned off to the state to deal with and the private sector does not have facilities to offer any level of emergency care which is what is needed to deal with Covid more often than not, especially if it's serious. 

I'm surprised to read this, but thanks for the info.
Clarnet v2.0
Reply
#38
(10-04-2021, 05:01 PM)baggiebuckster Wrote:
(10-04-2021, 04:52 PM)Kit Kat Chunky Wrote: it needs one of these high profile players to end up in hospital, recover and say they wished they had the jab.

Isn't Karl Darlow high profile enough?

He isn't no. I'm talking a top notch England regular, if (as suggested) some of them have refused the jab. I don't wish any of them any personal harm, or long term issues, but it needs this kind of profile for the rest to come to the party.
Reply
#39
(10-04-2021, 04:55 PM)baggiebuckster Wrote:
(10-04-2021, 04:41 PM)baggy1 Wrote: What makes you think that isn't effective at reducing transmission?

Just going on the pure number of jabbed people catching Covid. I know 3 households where one of the members caught Covid and then within a few days the rest of the family caught it too. These weren't old people who may have waning immunity either. 

As I said previously with waning immunity, length of time from when jabbed, strength of individuals immune system etc it is hard to determine just how effective the jabs are. 

The fact that boosters are already required only 6 months after the second jab tells it own story surely.

People who are jabbed will still run the chance of getting covid, the jab just reduces the chance of them getting it. That's got nothing to do with transmission - if someone in your vicinity gets covid and you are exposed to it then you will likely get it, the symptoms will likely be reduced from they would be if you hadn't had the jab but that's it.

It's hard to determine how effective the jabs are because it is so new, nothing else. And of course we will have waning immunity, its a jab not a shield for life in the same way that we have flu vaccine boosters.

So basically you just have a feeling that it isn't effective at reducing transmission, there's nothing to back that up.
Reply
#40
(10-04-2021, 05:17 PM)baggy1 Wrote:
(10-04-2021, 04:55 PM)baggiebuckster Wrote:
(10-04-2021, 04:41 PM)baggy1 Wrote: What makes you think that isn't effective at reducing transmission?

Just going on the pure number of jabbed people catching Covid. I know 3 households where one of the members caught Covid and then within a few days the rest of the family caught it too. These weren't old people who may have waning immunity either. 

As I said previously with waning immunity, length of time from when jabbed, strength of individuals immune system etc it is hard to determine just how effective the jabs are. 

The fact that boosters are already required only 6 months after the second jab tells it own story surely.

People who are jabbed will still run the chance of getting covid, the jab just reduces the chance of them getting it. That's got nothing to do with transmission - if someone in your vicinity gets covid and you are exposed to it then you will likely get it, the symptoms will likely be reduced from they would be if you hadn't had the jab but that's it.

It's hard to determine how effective the jabs are because it is so new, nothing else. And of course we will have waning immunity, its a jab not a shield for life in the same way that we have flu vaccine boosters.

So basically you just have a feeling that it isn't effective at reducing transmission, there's nothing to back that up.
Isn't that what transmission is?

And we don't have flu vaccine boosters. We have a different flu vaccine each year for different strains not the same one as the year before.
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: