England v India
(09-10-2021, 09:53 AM)rsbaggy2 Wrote:
(09-10-2021, 09:49 AM)boingingbaggie Wrote:
(09-10-2021, 09:39 AM)rsbaggy2 Wrote:
(09-10-2021, 09:28 AM)boingingbaggie Wrote: I've not been impressed by the number 1 team in the world at all.
A few things here and there that have changed the series. India have hardly been dominant. Bumrah and Sharmah have been the major difference between the 2 teams. India have been pretty much at ful strength where England have been missing Broad, Archer, Woakes, Wood and most importantly Stokes at one point or another.

India shouldn't really be surprised people don't have a lot of time for them when the captain acts the way he does either. As others have said on here he's an embarassment to a decent team and let's face it, his form hardly backs up his cockiness does it?

The first test people seem convinced would have been an India win..  They still needed 156 to win. In the first innings in that match they lost 8 for 174, in the 3rd test they were bowled out for 78 and then lost 8 for 162 so it was no given those 156 were easily obtainable especially as wickets throughtout the series have come quickly.

There's an argument to say they have been marginally the better team but what's saying they wouldn't have been hammered in this test like they were in the third one?

First point ... whether we like it or not we are not OFFICIALLY No 1 test team.

Two ...Siraj and Thakur have played less tests than Overton and Robinson. And losing Shami for the last test too. Woakes was not played in the earlier tests by not been picked even when available.

Three .. We have lost Aggarwal, Gill and Hardik Pandya for the whole of the series.

Four ... could have and would have ... any level headed and independent observer would not agree with your assessment of the curtailed 1st test. Even Root admitted that they got away with a likely defeat.

So let us deal in a balanced way instead of crying over missing team members. I accept losing Stokes was perhaps the biggest miss of the lot on BOTH sides. However, Broad is way past his best and I believe Robinson has done a better job than him.

Aggarwal was replaced by Gill when he failed in Aus and Pandya last played a test match in 2018 ( I know he was injured for some of that time but he hasn't forced himself back in) so neither of those were mainstays of this side.

I agree completely on Broad, Robinson has been the find of the summer for England but all of those mentioned who have missed time, with maybe the exception of Wood, would have started for England. So whilst nobody is 'crying' over missing members it's certainly a valid argument.

As for the could have and would have.. it's sport anyhting can happen. Your observation India would have won carries as much weight as my observation they could have lost. Whatever Joe Root or anyone else says the game needed completion before appointing winners.

The current score is      England 1 (hammer) India 2 (hammers)

funnily enough I can't see where I said it wasn't
Reply
(09-10-2021, 09:28 AM)boingingbaggie Wrote: I've not been impressed by the number 1 team in the world at all.
A few things here and there that have changed the series. India have hardly been dominant. Bumrah and Sharmah have been the major difference between the 2 teams. India have been pretty much at ful strength where England have been missing Broad, Archer, Woakes, Wood and most importantly Stokes at one point or another.

India shouldn't really be surprised people don't have a lot of time for them when the captain acts the way he does either. As others have said on here he's an embarassment to a decent team and let's face it, his form hardly backs up his cockiness does it?

The first test people seem convinced would have been an India win..  They still needed 156 to win. In the first innings in that match they lost 8 for 174, in the 3rd test they were bowled out for 78 and then lost 8 for 162 so it was no given those 156 were easily obtainable especially as wickets throughtout the series have come quickly.

There's an argument to say they have been marginally the better team but what's saying they wouldn't have been hammered in this test like they were in the third one?
Very very bitter!!!......England did exactly the same we they toured SA we are still in the midst of a pandemic there is well over a 1000 deaths a week has been for a month or so with around 200000 infections a week!!!.
Indian team has been here for over 3 months with families there concern and actions understandable.
I'm damn sure test will be arranged before the ODI tour next season not ideal but be live in strange times!!!... Angry
Reply
(09-10-2021, 10:58 AM)pindgill Wrote:
(09-10-2021, 09:28 AM)boingingbaggie Wrote: I've not been impressed by the number 1 team in the world at all.
A few things here and there that have changed the series. India have hardly been dominant. Bumrah and Sharmah have been the major difference between the 2 teams. India have been pretty much at ful strength where England have been missing Broad, Archer, Woakes, Wood and most importantly Stokes at one point or another.

India shouldn't really be surprised people don't have a lot of time for them when the captain acts the way he does either. As others have said on here he's an embarassment to a decent team and let's face it, his form hardly backs up his cockiness does it?

The first test people seem convinced would have been an India win..  They still needed 156 to win. In the first innings in that match they lost 8 for 174, in the 3rd test they were bowled out for 78 and then lost 8 for 162 so it was no given those 156 were easily obtainable especially as wickets throughtout the series have come quickly.

There's an argument to say they have been marginally the better team but what's saying they wouldn't have been hammered in this test like they were in the third one?
Very very bitter!!!......England did exactly the same we they toured SA we are still in the midst of a pandemic there is well over a 1000 deaths a week has been for a month or so with around 200000 infections a week!!!.
Indian team has been here for over 3 months with families there concern and actions understandable.
I'm damn sure test will be arranged before the ODI tour next season not ideal but be live in strange times!!!... Angry

I see the post as a balanced view with data to back up the reasoning. 

Oh well, at least it’s not derogatory.
Reply
(09-10-2021, 10:58 AM)pindgill Wrote:
(09-10-2021, 09:28 AM)boingingbaggie Wrote: I've not been impressed by the number 1 team in the world at all.
A few things here and there that have changed the series. India have hardly been dominant. Bumrah and Sharmah have been the major difference between the 2 teams. India have been pretty much at ful strength where England have been missing Broad, Archer, Woakes, Wood and most importantly Stokes at one point or another.

India shouldn't really be surprised people don't have a lot of time for them when the captain acts the way he does either. As others have said on here he's an embarassment to a decent team and let's face it, his form hardly backs up his cockiness does it?

The first test people seem convinced would have been an India win..  They still needed 156 to win. In the first innings in that match they lost 8 for 174, in the 3rd test they were bowled out for 78 and then lost 8 for 162 so it was no given those 156 were easily obtainable especially as wickets throughtout the series have come quickly.

There's an argument to say they have been marginally the better team but what's saying they wouldn't have been hammered in this test like they were in the third one?
Very very bitter!!!......England did exactly the same we they toured SA we are still in the midst of a pandemic there is well over a 1000 deaths a week has been for a month or so with around 200000 infections a week!!!.
Indian team has been here for over 3 months with families there concern and actions understandable.
I'm damn sure test will be arranged before the ODI tour next season not ideal but be live in strange times!!!... Angry

I don't think boinging is suggesting anything untoward about the cancellation!
Reply
Frankly it stinks doesn't it, they all tested negative yesterday, the BCCI have interjected panicking like fuck in case one of their "star" players picks up Covid before the IPL kicks off

Unfortunately the world we live in now, the T20/IPL/Hundred carries far more clout than Test Cricket which to a connoisseur like me is a real shame

To be honest replaying it is farcical, a series is exactly that, you forefit the match, you lose, as crap as that sounds if India couldn't have got 11 fit players onto the pitch at 11am this morning I'm a dutchman! Absolute horse shit of the highest order, 14 years they've not won a series on English soil and they put the glitz and glamour of the IPL over a chance to secure that, as I said sign of the times and as always it's the fans that miss out on the spectical, all those travelling up to OT, hotels, train journeys etc, utterly shambolic

Pindgill brings up the Eng v SA withdrawal as some kind of comparison? It's not even close, at the time Covid was rife through both camps, SA had no handle on the spread of the virus, no crowds were in stadiums etc, this has been handled perfectly from day one with regular testing and as I said the Indian squad all passed fit yesterday evening, it's an interjection from the BCCI who, a bit like their captain, think they are bigger than the game!

A right shitshow.....

Cuzer
Fisheatingdeludedsealwankers
Reply
(09-10-2021, 03:06 PM)Cuzer Wrote: Frankly it stinks doesn't it, they all tested negative yesterday, the BCCI have interjected panicking like fuck in case one of their "star" players picks up Covid before the IPL kicks off

Unfortunately the world we live in now, the T20/IPL/Hundred carries far more clout than Test Cricket which to a connoisseur like me is a real shame

To be honest replaying it is farcical, a series is exactly that, you forefit the match, you lose, as crap as that sounds if India couldn't have got 11 fit players onto the pitch at 11am this morning I'm a dutchman! Absolute horse shit of the highest order, 14 years they've not won a series on English soil and they put the glitz and glamour of the IPL over a chance to secure that, as I said sign of the times and as always it's the fans that miss out on the spectical, all those travelling up to OT, hotels, train journeys etc, utterly shambolic

Pindgill brings up the Eng v SA withdrawal as some kind of comparison? It's not even close, at the time Covid was rife through both camps, SA had no handle on the spread of the virus, no crowds were in stadiums etc, this has been handled perfectly from day one with regular testing and as I said the Indian squad all passed fit yesterday evening, it's an interjection from the BCCI who, a bit like their captain, think they are bigger than the game!

A right shitshow.....

Cuzer
Sorry Covid did not run rife through both camps the England team rightly so wanted to come home as the pandemic was gathering pace here!!!…
Just some balance perspective and understanding would be good before such rants..
I’m damn certain Kohli and his team would have wanted a decisive win so completing away victories in SA,Australia & England in same year but it was not meant to be.
I repeat we live in difficult times a great series I for one have no issue with England fans calling it 2-2 as hollow as it sound..
Reply
It was Kholi and his board who cancelled the game, if they were that desperate to try and achieve a series win, something they’ve not done for 14 years and counting, they would have played the fixture to see if they could win it fair and square

India have travelled with a squad of 18, England don’t take that to the Ashes FFS, if they couldn’t field eleven players, bearing in mind they were all COVID free 24 hours prior Ill camp out!

Money over success…..for all Kholis ranting and gesturing when it came down to it, they prefer the cash off the IPL, not for me fella

Cuzer
Fisheatingdeludedsealwankers
Reply
It's all about the IPL. Here's a link to a Guardian article back in May this year:

https://www.theguardian.com/sport/2021/m...inst-india

Tom Harrison, ECB chief executive, has been utterly spineless in stating that the cancellation is nothing to do with the IPL commitments of the Indian players - citing mental health issues, which seems to me a complete nonsense. I understand that he is trying whatever he can to get an insurance payout for the huge losses sustained by Lancashire CCC and ECB, but he is letting BCCI completely off the hook.

Sorry, Indian cricket supporters, your boys have let themselves and the game down very badly. Up there challenging Australia as the least likeable Test-playing nation.
Reply
(09-10-2021, 10:37 PM)Cheshire East Baggie Wrote: It's all about the IPL. Here's a link to a Guardian article back in May this year:

https://www.theguardian.com/sport/2021/m...inst-india

Tom Harrison, ECB chief executive, has been utterly spineless in stating that the cancellation is nothing to do with the IPL commitments of the Indian players - citing mental health issues, which seems to me a complete nonsense. I understand that he is trying whatever he can to get an insurance payout for the huge losses sustained by Lancashire CCC and ECB, but he is letting BCCI completely off the hook.

Sorry, Indian cricket supporters, your boys have let themselves and the game down very badly. Up there challenging Australia as the least likeable Test-playing nation.

Totally agree Chesh, just nowhere for them to hide, I heard it mentioned earlier they were desperate to move this test sometime ago but didn’t have any links to articles so fair play

You actually must feel for the players who must have been desperate to try and win a series here, as for the paying UK public….zero fucks given

Shocking

Cuzer
Fisheatingdeludedsealwankers
Reply
The need to have someone to blame for what has happened with the fifth test, misses the point entirely.

There is far too much cricket being crammed in, leaving players at a massive risk of both physical and mental exhaustion. Especially for the top cricketing nations, where players seem to be playing non stop throughout the year.

Playing a test at this time of the year always seems a bit risky to me, moving this test to the start of the series appeared to be the most sensible option, but that would have led to a clash with the launch of the hundred, and that would never do.

I first got interested in cricket in the early 70s, when there were no one day internationals and no more than 6 tests in an English summer, and the county game had some meaning.

Things change with time, but when audiences are prevented from watching top performers like Ben Stokes, have all the changes been for the good of the game.
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: