Poll: Pen or no pen?
You do not have permission to vote in this poll.
Pen
36.51%
23 36.51%
No pen
63.49%
40 63.49%
Total 63 vote(s) 100%
* You voted for this item. [Show Results]

Pen or no pen?
#21
No penalty - Would have been very disappointed had that been given against us in a crucial game. That said, it seems unanimous amongst past and present referees that it should have been given, so what do I know.
Reply
#22
(03-07-2019, 10:26 AM)Pickle Rick Wrote:
(03-07-2019, 10:20 AM)CA Baggie Wrote: Clear and obvious error? Nope.

Put simply - had it not been given no one would have commented on it being hand ball.

How long before clever players, when close up to a defender, deliberately flick the ball up to hit an arm and then draw a square with their fingers?

There is the game changing option to use var isn't there? 
I know what you are saying but if players knows the ref will give them the benefit of the doubt then clever plsyers will always jump with arms out and have that option for blocking that way 'accidentally'. The player has to have his arms out of the way or he could be doing it deliberately - how would the ref know.

Agree with this. It's not a bad idea to say if you arm is away from your body and deflects the ball it's a pen as "deliberate" is only clear if someone dives like a cat to save it.
Reply
#23
Pre-VAR, that would hardly ever be given as a penalty and literally wouldn't even have been mentioned by commentators or anyone else. I remember watching many televised games (including some of ours) where a similar incident has occurred, the TV production team has spotted a possible handball and played in a replay later and the commentators/summarisers have said things along the lines of: "Well, it did hit his hand, but you can't give a penalty for that."

With VAR, we no longer live in that world. We live in a world in which the game is going to be reduced to the analysis of minutiae and the laws of the game applied literally with no context. I was at a non-league game on Saturday when a player got a boot in the face and had to have 17 stitches. At no point did I (or anyone around me) think the challenge was dangerous and the opposition player should have been sent off, but I'm pretty sure he would be under VAR.

I've said it before, but the game will evolve so that every single goal scored will be subject to the referee checking it's OK for him to award it. The mission creep we've seen so far will be nothing - the cumulative effect of pressure from the media, players, managers, coaching staff and fans will be such that television replays will come to dominate every aspect of the game.

I have no idea what happened in extra-time in the Porto v Roma game yesterday other than on the radio it said Porto went through "thanks to a VAR-awarded penalty". This will become commonplace - technology will determine everything and while the "right" decision may be reached in a technical sense, it'll change the game irrevocably and not for the better in my opinion.
Reply
#24
(03-07-2019, 11:55 AM)steviedm Wrote: Pre-VAR, that would hardly ever be given as a penalty and literally wouldn't even have been mentioned by commentators or anyone else. I remember watching many televised games (including some of ours) where a similar incident has occurred, the TV production team has spotted a possible handball and played in a replay later and the commentators/summarisers have said things along the lines of: "Well, it did hit his hand, but you can't give a penalty for that."

With VAR, we no longer live in that world. We live in a world in which the game is going to be reduced to the analysis of minutiae and the laws of the game applied literally with no context. I was at a non-league game on Saturday when a player got a boot in the face and had to have 17 stitches. At no point did I (or anyone around me) think the challenge was dangerous and the opposition player should have been sent off, but I'm pretty sure he would be under VAR.

I've said it before, but the game will evolve so that every single goal scored will be subject to the referee checking it's OK for him to award it. The mission creep we've seen so far will be nothing - the cumulative effect of pressure from the media, players, managers, coaching staff and fans will be such that television replays will come to dominate every aspect of the game.

I have no idea what happened in extra-time in the Porto v Roma game yesterday other than on the radio it said Porto went through "thanks to a VAR-awarded penalty". This will become commonplace - technology will determine everything and while the "right" decision may be reached in a technical sense, it'll change the game irrevocably and not for the better in my opinion.

This is such a good observation - to be fair the whole post is good.

The game will eventually become 2 separate sports the way we are going. There will never be enough money in the sport to allow VAR to be used in lower leagues professional football. The way the game is officiated where there is VAR and where there is not, will mean that the game will be so differentiated that it will become like 2 separate sports.
Reply
#25
(03-07-2019, 11:55 AM)steviedm Wrote: Pre-VAR, that would hardly ever be given as a penalty and literally wouldn't even have been mentioned by commentators or anyone else. I remember watching many televised games (including some of ours) where a similar incident has occurred, the TV production team has spotted a possible handball and played in a replay later and the commentators/summarisers have said things along the lines of: "Well, it did hit his hand, but you can't give a penalty for that."

With VAR, we no longer live in that world. We live in a world in which the game is going to be reduced to the analysis of minutiae and the laws of the game applied literally with no context. I was at a non-league game on Saturday when a player got a boot in the face and had to have 17 stitches. At no point did I (or anyone around me) think the challenge was dangerous and the opposition player should have been sent off, but I'm pretty sure he would be under VAR.

I've said it before, but the game will evolve so that every single goal scored will be subject to the referee checking it's OK for him to award it. The mission creep we've seen so far will be nothing - the cumulative effect of pressure from the media, players, managers, coaching staff and fans will be such that television replays will come to dominate every aspect of the game.

I have no idea what happened in extra-time in the Porto v Roma game yesterday other than on the radio it said Porto went through "thanks to a VAR-awarded penalty". This will become commonplace - technology will determine everything and while the "right" decision may be reached in a technical sense, it'll change the game irrevocably and not for the better in my opinion.

Don't really disagree. However, the original question was whether it was a pen or not. It was reviewed by VAR (rightly so, given that's what it's there for), the UEFA directive was hand outside bodyline causing a deflection in penalty area so it was a pen.
Reply
#26
I've only just seen the penalty claim online. During his time with Blackburn Rovers Colin Hendry made an art form of unintended hand ball in and around the penalty box. It used to do my head in watching him do this on MotD. It annoyed me even more when other defenders followed suit. In this instance the defending player knew the ball was coming and flew through the air with the greatest of ease in his attempt to block the shot. No problem there and no penalty if that was all it was. However, he stuck his arm out to gain momentum and increase his natural presence while deliberately executing an aerial pirouette. This to my mind is not a simple ball to hand and as such makes things entirely different. No need for VAR, I'd have given a penalty all day long. Genuinely don't understand the fuss.
Reply
#27
Penalty. Kimpbele threw himself on the way with 0 regard of where the ball hit him, arms out to make a big target. His reaction after says it for me, he knew what he was doing and just hoped it wouldn't hit his arm or be noticed if it did.
Reply
#28
(03-07-2019, 01:05 PM)Fido Wrote:
(03-07-2019, 11:55 AM)steviedm Wrote: Pre-VAR, that would hardly ever be given as a penalty and literally wouldn't even have been mentioned by commentators or anyone else. I remember watching many televised games (including some of ours) where a similar incident has occurred, the TV production team has spotted a possible handball and played in a replay later and the commentators/summarisers have said things along the lines of: "Well, it did hit his hand, but you can't give a penalty for that."

With VAR, we no longer live in that world. We live in a world in which the game is going to be reduced to the analysis of minutiae and the laws of the game applied literally with no context. I was at a non-league game on Saturday when a player got a boot in the face and had to have 17 stitches. At no point did I (or anyone around me) think the challenge was dangerous and the opposition player should have been sent off, but I'm pretty sure he would be under VAR.

I've said it before, but the game will evolve so that every single goal scored will be subject to the referee checking it's OK for him to award it. The mission creep we've seen so far will be nothing - the cumulative effect of pressure from the media, players, managers, coaching staff and fans will be such that television replays will come to dominate every aspect of the game.

I have no idea what happened in extra-time in the Porto v Roma game yesterday other than on the radio it said Porto went through "thanks to a VAR-awarded penalty". This will become commonplace - technology will determine everything and while the "right" decision may be reached in a technical sense, it'll change the game irrevocably and not for the better in my opinion.

Don't really disagree. However, the original question was whether it was a pen or not. It was reviewed by VAR (rightly so, given that's what it's there for), the UEFA directive was hand outside bodyline causing a deflection in penalty area so it was a pen.

I thought that ruling was not being applied until June 1st?

The difference of opinion on this thread alone would indicate (to fans at least, if not referees) that it wasn't "clear and obvious" that a pelanty should be awarded.
Reply
#29
Dont forget, VAR saw the only goal that has ever been scored by a direct header from a corner ruled out for offside. What a load of old bollocks it is
Reply
#30
Dermot Gallagher just said "no penalty."

Not that I'm holding him up as the shining light of all things correct. He mostly talked bollocks on any decision involving us.
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: