Posts: 15,278
Threads: 273
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
57
Yet 'kick and rush' has got us top of the table unbeaten.
Peterborough have one if the best home records in the league, we won. Millwall are always a bit of a ball ache for us, amd others. We've lost two key players, Robinson on inter.ationsl duty until late this week.
I'm not at all concerned, when we play poorly yet don't lose, that's important.
Posts: 10,866
Threads: 497
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
23
(09-11-2021, 04:49 PM)SW4Baggie Wrote: So before the meltdown ensues, can we give credit to Rowett who absolutely got his tactics spot on, and to a Millwall side who did an absolute job on us. They had clearly spent the last couple weeks preparing for this game and to a man everyone knew their job and executed it perfectly - I wouldn’t be surprised if they go and lose their next match, and if Derby and co. don’t employ very similar tactics going forward.
How do you beat a high press? You leave man for man players up top, Millwall always had 3 men occupying our CBs, and you have midfielders who switch with attackers to occupy pockets of space between the lines. They didn’t spend any time on the ball in their half and hit it aimlessly first time out of defence and we just couldn’t adapt.
After being very weak at set pieces so far this season they tightened up, focused on winning the first ball and dropping into a low block, not engaging with us and giving us a wall to break through. Peterborough did something similar but we just couldn’t breach a very stoic Millwall side.
Bialkowski did what he’s done for years at this level and played very well as the last line of defence, and this solidity along with the creativity of Wallace and the directness of Ojo, and supplemented with an absolute mastery of the dark arts earned them a deserved point.
We have to get better, fast.
Johnstone - 7
Kipré - 4 - looks like a fan who has won a competition to play, utter liability. Let’s get Bryan fit, fast.
Bartley - 7 - cracking goal
Ajayi - 6 - nearly cost us early on, but better than Cedric!
Townsend - 8 - MOTM - excellent for a league one player
Furlong - 6
Livermore - 7
Mowatt - 7 - probably his poorest game for us so far
Diangana - 6 - lively but still lacking a cutting edge
Grant - 5 - drops a point for the worst penalty since Earnie put one it orbit
Phillips - 6
Robinson - 6
Hugill - 6
Val - 5 - disappointing we started that front 3 when it looked toothless at P’boro.
Had we scored that penalty it could have been a very different game, but we can’t expect to win very game. Just disappointing we’ve dropped very achievable points today.
Interesting as I didn't see any of the game today. Its a worry that we didn't try a different tactic if they matched us up and worked us out.
People have already mentioned a lack of Plan B but for games like today we really should be more fluid and be able to counter their tactics.
My one issue with Valball® is it doesn't rely on much skill. It relies on fitness, pace and tenacity. That's all great but what that does do it levels the playing field when any team can match those characteristics if they apply themselves.
We have better more skillful forward players than most of the opposition so I would like to see us switch it up and trust those players to be able to use their skill and adapt to another formation.
We cant keep relying on grinding teams down as the longer the season goes on more and more teams will work us out.
Posts: 19,498
Threads: 824
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
60
(09-11-2021, 05:26 PM)Peachy Wrote: Interesting as I didn't see any of the game today. Its a worry that we didn't try a different tactic if they matched us up and worked us out.
People have already mentioned a lack of Plan B but for games like today we really should be more fluid and be able to counter their tactics.
My one issue with Valball® is it doesn't rely on much skill. It relies on fitness, pace and tenacity. That's all great but what that does do it levels the playing field when any team can match those characteristics if they apply themselves.
We have better more skillful forward players than most of the opposition so I would like to see us switch it up and trust those players to be able to use their skill and adapt to another formation.
We cant keep relying on grinding teams down as the longer the season goes on more and more teams will work us out.
Sums it up perfectly.
It allowed him to overachieve hugely with Barnsley, but it can be as detrimental to us as it can do us good. When we’re good there isn’t a team in this division that will live with us, when we’re poor, we’re really poor and will drop silly points.
Posts: 4,261
Threads: 263
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
25
(09-11-2021, 04:49 PM)SW4Baggie Wrote: So before the meltdown ensues, can we give credit to Rowett who absolutely got his tactics spot on, and to a Millwall side who did an absolute job on us. They had clearly spent the last couple weeks preparing for this game and to a man everyone knew their job and executed it perfectly - I wouldn’t be surprised if they go and lose their next match, and if Derby and co. don’t employ very similar tactics going forward.
How do you beat a high press? You leave man for man players up top, Millwall always had 3 men occupying our CBs, and you have midfielders who switch with attackers to occupy pockets of space between the lines. They didn’t spend any time on the ball in their half and hit it aimlessly first time out of defence and we just couldn’t adapt.
After being very weak at set pieces so far this season they tightened up, focused on winning the first ball and dropping into a low block, not engaging with us and giving us a wall to break through. Peterborough did something similar but we just couldn’t breach a very stoic Millwall side.
Bialkowski did what he’s done for years at this level and played very well as the last line of defence, and this solidity along with the creativity of Wallace and the directness of Ojo, and supplemented with an absolute mastery of the dark arts earned them a deserved point.
We have to get better, fast.
Johnstone - 7
Kipré - 4 - looks like a fan who has won a competition to play, utter liability. Let’s get Bryan fit, fast.
Bartley - 7 - cracking goal
Ajayi - 6 - nearly cost us early on, but better than Cedric!
Townsend - 8 - MOTM - excellent for a league one player
Furlong - 6
Livermore - 7
Mowatt - 7 - probably his poorest game for us so far
Diangana - 6 - lively but still lacking a cutting edge
Grant - 5 - drops a point for the worst penalty since Earnie put one it orbit
Phillips - 6
Robinson - 6
Hugill - 6
Val - 5 - disappointing we started that front 3 when it looked toothless at P’boro.
Had we scored that penalty it could have been a very different game, but we can’t expect to win very game. Just disappointing we’ve dropped very achievable points today.
SJ deserves 8 for getting us out of jail at least twice. Ajayi was barely any better than Kipre, his two backpasses were criminal, 5 for him. Livermore and Mowatt didn't really have a grip in midfield, 7s are generous for them. Hugill made a huge difference because the ball stuck to him. If we're going to play hoofball, he has to start. He's worth a 7.
I think Kipre struggles with playing such a high line. He fudged a few "must win" situations on the halfway line, but his work in our penalty area was at least equal to Ajayi. I don't want either of these two in the team, but we haven't seen Bryan yet and Clarke hasn't looked fit at any point so far. I'm guessing we don't get 20 games out of him this season.
We're top of the league. COYB!
Posts: 5,201
Threads: 197
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
14
Interesting reading this when I pretty much said exactly the same post Peterborough and the general come back was it was a one off, we were tired and it won’t happen again…..we’ll it did, today
I like Val and I like his principles however it is so much more suited to a team punching above their weight who harass the superior opposition into mistakes, maybe next year if we get up it may be an interesting watch, if we keep playing like this all season it will be a tough one for us. For all his bitterness when we won at Blackburn Mogga summed it up perfect when he said “Albion fans like their teams to play football, this is fine when they are winning let’s see how the fans like it when they are not”…..and you get his point
What I said post Peterborough and it’s the same here, we are better than the opposition, man for man, let’s not play 100mph Val Ball for 90 minutes and turn it into a scrap, I’m all for it, but not all the time, today the few times we got it down and played we threatened.
The second half was better, marginally, we passed more, spaces opened up but that first half is a blue print of how all the division will come and set up against us and we have to find a way to handle it better, Ferguson got it right last week, Mowatt just picked up the baton and carried on
Beat Derby and Preston and today is forgotten but hopefully it’s a bit of eye opener to Val and his staff
Mark’s
SJ 7 Three big saves generally from Semi mistakes, other end of the ground to me but you just know when those dangerous crosses come in he’s glued to that line, would love to see him command that box better
Furlong 6 Nothing worked for him today,even the throws, caught in possession in a dangerous area late on with no options to pass too, plenty of effort but tough afternoon
Townsend 6 Good 2nd half and lovely cross for goal, AWOL in the first half as like Furlong he didn’t know whether to push up or drop back to make a five
Kipre 6 Some watching a different game to me, thought he did OK, improved well 2nd half, some talk he may have been at fault for their goal but overall he did OK, also bear in mind he’s playing on his non preferred side
Bartley 7 Pick of the back three, won his aerial duels in the main and great header for goal
Semi 5 One to forget, no composure on the ball and three short back passes nearly resulted in Milwall goals, two of them clear chances, poor
Livermore 6 Good 2nd half much more like what was required, non existent first half as the game just passed over his head time and time again
Mowatt 6 See Livermore, improved,set pieces very poor today, his worse game for us by a distance
Grady 7 Pick of the front 3 and surprisingly hooked ahead of others, maybe a knock? In 45 minutes of scrappy football he was the only bright spark
Phillips 6 Terrible first half, better 2nd when moved wide
Grant 5 Another poor showing capped with a truly terrible penalty, what sort of height was that?
Subs
Hugill 6 Did OK and definitely should have been introduced as we needed that physicality up against Millwall’s giant centre halves, put himself about and held the ball up well OK
Robinson 7* Just seemed to ooze a bit of quality we were lacking when he came on, put his foot on it, found space and inches away from a tap in to win it
Surprised we didn’t maybe see Snoddy last 10 as felt it needed somebody who would put their foot on it a little more, let’s hope we learn from this on the training ground
Cuzer
Fisheatingdeludedsealwankers
Posts: 15,278
Threads: 273
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
57
As often Cuzer I don't disagree much there.
I think we naturally play better just by having Robinson on the pitch, he adds so much to the attack.
Posts: 8,841
Threads: 315
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
78
(09-11-2021, 06:32 PM)Cuzer Wrote: Interesting reading this when I pretty much said exactly the same post Peterborough and the general come back was it was a one off, we were tired and it won’t happen again…..we’ll it did, today
I like Val and I like his principles however it is so much more suited to a team punching above their weight who harass the superior opposition into mistakes, maybe next year if we get up it may be an interesting watch, if we keep playing like this all season it will be a tough one for us. For all his bitterness when we won at Blackburn Mogga summed it up perfect when he said “Albion fans like their teams to play football, this is fine when they are winning let’s see how the fans like it when they are not”…..and you get his point
What I said post Peterborough and it’s the same here, we are better than the opposition, man for man, let’s not play 100mph Val Ball for 90 minutes and turn it into a scrap, I’m all for it, but not all the time, today the few times we got it down and played we threatened.
The second half was better, marginally, we passed more, spaces opened up but that first half is a blue print of how all the division will come and set up against us and we have to find a way to handle it better, Ferguson got it right last week, Mowatt just picked up the baton and carried on
Beat Derby and Preston and today is forgotten but hopefully it’s a bit of eye opener to Val and his staff
Mark’s
SJ 7 Three big saves generally from Semi mistakes, other end of the ground to me but you just know when those dangerous crosses come in he’s glued to that line, would love to see him command that box better
Furlong 6 Nothing worked for him today,even the throws, caught in possession in a dangerous area late on with no options to pass too, plenty of effort but tough afternoon
Townsend 6 Good 2nd half and lovely cross for goal, AWOL in the first half as like Furlong he didn’t know whether to push up or drop back to make a five
Kipre 6 Some watching a different game to me, thought he did OK, improved well 2nd half, some talk he may have been at fault for their goal but overall he did OK, also bear in mind he’s playing on his non preferred side
Bartley 7 Pick of the back three, won his aerial duels in the main and great header for goal
Semi 5 One to forget, no composure on the ball and three short back passes nearly resulted in Milwall goals, two of them clear chances, poor
Livermore 6 Good 2nd half much more like what was required, non existent first half as the game just passed over his head time and time again
Mowatt 6 See Livermore, improved,set pieces very poor today, his worse game for us by a distance
Grady 7 Pick of the front 3 and surprisingly hooked ahead of others, maybe a knock? In 45 minutes of scrappy football he was the only bright spark
Phillips 6 Terrible first half, better 2nd when moved wide
Grant 5 Another poor showing capped with a truly terrible penalty, what sort of height was that?
Subs
Hugill 6 Did OK and definitely should have been introduced as we needed that physicality up against Millwall’s giant centre halves, put himself about and held the ball up well OK
Robinson 7* Just seemed to ooze a bit of quality we were lacking when he came on, put his foot on it, found space and inches away from a tap in to win it
Surprised we didn’t maybe see Snoddy last 10 as felt it needed somebody who would put their foot on it a little more, let’s hope we learn from this on the training ground
Cuzer
Not sure where you sit, but it matches what I saw from the Brummie. Missing Clarke and O'Shea. Very good to see Diangana getting stuck in. With a less brutal side, he may have got some joy today.
I thought we looked a bit disjointed today. Too many passes without a player being in the right place to receive them. Goodness me though, that cross from Townsend for the goal was sublime.
Looked much better with Robinson and then with Hugill.
Today was the sort of lesson we needed.
Posts: 5,201
Threads: 197
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
14
09-11-2021, 08:38 PM
(This post was last modified: 09-11-2021, 08:38 PM by Cuzer.)
(09-11-2021, 07:31 PM)Squid Wrote: (09-11-2021, 06:32 PM)Cuzer Wrote: Interesting reading this when I pretty much said exactly the same post Peterborough and the general come back was it was a one off, we were tired and it won’t happen again…..we’ll it did, today
I like Val and I like his principles however it is so much more suited to a team punching above their weight who harass the superior opposition into mistakes, maybe next year if we get up it may be an interesting watch, if we keep playing like this all season it will be a tough one for us. For all his bitterness when we won at Blackburn Mogga summed it up perfect when he said “Albion fans like their teams to play football, this is fine when they are winning let’s see how the fans like it when they are not”…..and you get his point
What I said post Peterborough and it’s the same here, we are better than the opposition, man for man, let’s not play 100mph Val Ball for 90 minutes and turn it into a scrap, I’m all for it, but not all the time, today the few times we got it down and played we threatened.
The second half was better, marginally, we passed more, spaces opened up but that first half is a blue print of how all the division will come and set up against us and we have to find a way to handle it better, Ferguson got it right last week, Mowatt just picked up the baton and carried on
Beat Derby and Preston and today is forgotten but hopefully it’s a bit of eye opener to Val and his staff
Mark’s
SJ 7 Three big saves generally from Semi mistakes, other end of the ground to me but you just know when those dangerous crosses come in he’s glued to that line, would love to see him command that box better
Furlong 6 Nothing worked for him today,even the throws, caught in possession in a dangerous area late on with no options to pass too, plenty of effort but tough afternoon
Townsend 6 Good 2nd half and lovely cross for goal, AWOL in the first half as like Furlong he didn’t know whether to push up or drop back to make a five
Kipre 6 Some watching a different game to me, thought he did OK, improved well 2nd half, some talk he may have been at fault for their goal but overall he did OK, also bear in mind he’s playing on his non preferred side
Bartley 7 Pick of the back three, won his aerial duels in the main and great header for goal
Semi 5 One to forget, no composure on the ball and three short back passes nearly resulted in Milwall goals, two of them clear chances, poor
Livermore 6 Good 2nd half much more like what was required, non existent first half as the game just passed over his head time and time again
Mowatt 6 See Livermore, improved,set pieces very poor today, his worse game for us by a distance
Grady 7 Pick of the front 3 and surprisingly hooked ahead of others, maybe a knock? In 45 minutes of scrappy football he was the only bright spark
Phillips 6 Terrible first half, better 2nd when moved wide
Grant 5 Another poor showing capped with a truly terrible penalty, what sort of height was that?
Subs
Hugill 6 Did OK and definitely should have been introduced as we needed that physicality up against Millwall’s giant centre halves, put himself about and held the ball up well OK
Robinson 7* Just seemed to ooze a bit of quality we were lacking when he came on, put his foot on it, found space and inches away from a tap in to win it
Surprised we didn’t maybe see Snoddy last 10 as felt it needed somebody who would put their foot on it a little more, let’s hope we learn from this on the training ground
Cuzer
Not sure where you sit, but it matches what I saw from the Brummie. Missing Clarke and O'Shea. Very good to see Diangana getting stuck in. With a less brutal side, he may have got some joy today.
I thought we looked a bit disjointed today. Too many passes without a player being in the right place to receive them. Goodness me though, that cross from Townsend for the goal was sublime.
Looked much better with Robinson and then with Hugill.
Today was the sort of lesson we needed.
Yeah, upper tier of the Brummy
Really surprised he hooked Grady, would have knocked his confidence too after what was a decent 45
Hope he gets the nod v Derby against Davis and Jagielka too, surely against that pair nimble movement and interplay should be a lot more productive than a Hugill type striker
Cuzer
Fisheatingdeludedsealwankers
Posts: 3,488
Threads: 101
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
5
The Val revolution really is a strange one in many ways.
Really don’t want us to place lovely tip tap stuff with no end result BUT
Great to be top and unbeaten yet left really frustrated with the last two performances.
The late winner at Peterborough papered over a very average to disappointing effort from us with one of the few quality moments from Phillips the difference against a poor team.
Today was quite painful to watch as both teams looked the level of a parks outfit for most of the time.
Yes it’s great to see the players so fit and enthusiastic but where was the undoubted quality against such agricultural opponents ?
It looked like we could open them up with a bit of guile on the ground yet kept playing nothing football that their defence lapped up.
We did get ourselves in front yet, worryingly, they then seemed all over the place when Millwall decided to cut out the nonsense and have a go.
Today I didn’t see much of what I’d call attacking football from us with so many aimless hoofs forward with no direction or care. Mowatt has been brilliant so far but looked lost today.
Anyone enjoy that today ?
Posts: 676
Threads: 15
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
1
(09-11-2021, 08:53 PM)EastMidsBaggie Wrote: The Val revolution really is a strange one in many ways.
Really don’t want us to place lovely tip tap stuff with no end result BUT
Great to be top and unbeaten yet left really frustrated with the last two performances.
The late winner at Peterborough papered over a very average to disappointing effort from us with one of the few quality moments from Phillips the difference against a poor team.
Today was quite painful to watch as both teams looked the level of a parks outfit for most of the time.
Yes it’s great to see the players so fit and enthusiastic but where was the undoubted quality against such agricultural opponents ?
It looked like we could open them up with a bit of guile on the ground yet kept playing nothing football that their defence lapped up.
We did get ourselves in front yet, worryingly, they then seemed all over the place when Millwall decided to cut out the nonsense and have a go.
Today I didn’t see much of what I’d call attacking football from us with so many aimless hoofs forward with no direction or care. Mowatt has been brilliant so far but looked lost today.
Anyone enjoy that today ?
I think you had to be there to realise how bad it actually was.
|