Poll: Pen or no pen?
You do not have permission to vote in this poll.
Pen
36.51%
23 36.51%
No pen
63.49%
40 63.49%
Total 63 vote(s) 100%
* You voted for this item. [Show Results]

Pen or no pen?
#31
I'm surprised so many people say its a pen. Didn't look at all intentional and when you fly in to try and block a shot, your arms are never going to be flat by your side.
If this is how it is now, there will be plenty hand ball offences going on in games.
I'd be fuming if we had conceded one like that.
Reply
#32
(03-06-2019, 11:31 PM)4-hero Wrote:
(03-06-2019, 11:17 PM)methoxyl Wrote: It was a biro
People will be BICkering over this for years to come

Especially Scott Parker!
Reply
#33
(03-07-2019, 06:32 PM)Pickle Rick Wrote:
(03-07-2019, 05:03 PM)tiptontown Wrote: I'm surprised so many people say its a pen. Didn't look at all intentional and when you fly in to try and block a shot, your arms are never going to be flat by your side.
If this is how it is now, there will be plenty hand ball offences going on in games.
I'd be fuming if we had conceded one like that.

Then players can continue to fly in like that making themselves wide with arms out if they are not given, knowing full well there is a chance it will hit their arms - and managers will ask them to do that if they know the pen won't be given. The onus is on the player if he is  going to block to keep his hands obviously out the way and if he doesnt then he rightly concedes a penalty.  The ref can't do a lie detector test and they will all say accidental. So he goes on probabilities and I think if the arm is out he is probably right that the arm was meant to be out. Can be harsh but better this way than the other which will be exploited. They are well paid professional footballers and I think they probably can keep their arms tight to their sides if they try hard.

It's natural to lift your arms as you jump, run which ever way you want to put it. His arm wasn't abnormally away from his body and looked completely natural with what he did. It's up to the ref to judge if it's intentional or not. 
Can't see how anyone would see that as a deliberate hand ball.
Reply
#34
(03-07-2019, 07:03 PM)Pickle Rick Wrote:
(03-07-2019, 06:49 PM)tiptontown Wrote:
(03-07-2019, 06:32 PM)Pickle Rick Wrote:
(03-07-2019, 05:03 PM)tiptontown Wrote: I'm surprised so many people say its a pen. Didn't look at all intentional and when you fly in to try and block a shot, your arms are never going to be flat by your side.
If this is how it is now, there will be plenty hand ball offences going on in games.
I'd be fuming if we had conceded one like that.

Then players can continue to fly in like that making themselves wide with arms out if they are not given, knowing full well there is a chance it will hit their arms - and managers will ask them to do that if they know the pen won't be given. The onus is on the player if he is  going to block to keep his hands obviously out the way and if he doesnt then he rightly concedes a penalty.  The ref can't do a lie detector test and they will all say accidental. So he goes on probabilities and I think if the arm is out he is probably right that the arm was meant to be out. Can be harsh but better this way than the other which will be exploited. They are well paid professional footballers and I think they probably can keep their arms tight to their sides if they try hard.

It's natural to lift your arms as you jump, run which ever way you want to put it. His arm wasn't abnormally away from his body and looked completely natural with what he did. It's up to the ref to judge if it's intentional or not. 
Can't see how anyone would see that as a deliberate hand ball.

Then like I say you can just jump in the way all the time like that and say oops sorry I naturally blocked the ball with my hand/arm if the ball hits the arm. I agree with the decision anyway, but if his arm was tight by his side I wouldn't have agreed, so I would blame the player rather than the ref / panel. If there is more consistency and these are always given I imagine you'll find players can keep their hands out the way.

I just don't get that theory mon. That's football, sometimes the ball does accidentally hit the hand/arm, but it's normally pretty obvious if the arm is out in a un natural position. 
If that's the criteria now, always keeping your arm close to your body, we're going to get a hell of a lot of hand ball offences in games.
Reply
#35
(03-07-2019, 07:26 PM)Pickle Rick Wrote:
(03-07-2019, 07:11 PM)tiptontown Wrote:
(03-07-2019, 07:03 PM)Pickle Rick Wrote:
(03-07-2019, 06:49 PM)tiptontown Wrote:
(03-07-2019, 06:32 PM)Pickle Rick Wrote: Then players can continue to fly in like that making themselves wide with arms out if they are not given, knowing full well there is a chance it will hit their arms - and managers will ask them to do that if they know the pen won't be given. The onus is on the player if he is  going to block to keep his hands obviously out the way and if he doesnt then he rightly concedes a penalty.  The ref can't do a lie detector test and they will all say accidental. So he goes on probabilities and I think if the arm is out he is probably right that the arm was meant to be out. Can be harsh but better this way than the other which will be exploited. They are well paid professional footballers and I think they probably can keep their arms tight to their sides if they try hard.

It's natural to lift your arms as you jump, run which ever way you want to put it. His arm wasn't abnormally away from his body and looked completely natural with what he did. It's up to the ref to judge if it's intentional or not. 
Can't see how anyone would see that as a deliberate hand ball.

Then like I say you can just jump in the way all the time like that and say oops sorry I naturally blocked the ball with my hand/arm if the ball hits the arm. I agree with the decision anyway, but if his arm was tight by his side I wouldn't have agreed, so I would blame the player rather than the ref / panel. If there is more consistency and these are always given I imagine you'll find players can keep their hands out the way.

I just don't get that theory mon. That's football, sometimes the ball does accidentally hit the hand/arm, but it's normally pretty obvious if the arm is out in a un natural position. 
If that's the criteria now, always keeping your arm close to your body, we're going to get a hell of a lot of hand ball offences in games.

Plenty of players already are in the habit of sticking their arms behind them or by their sides when blocking a cross or shot so you don't gave to make a call on what is natural or not. If this player had practiced that it would have missed him (and gone over probably)  or hit his arse or something. So tough but fair for me.

If he had his arms behind him with the way he tried to block the shot, he probably would have fell flat on his face. 
Your arms are used for balance in certain situations, so it's not as black and white as always keeping your arms behind you whatever the challenge.
Reply
#36
(03-07-2019, 07:44 PM)Pickle Rick Wrote:
(03-07-2019, 07:40 PM)tiptontown Wrote:
(03-07-2019, 07:26 PM)Pickle Rick Wrote:
(03-07-2019, 07:11 PM)tiptontown Wrote:
(03-07-2019, 07:03 PM)Pickle Rick Wrote: Then like I say you can just jump in the way all the time like that and say oops sorry I naturally blocked the ball with my hand/arm if the ball hits the arm. I agree with the decision anyway, but if his arm was tight by his side I wouldn't have agreed, so I would blame the player rather than the ref / panel. If there is more consistency and these are always given I imagine you'll find players can keep their hands out the way.

I just don't get that theory mon. That's football, sometimes the ball does accidentally hit the hand/arm, but it's normally pretty obvious if the arm is out in a un natural position. 
If that's the criteria now, always keeping your arm close to your body, we're going to get a hell of a lot of hand ball offences in games.

Plenty of players already are in the habit of sticking their arms behind them or by their sides when blocking a cross or shot so you don't gave to make a call on what is natural or not. If this player had practiced that it would have missed him (and gone over probably)  or hit his arse or something. So tough but fair for me.

If he had his arms behind him with the way he tried to block the shot, he probably would have fell flat on his face. 
Your arms are used for balance in certain situations, so it's not as black and white as always keeping your arms behind you whatever the challenge.

So maybe he shouldn't have tried to block that way knowing handball was a risk? Managers will have players jumping in to block that way all the time with arms out if you can get away with it. The player took the risk - blame him not the ref.

Maybe he should've just let him have a free shot at goal, no risk at all then  Rolleyes
Reply
#37
(03-07-2019, 07:59 PM)Pickle Rick Wrote:
(03-07-2019, 07:53 PM)tiptontown Wrote:
(03-07-2019, 07:44 PM)Pickle Rick Wrote:
(03-07-2019, 07:40 PM)tiptontown Wrote:
(03-07-2019, 07:26 PM)Pickle Rick Wrote: Plenty of players already are in the habit of sticking their arms behind them or by their sides when blocking a cross or shot so you don't gave to make a call on what is natural or not. If this player had practiced that it would have missed him (and gone over probably)  or hit his arse or something. So tough but fair for me.

If he had his arms behind him with the way he tried to block the shot, he probably would have fell flat on his face. 
Your arms are used for balance in certain situations, so it's not as black and white as always keeping your arms behind you whatever the challenge.

So maybe he shouldn't have tried to block that way knowing handball was a risk? Managers will have players jumping in to block that way all the time with arms out if you can get away with it. The player took the risk - blame him not the ref.

Maybe he should've just let him have a free shot at goal, no risk at all then  Rolleyes
Or block without your arms out - he is a professional footballer and knows the rules

Like I said earlier, his arm wasn't that far from his body and certainly didn't look un natural and I do blame the ref, he should have gone with his gut instinct rather than a un natural slow motion replay, but I think we ain't going to agree, so I'll leave it there.
Reply
#38
The point I think that has been missed on the thread is that if I read the views correctly it's now ok to have different decision outside the box and inside the box.

That player jumps 5 yards from the ball to block a shot 30 yards out and it hits his hand ( not ball to hand we all agree) and there's no way the game stops for a Var decision. The exact same thing happens in the box and Var is all over it.

I thought there was one set of rules that covered the whole pitch. Clearly not with this farcical decision. If you're going to enforce a rule it has to be consistent which is why they stated the clear and obvious tenet. Last night was not. It also broke the consistency rule. Plus the shot was going miles over. So if you want that level of sophistication get a Hawkeye system not some ref who in the 94th minute has been set up by his 3 pals , who had already deemed no pen from 5 yards away in real time, who's now thinking he's made a cock up because those 3 pals have asked him to have another look. It's such s loaded system it will never consistently get the right result
Reply
#39
(03-07-2019, 10:26 AM)Pickle Rick Wrote:
(03-07-2019, 10:20 AM)CA Baggie Wrote: Clear and obvious error? Nope.

Put simply - had it not been given no one would have commented on it being hand ball.

How long before clever players, when close up to a defender, deliberately flick the ball up to hit an arm and then draw a square with their fingers?

There is the game changing option to use var isn't there? 
I know what you are saying but if players knows the ref will give them the benefit of the doubt then clever plsyers will always jump with arms out and have that option for blocking that way 'accidentally'. The player has to have his arms out of the way or he could be doing it deliberately - how would the ref know.

It only became “game changing” when var got involved.  The shot that hit the back of his elbow was destined for the stands.

I accept that some players deliberately make themselves bigger when attempting to block shots and the ref should award penalties when arms/hands are in an unnatural position.  This is the grey area, I didn’t think his arms were in an unnatural position.

What you seem to be saying is that players are no longer able to charge a shot down etc.  They can only stand, run and jump with their arms strictly by their sides?  

It’s like the “contact in the box therefore entitle to go down” argument.  The ball will sometimes unintentionally hit and arm that doesn’t make it a penalty.  There has to be a certain degree of context and interpretation, VAR doesn’t give that it just gives factual evidence of did it hit the arm or not.

No one involved with that game would have complained about a penalty not being given.  And certainly not before var.  

it’s changing the game and not for the better.  Had the shot come from a throw in awarded the wrong way then how long before there’s a demand for it to be taken back to that decision?  This search for the “right decision” is a fools gold.  It can only exist if every decision from the kick off is reviewed along with every tackle made.
Reply
#40
I agree that VAR will creep ever deeper, changing the sport, increasing the tension for TV viewers and advertising potential for broadcasters. A few drinks and "the day" are important, but that moment of exhilaration when the ball hits the net is the drug inside the ground. It will ruin it for stadium spectators by killing that, but the broadcasters don't care as long as they make their bucks. They promised a 'whole new ball game' and are delivering that.

With VAR, Leeds first goal would rightly have been disallowed for the offside player running across the flight of the ball in front of SJ. That incredible atmosphere and what Leeds fans are regarding as a truly special night may have been stopped in its tracks. Imagine Livermore's goal being correctly disallowed against Spurs because he was offside.

Regarding the United decision, it was a nailed on penalty for me. The argument that the incident should only be reviewed in real time is ridiculous IMHO. The slo-mo and stills are revealing. The defender sees the shot coming and puts his arm out first, before the ball is struck. He's anticipating the shot, puts his arm out, then jumps and turns as the shot has been hit. Even though he may have been protecting himself, but he knew what he was doing, making it deliberate.

His reaction was telling. Head in hands. Didn't look like a victim of gross injustice, but someone who knew he had been caught out.

Incorrect decisions are part and parcel and should be left alone, but money talks. The stakes are too high. The reality is that we'll just end up arguing about inconsistencies in VAR interpretation instead, as proved by this thread.
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: