Silwood
#51
I see all points here and believe Remi has called it right. Regarding the length of the sentence, agree it seems harsh but I would prefer to listen to the viewpoint of our West Midlands black community before making up my mind. Romaine didn't say as much so....? Regarding Fido saying its only local news, wrong. It was Radio 4s news headline with the first words "A West Bromwich Albion fan...."
For me, the disappointment that this guy is a Baggie is the overwhelming blow. Fuck him.
Reply
#52
(10-01-2021, 10:50 AM)baggiebloke Wrote: This supposed Albion fan would not have been going to prison if he'd offered remorse.

Could it be that he dug his heels in because the "predictive text defence" is true?

I've tried it, I've got Buffon, buffoonery, Nihon, Biggin, button and Nixon but not baboon.

Notably, a is nowhere near u on the keyboard.
Reply
#53
The argument you should be able to say whatever you want about someone due to their ethnicity, disability, sexual orientation as long as it doesn't involve a threat to violence or actual violence is complete nonsense. You have no choice what race you are, whether you have a disability or what your sexual orientation is. To call someone hurtful, derogatory, hateful names simply due to who you are not what you do is bullying at best at worst irrational hatred. Let's be perfectly clear if there was no legal route to redress, people could simply go up to anyone who has learning difficulties for example and call them any name they like, repeatedly, just as long as they did it without a threat of violence! The person who has learning difficulties may not have the ability to argue back against those doing so, and that's acceptable? They should accept that's ok? Likewise a group of homophobic lads can name call one gay man at a bus stop under the pretence of banter using this logic. That's ok too, as they didn't threaten him. Liberties are no more sacrosanct than responsibilities. They are both human constructs to allow society to function as best it can, when it breaks down that is what the law is for. This seems lost on libertarians who seem to think their rights to say and do exactly what they want without redress are what matter most, whilst arguing that they are the victim!
Reply
#54
As someone has already said, he wouldn't have gone to jail if he had actually admitted his 'crime'. He chose to waste everybody's time and our tax money by coming out with a defence that was a blatant lie.

The free speech argument has been done to death. No country has free speech and for very good reasons. You would have to let many more islamic extremists and terrorist sympathisers and the like go before you move onto the racist idiots. Not to mention assorted perverts.

Unless of course you don't really mean free speech, you just mean free speech within a particular set of rules you're okay with? I'm guessing you do because the caveat of 'no violence' was included. So ultimately, not real free speech.

However, I'm guessing this is not really about the right to free speech, it's more a belief that saying something racist and then wasting the courts time isn't an important enough 'crime' to warrant a custodial sentence. Maybe you think calling somebody a racist name is the same as calling someone a 'ginger twat' and so shouldn't be a crime? It's a shame if you think that, but if that's your opinion (and no, it doesn't make you a racist), you're entitled to it.

But the philosophical argument is bullshit.

* In response to someone saying hearing from someone from the black community, I would say you would get a lot of different responses - as you would from the white community. My own personal opinion is that if he had of just admitted it, he should have got a fine and some sort of 'explanation' on why it's not acceptable - which is exactly what would have happened. However, if he's going to take the piss, then you have no alternative but to jail him. What else can you do?
Reply
#55
(10-01-2021, 11:39 AM)fuzzbox Wrote: As someone has already said, he wouldn't have gone to jail if he had actually admitted his 'crime'. He chose to waste everybody's time and our tax money by coming out with a defence that was a blatant lie.

The free speech argument has been done to death. No country has free speech and for very good reasons. You would have to let many more islamic extremists and terrorist sympathisers and the like go before you move onto the racist idiots. Not to mention assorted perverts.

Unless of course you don't really mean free speech, you just mean free speech within a particular set of rules you're okay with? I'm guessing you do because the caveat of 'no violence' was included. So ultimately, not real free speech.

However, I'm guessing this is not really about the right to free speech, it's more a belief that saying something racist and then wasting the courts time isn't an important enough 'crime' to warrant a custodial sentence. Maybe you think calling somebody a racist name is the same as calling someone a 'ginger twat' and so shouldn't be a crime? It's a shame if you think that, but if that's your opinion, you're entitled to it.

But the philosophical argument is bullshit.

Can you quote the person who said it please? It looks like you’re replying to me and I’m definitely on your side of the argument Fuzzbox.  Smile
Reply
#56
(10-01-2021, 11:43 AM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: Can you quote the person who said it please? It looks like you’re replying to me and I’m definitely on your side of the argument Fuzzbox.  Smile

I WAS replying to you. I'm glad you didn't let the fact that all my points are irrelevant to your post confuse you...
Wink
Reply
#57
(10-01-2021, 11:57 AM)fuzzbox Wrote:
(10-01-2021, 11:43 AM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: Can you quote the person who said it please? It looks like you’re replying to me and I’m definitely on your side of the argument Fuzzbox.  Smile

I WAS replying to you. I'm glad you didn't let the fact that all my points are irrelevant to your post confuse you...
Wink

Good practice to link to the actual post you are replying to. If you were replying to me it is really confusing.
Reply
#58
(10-01-2021, 11:57 AM)fuzzbox Wrote:
(10-01-2021, 11:43 AM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: Can you quote the person who said it please? It looks like you’re replying to me and I’m definitely on your side of the argument Fuzzbox.  Smile

I WAS replying to you. I'm glad you didn't let the fact that all my points are irrelevant to your post confuse you...
Wink

I used to cover court cases, many years ago, and an early guilty plea made an enormous difference. It would certainly in this case as his argument on the predictatext is so weak. As I said considering the thread he responded to clearly had white supremacy overtones, the use of baboon seemed to point to racism.

He was an idiot for not holding his hands up and apologising.

I still find the sentence harsh though, whilst having little sympathy for him.
Reply
#59
(10-01-2021, 12:14 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote:
(10-01-2021, 11:57 AM)fuzzbox Wrote:
(10-01-2021, 11:43 AM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: Can you quote the person who said it please? It looks like you’re replying to me and I’m definitely on your side of the argument Fuzzbox.  Smile

I WAS replying to you. I'm glad you didn't let the fact that all my points are irrelevant to your post confuse you...
Wink

Good practice to link to the actual post you are replying to. If you were replying to me it is really confusing.

Sorry, I thought you only did that if you were replying to a particular post within the topic. If you were responding to the original post you didn't need to as that takes precedence (unless you're a narcissist!).

If I had of been replying to your message I would have highlighted your response and used the reply button as you have done and I have in this case, so there would be no confusion.
Reply
#60
(10-01-2021, 12:25 PM)fuzzbox Wrote:
(10-01-2021, 12:14 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote:
(10-01-2021, 11:57 AM)fuzzbox Wrote:
(10-01-2021, 11:43 AM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: Can you quote the person who said it please? It looks like you’re replying to me and I’m definitely on your side of the argument Fuzzbox.  Smile

I WAS replying to you. I'm glad you didn't let the fact that all my points are irrelevant to your post confuse you...
Wink

Good practice to link to the actual post you are replying to. If you were replying to me it is really confusing.

Sorry, I thought you only did that if you were replying to a particular post within the topic. If you were responding to the original post you didn't need to as that takes precedence (unless you're a narcissist!).

If I had of been replying to your message I would have highlighted your response and used the reply button as you have done and I have in this case, so there would be no confusion.

Big Grin  It's ok I defend your right to confuse me which is very easily done  Wink
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: 1 Guest(s)