Posts: 3,488
Threads: 101
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
5
I thought the big problem with him last night was his shocking kicking.
Nearly always kicking into touch even with no pressure on him thus giving away possession time after time.
Posts: 7,408
Threads: 458
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
29
(10-02-2021, 11:35 AM)Cuzer Wrote: Some of the comments here are laughable, have a word with yourselves, it's a football forum for posting opinions, I'm not asking him to be pushed off a cliff FFS, it's an observation which to me is what probably stops him getting those moves in the summer for what, in todays market, is a relatively low transfer fee
The comment "A great shot stopper" is the most ridiculous saying in football, every GK should be a good shot stopper but they need to do so much more, comnand of their area and communication are two massive key points to a GK, they should be the voice on the pitch for 90 minutes, they have the best view of the game, SJ is too often like a mute, how many times do you see our defenders signalling to him to talk? Saw Furlong last night and Bartley do it, Livermore gave him an almighty bollocking v QPR for not talking and coming off his line
Don't see what you want to see, see what actually goes on, is he a good keeper, yes, is he playing sweeper keeper in our system of course he is, we play a high line but the QPR goal and last nights you can't just say "oh well he's a sweeper keeper that's going to happen" No it isn't, it's his job when to come and when not to come
It was also a nailed on penalty and a mistake from SJ as he was caught in two minds and 100% caught Sturridge
Cuzer
(10-02-2021, 10:54 AM)wba13 Wrote: (10-02-2021, 09:58 AM)Cuzer Wrote: I’m not going to go over last nights game, christ we were poor and it started from the top, nothing stuck with Hugill and the ball just kept coming back, 25 mins in it could have been 3-3 and we looked OK but from here on in Stoke took over and I was fully expecting us to improve in the 2nd half after a half time dusting down….we didn’t…..In fact we got worse and it was no surprise when we conceded from yet another mistake
I was really struggling to give a MOM, seems Sam is getting loads of praise and he made some good stops last night but fuck me he also does us no favors, his communication is non existent, that Furlong OG, Sunday league stuff just needs one shout from Sam and he says nothing, the penalty, what is he thinking, he’s stopped pulled out of the challenge and then still gone and caught the player, the goal, absolute no mans land, he stays in his goal, Powell doesn’t score, or if he does it’s a worldie strike across the keeper
He infuriates me SJ as he’s clearly a good keeper but the basic part of goalkeeping he seems to struggle with, must be a nightmare to play with as a centre half
Just my onions
Cuzer It doesn’t matter what SJ does for some of you if he stays on his line he’s wrong, if he comes of his line he’s wrong what’s the matter with you he was outstanding last night and he was berating our defence at times so stop coming out with all this rubbish. He’s England’s second choice keeper and our coaches and England’s coaches certainly know what there talking about as you clearly don’t . I’m sick and tired of the constant sniping at SJ there’s no need for it he’s a top class keeper.
Fuck me wba13, that's pathetic, it's not a vendeta it's an observation and my opinion, put your dummy back in fella!
Cuzer
How can I put my dummy in when you have it in your big trap. You along with others only pipe up when they Think SJ makes a mistake and do not praise him whenever he plays well. He was great last night if he hadn’t come out Powell would have had a clear run on goal beautifully taken. SJ stopped a rout last night and doesn’t deserve your so called limited observation. By the way go fuck yourself because I wouldn’t touch you with a barge pole.
Posts: 5,201
Threads: 197
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
14
(10-02-2021, 12:26 PM)wba13 Wrote: (10-02-2021, 11:35 AM)Cuzer Wrote: Some of the comments here are laughable, have a word with yourselves, it's a football forum for posting opinions, I'm not asking him to be pushed off a cliff FFS, it's an observation which to me is what probably stops him getting those moves in the summer for what, in todays market, is a relatively low transfer fee
The comment "A great shot stopper" is the most ridiculous saying in football, every GK should be a good shot stopper but they need to do so much more, comnand of their area and communication are two massive key points to a GK, they should be the voice on the pitch for 90 minutes, they have the best view of the game, SJ is too often like a mute, how many times do you see our defenders signalling to him to talk? Saw Furlong last night and Bartley do it, Livermore gave him an almighty bollocking v QPR for not talking and coming off his line
Don't see what you want to see, see what actually goes on, is he a good keeper, yes, is he playing sweeper keeper in our system of course he is, we play a high line but the QPR goal and last nights you can't just say "oh well he's a sweeper keeper that's going to happen" No it isn't, it's his job when to come and when not to come
It was also a nailed on penalty and a mistake from SJ as he was caught in two minds and 100% caught Sturridge
Cuzer
(10-02-2021, 10:54 AM)wba13 Wrote: (10-02-2021, 09:58 AM)Cuzer Wrote: I’m not going to go over last nights game, christ we were poor and it started from the top, nothing stuck with Hugill and the ball just kept coming back, 25 mins in it could have been 3-3 and we looked OK but from here on in Stoke took over and I was fully expecting us to improve in the 2nd half after a half time dusting down….we didn’t…..In fact we got worse and it was no surprise when we conceded from yet another mistake
I was really struggling to give a MOM, seems Sam is getting loads of praise and he made some good stops last night but fuck me he also does us no favors, his communication is non existent, that Furlong OG, Sunday league stuff just needs one shout from Sam and he says nothing, the penalty, what is he thinking, he’s stopped pulled out of the challenge and then still gone and caught the player, the goal, absolute no mans land, he stays in his goal, Powell doesn’t score, or if he does it’s a worldie strike across the keeper
He infuriates me SJ as he’s clearly a good keeper but the basic part of goalkeeping he seems to struggle with, must be a nightmare to play with as a centre half
Just my onions
Cuzer It doesn’t matter what SJ does for some of you if he stays on his line he’s wrong, if he comes of his line he’s wrong what’s the matter with you he was outstanding last night and he was berating our defence at times so stop coming out with all this rubbish. He’s England’s second choice keeper and our coaches and England’s coaches certainly know what there talking about as you clearly don’t . I’m sick and tired of the constant sniping at SJ there’s no need for it he’s a top class keeper.
Fuck me wba13, that's pathetic, it's not a vendeta it's an observation and my opinion, put your dummy back in fella!
Cuzer
How can I put my dummy in when you have it in your big trap. You along with others only pipe up when they Think SJ makes a mistake and do not praise him whenever he plays well. He was great last night if he hadn’t come out Powell would have had a clear run on goal beautifully taken. SJ stopped a rout last night and doesn’t deserve your so called limited observation. By the way go fuck yourself because I wouldn’t touch you with a barge pole.
Loffin fella
Pathetic comments, I call it how I see it pal, without agenda. I'll happily say Sam has played well when he has, I even said in my post he's a good keeper and have said many times we're lucky to have him, what I'm also pointing out is areas of his game he needs to improve and where he's let us down in certian matches, maybe you need to open your eyes and stop wanking over you Sam Johnson posters?
If I could fuck myself pal I wouldn't be wasting my time on here x
Cuzer
Fisheatingdeludedsealwankers
Posts: 3,808
Threads: 49
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
3
(10-02-2021, 12:28 PM)Cuzer Wrote: (10-02-2021, 12:26 PM)wba13 Wrote: (10-02-2021, 11:35 AM)Cuzer Wrote: Some of the comments here are laughable, have a word with yourselves, it's a football forum for posting opinions, I'm not asking him to be pushed off a cliff FFS, it's an observation which to me is what probably stops him getting those moves in the summer for what, in todays market, is a relatively low transfer fee
The comment "A great shot stopper" is the most ridiculous saying in football, every GK should be a good shot stopper but they need to do so much more, comnand of their area and communication are two massive key points to a GK, they should be the voice on the pitch for 90 minutes, they have the best view of the game, SJ is too often like a mute, how many times do you see our defenders signalling to him to talk? Saw Furlong last night and Bartley do it, Livermore gave him an almighty bollocking v QPR for not talking and coming off his line
Don't see what you want to see, see what actually goes on, is he a good keeper, yes, is he playing sweeper keeper in our system of course he is, we play a high line but the QPR goal and last nights you can't just say "oh well he's a sweeper keeper that's going to happen" No it isn't, it's his job when to come and when not to come
It was also a nailed on penalty and a mistake from SJ as he was caught in two minds and 100% caught Sturridge
Cuzer
(10-02-2021, 10:54 AM)wba13 Wrote: (10-02-2021, 09:58 AM)Cuzer Wrote: I’m not going to go over last nights game, christ we were poor and it started from the top, nothing stuck with Hugill and the ball just kept coming back, 25 mins in it could have been 3-3 and we looked OK but from here on in Stoke took over and I was fully expecting us to improve in the 2nd half after a half time dusting down….we didn’t…..In fact we got worse and it was no surprise when we conceded from yet another mistake
I was really struggling to give a MOM, seems Sam is getting loads of praise and he made some good stops last night but fuck me he also does us no favors, his communication is non existent, that Furlong OG, Sunday league stuff just needs one shout from Sam and he says nothing, the penalty, what is he thinking, he’s stopped pulled out of the challenge and then still gone and caught the player, the goal, absolute no mans land, he stays in his goal, Powell doesn’t score, or if he does it’s a worldie strike across the keeper
He infuriates me SJ as he’s clearly a good keeper but the basic part of goalkeeping he seems to struggle with, must be a nightmare to play with as a centre half
Just my onions
Cuzer It doesn’t matter what SJ does for some of you if he stays on his line he’s wrong, if he comes of his line he’s wrong what’s the matter with you he was outstanding last night and he was berating our defence at times so stop coming out with all this rubbish. He’s England’s second choice keeper and our coaches and England’s coaches certainly know what there talking about as you clearly don’t . I’m sick and tired of the constant sniping at SJ there’s no need for it he’s a top class keeper.
Fuck me wba13, that's pathetic, it's not a vendeta it's an observation and my opinion, put your dummy back in fella!
Cuzer
How can I put my dummy in when you have it in your big trap. You along with others only pipe up when they Think SJ makes a mistake and do not praise him whenever he plays well. He was great last night if he hadn’t come out Powell would have had a clear run on goal beautifully taken. SJ stopped a rout last night and doesn’t deserve your so called limited observation. By the way go fuck yourself because I wouldn’t touch you with a barge pole.
Loffin fella
Pathetic comments, I call it how I see it pal, without agenda. I'll happily say Sam has played well when he has, I even said in my post he's a good keeper and have said many times we're lucky to have him, what I'm also pointing out is areas of his game he needs to improve and where he's let us down in certian matches, maybe you need to open your eyes and stop wanking over you Sam Johnson posters?
If I could fuck myself pal I wouldn't be wasting my time on here x
Cuzer Hey, come on lads, lets not have this.
Posts: 3,396
Threads: 176
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
9
(10-02-2021, 09:58 AM)Cuzer Wrote: I’m not going to go over last nights game, christ we were poor and it started from the top, nothing stuck with Hugill and the ball just kept coming back, 25 mins in it could have been 3-3 and we looked OK but from here on in Stoke took over and I was fully expecting us to improve in the 2nd half after a half time dusting down….we didn’t…..In fact we got worse and it was no surprise when we conceded from yet another mistake
I was really struggling to give a MOM, seems Sam is getting loads of praise and he made some good stops last night but fuck me he also does us no favors, his communication is non existent, that Furlong OG, Sunday league stuff just needs one shout from Sam and he says nothing, the penalty, what is he thinking, he’s stopped pulled out of the challenge and then still gone and caught the player, the goal, absolute no mans land, he stays in his goal, Powell doesn’t score, or if he does it’s a worldie strike across the keeper
He infuriates me SJ as he’s clearly a good keeper but the basic part of goalkeeping he seems to struggle with, must be a nightmare to play with as a centre half
Just my onions
Cuzer
Agreed about the communication - it's not about ability, he can do it if he wants to, any keeper can so no excuses on that one.
Posts: 15,040
Threads: 339
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
93
I'll add my tuppence wuth;
He is a good keeper.
He isn't a great shouter.
He wasn't to blame for either the QPR goal (Bartley was), nor Stoke's, (Townsend was).
Posts: 13,261
Threads: 468
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
45
10-02-2021, 02:23 PM
(This post was last modified: 10-02-2021, 02:27 PM by Sliced.)
Everything is pre-emptively labelled a meltdown. When did this start happening? Surely message boards are about opinions.
Surely most people’s “agenda” is for Albion to do well. I agree that Sams communication could be much better, which is a shame because he has talent in abundance. He was definitely our best player yesterday however
Posts: 5,201
Threads: 197
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
14
I agree Slice merely an observation and something IMO he needs to improve on
He was MOM last night but I had issues with bits of his performance, he was probably the best of a very, very bad bunch
Cuzer
Fisheatingdeludedsealwankers
Posts: 2,465
Threads: 34
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
6
(10-02-2021, 04:23 PM)Cuzer Wrote: I agree Slice merely an observation and something IMO he needs to improve on
He was MOM last night but I had issues with bits of his performance, he was probably the best of a very, very bad bunch
Cuzer
I think this can be levelled at all of our players in every match. There will always be one or more bad decisions here and there amongst the good decisions. Obviously the best players are the ones who make the fewest bad decisions.
Johnstone needs to make better decisions regarding when to sweep and when not to but, in the ebb and flow of a game, there will always be that split second where a player thinks he can make up the ground only to realise that he can't. At that point that player effectively puts himself out of that particular passage of play. Whether it's the goalkeeper or an outfield player.
It is always frustrating because we want our players to always do the right thing at the right time.
Posts: 242
Threads: 20
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
1
It is always frustrating because we want our players to always do the right thing at the right time.
We do, but if they could they would'nt be playing for us
|